HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ataturk

264 karma · joined November 1, 2017

submissionscomments
ataturk··on US cell carriers are selling access to real-time phone location data
It's so strange--I never would have expected the boot of tyranny to come from private corporations, but here we are. And what all this proves is that technology is value-neutral and can wipe us all out, or just make us incredibly miserable, if we let it.

Hopefully there will be a way to opt out. Otherwise, I should start selling faraday bags for devices. Probably should anyways.

ataturk··on The Senate has forced a vote to restore net neutrality
It was Alinsky who instructed people on how to personalize politics. It is thus a tactic of the left. If conservatives are finally fighting back, that is to their credit.
ataturk··on Fake news was illegal in 17th century colonial Massachusetts
I worry because people today aren't reading history. They don't even have any idea what took place in the 1980s during the Soviet era and how the fall of communism shaped today's Europe. I think about the Czechs fighting back, all the intrigue of the two Germanys. Vietnam, Central America...

The other thing is, even though the media was always biased and agenda-driven, they weren't completely infiltrated by intelligence agencies and/or mega-corporations.

ataturk··on UK police say 92% false positive facial recognition is no big deal
Again, as mentioned above, read up on East Germany. All your questions about "why is this bad?" have already been lived by tens of thousands of hapless people.
ataturk··on 12-year study will look at effects of universal basic income
As someone who is friends who two different social workers and related to someone in family court diversions (think: parents getting their kids taken away and want them back) I can tell you that UBI isn't going to solve much of anything. These people have money to buy alcohol and cigarettes, and yet their kids go hungry and rely on school lunch programs, etc.

Also, I had a brother in law who was a raging alcoholic and stole money from his grade-school kids' piggy banks. He always had money for beer. Asshole. He did the world a favor and hung himself.

For all of them, their personal issues overwhelm their ability to be functional adults. They don't clean their houses, they don't mind their kids, they are addicted to various substances and lie about treatment, recovery, and lie about anything anytime it suits their needs in the moment. It's all lie, lie, lie.

There is nothing a UBI or anything else is going to accomplish for these people and it is a myth to believe that payments without oversight or qualifications will lead to positive outcomes. One would think the US's 50 year experiment with welfare would already provide more than enough data to prove that if you subsidize a behavior you get more of it.

Let people face death, then see how they act. Take their kids away, first, though. It's not the kids' fault their parents are deadbeats.

ataturk··on Why Men Love War (1984)
As someone who has probed the depths of his own "malevolence" in very anti-social ways (and with nothing to do with socially acceptable state-sanctioned acts) I understand what you are saying. However, "primates that talk" is not what we aspire to being, at least not me.

The enthusiasm that soldiers have for carrying out the policies of their leaders is what bothers me about them. It's really nothing to do with the basic mechanics of killing other than the outright cowardice that technology brings into it all.

ataturk··on NSA collected 500M U.S. call records in 2017, a sharp rise: official report
You're not the only one. What hurts the most for me is that I wrote my doctoral thesis on privacy back in 2003 and I touched on a number of these issues. 9/11 ruined my career, though. After 9/11, nobody wanted privacy or to even talk about privacy. I knew all this was going to happen. David Brin knew all this was going to happen, and so did a lot of other writers and pundits. And here we sit now, wondering what to do now that we have empowered a monster that without much more work is going to get us all killed.
ataturk··on A Criminal Gang Used a Drone Swarm to Obstruct an FBI Hostage Raid
From scratch, as in from bar stock and other raw metals? Yes, very easily, in fact. It's technology that is well over 200 years old. Machine guns are 100+ years old.

Making primers and smokeless powder might be tricky, but the mechanical stuff is easy peasy.

ataturk··on What I learned by living without artificial light
I'm way smarter at night. I wrote my dissertation between the hours of 10pm and 4am. Thus far, I have been unable to find an employer willing to tap into that.
ataturk··on Palantir is using War on Terror tools to track American citizens
My biggest issue with former military people is that their skills don't easily translate into any other fields and that their mindset is usually heavily canted towards statism, which is a big problem when you combine the kinds of surveillance technology we have with needing to turn a profit. It makes anything East Germany did look like they were underachievers.
ataturk··on Bill Joy: Why the Future Doesn't Need Us (2000)
I've read Kurzweil's books. Reflecting on them over time, I think he's kind of full of it. It's not that the material was un-interesting but rather that the claims he was making were a bit wild and overly-optimistic. I see the same kinds of flaws in the reasoning of many people of his generation, where they compile this list of truisms and try to get you from A->B but really the fundamental assumptions from A aren't that solid.

Kurzweil wants to live forever. He wants to become a cybernetic being. That was his undoing in those books--his desire to outlast death forced him to make wildly optimistic predictions.

The dangers facing us are not AI but simply mundane databases. Everything is being tracked these days. Compliance is being shoved down our throats. You are being watched on the Internet and in daily life. "But I have nothing to hide." Yes, you do. You just don't realize it. You should read up on how people were treated in East Germany and the Soviet Union because that is your future. Technology gives zero shits about humans.

ataturk··on Time to rebuild the web?
The little guy spreading ideas is not as easy as it was, though. If the search engines don't index your site, if Youtube removes the informative videos you made, if FB and Instagram are filtering you out, who is going to see it?

No, the Web has been weaponized by a collusion between corporations and government in order to press as hard as they can for censorship and thought control. Because at the end of the day, if people realized they didn't need big government or big corporations, where would that leave all these billionaires with their revolving doors in and out of publicly appointed power roles?

I honestly get depressed when I think about the dream of open government and more widespread knowledge that was supposed to come about with all this technology working for the little guy. Well, some of it came true, but as soon as it became a threat to the orthodoxy, they found a way to shut it down. And now the baseline model for all these companies is China. Google would be happy to censor Americans in the same way they censor content for the Chinese Communists. One policy for the whole world, and it's not a policy of freedom and openness, but one of oppression, as usual.

ataturk··on The Case Against an Autonomous Military
The Framers of the US Constitution were rightly concerned about standing armies. Not that anyone cares about any of it at this point--we're all going to go through hell again, probably nuclear hell, then people will understand.

Seriously, how much death and destruction does the US need to mete out on an annual basis, regardless of drones or what have you? All this tech has done is empower the worst, most brutal people.

ataturk··on Another Tesla on autopilot steers towards a barrier
I just don't understand the willingness people have to put their lives in the hands of unproven technology like this. I mean, I don't even trust regular old cruise control in my cars and I keep my finger on the "cancel" button whenever I use it during long highway drives.
ataturk··on I wandered off and built an IDE
Every place I have ever worked had that same kind of shitty Excel/Access pile of crap including the manual instructions. It's like people can't understand that if you can write down a procedure for someone to follow you can automate that procedure.
ataturk··on [dead]
A thinly-veiled ad for whatever consulting business they are.
ataturk··on YouTube and Reddit roll out new restrictions including channel and sub bans
"I have no sympathy towards gun use."

But you see you should because if the government in conjunction with private industry can ban the thing you don't like today, it can also ban the things you do like tomorrow.

You'll probably finally understand when the books start burning because that's right around the corner now.

ataturk··on Police Say Video Shows Woman Stepped Suddenly in Front of Self-Driving Uber
What sort of little bubble do you live in? Where I live people get pretty good utility out of their sport utility vehicles! We have had a ton of snow this winter, including a couple of storms where having ground clearance was key to getting around. The snow was coming down so hard that the plows couldn't keep up. I saw who got stuck and who didn't in that big storm. The interstates were a mess, secondary roads had 2' banks where plows had only gone through in one direction. Front-wheel drive cars and minivans were stuck everywhere, as were tractor trailers, RWD cars without snow tires, and so forth. Everything AWD was still moving pretty well.

Now if you're saying people with true low and high range 4wd trucks and SUVs don't go rock crawling with them that much, that's probably true, but those vehicles have a lot of utility doing things like pulling a boat trailer up a wet boat ramp, driving on a frozen lake to go ice fishing, and driving on farm roads or other unimproved surfaces.

ataturk··on Navy Medics Get Prepared for Combat with Tour of Duty in Chicago
We should not overlook the fact that in the 1970s, trauma surgeons practiced in the Bronx. Nothing ever really changes in the human condition, but new generations forget the old lessons.
ataturk··on California to Introduce 'Right to Repair' Bill
A step ahead? Didn't such a law already go down in flames in Idaho or someplace?
ataturk··on Who Killed the Junior Developer?
Welp, get back to me when you're 50 Mr. Senior and we'll see how you fared over the long haul. Because "coding monster" or not, when you hit 40, companies will be less enthusiastic about hiring you, and by the time you're 50, you'll be out, so I hope you're making bank right now and saving as much of it as you possibly can because there are no do-overs.
ataturk··on Is developer compensation becoming bimodal?
The reasons underlying the bi-modality are pretty clear to me. There are a couple of major factors at play:

1) Inflation. My starting salary out of college many years ago was $35K. Today's starting salaries are double that. Double in less than 20 years. A $50K salary in the early 1980s is equivalent to $120K today, not controlling for geographic location--HCOL areas are actually far worse than that. Let that sink in as you plan for retirement. My take is that you are never going to save enough for retirement because inflation is insidious and never sleeps.

2) The mythology of the higher salary range. How do developers get past that second mode? They start their own company! Only a few rarified corporate people and independent consultants can pull down pay in the 200s. Again, I'm not thinking about SV where the pay is so skewed due to the HCOL. So everyone else works a number of years and ends up in the 120s-150s and they think they are doing great, but they really aren't (me included) due to #1.

Any way you look at doing software development as a career you come to see that it stinks. I'm not going to recommend it to my kids. I think it's important to know how computers work and how code works and not to be afraid of tinkering with those things or coming to believe that you have no control over it, but as a business, it's nasty and getting nastier.

ataturk··on “The effects of lifelong exposure to a perverse contingency” (2002)
It's more of a cautionary tale about dealing with people--I can't count the number of times I've been in some kind of work situation where the people above me believed in some absolute folklore that was detrimental to the execution of the work but they would 100% argue with anyone trying to be reasonable about what was really going on. It's like a learned helplessness, or some kind of odd comfort with the status quo. They would invent from whole cloth a whole belief system about how some software worked that was completely irrational. I include IT admin people here, not just non-techies. And the thing is, I've seen it happen more than once amongst otherwise intelligent people!

So then you're in a situation where the believers begin to exert their authority over you in order to control the situation and back up their beliefs instead of trying to solve the problem, up to and including threats of termination. It's as though they might suffer emotional harm if you fix the actual underlying problems that caused the whole need to create the belief system in the first place. Those behaviors are that strong and that lizard-brained.

One example: A transaction issue (actually the lack of a proper transaction) in a database was causing duplicate order numbers to occur pretty frequently each day on a large, multi-user system. Instead of getting someone competent to come in to analyze and fix the issue, the people at the company developed all these elaborate procedures for how to enter orders so that they could avoid creating duplicates in the system. They had actual written procedures and even the work schedules were affected by this order entry bug. I swear they were twirling around three times and throwing salt over one shoulder before entering a new order, but only on odd-numbered Wednesdays and Fridays.

I've seen similar problems involving thread local data and badly written multithreaded code, odd caching issues on networks relating to AJAX calls from certain browsers, network setup issues, you name it.

There, but for the grace of God, go I.

ataturk··on In a society obsessed with success, how do we come to terms with failure?
First world problems!

I competed in two different Olympic sports and although I attended the Junior Olympics for one of the (big whoop, right?) and didn't place, I never once thought I was a loser--you just look at the competition and how a mere few seconds determines the winner versus going home with nothing. People have peak days, others are just a tiny bit off. What I realized is that greatness has a component of luck to it. I figured I was lucky to be able to compete there at all. There are letdowns for sure, but you're not competing with others as much as you are competing with yourself.

ETA--Having attended the Olympic Training Center around age 16, I can't tell you how depressing it was to see 20 and 30-something athletes living in the dorms there, striving for their moment of glory while everyone else was out having fun, working, starting families, etc. I look back at that as the moment I made a very conscious choice to focus on having a career. Olympic sports aren't pro sports, you aren't getting endorsement deals unless you're in one of the "popular" sports like swimming or downhill skiing.

ataturk··on Allstate uses social media to check claims
And install a tracking device in your car so we catch watch your every move and second guess everything you do while driving.
ataturk··on AI is going to supercharge surveillance
It is amazing how on the one hand people can detest Nazis and Soviets saying things like "I can't believe they could have been so stupid to have gone along with that" and then on the other hand, aid and abet the police state in a Kaggle competition of all things! I know it is naive of me to think that if I don't assist that it won't happen because someone will step up if for no other reason than bragging rights.

A long time ago I made a decision about my career and that was that I would not work for the MIC. It was a tough choice at times because so much US industry is involved with government one way or another and even private companies have governments as their major customers so it is all intertwined. Not all government is bad, though, but the shit like body scanners and all that--that's your technocratic police state writ large.

I don't imagine the future is going to be very rosy. It is top down control forever.

ataturk··on Scientists move Doomsday Clock ahead to 2 minutes to midnight
Does it ever move back? I mean, I've read this same article a half dozen times over the past 20 years or so and I keep wondering what kind of clock it is that is perpetually 5 mins. to midnight but can move two minutes forward all the time and yet NEVER REACH FREAKING MIDNIGHT?
ataturk··on The Lost Art of Staying Put
A lot! Post-industrialism is a huge problem. Most of Upstate NY is one ghost town after another punctuated by art studios and phoney-baloney tourist towns with a "pedestrian mall" which is just a bricked over main street with some landscaping added. All for the benefit of the massive state workforce, I guess. Anyone who can escape has escaped. Imagine my surprise on going back to visit my elderly parents after an 8 year hiatus only to find that absolutely nothing had changed! Nothing. That's not to say all of NY is like that, but I'm astounded at how very little economy there really is in that whole region. The mega-city has killed the rest of that political boundary, killed it dead.

It's sad what the US has become overall. We imagine sprawling futuristic cities and there's not a single one anywhere. Everywhere that isn't what I just described in some variation of bedroom community with endless strip malls and suburban blight and as you get closer to whatever city, then the urban blight takes over--mostly to do with trucking, warehouses, and so forth. There's little industry anywhere, just armies of people sitting behind computers while sipping coffee in climate-controlled offices. The 21st century is truly strange.

What's also truly strange is that it is nearly impossible to get "off the beaten path" anywhere on the east coast. The Eastern US is unending sprawl beginning somewhere near the Maine border all the way to Miami. You can still get away in the Northwest, Montana, and the Dakotas and maybe also down the center of "Flyover Country" but that's about it. Okay, the Upper Peninsula of Michigan is sufficiently remote, too.

ataturk··on Starting an ISP is hard (2016)
I worked at #1! The place all this went bad was when big cable and AT&T got into the game and flushed out all the rest of the competition.

Comcast is a reprehensible company from top to bottom--the pricing sucks, cable tv sucks, bundling sucks, and their customer service SUCKS! So I won't do business with them and am relegated to crappy DSL from Frontier which also SUCKS, just not as bad as Comcast as a company. How did we ever get into this situation?

Granted the ISP I worked at was mostly dialup at the time, but they ran a decent business with decent service. The Mom & Pop ISPs in the rural areas were so cool back then--real American entrepreneurs, which starkly contrast with the robber barons.

ataturk··on Community-Owned Fiber Networks: Value Leaders in America
So you think government infallible? I guess you look at Comcast and go "what a bunch of assholes" am I right? The problem is that the same people who work at Comcast also work in government. There's a really good reason why Americans are fed up with government, and it's not because of talk radio--it's because incompetence is very well identified at all levels.

Yeah, I hate Comcast. Maybe enough to give municipal a go. But I doubt very much that in the long run municipal Internet will end up anything but a cluster from top to bottom.

Infrastructure is simply hard--it has to pretty much be a monopoly with all the problems that monopolies create. It won't matter if it is a government monopoly or a private one at that point. At least with Comcast I can tell them to screw off and buy shitty DSL (true story, I did!). With government my only choice is to move.

By the way, all the cities around mine have muni liquor stores. Only my city has privately run stores. The privately runs stores are way better. My city is also the only one that has private trash collection. The prices aren't a hair's difference, though. It doesn't matter except that if I don't want my trash picked up I am free to take it to the dump myself and pay to drop it off there instead. It would save maybe $10 a month, e.g. not worth it.

In the end, I just want ethical companies selling me fast broadband. I don't really trust our city or county to do Internet when they screw up so many simpler things all the time. They have enough to do and enough people on the payroll.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →