HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

awfulneutral

147 karma · joined August 5, 2022

submissionscomments
awfulneutral··on Spotify is full of AI music
I listened to a few of the songs and I could definitely believe they are AI. They are extremely clean, near-identical covers, like karaoke versions I guess. If Spotify is funding these, that means they would be trying to poach money directly from the biggest artists/companies. That seems like a much bigger controversy than creating generic background music and spreading that around their algorithms.
awfulneutral··on Spotify is full of AI music
Isn't that a different phenomenon? This article is about hit songs that have cheap AI covers, almost identical sounding, presumably to poach royalties from the real musicians.

The "ghost" thing is interesting too, that sounds almost like the industry from before The Beatles, when bands were just people hired by the record companies to record songs written by others, and the companies owned pretty much everything.

awfulneutral··on AIs Will Increasingly Fake Alignment
The definition of "conscious" is kind of the whole question, but I could probably believe that as easily as the idea that every brain of sufficient complexity gets a single unit of conscious soul that inhabits it. I really don't know how it works.
awfulneutral··on AIs Will Increasingly Fake Alignment
I mean, consciousness is a really complicated topic. Either it's an illusion, it's a single thing that inhabits us (i.e. a soul), or there is some smaller "unit" of consciousness like they are describing, which to me does seem fairly reasonable to consider, since brains can act really weird and non-uniform in certain situations, plus most things are composed of smaller things.
awfulneutral··on School smartphone ban results in better sleep and improved mood: study
I think about this a lot because I was the same, I couldn't stop messing around with computers and I owe my career to it. But if I was a kid today I'd probably just get caught up in the easy distractions and not learn to program. It's a very different environment now.
awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
The existence of these loopholes creates two options:

1) Follow the spirit of the law, which is that on your death, your assets are taxed as they are passed on, thus you contribute to funding the laws and society we are supposedly working together to create.

2) Do work to avoid having to give up anything, even though you can easily afford it, and you'll be dead anyway.

I don't see how #2 is ethically the same as #1. He doesn't have to do the most selfish thing just because he isn't technically being forced otherwise. Caveat that I haven't researched if this guy is giving tons of money away otherwise or something, I'm just trying to explain why I think it's fair for people to criticize this behavior even though it might be legal.

awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
You may not "owe" the government, if you can find a loophole where you can technically avoid paying legally. But in my opinion ethics definitely comes into it, why wouldn't it?
awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
(deleted my previous reply as I wasn't happy with it.)

1. I'm not sure what the implication is here.

2. It sounds like he is attempting to create dynastic wealth by avoiding taxes owed after he dies. So, to me it does not seem like some protest against the US government. But if he was actively trying to do good with his wealth in the amount of billions of dollars, then maybe that could be defensible.

awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
It sounds like you do think the law defines what is ethical then. I disagree with that take.
awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
If you're referring to the desire to avoid unreasonable taxation without representation, it does not seem like the same thing to me. I don't know - maybe he is avoiding taxes so he can give it all to charity. But greed seems pretty commonly accepted to be unethical.
awfulneutral··on How One of the Richest Men Is Avoiding $8B in Taxes
The law does not define what is ethical. Of course you can blame somebody for trying to hoard an unreasonable amount of wealth. As George said, we live in a society.
awfulneutral··on Genie 2: A large-scale foundation world model
Well, in the future you could imagine that instead of programming a game, you can just generate each individual frame on the fly at 60fps. You could be playing 2D Mario and then the game could have him morph into 3D and take off into space or something. You could also generate any software or OS frontend on the fly really, if you can make it so the AI can keep track of your data and make it consistent enough to be usable. Does this have positive or negative value? I don't know.
awfulneutral··on Museum of Bad Art
To me it looks like pieces are chosen that show a contrast of good and bad - they have amateurish or weird proportions and colors, but generally they have good or at least interesting composition. I couldn't really say how much is intentional vs accidental, for a lot of them.
awfulneutral··on Pi Chess Board
I was trying to do something like this a while back, our approach was to have a different color underneath each piece, with an elaborate setup to get the colors reflected into a camera, but I could never get the color detection working reliably with the way we were doing it. It was a fun project though, there's got to be some easy way to detect moves and get a cheap-ish internet-enabled board.
awfulneutral··on Meta Movie Gen
Haha, this is the first thing I thought of too. I knew adult hippos walk on the bottom, but from looking at existing videos it looks like small (baby/pygmy) hippos do too, they don't float at the surface like this.
awfulneutral··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
If superintelligence happens, then money won't matter anymore anyway.
awfulneutral··on Please stop putting cookie pop-ups on your website (2022)
Why not do like with popups, and show a little toast with "x tracking cookies were blocked, click to allow"? Cookies could have to register whether they are essential or not. It's really wild how much work must have been created by distributing this problem to every website on earth instead of doing it in the browser.
awfulneutral··on Why Not Comments
Same, my coworker used this argument when I tried to get them to write more comments. The number of hours I've wasted due to there being no comments at all is way, way, way more than the very small number I've wasted due to a no-longer-accurate comment. And I usually find that people who write self-documenting code choose variable/function names that might make sense to them at the time, but are vague and confusing to me when I need to read the code.
awfulneutral··on iPhone 16 Pro and iPhone 16 Pro Max
Well, cynically that fits with my own experience. :) But I don't know if I'd say it's simpler, just that you don't have any choices. For me Apple UX often feels complicated and I can't figure out how to do what I want, or figure out what is going to happen when I accept some dialog they want me to accept. But I guess I end up going through the pipe eventually, out of frustration.

My impression of my non-tech friends is that they aren't too dumb to follow instructions, they just don't enjoy operating a computer like I do, so they are more okay with their choices being restricted if they don't have to waste time doing something they find boring.

awfulneutral··on iPhone 16 Pro and iPhone 16 Pro Max
As a "tech person" I feel like we've all been told for 20+ years that we can't have UX that makes any sense to us, or lets us do simple things we want to do, because we are power users and software has to cater to some imagined demographic of incredibly dumb people who can't understand basic computing metaphors. It can get frustrating.
awfulneutral··on Random Thoughts about Unity
Thanks for the recommendation! I'm currently doing a small project in Monogame to see how it is (maybe too low level to be practical for me), but I think you've convinced me to give Stride a look after this.
awfulneutral··on Random Thoughts about Unity
It just feels like C# is always going to be the better choice though. Why have both, with one of them inevitably getting less attention, and why spend resources reinventing the wheel?
awfulneutral··on Random Thoughts about Unity
I have FINALLY made the decision to leave Unity for my hobby games/programs, after about 10 years using it fairly heavily. It is just making my life miserable and I sincerely hate using it, with the latest beta being almost literally unusable on my computer. I do disagree with the author about UIToolkit though - that is one of the only things Unity has done in the last 5 years that is actually useful.

I'm not sure what to move to. I think there is a big vacuum for a code-first, open source framework that basically does what Unity does without the awful editor. I know a lot of people like GDScript in Godot, but to me it looks like the same mistake Unity made with UnityScript, which they eventually got rid of.

awfulneutral··on Random Thoughts about Unity
I spent a while working on a digital painting app in Unity. UIToolkit is not complete, but it is pretty good for web-like UI, and you can leverage existing knowledge of HTML/CSS layout. With some tweaks you tell Unity to only redraw the screen on demand, which is better for battery life. My experience is that Unity could be pretty good for cross-platform semi-graphical app development. Except that Unity dev is miserable (slow, never-ending compilation, bad docs, constant bugs, glacial update pace, broken Linux editor, etc etc etc).
awfulneutral··on Terence Tao on proof checkers and AI programs
Another one is Oak: https://oakproof.org/
awfulneutral··on Where are the builders?
What makes you think they are doing nothing else with their talent? Lots of speed runners are just high achievers and are doing it on the side while they work through college. Some have built a career on speed running. Some do it for charity at GDQ. It is a thing mainly young people do while they have free time. It is also a good social outlet.
awfulneutral··on Where are the builders?
The article is asserting that there's some meaningful absence of famous outliers in this generation, but it doesn't really support that assertion...are you sure there aren't any? It took a while for me to be aware of the people listed in the article, they were already very successful before I knew who most of them were. There are plenty of people building graphics cards at Nvidia currently, why don't they count? Plenty of young people are still striking it rich making video games and software, why don't they count? Even if it is true, I would suspect it has more to do with there being fewer low-hanging-fruit opportunities regarding internet tech, rather than the younger generation being too addicted to video games.
awfulneutral··on GPT-4o
That's true, but if it isn't able to be honest when it doesn't know something, or to ask for clarification, then I don't see how it's workable.
awfulneutral··on GPT-4o
In the customer support example, he tells it his new phone doesn't work, and then it just starts making stuff up like how the phone was delivered 2 days ago, and there's physically nothing wrong with it, which it doesn't actually know. It's a very impressive tech demo, but it is a bit like they are pretending we have AGI when we really don't yet.

(Also, they managed to make it sound exactly like an insincere, rambling morning talk show host - I assume this is a solvable problem though.)

awfulneutral··on The Age of Rage: Why Are People Are So Angry?
Also, on the internet, you can't tell who's a teenager. Social groups in real life are usually divided by age. If a much younger person has an overly extreme or overly argumentative opinion, it's kind of expected.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →