624 karma · joined February 17, 2008
Great job on starting HackerBuddy. I was impressed with how quickly it matched me up with someone!
Ideas as they came to me:
1. Cool icons and good tooltips for areas of expertise!
2. I like my profile but you should allow vanity URLs like hackerbuddy.com/artvankilmer
3. Are you pulling pics from Gravatar? Nice bit of personalization.
4. Twitter and HN icons would be a natural addition :)
5. My Twitter and HN usernames are probably my HackerBuddy username. Could suggest that automatically instead of making me type it in.
6. Browse Users isn't prominent enough!
7. How I can give feedback isn't prominent enough!
8. Browse Users can't just be a dump of profile names. I need to be able to slice & dice by expertise, general availability (don't suggest folks that have already been paired with a bunch of other users), etc.
9. Some kind of reputation / recommendation / feedback system would really help. Why not pull in a user's HN karma or StackOverflow score to help seed things a bit? Even feedback on a user's profile of how helpful they were would help.
10. "CSS" is painfully missing, esp. since you have "Design", "HTML", and "JavaScript". CSS != Design (e.g. I think Photoshop, Illustrator, wireframes)
11. Logged out home page is a good start but you need more to hook folks. Try imagery of hackers helping hackers, appealing to folks obsessed with HN karma / SO scores / Twitter followers, and just nailing your value prop. "Free karma for helpful hackers" doesn't do it for me.
Keep up the good work!
"Is this a core investment or something in which you have interest but would walk away from if things get difficult?"
Isn't this something you would know based on who the firm has invested in before? How can you get more specific than that?
It seems like a great idea to separate brainstorming and refining into two meetings. From my experience, doing them in the same meeting is hard. You don't know when to cross over from free thinking to critical thinking. Tension arises when some folks end up drilling down into one idea while others are still brainstorming new ones at a very high level.
"..then get out of the way so that you could just focus on the code" ...completely hate this.
At first read, the idea of a boss that is not yourself struck me as great because it helps give you a very different perspective on things. But having that boss simply "make all the decisions about what you should do" takes away all the duties of a founder. Figuring out what to do is the real hard work of a startup. Unless your technology is curing cancer, then you still need to understand everything you can about the problem you're solving and who you're solving it for. You can't just focus on the solution.
The way I currently summarize this is: What’s the simplest possible thing you can do today to learn what you need for tomorrow?
! Realtime tail and filter are not available with basic logging, please upgrade to expanded logging
:(
More info: http://37signals.com/svn/posts/466-sketching-with-a-sharpie
That's exactly the point. Isn't that something the GoDaddy designer(s) should know and take into account? They want people buying domain names, not drooling.
Again with GoDaddy, do you want a sexy brand image, a lead gen wet dream, people to quickly buy domain names in bulk, etc.? I completely agree that "important" isn't specific enough but it's up to you, as the designer, to figure out the balance.
Just wanted to extend that offer to everyone here as well. I too have the overload problem and am passionate about the value of Twitter, which is why I'm building something that will help. Happy to share & discuss further: http://slipstre.am/