HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

axg11

3,460 karma · joined May 13, 2020

DMs are open: https://twitter.com/arshamg_
submissionscomments
axg11··on AlphaFold reveals the structure of the protein universe
AlphaFold is the best counterpoint to tech cynics.

One of the largest public tech companies in the world funded a multi-year scientific project, executed the research flawlessly and moved forward an entire scientific field. They then went on to openly release the code _and_ data, working with a publicly funded organization (EMBL-EBI) to ensure researchers across the globe can easily access the outputs.

I'm not arguing that every tech company is a net positive for humanity. Google itself isn't perfect. Google + DeepMind is setting a bloody high bar though.

axg11··on AlphaFold reveals the structure of the protein universe
If we knew:

(a) the structure of every protein (what DeepMind is doing here)

(b) how different protein structures interact (i.e. protein complexes - DeepMind is working on this but not there yet)

Then we could use those two building blocks to design new proteins (drugs) that do what we want. If we solve those two problems with very high accuracy, we can also reduce the time it takes to go from starting a drug discovery programme to approved medicine.

Obtaining all protein structures and determining how they interact is a key step towards making biology more predictable. Previously, solving the structure of a protein was very time consuming. As a result, we didn’t know the structure for a majority of proteins. Now that it’s much faster, downstream research can move faster.

Caveat: we should remember that these are all computational predictions. AlphaFold’s predictions can be wrong and protein structures will still need to be validated. Having said that, lots of validation has already occurred and confidence in the predictions grows with every new iteration of AlphaFold.

axg11··on Shopify to lay off 10% of workers in broad shake-up
What don’t you understand about that? People leave all the time, before and after layoff events. You need to replace those key roles.

Layoffs are not always about reducing the size of the workforce, but can also be to remove the low performers.

axg11··on Likely cause of mystery child hepatitis outbreak found
Immunity and level of exposure are very tightly coupled. Children would ordinarily be exposed to a variety of viruses from birth. Most encounters with a virus happen at very low viral load (e.g. total number of virus particles you're exposed to). During lockdowns, the diversity of viruses that children were exposed to dramatically dropped. Newborns and young children were now only exposed to viruses that were already in their household. Hence, young children have likely developed immunity to a smaller pool of viruses.

Once lockdowns ended, they were then exposed to many viruses their immune systems had never seen. Some of these exposures would be at low viral load, giving them a chance to build immunity. Some of these exposures would be at high viral load, overwhelming their immune system and leading to illness.

axg11··on The New B-21 Stealth Bomber to Be Revealed Later This Year, Senator Says
They were able to shoot down _one_. This was after analysing many sorties and a bit of luck under ideal conditions. Radar has improved but so has stealth and operating procedures.
axg11··on Potential fabrication in research threatens the amyloid theory of Alzheimer’s
Fraud and fabrication of results are abhorrent, but this is too simplistic a take. These fraudulent results didn't single-handedly spawn 16 years of fruitless research. Instead blame the incentives that create a system where nobody validates a result for 16 years.

If academic science were in a healthy state, novel results would be validated 100s of times. The current system is setup such that only novel results are rewarded. There is no reward for validation. During my PhD I was actively discouraged from performing experiments/studies that weren't "new". Everything ultimately comes back to the funding model. Scientists are only funded for groundbreaking work, measured by the number of publications. In turn, journals will only accept previously unpublished work.

axg11··on Potential fabrication in research threatens the amyloid theory of Alzheimer’s
The most powerful results in science are continually reproduced by being built upon to uncover further new knowledge. I'm no expert in the toxic oligomer hypothesis or Aβ hypothesis, but it appears that these paths have led to very little new knowledge.
axg11··on Potential fabrication in research threatens the amyloid theory of Alzheimer’s
This is a powerful idea. Most problems in science are incentives problems. Sadly there's little or no incentive for journals to adopt this policy.
axg11··on Amazon to Acquire One Medical
I expect this won't be the last acquisition on the health front. All tech-adjacent companies are cheap right now and Amazon is making a big push into health (Amazon Care & Pharmacy). More of these acquisitions can accelerate plans. As a bonus, One Medical already runs on AWS.
axg11··on Deep Learning Papers Are Kinda Bullsh-T
Deep learning is one of the most reproducible areas of science. That might seem like an insane statement until you spend time in a biology (wet) lab. Experiment protocols are often poorly documented and access to materials needed to reproduce experiments are highly uneven. There is even more cherry picking when it comes to biology, especially since biologists don't often have the statistical knowledge to know better.

I'm not writing this to defend deep learning. Reproducibility is an incentives problem across ALL of science. We value novelty and prestigious publications over everything. Nobody wants to fund "boring" research that reproduces existing results. To fix academic science, we need to reward reproducible research and fund groups such that they're capable of performing it.

axg11··on Nvidia Canvas: AI for creating realistic landscape images
Exactly - they could think bigger than selling hardware alone.
axg11··on Nvidia Canvas: AI for creating realistic landscape images
Nvidia's approach to software is really interesting, and demonstrates that they have a hardware culture through and through.

They could turn Canvas into a web app and charge a monthly subscription. Alternatively they could go the OpenAI GPT-3/DALL-E-2 route and give it away as a web app or API to generate a huge potential customer list. Instead, they're only interested in technology demonstrations.

I'm not arguing that this is a good _or_ bad thing. It's just interesting to watch a company drive one of the greatest innovations humankind has ever developed (AI), yet fail to capitalize on the resulting value creation due to a hardware focused culture.

axg11··on Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?
That's the point! Locally, there are great options almost everywhere. In Canada, I can e-transfer (Interac) anyone and the transfer is ~instant. Across borders the solutions are much worse. Crypto is the only payment rail that can realistically reach _everywhere_.
axg11··on Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?
Do you live in North America? I would challenge anyone in Canada/US that claims it's easier to initiate a wire transfer (with zero ability to track progress) vs. send USDC to an ETH address.
axg11··on Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?
With one single integration, AngelList can receive USDC from anyone, anywhere in the world. It doesn't matter if you can transfer CHF very cheaply locally.
axg11··on Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?
I live in Canada and recently invested a small amount in a startup via AngelList RUV. There were two funding options: (1) wire transfer, (2) transfer USDC via Ethereum network. One of these options is cheaper, faster, and more flexible than the other.

Crypto has long been criticized for being gambling and lacking utility. I think utility is finally trickling in, although currently in limited settings. If you look at _all_ of crypto from afar, there is a lot of noise and bullshit. If you zoom into the right applications, there are use cases that are gaining product market fit.

axg11··on Inflation at 9.1% in June
CPI crossed the 2% threshold in March 2021, meaning we've only just barely had 1 year of >2% CPI. If inflation were to nosedive over the next 6-9 months, it would be pretty easy to argue that the inflation was transitory.

I'm not taking sides in the "inflation is transitory" debate, merely saying that it is too early to tell.

axg11··on A/B testing gets misused to juice metrics in the short term
A/B testing is local optimization. It should only be done on a mature(-ish) product when you have given up on finding a global minimum.

Running experiments and A/B tests are popular because it is _guaranteed_ to give you signal. If you have a large engineering team and you're not sure how to filter the quality of results, gating everything through A/B tests is a well understood methodical way to ensure only positive work makes it way through.

Early stage startups should never A/B test. When you're searching for product market fit, you're doing global optimization within the search space. Your product will change drastically as you make new learnings. Premature optimization (A/B tests) will only be detrimental.

axg11··on Deepest infrared image of universe
Incredible photo from a scientific perspective. The team must be ecstatic that everything went to plan so far.

Truthfully I don’t think a random member of the public would be impressed by this photo. I’m surprised that they led with this during their biggest moment of public reach.

Can they remove the diffraction artifacts by rotating and re-acquiring, then doing some kind of diff/averaging? They are very apparent and distracting.

axg11··on Ask HN: Why is the Facebook desktop website so bad?
Meta wants Facebook to die a slow death. Reading between the lines for Zuckerberg's public communications over the last two years, Meta is treating Facebook as a legacy product in maintenance mode. FB is still a cash cow but their social media efforts are focused on Instagram and the long term prospects of the company are focused on VR/AR.
axg11··on I should have loved biology
I think what is described here comes down to the fact that we don't have much (any?) _deep_ understanding of biology. The most concrete aspects of biology are observations. For example, anatomy is very well understood because it's essentially observations of structures within living organisms, as field it has been relatively stable for a long time, hence there are well-established methods for teaching anatomy.

There's a huge gap between the fundamental units of biology (biochemistry) and the resulting emergent behaviour (living things). We don't have a good bottom-up system to predict the emergent behaviour so we're mostly left with observing from the top down and poking/prodding sub-systems, hoping to gain some insight.

When so much of biology is observation without deep insight, it shouldn't be a surprise that biology is difficult to teach, and even more difficult to find beauty in for new students.

axg11··on Hangover prevention pill that breaks down alcohol in the body goes on sale
If this works as advertised, I could see this being useful at the end of a night (as long as you remember to take it).
axg11··on Peter Thiel-Backed Crypto Lender Vauld Suspends Withdrawals
You've never been more bearish than when the highest number of developers and builders are working on crypto?
axg11··on Fintech and Finance: Apple Debt Collections
Apple has the ability to blacklist Apple ID accounts. No idea if they’re using that power, but it’s not something that any collections agency can do.
axg11··on Delayed Messages on iOS
That’s idealism whereas this hack deals with realism: many people don’t have their notifications setup perfectly and also feel the pressure to respond immediately.
axg11··on Unity is laying off hundreds of employees
Every layoff I've witnessed first or second-hand was preceded by the same promise within <2 months from the layoff. I've come to the conclusion it's a necessary evil. These questions are only asked of leaders at companies on a shaky footing. As a CEO, your only option is to deny there will be layoffs. Any other statement will cause panic.
axg11··on Coinbase is reportedly selling geolocation data to ICE
>To see thousands of Americans who can't afford to lose their savings lose it to Coinbase due to wilful negligience, incompetence.

This is a weird take. Coinbase isn't perfect but I don't see this as a valid criticism. Coinbase are equally responsible for thousands of Americans becoming richer than they ever dreamed of by providing them easy access to the crypto world. Coinbase is a trading platform, losses and wins are to be expected.

axg11··on Coinbase is reportedly selling geolocation data to ICE
This is still a problem even if their product only uses public data. Coinbase has access to non-public data, which they can use to validate any analysis or algorithms. Until they explicitly say that no private information was ever used to validate the analytics, it's reasonable to assume they're doing so.
axg11··on Atlassian is 20 years old and unprofitable
Same for Amazon.
axg11··on Web3 is the big idea customers didn’t ask for?
The early "killer" products and projects are there, but most people are looking in the wrong places (DeFi). Some examples below.

Consumer apps:

- STEPN

- Superlocal

The future of brands (NFTs):

- Doodles

- BAYC

Science funding:

- VitaDAO

- Molecule

- HairDAO

← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →