I agree with a lot of this thanks for the response. What are your feelings on some kind of regulation around local protections? I know regulations are generally percieved quite harshly on HN. But in a highly efficient market it seems like you may at some point no longer have local access to goods. Which seems like a dangerous recipe if so&so location becomes no longer worth the cost of shipping goods there but the local stores have already perished.
I’m not an economist so someone with more insight can weigh-in if I’m speaking out of turn. My personal concern with Amazon is a similar one I had with Wal-Mart in that there seems to be a relationship between stagnant wages acceptance based on access to lower and lower cost goods. This seems to me to be an unsustainable race to the bottom that benefits large vertically integrated multinationals no matter how many economic arms they figuratively break in the process.
That being said I’m not sure if that is a problem that Amazon is actually creating or just a consequence of wage supression being easier to accept when technology makes goods cheaper.
Antecdotally in my experience there is also the fact that in large companies some functions no longer need to exist. That being said you have leaders who arent going to volunteer this and lose thier power or job so they clamp down and create middle management holds such as bureacracy or fierce protection of a function etc.
This is almost exactly my background as well. I have massive respect for tradespeople and family members in that space. That being said these type of articles leave a lot to be desired in terms of expressing the whole picture and why lots of blue collar families push for thier children not to go into their trade/field. Imho
To comment on one of the sentiments in the last paragraph. I often find myself wondering about the people doing the bidding above them where they are the last one compensated on a middle-upper class level before the VP or CEO or whoever that makes the 100X worker salary. What motivates that person? I’m sure they are compensated very well but at an exponentially lower rate than the will they are serving.
Good write up I’ve been working on a similar trajectory for my own smartphone usage. I’ve toyed with getting a dumb weekend phone but I think this might be the way to go. I don’t want to ignore technology I just want to make sure I’m in control as much as possible.
Agreed, there are timeliness and environmental variables to living costs and land for sure. The fear here seems to be that being a doctor or lawyer to use the cliche won’t secure you housing and that landowner becomes a profession that trumps all in terms of income and social class. I don’t mean this to be disingenuous I realize thats always been true to a certain extent but the extent is important.
I think you hit it head on with this. It seems to be a control thing first and foremost. The worst nightmare is that you will grab their content in a text only format with no ads.
I think there is some truth to this for sure. But speaking from a here and now perspective it’s hard to not take this stance. My wife and I make a good bit more than the average income for our area and at 27 we aren’t going to be even close to affording the house I was born into. That house was bought by my parents at 23 with my father working part time.
This! The inflation hedge also makes the wealth gap exponential for those without the capital to get in the real estate game for lack of a better term. The capital needed to get into a home with traditional financing seems to go up by the month and is essentially moving the finishing line for those millenials saving for homes.
This is a really good point. Empathy can be applied to judging moral crimes such as stealing food becuase you are starving. Although anctedotally I find that people who come from the exact background/situation tend to have less empathy even though they understand the context more.
I’am positive someone expressed that exact sentiment about the ocean at some point. I had a Botany professor who always used to say “there is no such place as away”.
I wish I could upvote this more than once. Both my parents were teachers. The disparities that children face from day one neighborhood to neighborhood are so large it makes me sigh so hard when I hear people say things like just work harder.
But seriously I still don’t know what to make of Microsofts new(ish) adoption of Linux it seems positive for Linux overall but I’m cautiously optimistic.
Piggybacking on what you were saying I don’t disagree from a purely business sense. But I find it ironic society seems to have this constant droning fear about actual robots becoming sentient and dissenting but doesnt fear the droves of these sudo-robots who are already able bodied and sentient and being actively antagonized (piss in bottles, etc) to dissent.
There is an awesome Adam ruins everything episode on Tax returns. It seems that rent seeking is pretty much the only thing keeping the current system in place.
Agreed I’m always amazed by DIY houses or just extremely DIY modified houses. It seems to be an area where people who don’t consider themselves creative can express creativity. Good stuff.