22,490 karma · joined November 2, 2011
Tweet @austen
https://bloomtech.com
austen@bloomtech.com
We are not profitable, so if it’s a scam it’s not a very good one.
Nothing about Lambda School is predatory and I have never lied.
You have to construct a chain of what-ifs to generate a scenario as bad as what is the default everywhere else (and it’s still better), yet you are constantly yelling about how evil we are. Perhaps just re-examine your priors?
In the past I have offered a bounty for you to point out even a single one of those things and you have never been able to do so.
Also every student is quite expensive. We gain nothing and lose a lot by enrolling students who don’t get hired.
If I take out a car loan for $20,000 I have not been paid $20,000.
I have never lied about this. Not once. My words are taken out of context to try to make it seem like I lied, but I did not.
The article is wrong in many different ways, this is only one of them.
A Stanford grad doesn’t know what the marginal cost of their enrollment is.
The financing is all cashflow management behind the scenes that doesn’t really matter.
Instead of running the entire school on venture capital, which wouldn't make sense (VCs need a huge return per dollar), we use an advance from investors based on the future value of an ISA to offset the cost.
If we work with investors to say that an ISA will be worth $x, we can borrow $x minus interest the same way you would be able to for any other asset.
Of course, that amount needs to be repaid. So it's still completely risk-aligned.
There has been a constant allegation that Lambda School sells its ISAs and therefore no longer has incentives that are aligned with students. The assertion is that, in “Big Short” style, we sell off all the risk of our students being placed to someone else and don’t have to care about outcomes.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
When Lambda School finances ISAs here’s how it works:
We get together with investors and say, “Based on past performance, we predict this ISA will be worth $x.” We can then receive an advance of $x, minus interest and a possible margin of error.
Importantly:
1. That amount needs to be paid back, plus interest. 2. If the value of the ISAs ends up being less than predicted, either we have to reimburse investors for the loss, or we won’t be able to continue borrowing in the future.
This is not a unique or predatory structure in any way.
If a student drops out, doesn’t get hired, or doesn’t pay back, Lambda School makes less money. If a student does great, gets hired, and pays back quickly, Lambda School makes more money.
This is not a scandal, and holds true to incentive alignment in any way. Lambda School remains entirely aligned with its students.
Of course if they used Google or Gmail or Chrome Google would make more money. Doesn’t have to be linked to the Internet itself.
It's not really hard to make my life $10/month better, and who knows how many people that is true for? I wouldn't overthink it.
What is the supply of workers? All things being equal the company will pay the least amount possible.
What is the demand for those workers? All things being equal the worker will work for the company that pays the most.
When you move from San Francisco to Des Moines, Iowa you shift markets. If you move from San Francisco to “the metaverse” you shift markets.
Facebook may have moved from a small handful of people able to do a job to a whole world of people. You may have moved from a small handful of opportunities to a world of opportunities.
It’s difficult to predict how prices will change, but they almost definitely will, and it’s not a matter of “holding out” or “negotiating” in the long run.
To me it sounds like a person with an obsession trying to scour the internet for anything potentially bad, and it’s just sad.
Elon’s flaws are pretty transparent. You don’t have to dig for them that hard.
It's still completely aligned, we just fast-forward some of the cash so we don't have to raise endless amounts of VC.
You are incorrect in your understanding of how ISA financing works. Our interests and incentives remain aligned.
The only times we can’t do that (and that’s happened maybe 1-2 times in the history of Lambda School) is when it’s a change to teams of students that run across multiple cohorts.
There can never be too many reminders to listen to student feedback. Thank you!
> Do you plan on at least giving these students a chance to retake prior units without further charging them for knowledge you should have already taught them?
Students are actually strongly encouraged to retake units at no additional cost in order to move on to the next level, and in some instances we require it.
This is actually where some of the greatest frustration comes. It would be easy to close our eyes and wave people along but we have to say at times, “You’re not quite there yet, let’s keep working at it.” That’s not what students want to hear.