HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

atweiden

566 karma · joined June 1, 2013

submissionscomments
atweiden··on Starting a crypto project
There’s a difference between the cryptocurrency world’s definition of “innovation”, and solving longstanding problems for humanity.

How does Bitcoin solve inequality?

How does Bitcoin solve world hunger?

How does Bitcoin solve disease?

Bitcoin — and cryptocurrencies more broadly — do none of those things, with only one notable exception. Bitcoin — being a global currency of fixed supply — stands to usher in a global deflationary economic system. Investors in a deflationary environment have little incentive to invest in the future, and consumers have little incentive to spend. These two things could grind the caustic consumerism destroying our planet’s natural ecosystems to a halt. However, there’s room for interpretation even here; many humans would likely not trade off their own survivability for that of the planet’s natural ecosystems.

All of the hullaballoo about “Defi” and Ethereum only amounts to a Wall Street reskin, i.e. better high brow gambling. This does nothing for humanity either. Very innovative (!), lots of money being made, nicely exascerbating inequality of course. But achieves nothing.

(The S&P is actually down since 1970 as measured in gold [1]. Wall St is a carnival, and defi is just that carnival, squared.)

[1]: https://www.longtermtrends.net/stocks-vs-gold-comparison/

atweiden··on Starting a crypto project
“Bitcoin maximalist” is a pejorative invented by Vitalik Buterin circa the Ethereum ICO. It’s best understood as a laxative for one’s disposable income, prescribed by the Ethereum doctors to be imbibed by would-be altcoin investors.

Altcoin promoters quickly attached themselves to the term for financially motivated reasons, unsurprisingly. Notably it has little to no meme/entertainment value: its value is strictly limited to psychological warfare, and is rooted in sophistry.

atweiden··on UFOs shows government competence as either surprisingly high or low
> This assumes resource competition, which isn't a guarantee. Colonialism was driven by the need for open markets, resources, and vanity satisfaction from a declining class of European elites.

What about enslavement? Here Hawkings / Neil deGrasse Tyson make another interesting point: any civilization which could peacefully colonize a galaxy is not the kind of civilization that would colonize the galaxy at all. The very act of wanting to colonize self-selects for violence/exploitation.

> It's very likely that we don't have anything that a technologically advanced civilization would actually need. In this case, the situation would be more akin to Amazon coexisting with brick and mortar coffee shops, and less like Netflix competing with video rental shops.

Surely any civilization advanced enough to master interstellar travel would be better than we are at gathering intelligence and predicting humanity’s next move, which for all we know might threaten their interests.

If extraterrestrials are silently monitoring humans, isn’t it more likely to be for intelligence gathering purposes than for altruistic reasons? If the monitoring were intended to be altruistic, where’s the proof of the altruism?

atweiden··on UFOs shows government competence as either surprisingly high or low
As Stephen Hawkings and Neil deGrasse Tyson have quipped, in Earth’s history, any time a more technologically advanced civilization has come across a less technologically advanced civilization, it has never ended well for the less technologically advanced civilization.

Any hypothetical which places a group of extraterrestrials capable of interstellar travel on Earth is fundamentally a catastrophe. It’s a lot like discussing an imminent asteroidal impact.

There is absolutely no reason to believe any human-extraterrestrial contact would end well for humanity. If anything, I’d expect it to be like playing a chess game against an AGI where the loser gets “terminated”.

Anyway, the basic human need to expediently file away all low likelihood ideas into the deep recesses of the brain, never to be examined; the proliferation of general con artistry rooted in financial desperation; and the immense social stigma attached to the pursuit keep people from contemplating the potential of extraterrestrial intelligence. None of those are an especially good reason.

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
GP asked how a company like Apple would be made more efficient by becoming a “DAO”. A DAO acolyte — miketery is assuredly invested in a closely linked cryptocurrency — then opined Apple would save money on dividend distributions by becoming a DAO. And that shareholder voting would become more efficient. Yet neither thing requires having a DAO, assuming efficiencies are even possible to obtain that way.

I’m sorry, but I don’t see how what you posted is relevant to this discussion.

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
> Taproot will enable better privacy on bitcoin and more efficient transactions. It will not enable an EVM-like smart contract system.

You can already price EVM transactions in Bcash: https://smartbch.org/

(Notably Bcash has chosen to do “Ethereum on Bitcoin” using a sidechain, rather ironic from a historical perspective)

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
> It's not exactly the same, but this rings at least somewhat similar to what Ethereum is going through - the demand is pretty clearly there (people are willing to pay very hefty transaction fees to use it), and scaling solutions are just starting to launch that are enabling entirely new features, which I imagine will unlock another wave of demand.

This is notable for confusing “demand” with speculation-fueled investment.

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
A fairer comparison would be to that of MtGox, three years earlier, in which approximately 10X as much money was stolen from early Bitcoiners, but which did not result in any clawback of funds.

Conversely, in the “billion bitcoin bug” situation, no funds were stolen from anyone — 51% of mining power merely chainforked to a non-buggy version of the network. FWIW an identical situation could happen today on Bitcoin via a 51% attack, but it probably would be rejected in exactly the same way and for exactly the same reasons.

In both the MtGox and Ethereum DAO incident, the underlying network was functioning normally; but only one resulted in a clawback of funds from a sovereign entity. Notably, Ethereum had been advertising itself under the banner of “unstoppable applications” up to that point. Seemingly it’s a case of “unstoppable applications, not unstoppable applications”.

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
> Voting, and dividend distribution today requires intermediaries (e.g. broker). Those can be direct.

Issuing dividends in a cryptocurrency would disintermediate brokers and doesn’t require a DAO. Nor does “let’s upgrade our voting systems” require a DAO.

atweiden··on D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs”
The worst part about reading these articles is how you can immediately tell they’re an advertorial for Ethereum. You’re one sentence into it, and you can already tell the target market is your disposable income. It makes you feel hustled. Like the internet equivalent of a one-room shop in a third world country.
atweiden··on Opera adds native support for blockchain domain names
If the blockchain manipulates balances according to the whims of a court, then manipulating the court becomes a potential source of revenue for anyone able to game the system.

But if the blockchain doesn’t manipulate balances according to the court, and the court decides half of your crypto equities in $WALLET now belong to someone else, then at that moment in time the blockchain’s account balances become inaccurate. These types of events happen not infrequently, which creates a problem.

Perhaps blockchain property titles will make my point easier for you to understand. Say you own the house at 187 Blue Kodiak Drive, and the title is an “NFT” recorded on the blockchain. The NFT must be respected (!). Then a court steps in and assigns ownership of 187 Blue Kodiak to a bank, because it turns out you haven’t been paying your mortgage. But wait, the blockchain still says you own the home at 187 Blue Kodiak Drive (!). However, you don’t own it anymore — not legally, not physically.

Now pretend the blockchain on which the 187 Blue Kodiak Drive house title is recorded dutifully obeys the commands of the court which in our previous example allowed the bank to repossess it. In our previous example, that’d be just fine — after all, you haven’t been paying your mortgage. But now the issue changes: The Pink Panther slides his way into the court one day, and one way or another convinces an decision-making authority there that you’ve sold him the home at 187. The Pink Panther is now in possession of the title, and you’re out of luck.

Ultimately, this criticism of smart property has been around for many years now. It wasn’t my intent to “surprise” you with it. However, people invested in tangentially related crypto systems tend to really struggle with this. That’s because public blockchains were never designed to track non-bearer assets which exist in in the real world. Unlike companies built by humans or real estate, the (public) blockchain exists only in cyberspace, and therefore any ownership data of company shares or real estate recorded on the blockchain can only ever be an approximation of the truth. Permissioned blockchains — or simple databases for that matter — tend to be a better fit for situations such as this. The issue with them is they don’t take investors.

atweiden··on “Shared libraries are not a good thing in general”
> Given these, it seems worthwhile to re-evaluate the tradeoffs that come with dynamic linking

Perhaps this is just a Linux distro thing, but as someone who closely monitors the Void packages repo, dynamic linking burdens distro maintainers with hundreds of additional packages which need to be individually tracked, tested and updated.

(Packages which could otherwise be vendored by upstream and statically linked during the build.)

Dynamic linking also adds complexity to distro upgrades, because dependant packages often need to be rebuilt when the libraries they dynamically link to are changed or upgraded. For example, Void’s recent switch from LibreSSL to OpenSSL borked my install script which wasn’t aware of the change. It resulted in a built system whose XBPS package manager couldn’t verify SSL certs. On Arch, AUR packages were notoriously prone to dynamic linking errors (back when I still used it).

Personally, I don’t find the bandwidth efficiency and CVE arguments for dynamic linking to be all that convincing [1]:

    Will security vulnerabilities in libraries that have been statically
    linked cause large or unmanagable updates?

    Findings: not really

    Not including libc, the only libraries which had "critical" or "high"
    severity vulnerabilities in 2019 which affected over 100 binaries on
    my system were dbus, gnutls, cairo, libssh2, and curl. 265 binaries
    were affected by the rest.

    The total download cost to upgrade all binaries on my system which
    were affected by CVEs in 2019 is 3.8 GiB. This is reduced to 1.0
    GiB if you eliminate glibc.

    It is also unknown if any of these vulnerabilities would have
    been introduced after the last build date for a given statically
    linked binary; if so that binary would not need to be updated. Many
    vulnerabilities are also limited to a specific code path or use-case,
    and binaries which do not invoke that code path in their dependencies
    will not be affected. A process to ascertain this information in
    the wake of a vulnerability could be automated.
[1]: https://drewdevault.com/dynlib
atweiden··on Fediverse.Party – Explore Federated Networks
It’s notable how prevalent AGPLv3 licensing is all throughout the Fediverse. This, and the fact user accounts are decoupled from the federated frontends present a radically different incentive structure for providers compared to the traditional model of social media.

You can feel the impact this has when browsing PeerTube: eclectic videos — a good sign of a burgeoning ecosystem — but with video buffering rates seemingly decades behind YT.

I’m actually a huge fan of the fediverse. But if PeerTube in particular wants to hit it big, there are some serious scalability issues which need to be addressed, despite fediverse development being largely antithetical to profit.

atweiden··on SSD makers start warning that mining products like ChiaCoin will void warranty
Every aspect of cryptocurrency save for one either fails to solve any societal issue, exascerbates existing ones, or is otherwise hype entrepreneurship.

But the deflationary global economic system Bitcoin facilitates disincentivizes mass consumerism — mass consumerism which is destroying the world’s natural ecosystems. This is only possible via a global currency of fixed supply controlled by computer algorithms. Bitcoin’s creator invented this. It is an innovation, in every sense.

Deflationary economics discourages capital investment, because it rewards saving — i.e. “hoarding” — not spending or investing. Assuming a Bitcoin-based economic system, as the pace of technological advancement continues to quicken, and more products and services hit the market, absolute BTC-denominated prices will have to decrease. More products and services on the market, with a fixed supply of money, equals lower absolute prices.

In addition, global adoption of a free-market money like Bitcoin would eliminate the ability of governments to fund weapons of war and public works projects by printing their own money. That would no longer be possible.

Bitcoin throttles humanity, and with it humanity’s ecological destructiveness could be kept at bay. No other aspect of cryptocurrency is of societal value in any way.

atweiden··on SSD makers start warning that mining products like ChiaCoin will void warranty
> The interesting thing about cryptocurrency is not that it facilitates illegal activities, but that it does very little else - and that is in fact quite different from the rest of your list.

How can the same people who make this argument turn around and in the same breath decry Bitcoin for being nothing more than a speculative store of value? You can’t have it both ways.

No one buys Bitcoin to spend it. This much is abundantly clear. And Bitcoin, as an inflation-proof global currency of fixed supply controlled by computer algorithms, never had to do anything other than sit there as an idle speculation to fulfill its primary role as safest safe haven asset. That’s what makes it such a powerful idea.

atweiden··on SSD makers start warning that mining products like ChiaCoin will void warranty
Bitcoin is the #1 SoV because:

1) it was launched fairly by a person who uniquely had no reasonable expectation of profit when doing so,

2) it was launched first, giving it first-mover advantage, and

3) its proprietors made the very wise choice from 2015-2017 of censoring their populist opponents pushing for Bitcoin to become PayPal 2.0, and instead euphemistically refering to Bitcoin as “digital gold” — the speculative store of value to end all speculative stores of value

The very fact you’ve asked this question in full knowledge of owning both BTC and altcoins whilst also alluding to altcoins being more valuable, and the fact readers can only possibly act on your narrative by investing in the coins to which you allude — obviously only as a speculative store of value — just goes to show why Bitcoin is #1. Cryptocurrencies are simply nothing more than speculative stores of value, there are no exceptions.

atweiden··on SSD makers start warning that mining products like ChiaCoin will void warranty
> It has so far produced nothing except higher values measured in fiat. And the higher the values go the more resources needed for the computer networks.

That isn’t strictly true. Before the advent of Bitcoin, there was no global currency of fixed supply controlled by computer algorithms. That simple academic experiment was quickly infiltrated by profiteers, however. Most people never cared to cultivate an understanding of Bitcoin beyond the barest of surface level understandings, and these same people are now able to finger point at blatantly self-serving get-rich-quick ICO projects — like Ethereum and Chia — which have clearly achieved nothing in spite of endlessly promising investors “innovation”.

The only thing innovative that has ever come out of the Bitcoin space is Bitcoin itself: a speculative store of value. Every national currency is similarly speculative, and people who “missed” Bitcoin are loathe to admit the same thing that happened to gold’s market capitalization prior to its ubiquitous use as money, is now happening to Bitcoin.

atweiden··on The End of the Road
What Neanderthals did to Homo Erectus, and what early indigenous Homo Sapien tribes did to Neanderthals; later indigenous tribes did to earlier indigenous tribes; and so on and so forth.

At no point was the land homesteaded — by indigenous tribes or otherwise — ever fully unoccupied prior, by some definition of “unoccupied”. Intelligent lifeforms had to be driven from their rightful homes by “invaders”, categorically.

Nomads in antiquity — oweing to the lack of societal advancement — could settle air quotes “unoccupied” land. This is no longer possible in the modern, advanced world where every square inch of earth is claimed by a reasonably well-organized group of (highly violent) people, at minimum. Which means nomadism in today’s world isn’t what it once was. Nomadism in antiquity might even be viewed as outright nation building; after all, every nation has to start somewhere. But nomadism in modernity — and I say this as someone with a reasonable level of experience backpacking in various countries — is really just glorified homelessness, and I think that’s a point worth making.

atweiden··on Opera adds native support for blockchain domain names
What about people being sued for damages, or creditors laying claim to the assets? There are endless cases where a court can unilaterally decide your assets are not your assets any longer.

Also, your hypothetical solution to the blockchain not reflecting court orders in the narrow case of divorce law is to ensure every married buyer of a crypto equity has a prenuptual agreement in place in their crypto wallet. Can you think of any problems with that plan?

atweiden··on Ask HN: How did you transition from FTE to self-employed/sole proprietor?
In the US, decent health insurance plans are all corporate. Particularly if you want something non-HMO with reasonable out-of-state coverage.

A few states have laws on the books which compel health insurance companies there to sell corporate health insurance plans to sole proprietors and single member LLCs. Florida is one example.

(Florida also tends to have some of the best health insurance options in general in the US, at least as of several years ago.)

Sadly, just because the state law says health insurers must sell corporate plans to sole proprietors and single member LLCs doesn’t mean those health insurers will happily sell you a corporate plan without a fight. For example, I tried to buy a corporate health insurance plan via a Florida sole proprietorship, per the state law. Every Florida insurer I contacted refused to sell me a corporate plan.

I ended up calling the FL regulators who ensured me Florida law indeed does compel these companies to sell me the plan. They either just didn’t want to sell me the plan, or their corporate division was entirely unfamiliar with working with sole proprietors. I left the US shortly thereafter.

If I were in the US, I’d try for a corporate plan again, maybe even in Florida. Unless something has changed, the alternative is far worse. E.g. paying $600+ per month for a plan with essentially zero out-of-state coverage, a deductible so high it almost makes no sense to even have the insurance plan at all for a healthy young person, and a bunch of weasely out clauses that let them screw you over even if you pay them ludicrous sums of money. Plus if you’re on an individual plan, the health insurers tend to systematically deprioritize you compared to their corporate customers who have far more bargaining power than you do. I would sooner go uninsured, or leave the US entirely.

atweiden··on A brief history of Rust at Facebook
I just got done cowboy coding 2500 lines of unchecked input validation code in Rust. While I didn’t particularly enjoy writing Rust — the syntax has taken some getting used to — I also don’t expect to enjoy writing anything in the domain of C or C++. What I did enjoy was correcting the hundreds of errors which had accumulated over the course of several days without checking the code at all, thanks in large part to rust-analyzer and VSCode.

On the cmdline, rustc displays gorgeous error messages — easily the best compiler error messages I’ve seen from any programming language — and Cargo is a dependency manager and build tool without equal. The Rust ecosystem in general is already quite large. Although I’m a neophyte at coding Rust, I haven’t run into an error message yet that StackOverflow or Reddit didn’t end up resolving.

On paper, Rust saves companies money by eliminating the memory safety bugs which would otherwise show up in C/C++ code. At the same time, Rust’s developer tooling ends up being so ergonomic to work with, and the language sufficiently expressive and flexible, that I can see Rust competing in areas beyond those reserved for C/C++.

IMO Rust is basically OCaml for the 21st century. My bet is on Rust usurping C/C++, and I expect Rust’s rise will be nothing short of meteoric over the coming years. The involvement of Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft and Google in the Rust Foundation bodes particularly well for this, as do informal surveys of developers which consistently show tremendous grassroots enthusiasm for the language. Just my 2c: but bet on Rust, bet heavily on Rust, and bet on Rust immediately, without delay.

atweiden··on Opera adds native support for blockchain domain names
> You could hold a non-complying party in jail/contempt of court for one, this happens with real world assets that do not get turned over now.

This doesn’t appear to resolve the issue of the blockchain reflecting a different reality than that decided by a court.

> But again there are implementation of blockchain solutions, where say the Company that issued shares did so on a smart contract and with a Court order they could burn half the tokens/stock in the wallet mint that same number and transfer them to the wife per the Court order.

How would this hypothetical court order be verified without the involvement of trusted third parties? Presumably judges in many places could be bribed or coerced into rubber stamping such an order.

This seems ripe for abuse.

atweiden··on Opera adds native support for blockchain domain names
> Usually the "Dole" case is the most famous example, where you have a publicly traded company with all the benefits of corporate record keeping, stock trusts and banks, and centralized stock exchanges, but when the buyer went to take it private low and behold the public company with all the centralized safe guards in the world should have had a total capitalization of 36M shared but somehow had about 49M share issued, it only ended up in $150M in damages, but this could not have happened using blockchain and most agree nearly every publicly traded company likely would have the same inconsistencies.

This sounds like a technology problem for which a public blockchain is but one possible solution. Surely other append-only log data structures exist which could step in to fill this void.

AFAICT the main issue with crypto equities — and all other similar constructs — is what happens when a court of law overrides them. If a court says your ex owns half of the shares in $WALLET, but the blockchain doesn’t, and $COMPANY which issued the shares is also subject to the whims of the court, then what are we to do about this?

OTOH maybe this rabbit hole really just never ends until courts are also somehow replaced by a public blockchain, likely at the behest of the very biased investors who stand to disproportionately profit from this game.

atweiden··on The End of the Road
We’ve never homesteaded truly unoccupied land by some definitions of “unoccupied”. Depending on how far back we want to take the social justice, even Neanderthals drove out earlier pre-humans from their rightful homes, however sporadically inhabited and/or poorly defended they might’ve been.

Regardless, I think it’s a horrible critique of the miserably dystopic political climate we’re in today that such plain statements about factual reality can’t even be made without someone feeling it necessary to call attention to a more recent historical example of the powerful driving out the powerless — a dynamic which has been with humans and every other creature on this planet since time immemorial.

Nomadism in antiquity had at least some chance of resulting in zero cost homesteading for those brave people willing to endanger their own lives to engage in it. It was more a reflection on the hidden plight of modernity — not being able to afford a home, despite our forefathers being able to just homestead at zero up front cost mere centuries ago — than a projection of jealousy or some other contrivance.

atweiden··on The End of the Road
At some point in antiquity, it was feasible for human adults to settle “unsettled” land. It is a boring and simple fact that this is no longer possible. TFA used an example from the 1800s, so I stuck with that era. This is getting off topic.
atweiden··on The End of the Road
These days anywhere desireable to live, and likely all known available farm land, is already owned by someone or some company.

Vagabonding isn’t what it used to be, insofar as there is seemingly not even the remotest chance in modernity of backdooring your way into zero cost homesteading. Societal advancement has come at the cost of those opportunities which have more or less vanished.

atweiden··on The End of the Road
> After some months spent living in a shack in town, the Ingalls family claimed a plot of land through the Homestead Act, one of the country’s earliest large-scale social welfare programs, which promised free land to white settlers willing to cultivate it. After five years, if a family could “prove up,” showing they had built a profitable farm, they could keep it.

Centuries ago, home ownership was readily obtainable for anyone willing to endure the hardship of settling “the new world”. Case in point, the early Australian settlers essentially paid nothing for enormous swathes of farm land [1]:

> From about 1815 Sydney began to grow rapidly as free settlers arrived from Britain and Ireland and new lands were opened up for farming. Despite the long and arduous sea voyage, settlers were attracted by the prospect of making a new life on virtually free land. Many settlers occupied land without authority; they were known as squatters and became the basis of a powerful landowning class.

In light of today’s hot housing market, and the increasingly burdensome restrictions on immigration, it’s difficult to fathom how easy it used to be to change your lot in life with just some gumption.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_history_of_Austral...

atweiden··on EV Charging Infrastructure in America Still Sucks
The 500 mile figure is roughly the range of a modern Toyota Camry. It’s just a useful baseline.

But as it happens, we’d drive 500 miles from Atlanta to St Louis every winter to visit our grandparents when we were growing up. I’m sure lots of people have relatives or friends they could visit who live about that far away.

Alternatively, Birmingham to Orange Beach is a bit shy of 300 miles one way. Atlanta to various popular beach vacation spots in Florida and South Carolina is roughly comparable. Beach vacation territory, IOW, is commonly several hundred miles one way.

atweiden··on EV Charging Infrastructure in America Still Sucks
I’m personally a lot happier not living in HCOL, noisy, polluted and just downright unsafe major metropolitan areas these days. The tradeoff is this precludes practicable EV ownership IME, at least at the current time. Even still, I’ve loved driving every EV I’ve had the opportunity to, and would be quite ecstatic were modern ICE vehicles to be entirely replaced by full EVs. (Classic and 90s era Japanese sports cars are another story.)
atweiden··on Pfizer is testing a pill that, if successful, could cure Covid-19
> America has poor control of its international borders and would be unconstitutional, not just unpopular, to lock down with a right of freedom of movement from state to state.

It was also arguably “unconstitutional” [1] for Australian states to close their borders with one another over the pandemic. Business magnate Clive Palmer sued Western Australia over its border closures, in fact, and even received backing from the Australian federal government [2].

Particularly in light of the patchwork framework surrounding state-mandated church closures in the US, the difference between Australia and the United States as it pertains to interstate border closures seems to be more a matter of cultural expectation, than legal impossibility. But IANAL.

US airports are highly controllable ports of entry. I think a lot more could’ve been done there had the population willed hard border closures into existence.

[1]: https://auspublaw.org/2020/08/border-closures-and-s-92-clive...

[2]: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/02/feder...

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →