HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

awhitby

261 karma · joined October 1, 2012

andrewwhitby.com me@andrewwhitby.id.au
submissionscomments
awhitby··on Help HN: Can't open childhood files
I would guess the CHT files are commands for text output on a dot matrix printer, or a format pretty close to that.

* The MARLEY songs are laid out in two columns (side A, side B) from left to right then top to bottom, which suggests its pretty close to a matrix of characters, rather than something more abstract/structured.

* Every character is taking up two bytes, which could be some Slovenian encoding but I doubt any European language was taking up 16 bits in the early 1990s, which makes me think every second character is a formatting for the character that precedes or follows it.

* The MARLEY title has a repetitions like "BBoobb MMaarrlleeyy" which might be the kind of overprint mode I remember dot matrixes having, where the printer prints a character then goes back and reprints it, to get a bold effect.

I would dig around for old dot matrix standards, Epson and so on.

awhitby··on Bill Gates: My new pandemic book is coming soon
But Gates is not "every billionaire, politician, celebrity, and crackpot on the planet" on this issue. He stepped away from day to day involvement in Microsoft in 2008, and it seems that since then his major focus has been his foundation. Global health is one of the main focuses of that organization.

That's a bit different from some random celebrity weighing in.

It should also be clear to everyone now that pandemics are not solely an infectious diseases issue. Presumably Gates could bring a valuable perspective on science-adjacent issues like governance, financing and global cooperation.

You can absolutely disagree with his views on this topic (and maybe should), but it's unfair to write him off as some dilettante.

(edit: Also you should absolutely question how he came to have this level of wealth and influence in global health.)

awhitby··on Please make a dumb car
The horn thing doesn't seem like that big a deal actually. I've never used the horn in a potential accident situation because there's always something better I could be focusing on to avoid the accident. As pilot say: aviate, navigate, then communicate. [0] Some studies seems to support that [1].

The only accidents I can imagine the horn preventing are ones where you are stationary, which almost always means the other car is moving slowly - like somebody backing into you in a parking lot. Overall pretty low consequence incidents.

So to the extent that horn use is nearly all elective rather than emergency, is antisocial and has few benefits: make it a small, hard-to-reach button.

(With important exceptions like heavy vehicles that can't maneuver well and non-Western driving cultures that rely on routine horn use to communicate intentions.)

[0] Granted aircraft have an extra dimension to play in for collision-avoidance. [1] https://slate.com/technology/2008/11/honk-if-you-know-why-yo...

awhitby··on Did I just lose half a million dollars?
It's notable that after hundreds of years of experience in writing contracts, real world legal systems still rely on courts to interpret them in a reasonable and equitable manner because we cannot possibly anticipate every edge case and build in every rescue mechanism.

Smart contracts really shouldn't be called contracts - it's a misleading analogy.

awhitby··on 'Dutch reach' rule change to Highway Code welcomed
At least compared with a few other fairly big cities I've lived in this is a distinctively New York and even Manhattan phenomenon. I drive rarely here but my assumption is that drivers would often never get to turn the corner if they gave crossing pedestrians the polite space they do elsewhere, because of a combination of (foot) traffic density and pedestrians ignoring their light.

That last part, I think, is because New York pedestrian lights have a relatively long "red flashing" phase, which combined with New Yorkers being New Yorkers has the counterintuitive effect that everyone treats red flashing, and even the few seconds after, as "go ahead and start crossing."

awhitby··on 'Dutch reach' rule change to Highway Code welcomed
My guess is the kind of careless people who don't check for cyclists tend to be the kind that throw their doors wide open in one movement, so while this doesn't hurt, it gives cyclists a split-second's warning at best.
awhitby··on French moratorium on prion studies after two cases of fatal brain disease (2021)
Not a biologist, so this is just a guess, but I imagine their simplicity is their weakness.

Viruses rely on the machinery of nucleic acids to replicate. That machinery is complex and robust and the result of some long period of continuous evolution, which means viruses exists in a fairly smooth fitness space where mutation and recombination are effective means of improving fitness.

Prions by contrast seem more like isolated spikes in a much sparser fitness space. Presumably the equivalents of mutation and recombination for prions lead to molecules that almost never retain the capacity to replicate, so they have limited potential to become fitter over time.

awhitby··on What the world will be like in a hundred years (1922)
This was my initial reaction too: it doesn't seem to pass basic conservation of mass.

But actually how much mass must you necessarily lose to stay alive each day? Most of it is probably water, so if we allow "four pills plus as much water" at a meal then it's harder to rule out the pill diet.

Maybe a better way to bound it: apparently we exhale around 1 kg of CO2 each day, which has 370g of carbon in it so unless we can radically reengineer our metabolism I guess you need a minimum of 370g daily to maintain carbon levels. 370g / 3 meals / 4 pills = 30g per pill. Even with the density of diamond that would be (picking a convenient rough number) 8 cm3 or 2x2x2cm.

Which is... a hard pill to swallow. Maybe not impossible though.

awhitby··on Omicron variant was 73% of U.S. covid cases last week
It's obviously possible that this is a bad nowcast (as argued in Edit2 of the parent), but there are other possibilities.

I suspect the % of tests that are of asymptomatic people is much higher than a few weeks ago, because of travel plans and publicity around omicron. If omicron does produce milder symptoms (either inherently or because more omicron cases are breakthrough and mitigated by vaccination) then it could be that a higher proportion of omicron cases are now being tested (and some fraction sequenced), relative to delta, compared with a few weeks ago.

awhitby··on Worker pay isn’t keeping up with inflation
Quality of life is pretty subjective but US life expectancy rose from about 70 to 79 between 1970 and today.
awhitby··on Sothebys Auction of Source Code for WWW X Tim Berners-Lee NFT
Impressive that TBL wrote all the code for the WWW in 30:25.
awhitby··on Poor in Tech
At least. NYC is more than double that: $120-130 a month.
awhitby··on Motorcycle airbag vest will stop working if you miss a payment
I agree this feels pretty questionable, but if you take that view, you should ask yourself how you feel about the Garmin inReach Mini [1] (and possibly other devices in that family). It's an emergency satellite SOS device for outdoor recreation, with a monthly subscription option—and many features beyond pure SOS. When the subscription is suspended though, the SOS functionality will not work (unlike, say, a cellphone).

And yet it is—from my observation—an incredibly popular device, and I would bet that the start/stop monthly plan is the most popular (it's the one I use).

Obvious one difference is that here you get something for your monthly subscription (maintenance of the Iridium network, an emergency response center, etc). But given the incredibly low rate of people pushing the SOS button, the relatively low cost of that happening (it's not like they actually mount the search and rescue, they just pass on a message), and the incredibly high benefits, how different is it really?

[1] https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/p/592606

awhitby··on Suez canal blocked by a massive ship
There's no reason to do this. Shipping cost is disproportionately affected by loading/unloading, and every other type of transport is more expensive (per mile travelled). So what you actually want to do is take the ship as close as possible to the goods' final destination, and minimize trucking and rail and so on.

I'm not sure exactly where the "economic center" of Europe is but maps of gridded GDP [0] or nightlights [1] suggests Rotterdam is a pretty good choice.

(Also don't forget the Alps.)

[0] https://bit.ly/31h1hsK [1] https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2012/03/Night_ligh...

awhitby··on SF poop-testing startup, once compared to Theranos, charged in $60M fraud scheme
From http://www.paulgraham.com/founders.html

4. Naughtiness

Though the most successful founders are usually good people, they tend to have a piratical gleam in their eye. They're not Goody Two-Shoes type good. Morally, they care about getting the big questions right, but not about observing proprieties. That's why I'd use the word naughty rather than evil. They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. This quality may be redundant though; it may be implied by imagination.

Sam Altman of Loopt is one of the most successful alumni, so we asked him what question we could put on the Y Combinator application that would help us discover more people like him. He said to ask about a time when they'd hacked something to their advantage—hacked in the sense of beating the system, not breaking into computers. It has become one of the questions we pay most attention to when judging applications.

I believe they took that question off the application in the last few years. Perhaps “rules that matter” versus “rules that do not” turned out to be not so cut and dried.

awhitby··on Investigating how the New York Times A/B tests their headlines
This is interesting but unless I missed it the author doesn't really explain why they believe they observe all A/B tests. They kind of assume that the randomization is over time (so every reader within a window sees the same headline, and then it changes) rather than within cohorts at a fixed time.

But the quote included suggests the NYT does do the latter: "Half of readers will see one headline, and the other half will see an alternative headline, for about half an hour."

So given that the author mostly observes long consistent blocks of time with the same headline, that suggests the NYT is allocating them to a subgroup in a persistent way (by IP or whatever). Then perhaps the cases where they didn't observe A/B testing were just cases where they were randomized into the optimal (hence final) headline subgroup by accident at the beginning, and never saw any different.

awhitby··on IBM Port-A-Punch: create punched card documents anywhere
Presumably if the data were to be archived or processed multiple times it could simply be duplicated onto regular punch cards.
awhitby··on Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
Also "high tension power lines," which being heavy catenaries presumably are in high mechanical tension, but must surely have gotten that name from the voltage = tension thing.

German has this too: voltage = Spannung = tension.

This must go right back to the earliest writings on voltage as a concept.

awhitby··on Sony DD-1EX Electronic Book Player
This made me nostalgic for a 1990s Sony shortwave radio that I had as a kid. It replaced a much larger probably 1980s era radio that my grandfather passed on to me. By comparison this 1990s one was magically miniature - and very similar design to book reader:

https://swling.com/blog/2016/09/the-sony-icf-sw100-a-minitur...

awhitby··on Stepping Down as CEO of the Wikimedia Foundation
I have no connection to and don't know Wikimedia Foundation, and the context for these references is not totally clear. (Maybe it was related to these https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_20/Events.)

Regardless, do you really begrudge the CEO visiting these places?

I get where you're coming from: it's easy to roll your eyes and dismiss this kind of thing as political correctness, pointless "diversity and inclusion" work, pandering to liberal friends etc.

But step back: Wikipedia aims to be the world's encyclopedia. I'm as much in awe as anyone of what a fairly narrow group of pretty obsessive contributors has been able to achieve (I just checked: I've made five tiny edits in 15 years, so not me). But Wikipedia will never succeed in its aim unless it has active contributors in places like Accra, Berlin and Chandigarh.

I honestly don't remember what the donation banners have said in past years. Did they imply they were funding servers and bandwidth only? Maybe they did. But if you actually believe in the mission of Wikipedia, you have to consider that servers and bandwidth will not be enough and that community—maybe including the odd party—is a core part of it.

In that respect, I'm not sure it's too helpful to lump it with Mozilla.

awhitby··on Medieval Cambridge skeletons reveal injuries to manual labourers
It's off topic but there may indeed be a need to say 3.0 rather than 3 for median - the use of a median is orthogonal to the choice of precision.

Consider the median of: 2.9, 3.0, 3.1 years.

awhitby··on Launch HN: Aviron (YC W21) – High-Intensity Peloton for Rowing
Thanks for sharing. Isn't it odd though that of the four product photos on the Home Fitness page two focus on the screen (sure - your selling point) and two show non-rowing workouts. None of them really show rowing.

Not everyone can or will watch the video - you're leaving me with the takeaway that this is a rather expensive dip bench.

awhitby··on States bring action against Google under federal and state antitrust laws [pdf]
Indeed.

> People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.

– The Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter X.

awhitby··on SEO Is Gentrifying the Internet
Google's dominance creates a monoculture, so that any weakness in their ranking is immediately exploited by SEO folks. If there were multiple real search engines using different ranking algos, it would be harder to game them all at once, which would shift the balance somewhat towards just making good content.
awhitby··on Tunnels in the US cost more than anywhere else
I haven't been to the Hudson Yards stop, but many NY subway platforms are very cramped by modern transit standards (compared with even, say the DC metro). I'm sure they're not accessible and hard to make so, and some sections are so narrow as to be positively dangerous.

Building new platforms that were just "as wide as the original subway platforms" would be the bonkers thing.

Sure it's more expensive to build it big, but I bet its more expensive still (if not totally impossible) to build it small then _re_build it big a few decades later.

awhitby··on America's True Unemployment Rate
This is the labor force, as it says: "the sum of employed and unemployed persons."

So it only includes people who are working or looking for work. This kind of distinction is the key to the OP.

So thankfully the dip is mostly not deaths, but for example

- a second earner in a household who lost a job in April but hasn't looked for new work since, due to child care commitments

- a cook who was furloughed but knows there are no new kitchen jobs going right now, but isn't yet willing to do something else, so isn't looking

- a person who lost a job one year out from retirement and is just retiring early

https://www.bls.gov/cps/definitions.htm#nilf

awhitby··on Police are requesting data from smart speakers
Specific Orwell reference:

"He thought of the telescreen with its never-sleeping ear."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telescreen

awhitby··on YouTubers are upscaling the past to 4K, but historians want them to stop
I wonder if it is possible - if not practical - to extract color information from processed black and white film negatives.

It seems plausible that there are trace chemical imperfections in the film medium, and these might react differently to different wavelengths, so that if you could inspect the image at a molecular level you could make pretty good guesses about colors.

awhitby··on Hiring Without Whiteboards
Aren't opinions something an employer should want in developers? And not just opinions on tech stack but all the way up to requirements etc.

If I hire a developer "to build X," I would rather work with the developer who explains that X is the wrong thing and we should actually build Y, than the one who shrugs, asks no more questions, and builds a really excellent X - that later turns out to be the wrong thing to have built.

awhitby··on Your Career in Computer Programming (2015)
It's an interesting idea but I don't think it holds up. The earliest tabulators didn't use punch cards to store "programs" but to encode data, and the mechanical work of punching data into cards, then processing those cards, was fairly rote. "Programming" those machines meant rewiring, as it did for quite a few generations of technology. So while the card handling was certainly done by both men and women [0], I think it's a stretch to suppose it bridged weaving and later (stored program) programming.

Others here will probably have personal memories of the late mainframe era, but my understanding is that even then writing code and punching it on to cards were not necessarily done by the same person, with code first written out long hand on special forms then punched by a specialist. [1]

[0] First, at scale, in the 1890 US census. I just published a book with a chapter on this: http://www.thesumofthepeople.com

[1] e.g. as described here https://code.likeagirl.io/the-first-program-i-ever-wrote-5a5...

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →