HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

atakan_gurkan

888 karma · joined April 3, 2011

submissionscomments
atakan_gurkan··on Lichess will no longer cooperate with the USCF and the Saint Louis Chess Club
Not necessarily. Unless the presence of the accusation already was used to get that 30% number, you also need to take into account the a priori probability of someone maliciously lying (or better yet, the particular accuser to be lying in this case) and apply Bayes's theorem.
atakan_gurkan··on Common Lisp – Myths and Legends (2002)
I was replying to your original post, did not notice you posted something different here. Formatting a string and then either returning it or sending it to stdout (or any other stream) has too much in common. The work is done in the formatting, sending is just an after thought.

In a sense, this is similar to the parentheses and the prefix notation: it can be distracting if you are not used to it, but after a while it becomes very convenient.

And I do not mean to sound snobbish, but you can easily write a couple macros to have different syntax for these two tasks if it really bothers you.

atakan_gurkan··on Common Lisp – Myths and Legends (2002)
Simply, because they are not unrelated. It would be duplication to have two separate functions to do two tasks that have so much in common.
atakan_gurkan··on Lessons I wish I had learned before I started teaching differential equations [pdf] (1997)
I really would like to learn Rota's thoughts on Arnold's book on ODEs. I love that book, but I cannot recommend it easily since it has little overlap with our undergraduate curriculum DE course (in a physics department).
atakan_gurkan··on Icecream: Never use print() to debug again in Python
Which debugger would you recommend?
atakan_gurkan··on This $12B Company is Monetizing Cheating
The solution of course is not to prevent cheating, but to make it irrelevant. We need to find new ways to assess the student performance, such that cheating will be unnecessary or impractical, i.e., not worth it. There are ways for small classes (project based assessment), but these do not scale up easily.
atakan_gurkan··on Ask HN: How to Think Clearly?
Writing things down helps me a lot, so does making a sketch. Basically things that will lower your cognitive load, so you can use your brain on the problem.

For big projects, I have to write an outline. First big steps, then divide those into smaller and smaller ones. Again, always in writing. And somehow, paper and pencil works much better for me than electronic tools.

If you are talking about problems like physics problems, I highly recommend Reif's book: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/applying-cognitive-science-ed... and his papers on the subject (they are under "Physics Education Research"). Even if you are talking about other problems, reading these might provide some clues.

atakan_gurkan··on “Invalid username or password” is a useless security measure
The concerns about the denial of service attack, if an exponentially rising delay or similar lockout after a certain amount of login attempts are made, can be simply addressed by emailing an "unlock" email to the registered email address if a lockout takes place. That is, lock the account for 1/2 hours if there are a number of failed logins, but at the same time send an email that will allow logging in, by passing the lockout. Would this be a big security gap?
atakan_gurkan··on Frequentism and Bayesianism: A Practical Introduction
The follow-ups are also well worth reading:

http://jakevdp.github.io/blog/2014/06/06/frequentism-and-bay...

http://jakevdp.github.io/blog/2014/06/12/frequentism-and-bay...

http://jakevdp.github.io/blog/2014/06/14/frequentism-and-bay...

atakan_gurkan··on Ask HN: Is there a way to reinstate a community page suspended by Facebook?
According to their latest tweet https://twitter.com/RadikalAktivist/status/35326417912320000... The reason given was "content including nudity, pornography or sexual solicitation" (my translation)
atakan_gurkan··on OccupyGezi raises funds for full page ad
It is not black and white indeed, but you are painting a black and white picture yourself. You should ask your question about the Syrian refugees to BDP, CHP and TKP themselves, nobody can know what they are thinking.

The bottom line is: this is a grassroots movement. These parties are just piggybacking, perhaps because they see an opportunity for political gain, perhaps because for such a wide response inevitably some people who cannot disassociate themselves from their parties are also joining the protests.

atakan_gurkan··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
When the events were escalating, while there were clashes between the police and thousands of protesters and hundreds were walking across a bridge over the Bosphorus only one TV channel reported these. And you are dismissing this neglect of the media by "Some press reports things less than you like. Some reports with exaggeration."???

The events unfolding at the moment shows that it was possible to celebrate the May Day in Taksim. "This year there is construction so it was not allowed." does not hold water.

As I gave an example (the journalists being fired), it is not my opinion, it is a fact. And if you do not observe other examples around you then you are simply not looking. Of course every government benefits their supporters to some extent, but getting journalists fired? When was the last time did that happen? And regardless of this happening before or not, is it not suppression of free speech?

You say, "To me, Turkish Academy of Sciences issue is overrated", to me it is not. To a lot of my scientist friends it is not (For the record, I am an astrophysicist). People spent a lot time and energy to build the Turkish Academy of Sciences and the Feza Gürsey Institute. And I know these developments did hurt scientists for a fact; I work in a university and I am personally affected. They may be pouring more money into R&D but did you look at the projects in the last science project fair? http://www.sendika.org/2013/05/kuran-mucizesinden-seriat-huk... Do you recall what the Science and Technology minister said about faculties of science or the theory of evolution? That's where a lot of money is going. It is hard to quantize how much real science is getting.

The satellite is in the sky and the team that built that satellite is mostly fired. Pardus was an independent distribution, the team that built Pardus is also gutted and the distribution is now a (badly) translated Debian.

atakan_gurkan··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
The press could report on these events 10 years ago. Now they don't. The workers could celebrate May day in Taksim square just a few years ago, this year they were banned. People could express themselves more freely if they were not religious or if they were against the government. Now they fear retaliation, losing their job etc. This actually happened to journalists, they did lose their jobs. Hundreds are imprisoned without being convicted or even having a trial for months and years.

There are other indications that Turkey is turning into an Islamic (Sunni in particular) state and our culture is being destroyed. Scientists and artists are ridiculed routinely by the politicians in power. They destroyed Turkish Academy of Sciences. They shut down Feza Gürsey institute. They fired majority of people who made Pardus GNU/Linux distribution and Göktürk satellite from TÜBİTAK.

Unfortunately, this is no joke.

atakan_gurkan··on The Impact of the Megaupload Shutdown on Movie Sales
In my experience, a lot of biologists avoid debates on creationism because it is not a scientific theory. Getting into a debate as a scientist would suggest there is something to discuss scientifically, there is not. Richard Dawkins voiced this publicly many times.

Furthermore, and more importantly, avoiding public debate is very different from changing the results of your research. If you are implying that some people have results that support creationism and keep it to themselves, I would like to hear more about this. I cannot even imagine how you would conduct scientific research on creationism.

Another point: you are using the word "confess" which has negative connotations. It is perfectly normal for a funding agency to voice their concerns on, e.g., the design of an experiment, if they can think of an improvement. There is nothing wrong with this, there is nothing to "confess". In some cases the agency might be altering the design to game the results. That is wrong, of course; but your phrasing is too general.

If noone really knows, than maybe nothing substantial is happening. "slightly threatening phone-call from the funding agency" sounds near paranoid. And again, your wording is way too general. For example, it would include NASA (as the funding agency) ask a laboratory that is designing a detector to make modifications to allow higher resolution in higher energies.

atakan_gurkan··on Nobel laurate Andre Geim: Be afraid, very afraid, of the tech crisis
I went there from news.google.com and did not see a paywall (I am not registered w/ FT).
atakan_gurkan··on China Mafia-Style Hack Attack Drives California Firm to Brink
Your question is not fair. I am sure there are cases where NSA tried an attack and failed. It is a matter of how badly they want the attack to succeed. Just because you are being attacked by "the Chinese" does not mean they will put all their resources behind it.
atakan_gurkan··on Why Coke Cost A Nickel For 70 Years
The vending machine part of the story is a bit strange. Why did they not make a machine that would accept a dime and return a couple pennies with the coke?
atakan_gurkan··on Federal judge tosses Apple patent lawsuit against Motorola
"It seems that the disagreement is over the percentage model that Motorola wants. Motorola wants 2.25% of the full retail price of the device. So, if you make a dumbphone for $35, you pay 79cents. If you make a 16GB iPhone 5, you pay $14.63. Somewhat ridiculously, if you make a 64GB iPhone 5, you'd pay $19.13."

There is a simple solution: Sell iPhones w/ little memory and sell the memory separately. Of course, then other people can also sell that memory, probably at a cheaper price. If you want to charge a premium on memory, then you should let Motorola charge a premium, too.

atakan_gurkan··on Tonnes of iron dumped off B.C.'s coast
A simple product that encourages the growth of simple organisms can be harmful. Try pouring sugar to the pot of a plant. It will encourage the growth of bacteria which will compete with the plant for other nutrients in the soil and in the end harm the plant.

Messing with nature like this sounds like a bad idea. _This_ experiment is not necessarily bad, but the risk is too big if you ask me.

atakan_gurkan··on Monsanto Seed Patent Case Gets U.S. Supreme Court Review
That would not be analogous at all. An analogous example would be if you made an artificial human organ that (supposedly) serves an identical function, but is different enough that it is immune to certain diseases.
atakan_gurkan··on Depression lies
It is not that simple. In most brain studies I read there is a stroke or something like that which causes a lesion in the brain, and the changes came about after this. Since we already have a good idea where the change in the brain comes from, it is reasonable to assume the personality change is caused by it.
atakan_gurkan··on Y Combinator Founder Paul Graham Issues New Warning to Start-ups
As ugly as it may be, this is _business_, a.k.a. capitalism. Trying to interpret it as everyday human interaction using concepts like "ethics" will fail. Skip this step and try to decide whether you are comfortable or not without using these models from your past (human interaction) experience.
atakan_gurkan··on Whatever happened to kids' chemistry sets?
My guess is he meant Na.
atakan_gurkan··on Keyless BMW cars prove to be very easy to steal
If this is because of OBD regulations, perhaps it can be changed somewhat. Give the owner a small electronic device that will be necessary to generate a new key for the car they purchased. That device can be kept separate from the car but when the key is actually lost, the owner can bring it to the mechanic and generate a new one. The thieves would need to steal the device before stealing the car, which would make their job harder (and admittedly perhaps put the owner at greater danger).
atakan_gurkan··on Neutrinos from CERN to Gran Sasso Respect Cosmic Speed Limit
The numerical value is determined empirically, and as far as I know it is simply a result of our historical choice of length and time units.

The fact that there is a definite speed of light is also a property of nature but there is some "explanation". We know that space and time mix. When you speak of an event you need to state both position and time. When you speak about two events, you need to tell their relative position and time difference as well as a reference frame (by indicating its velocity). This separation of events in space and time will be different for different observers, if they are moving at different speeds. The way you transform this quantity includes a constant. When you write the equations governing the electromagnetic phenomena and require that the results obey these transformation rules, it turns out that this constant is the speed of the electromagnetic waves, which is of course light.

The event separation transformation rule dictates that no information can be transferred faster than this constant, the speed of light. Otherwise you can have two events A & B, where the A can influence B in one reference frame and B can influence A in another reference frame. This would lead to a contradiction.

These are explained much better in standard relativity texts. I'd recommend Rindler's "Essential Relativity" and Thorne's "Time Warps and Black Holes"'s first few chapters.

atakan_gurkan··on Neutrinos from CERN to Gran Sasso Respect Cosmic Speed Limit
There has been enough criticism from scientific community at large and more importantly from within the OPERA collaboration that their spokespeople resigned from their position.

Not much of that criticism coming from respectable scientists made it to mainstream media, though. I presume that is because they did not want to show a "holier than thou" attitude openly. But internally a lot of people thought "they must have done something wrong" and after they found the error "what were they thinking?".

I think your impression is wrong, but very understandable unless you interacted with people offering criticism directly or semi-directly through one or two persons.

atakan_gurkan··on Plagiarism
Plagiarism is not about copyright, it is about citing properly. A direct quote has to be indicated as such, a paraphrasing has to include a reference.

I learned this in my freshman year in college, this is so basic that an "editor" cannot claim ignorance of these rules.

atakan_gurkan··on Skinny fat founder strips for launch of startup
I certainly do not mean to dispute your experience, but others' mileage may vary. When you are burning fat, you produce ketones and brain can actually burn ketones, so you are not "starving" your brain. However, the psychological effect of low blood sugar might of course be hindering your productivity and mental capability.
atakan_gurkan··on People Aren't Smart Enough for Democracy to Flourish, Scientists Say
I am surprised that a normal distribution was used for the distribution of "leadership skills". I imagine this could be similar to income distribution which has fat tails. I wonder if the result would change if such a distribution was used.
atakan_gurkan··on The Zuckerberg Tax
Regardless of Jobs's and Ellison's intentions, they did avoid taxation despite accumulating large wealth. Furthermore, the people who inherit from them will not pay taxes over this accumulation of wealth, either. This could be a side effect, but it is a real effect.

It is possible to prevent the creep you are referring to, just decouple control from the wealth brought by the shares. After all, this is by design. You can distribute voting rights independent of the share of income. I realize one has to be intelligent about this, but I don't see how it is inherently impossible.

The good it brings is fairness. I am taxed on the wealth I accumulate, so should the others. Now, there are exceptions to this; e.g., very poor should not be taxed since that does more harm than good. Perhaps what is suggested in the article would also do more harm than good, but to me it looks like the harm can be prevented.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →