HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

austinz

2,359 karma · joined May 26, 2013

submissionscomments
austinz··on The True Size of Africa - Misleading Maps
I'm almost disappointed that he didn't stick North America in there with the rest of them.
austinz··on Ripping Off Young America: The College-Loan Scandal
As someone who has both a liberal arts and a STEM degree, I resent the insinuation that STEM majors are drooling sociopaths who don't know how to relate to other people. Also, there's more to liberal arts than "empathy". Thanks.
austinz··on Do you need a degree to be a coder?
I don't think a degree is necessary; certainly not necessary in the same sense that you would want your brain surgeon to have graduated from medical school.

I think there are two separate problems here, though - one in which a particular individual is being assessed for his or her aptitude, and one where dozens or hundreds of applicants for a particular position must be evaluated on the basis of limited information, often from a pool of even more candidates.

A degree by itself is not a terribly reliable proxy for capability or potential, but better proxies are harder to scale and apply to many more people. Companies like degrees because they're an easy, lazy way to (at least in the minds of HR people) establish a competency baseline, and if it's true that most companies would rather have false negatives than false positives, it's easy to see why a degree would be "required" in a lot of cases. Hopefully that will change in the future.

austinz··on The Pedal-to-the-Metal, Totally Illegal, Cross-Country Sprint for Glory (2007)
I think for me being impressed may be more closely coupled to approval than most people. I wanted to express my disapproval but I didn't think I could do it in a way that wouldn't degenerate into a personal attack. So, my intent was not particularly clear. Sorry.

From a technical perspective, I guess I'm impressed by the fact that he was able to marshal together the resources, time, and support necessary to make this happen. He's done similar stunts without killing anyone, so I'm somewhat impressed by his driving skills (although there's also the advanced safety technologies in his car, as well as the intrinsic chance you'll find yourself in a situation that could result in an accident). His endurance is also admirable - it must have been very difficult racing the clock for hours on end while maintaining extreme concentration. But then, there are also people who drive drunk, drive while distracted, or drive dangerously badly-maintained vehicles regularly, and nothing happens to them, so I guess that makes the 'reckless driving' aspect slightly less impressive.

austinz··on How Objective-C messaging works
What is "0xreadbook" in the context of a 32-bit int supposed to mean? Is the author just trying to be cute, or is this some sort of nonstandard representation of hexadecimal digits that I need to read up on?
austinz··on The Pedal-to-the-Metal, Totally Illegal, Cross-Country Sprint for Glory (2007)
Technology can mitigate the risks, but not eliminate them altogether. I've nearly skidded off a road a few times when misjudging the curvature of unfamiliar onramps or offramps (and taking them far too fast). I've seen a couple of other highway features which, if taken too fast by an unfamiliar driver, could easily lead to calamity. Technology also can't compensate entirely for driver fatigue or bad snap judgments, both of which are a real threat for any traveler (not just these guys).

The article makes it clear that he plans ahead, relies upon support, and tries to stick to straight stretches of highway. Good for him, and if he wants to risk his life doing 130 down a deserted highway at 2 in the morning so be it. But honestly, from the article, it looks like he has a habit of weaving through traffic at unsafe speeds, and as someone who's nearly been killed by insane drivers trying similar stuff...well, honestly, I'm not impressed.

austinz··on Why do we waste our lives as servants?
This rubs me the wrong way. I guess I don't see why doing stuff that makes someone else wealthier, even incidentally, is intrinsically a bad thing.

If someone happens to find their job challenging, meaningful, and enjoyable, learns a lot, enjoys the company of their coworkers, and achieves their personal goals while working for a company or starting a business, why would the fact that other people are benefitting from their work put a damper on their enjoyment?

Or, like other commenters have mentioned, a job or self-employment might provide the income and opportunities to enrich one's life by living in an interesting place, getting to meet interesting people, supporting a certain lifestyle, enabling new experiences, and increasing someone's standard of living overall.

Don't get me wrong - I don't think that it's a bad thing, either, for someone to derive enjoyment from the mere fact that they aren't making someone else richer. And if that's what the author values, more power to him or her. But I really think it's sort of silly that the author is so puzzled that not everyone else thinks the same way.

austinz··on Buzz Aldrin calls for humans to colonise Mars
You know what I wouldn't mind seeing first? An unmanned base on the moon to work through the kinks of in-situ fabrication and resource extraction in an extraterrestrial environment. It wouldn't have to be too big and it could even be semi-tele-operated (given a lag time of seconds, rather than minutes or hours) by researchers and technicians on Earth.

If we're talking about sending people to Mars to live for long periods of time, and worrying about whether in doing so we're consigning them to miserable deaths, it seems like spending the money to work out the bugs in a non life-and-death situation might be a prudent idea. We've sent people to orbit the moon, we've landed people on the moon and robots on Mars, but we've never had people spending time on another world without relying entirely upon supplies they brought with them.

austinz··on A staggering migration – 250M people into Chinese cities in 12-15 years [video]
It depends. Coal, charcoal, wood. The house where my father grew up vented smoke/exhaust from the fires in the kitchen under a hard clay bed built into the house to keep the family warm in the winter.

You can see the effect of years of exposure to soot on the faces of people who live in rural China (and, I daresay, anyone who lives in similar circumstances). These people are not living particularly environmentally clean lives right now (although, to be fair, they probably do consume far fewer manufactured goods than their city-dwelling brethren).

Something of interest is the prevalence of solar water heaters, both in urban and rural areas. They are surprisingly common, much better than heating water using fire or electricity, and affordable even to those outside the cities.

austinz··on A staggering migration – 250M people into Chinese cities in 12-15 years [video]
I'm glad to see someone with this point of view. A lot of people don't seem to realize that there is a huge difference between the idealized American farmer and the lives of real peasants living in rural China. It's extremely difficult to run roads, electricity, and water to all these villages, or to provide them with modern schools and clinics (and corresponding staff) necessary to implement social welfare that extends beyond the cities.
austinz··on Getting Real Value Out of An Engineering Education
When I was taking EE/CS courses, I'd consciously try to look for courses with large, open-ended projects (without eschewing theory completely). Although project classes can be run very poorly, the good ones tend to be the exact opposite of memorization/test-regurgitation.
austinz··on Building a Modern Computer from First Principles
It might be beyond the scope of a normal hobbyist project, but writing Verilog or VHDL to drive an FPGA might bring interested people half of the way there. You mentioned Altera design software in another post; I don't know if Xilinx's is any better (I'm guessing not really), but Digilent sells FPGA boards intended for the educational market at a pretty reasonable cost. Powerful enough, I'd reckon, to allow for something of this scope to be built.
austinz··on San Francisco
I was reading up on Catania (the city from which he hails) and it looks like a beautiful place - very different from SF, but still having a large number of tech companies.
austinz··on Is China behind the PRISM leak?
Re. (2): The US could bolster its case by pointing to specific examples of products or technologies produced by Chinese companies which appear to have benefitted from IP stolen through hacking. This is something that the government hasn't done, as far as I can tell (please correct me if I'm wrong).

Presumably Chinese industrial espionage hackers would want to do more with their stolen schematics than let them sit untouched on a server somewhere.

austinz··on Ask HN: Is 30 too old to start in software engineering or CS?
I'm 25 as well. I share a bit of my own experience, in the hopes that you may find lessons (both positive and negative) from it. I don't pretend that anyone should consciously follow the path I took, but it did work out pretty well for me.

I graduated college with a degree in electrical engineering not really knowing anything about what I wanted to do for a living or where I wanted to be in five or ten years. So I sort of drifted into a master's program, again in the same field, hoping to figure out what I was doing before I was forced to confront the job market or academia proper.

I didn't realize until the second half of my first year at that graduate program that I enjoyed the CS courses I was taking as electives far more than the normal engineering courses. So I ended up taking my second year and throwing all my effort into taking as many CS classes (which were cross-listed departmentally) as I could: operating systems, databases, compilers, etc. I made some stupid mistakes choosing some classes that turned out to be neither interesting nor relevant, and skipping on classes that would have been extremely useful or informative.

When I graduated, I took a position at a startup in the area, doing work that fell between the interface of EE and CS. I realized that I wasn't too fond of the work or the company (for various reasons), and so I spent months teaching myself the practical and theoretical stuff I had missed out at school, whether out of inexperience, disinterest, or sheer decision-making ineptitude. Some of this stuff was useful for my position at the time, other topics were completely exploratory in nature. And when I was ready, I started sending out my resume and interviewing for positions. I did get a new job, and I'm a software engineer at a well-regarded mid-size tech company in Silicon Valley right now.

Some thoughts regarding your position:

- CS is one of the fields with the lowest barrier to self-teaching. You don't need expensive lab equipment or fieldwork - just software, much of which is freely available, an ordinary computer, and enough motivation to actually utilize both.

- You don't need a 4 year degree. In the US a lot of schools won't even allow you to enter their bachelors programs if you already have one. A BS would be a waste of your time.

- The MS degree isn't a prerequisite. Build something substantial, and people will take notice. If you don't have anything you can show them, the degree can sometimes be useful. I'm not proud of this and it's actually really shitty, but the name of the school on your resume may sometimes make the difference between people taking a look at it and throwing it out (at least from my experience).

- If you do go back for formal schooling know what classes you should take, in order to acquire knowledge you need to have. You mention data structures and algorithms in a comment earlier; there are classes which focus on those; there are also classes that focus on discrete math, statistics, and other foundational topics. You should build an OS and a compiler while you're there. I always thought this was a thought-provoking read: http://matt.might.net/articles/what-cs-majors-should-know/

- A lot of MS programs are coursework programs; they've been charitably described as financially lucrative to their host institutions. Mine almost certainly would have qualified (both the EE and CS programs). This is not necessarily poison, but it does mean that if you attend, you should make the most out of the classes you take.

- If you are interested in working at certain companies, see if you can get someone to give you an internal referral once you're ready to begin the job application and interview process. A lot of companies (again, this is a controversial topic) seem to give more weight to internal referrals than unsolicited submissions. Contact with most of the companies I was looking at started either when a recruiter reached out, or when I asked someone I knew to put in a word. If you feel that people are loath to consider you due to your late start/lack of formal credentials this may be a way to offset that.

Finally, the fact that you are considering this move because of passion, interest, and demonstrated competence bodes really well for you. Best of luck!

austinz··on The Echo Chamber of Silicon Valley
How do we know which problems are fake problems and which ones are real problems, though? Sometimes it's obvious, sometimes it might not be as clear.

Twitter probably seemed like a fake problem at its inception (post 140 characters to a personal blog from your phone), and yet it's been adopted and used daily by many, many people outside the Valley. Google's founders weren't thinking about ads when they first built their search engine, but apparently the ads they serve are considered lucrative enough by their customers to turn the company huge. (Of course there are the data privacy issues, but on a more cynical note someone's needs are being served.)

On the other hand, Better Place seemed like a useful idea. EVs presumably aren't more widely adopted because of range anxiety and charge times, so why not create a business model and technology to swap out batteries and make recharging as painless as filling up at a gas station? But Better Place is dead now and Tesla is building out its fast charger network and selling more and more cars.

austinz··on Learn C
I agree with you; in the cases you mentioned there don't seem to be any good arguments for not using a higher-level language with managed memory, properly implemented data structures, etc.

It seems like there are at least two threads of thought going on in the comments in general. One of them is, "does C have any role in any domain, and if so what is that domain?". I think that it does; software development is much wider than kernels, userland applications, and compilers, and there are fields where C and/or C++ are the right tools as things currently stand. I don't think anyone would argue that either language exists as a global optimum in any problem space, but from an engineering (rather than a theoretical purism) standpoint sometimes there are few practical alternatives. Maybe these domains are small, maybe they're unexciting, but they do exist.

The other is, "what is the point of learning C?". Maybe they want a deeper understanding of manual memory management, the concept of stack and heap storage, pointer manipulation, etc. Learning more about C to play with these concepts isn't a terrible idea, although it's not the only way to learn about these things. If nothing else, learning C and trying to implement your own parsers or data structures might be a good way to better understand why writing correct code in C that accounts for buffer overflows and string issues is so difficult, and what challenges higher-level languages face in order to overcome these flaws.

austinz··on Learn C
Agreed; OS kernels and firmware for embedded systems all require low-level access to hardware in a way that high-level desktop applications do not. Being able to easily reason about how C is going to use resources and be compiled down to machine code for the architecture you are using can sometimes be an important asset.
← PreviousPage 12 of 12