This article's thesis is pretty much "both object-oriented and functional paradigms have limitations which become apparent when you push them to ridiculous extremes". Which is neither an interesting thesis nor one that is in dispute (except maybe among a very small number of people). But to be fair that thesis makes for far less linkbaity a title than "What’s Wrong with OOP and FP".
I love FTL. I can beat it semi-reliably on Easy with a few of the ships, and occasionally on Normal. And that's part of the game's genius - there are quite a few practical ways you can build your ship and crew in preparation for the final boss, and each of the ships (and even layouts) is tailored towards facilitating a particular strategy. So even if you master one strategy, there are plenty more waiting to destroy you through your inexperience or ineptitude.
Looking forwards to the day Google includes electronic component datasheets in its search results and puts all those stupid unusable SEO-gaming datasheet repository websites out of business.
You bring up a good point, though. There's a spectrum of financial industry activity, ranging from stuff necessary for the modern economy to function to stuff that many observers would consider dangerous, irresponsible, immoral, and rent-seeking. Maybe Goldman Sachs touches every part of that continuum, maybe it doesn't - I don't know.
There are philosophical and bureaucratic similarities among almost all of the major/dominant dynasties after Qin that disappeared after the Qing fell and probably won't come back ever again. But I could have chosen a better example.
Sure, I think what you say is reasonable. I don't know how much I like the ideas in this article to be honest, and I'm not really qualified to judge them. I do like the fact that people are throwing out ideas and discussing them, even if they're not good ideas.
The Chinese dynastic system lasted for thousands of years, until it stopped working because it turned out to be a shitty system that couldn't cope with the demands placed upon it by a rapidly changing and industrializing world. So I don't even feel that 'time tested' is a particularly good criterion.
I never said (or implied) that I prefer the academics give us a replacement. And neither I nor the article claim that the Constitution should be changed or discarded using extralegal means. Your response, in contrast, is exactly the sort of knee-jerk thought-terminating shoutdown response I was alluding to.
This will never happen until the significant part of the population that considers the Constitution de facto divine writ is disabused of that notion. It's the same notion that gives rise to some of the more odious forms of American exceptionalism and encourages a firewall between ideological and academic views of that document.
Given the comparisons to other companies...I wonder if Huawei, ZTE, or any European or Japanese company in recent memory has been explicitly outed for this kind of behavior in the same fashion the American telecoms have. My (very limited) understanding is that before Snowden, these types of accusations were backed mostly by insinuations and conjecture. (For example, Huawei is suspect because it has supposed ties to the Chinese military, not because a security researcher has discovered a clearly nefarious backdoor in a router.)
I agree with you. I think the rule is asinine as well, I'm glad it's dead, and I think we should be pushing back against stupid things. And following rules for rules' sake is a stupid thing.
But I don't think that meaningless platitudes or misogynistic stereotypes are a good justification for entitlement. Someone who's read the literature and understands why there's almost no way consumer electronics can affect a modern airliner's avionics might be more entitled than someone who thrives on 'breaking the rules' and thinks flight attendants are stupid 'ditzes'. What happens when that stupid ditz says something that turns out to be right?
Thank you for proving the parent's point about entitlement. "So why should I give that ditz any respect?" Seriously? "There is no man like a free man"? As if reading your Kindle during takeoff is going to turn you into a Randian ubermensch ready to disrupt every industry in the world?
If this is the smartest bracelet I'll ever wear, I weep for the future of the smart-bracelet industry. Or is there more to the product than the web site lets on?
I had a Macintosh Plus when I was a kid. (My dad wrote his Ph.D dissertation on it, and he had a HD and some game disks before I somehow destroyed them.) I remember that computer fondly. When I was in first grade we got a new machine, and we took the Mac Plus out and left it next to the apartment complex dumpster that morning. By the afternoon it was gone. Sometimes, I still think about it...who picked it up, whether they plugged it in and found out it was still completely functional, and if they still have it today.
As are Google and Apple (albeit not always for privacy). I think the only oft-mentioned companies I've seen that consistently get better-than-neutral sentiment are Tesla and SpaceX, although there are probably others I'm forgetting.
I don't know about this particular implementation, but MAKE Magazine recently featured a similar DIY project (although this one doesn't use an iPhone, and instead projects the image onto a wall).
From that link: "In April 2010 Hugo Alfredo Tale-Yax was stabbed to death in New York City after coming to the aid of a woman who was being attacked by a robber. Yax was on the sidewalk for more than an hour before firefighters arrived. Almost twenty-five people walked by while he lay dying on a sidewalk in Queens, several stared at Yax; one of them took pictures, however none of them helped or called emergency services".
I know the author of the news article pooh-poohs the common depiction of the Kitty Genovese murder as not being true, but that has nothing to do with the veracity of the effect as a whole (or the other examples provided on that Wikipedia page).
If I felt competent enough to call myself a "10X developer, marketer and entrepreneur", I'd consider becoming a consultant. But I'm not anywhere near that stage yet, and there's a lot I can learn (and am learning) where I am right now. So, the argument can be a decent one (self-employment brings certain benefits that are inimical to working for a salary), but there are also trade-offs involved.
The truly good student is the one who signs up for the class with the goal of mastering the material being taught as well as possible. The 'good' student in this example cares more about gaming the signaling mechanism than actually learning the material - this is why he'll spend his time arguing with the TA over a handful of points on his problem set than spending that time going over the material again. The 'cynical bad' student is already convinced that he's not going to get anything out of the class, in which case he either 1). is taking the class because he has to or 2). is a fool who should be taking a class better serving his needs and not wasting his time.
Also, I don't know much about philosophy (and I suspect this is far less applicable for philosophy), but in science and engineering often mastery and innovation in a field requires an extremely narrow focus that, in turn, requires a significant investment in time and resources. This includes transmission of specialist knowledge to graduate students and postdocs, grant writing, paper publishing, acquisition of equipment or access to equipment. So I don't really think it's entirely fair to chalk up lack of interdisciplinary interest and/or innovative methodology predominantly to a system that weeds out people not willing to think the way it wants them to. (Not saying that tenure doesn't have its own problems...)
Ooh. I remember "Dynamic-C" and its built-in support for coroutines. TI and Microchip had their own quasi-proprietary extensions to C, but I don't think I ever saw anyone go as far as Rabbit did.
This. There is so much more to software engineering/CS than building web sites (not that there's anything intrinsically wrong with that, either).
At my last job I wrote firmware for an embedded device that served as a bridge between household appliances equipped with low-power radios, and our company's Internet servers. Right now I'm working on mobile applications for a large Silicon Valley tech company (and I work with both web devs and server people every day there).
The challenges, goals, tools, work environment, and sense of accomplishment between those two jobs were/are so different I can easily see why someone would flourish in one and be stifled in the other.
There are different schools of Chinese philosophy that have differing approaches and conclusions, and even then sub-schools with differing beliefs within them (e.g. the Confucianist scholars Xun Zi and Mencius on the innate goodness of human nature). Saying that students should apply something as broadly and uselessly defined as "Chinese philosophy" into their lives is not particularly helpful, and sort of implicitly reinforces the stereotype that Chinese (or East Asian) people all adhere to this rigid, alien way of thinking.
Also, it's sort of condescending. No Western professor teaches Heidegger or Schopenhauer by breaking them up into easy-to-digest, feel-good aphorisms for better living.
My guess is that it's closely related to the collegiate alcohol culture, which is just as shitty and pretty much ubiquitous, and which many younger devs were a part of before graduating into industry.
If they're not competent enough to blame this mishap on 'test data', I wonder if they'll prove competent enough to change the data for the final reported results.
Good for these researchers. This ban is, as far as I've been able to tell, racism arising from political expediency. If it were about national security, we wouldn't be collaborating with Russia on the ISS (or allowing ourselves to be completely dependent upon Soyuz for access to the station for the indeterminate future). It's not about human rights, either - NASA collaborates with Saudi Arabia, enough said.
I find it absolutely frightening how much incompetent instruction there exists for teaching people skills like programming - with regards to the author's experiences, in particular. I'm glad that he finally found something that worked for him, but I'm left wondering how many other people will have had that caliber of instruction as their first (or only) exposure to the field.
Regarding his assertion about reference counting: Apple's implementation of ARC for Objective-C doesn't handle cycles (it requires the engineer to reason about weak and strong references in order to prevent memory leaks), but it is certainly a "serious" implementation. The fact that it doesn't have facilities for detecting and releasing cyclic references makes it definitely not the "other side" of the GC coin.
That being said, ARC-style reference counting is more limited in terms of what developers can do with their code, and it may not be a general enough solution for a language like C++ (which strives to be all things to all people). Weak pointers in Objective-C also require runtime support, which could probably not be appropriate for high-performance applications in many cases.
There's a particular XKCD comic that used to constantly reflect my experience while searching for the solutions to technical problems in one particular area of expertise (http://xkcd.com/979/).
Seeing EE answers gumming up the search results (especially if you didn't know the trick) was at least an order of magnitude more frustrating.
I'm glad EE treated its employees well, but the way a company treats its employees can be completely unrelated to the way a company treats its competitors, or its potential or actual employee base. And it seems pretty clear that EE treated its potential customer base so poorly that Stack Overflow was able to tap into latent frustration and anger and quickly corner the market on community technical Q&A. The hatred for EE grew up organically, and I doubt Joel's campaign did much more than giving direction and a voice to pre-existing resentment.