HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

auntienomen

1,886 karma · joined October 4, 2012

submissionscomments
auntienomen··on Is particle physics dead, dying, or just hard?
There's always some risk of confusing the model with the reality, but yeah, if you have chiral fermions interacting through gauge fields and gravity, the charges have to say satisfy all of the anomaly cancellation conditions (there's about half a dozen) or the model will be inconsistent.
auntienomen··on Is particle physics dead, dying, or just hard?
There does appear to be a deeper reason, but it's really not well understood.

Consistent quantum field theories involving chiral fermions (such as the Standard Model) are relatively rare: the charges have to satisfy a set of polynomial relationships with the inspiring name "gauge anomaly cancellation conditions". If these conditions aren't satisfied, the mathematical model will fail pretty spectacularly. It won't be unitary, can't couple consistently to gravity, won't allow high and low energy behavior to decouple,..

For the Standard Model, the anomaly cancellation conditions imply that the sum of electric charges within a generation must vanish, which they do:

3 colors of quark * ( up charge 2/3 - down charge 1/3) + electron charge -1 + neutrino charge 0 = 0.

So, there's something quite special about the charge assignments in the Standard Model. They're nowhere near as arbitrary as they could be a priori.

Historically, this has been taken as a hint that the standard model should come from a simpler "grand unified" model. Particle accelerators and cosmology hace turned up at best circumstantial evidence for these so far. To me, it's one of the great mysteries.

auntienomen··on The Q, K, V Matrices
This might be the single best blog post I've ever read, both in terms of content and style.

Y'all should read this, and make sure you read to the end. The last paragraph is priceless.

auntienomen··on The Great Gatsby is the most misunderstood novel (2021)
No wonder Gatsby is frequently misunderstood: Most people won't have the experience needed to understand it until they're in their 30s, but we prescribe it for high schoolers year after year.
auntienomen··on The Great Gatsby is the most misunderstood novel (2021)
There is a good ending to Game of Thrones: evil wins, everyone dies. All the fools who pursued their own interests rather than face an annihilating threat get annihilated. It's right there in the show's motto. "Winter is coming."

The writers just lacked the courage to do it. They tried to tack a Disney ending onto a tragedy.

auntienomen··on AI's real superpower: consuming, not creating
A lot of the time, the definitions peculiar to a subfield of science _don't_ require much or any additional technical background to understand. They're just abbreviations for special cases that frequently occur in the subfield.

Looking this sort of thing up on the fly in lecture is a great use for LLMs. You'll lose track of the lecture if you go off to find the definition in a reference text. And you can check your understanding against the material discussed in the lecture.

auntienomen··on If you're going to vibe code, why not do it in C?
On a related note, I've always regarded Python as the best IDE for writing C. :)
auntienomen··on If you're going to vibe code, why not do it in C?
The answer is still "No".
auntienomen··on If you're going to vibe code, why not do it in C?
If the headline is a question, the answer is "No".
auntienomen··on Quanta to publish popular math and physics books by Terence Tao and David Tong
His foundations are still doing good work.
auntienomen··on A new bridge links the math of infinity to computer science
I think at this stage, most mathematicians recognize that formal proof verification is a real and interesting thing. We have extremely prominent mathematicians like Scholze & Tao making a point of using these tools.

But in many cases, it's extra effort for not much reward. The patterns which most mathemematicians are interested in are (generally) independent of the particular foundations used to realize them. Whether one invests the effort into formal verification depends on how hard the argument is and how crucial the theorem.

auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
Agree. In fact, I said the list included both genres in my original comment.
auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
I think there are 2 different series. The "SF Masterworks" seeme to be fans-liked-it, while the "Fantasy Masterworks" is editor favorites.
auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
The Ted Sturgeon of our era.
auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
The genres weren't always as defined and distinct. The early authors and especially the editors who popularized the genre frequently worked in both.
auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
If you like these books -- early classics of the genres -- it's going to be well worth your time to check out Fantasy Masterworks collection (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantasy_Masterworks). It's a set of reissued sci-fi and fantasy novels, chosen by the British publisher Millennium for their quality and influence on later writers.

3/5 of the books in the linked article are included.

It's not perfect-- it's missing War for the Oaks, for example, and doesn't have any Iain M Banks. But there's an awful lot of good material in there.

auntienomen··on My favorite cult sci-fi and fantasy books you may not have heard of before
Little, Big by John Crowley. Also everything else he's written.
auntienomen··on Who benefits from the MAHA anti-science push?
The quack rich kid is breaking the parts of NIH/CDC/etc that were working correctly. Writing that off as "some effect" ignores what we can already plainly see.
auntienomen··on Tesla is heading into multi-billion-dollar iceberg of its own making
I watched the same video. Karpathy isn't predicting AGI in 10 years. He's saying we won't have AGI in less than 10 years -- contrary to what industry boosters are promising -- and that what we end up with won't be some sort of god-in-a-box.
auntienomen··on Andrej Karpathy – It will take a decade to work through the issues with agents
Fusion is a lot closer than it used to be. In the last decade, research uncovered a relatively large regime that seems like it could be commercializable. I know a couple researchers who've recently exited academia / national labs to start commercial fusion power companies. Maybe they fail, but they're optimistic enough to make the bet.
auntienomen··on DOJ seizes $15B in Bitcoin from 'pig butchering' scam based in Cambodia
That's more of a crime film than a spy film. Worth watching though!
auntienomen··on Busy beaver hunters reach numbers that overwhelm ordinary math
The Compton wavelength will probably cause trouble for the storage scheme long before gravity becomes a problem.
auntienomen··on Why are there no good dinosaur films?
Yeah, it was bad. And then they really betrayed the story by trying to graft a happy ending on.

The only ending that makes any sense is "Everyone dies, the bad guys win, the end". It's right there in the story's motto: Winter is coming.

auntienomen··on What do wealthy people buy, that ordinary people know nothing about? (2015)
Jim Simons did in fact fund Brookhaven national lab directly at one point. His foundations and friends continue to fund a variety of scientific endeavors. But we don't have too many scholar-turned-philanthropists around, unfortunately.
auntienomen··on Why is C the symbol for the speed of light? (2004)
"Photons (being massless) have 100% of their velocity in the spatial dimensions and no velocity in the time dimension"

I kinda see what you're trying to say, but these words aren't a particularly good match for the math in special relativity. To an observer, any photon's velocity 4-vector looks like V = (c,c,0,0). That's a "c" in the spatial direction the photon's moving, and a "c" in the time direction. So, plenty of velocity in the time direction.

What is zero is the _proper time_ along a photon's trajectory through space & time. An observer who's co-moving with the photon (call me if you ever meet one, we can write a paper together) would see a) the photon holding still and b) no time passing.

auntienomen··on Mapping the University of Chicago's 135-year expansion into Hyde Park and beyond
And Rajun Cajun. :)
auntienomen··on Ask HN: What less-popular systems programming language are you using?
I've generally found it to be within a factor of 2 of hand-tuned C. (It's literally autogenerated C.) But implementation matters, and I doubt we're going to check your work here in the comments.
auntienomen··on Ask HN: What less-popular systems programming language are you using?
Cython. Writes like Python, runs like C. Strangely underappreciated.
auntienomen··on The young, inexperienced engineers aiding DOGE
They were allocated equally. The goal is to change that.
auntienomen··on Confusion, uncertainty in industry as Army contracts seemingly halted
He's been convicted of accounting fraud and he's nowhere near delivering the kind of returns that YCombinator seeks. Plenty of things to hold against him.
← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →