HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

azylman

1,351 karma · joined August 22, 2011

Sr Staff engineer at Uber working on commerce systems. Former Google engineer. Former engineering manager, tech lead, and founding engineer at Clever (YCS12). My comments are my own, I don't represent any employer, past or present.

I do not put disclosures in my comments, my background is fully disclosed here. Per HN commenting guidelines: assume good faith.

submissionscomments
azylman··on Challenges with distributed systems
> the client should just error out and stop processing and return the error to the user, who will have more context and knows whether or not a retry is necessary or desirable... Even banks do that. It's fine

If a user at a bank tries to transfer $10,000, gets an internal server error and retries because their balance hasn't updated (banks don't process these in realtime), and checks the next day and finds $20,000 gone, that's a big problem. The user can't be responsible for this, you need something more.

You're not wrong that this isn't necessary in the majority of cases (updating your email address?) - but the majority of cases don't need distributed systems. By the time you're talking about distributed systems (which is the focus of this article and discussion), you absolutely do need this, in the vast majority of cases.

azylman··on Challenges with distributed systems
> failure to receive back any reply within the stipulated deadline

If you get this error back, the client doesn't know if the server actually processed it or not, so knowing where the client failed isn't actually useful for knowing the state of the request and what needs to happen next.

To handle something like this, you need a resilient design around client-server communications (e.g. assuming retries on the client side and idempotent behavior on the server side).

Immediately erroring out on the client is usually going to lead to a poor user experience and might lead to inconsistent behavior.

azylman··on Kansas City is first major city in U.S. to offer no-cost public transportation
Most of the tax payer population, but not most of the gains available for taxation. Small increases in taxes to the very wealthy would far outweigh large increases in taxes to the middle class in terms of government revenue.

On top of that, you say "unless you added 20%" as if that's something that's beyond the pale when in fact the wealthiest people pay far less in taxes that at any point in our country's history.

azylman··on Amazon Blocks Sellers from Using FedEx Ground for Prime Shipments
> Amazon is going to vertically integrate shipping, no question. The market demands it, and Amazon will probably eventually ship more packages than any of its competitors.

Amazon already delivers half of its own packages. Currently they're about 85% of the size of FedEx.

https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/13/21020938/amazon-logistic...

azylman··on How to fight back against Google AMP as a web user and a web developer
Large companies spend a LOT of money trying to increase conversions by even tenths of a percent. Yes, 2% is substantial.
azylman··on Neither, and New: Lessons from Uber and Vision Fund
The third line of thinking is a combination of the two: "In the short term, the market is a voting machine. In the long term, the market is a weighing machine". This is a popular quote from Benjamin Graham (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benjamin_Graham), who taught Warren Buffett. It's basically the whole principle behind value investing.
azylman··on WeWork’s Back Is Against a Wall
WeWork takes this much further than other SV companies. In their S-1 filing, they had to disclose something like 100+ related party transactions: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alapshah/2019/08/19/just-how-un...
azylman··on Building a Better Go Linker
If you're going to rely on personal experience in an argument, "in six weeks I learned enough to criticize many engineers with decades of experience" is not a strong argument. That's not even claiming to be a 10x engineer, that's claiming to be a 1000x engineer.

I don't intend this to sound harsh, apologies if it does. I strongly recommend you introspect on your own confidence and experience levels. I've mentored a lot of junior engineers with similar viewpoints and often there's a lot of hidden complexity they simply lack the experience to understand.

This isn't to say you should take everything anyone with more experience says at blind faith, simply that dismissing without understanding is counter to a growth mentality.

azylman··on Update on AB5
This is an interesting read about the hotel industry. I don't think it disproves the idea though that there are people who want to low-skilled jobs who can't find them. For instance, from that article:

"The popular Mackinac Island in northern Michigan has only 500 year-round residents but approximately 3,000 jobs in the summer months. Delays on the approval for seasonal worker visas this year forced one resort to temporarily close its restaurant."

When it's their "season", they're probably hurting for staff, but when it's not, all those thousands of people are out of work and need to try to find a new job...

azylman··on Update on AB5
My point was that there's not an unlimited supply of low-skilled jobs. The fact that if you're qualified for one, you're qualified for another isn't really relevant when they can be very hard to find in some areas.
azylman··on Update on AB5
You're assuming there's unlimited demand for employees by McD's... which, in point of fact, is absolutely not the case.
azylman··on Anthony Levandowski Charged with Theft of Trade Secrets
You're comparing apples to oranges.

I know a lot of engineers at a lot of companies who look at porn on their work laptops (which isn't illegal). I don't know a single engineer who would take documents from their previous company to their new company (which is very illegal).

azylman··on Bad Times in Tech? Not If You’re a Startup Serving Other Startups
Currently they're unprofitable and their target market is other, unprofitable companies (e.g. turning away Fortune 500s, from the article). If that changes then it looks more sustainable.
azylman··on Pine Gap, Australia
This comes up in a lot of Australian TV, like Pine Gap (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pine_Gap_(TV_series)) and Secret City (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_City_(TV_series))
azylman··on Lyft Files S-1
I have some friends at AirBnB and I've heard it's much more modest, like $300/yr or something. My experience with these type of "dogfooding" credits is that companies are much more generous when they're smaller, so it could be that older employees get more than newer employees.
azylman··on Tesla Faces Criminal Probe Over Whether It Misstated Production Figures
Lying to investors is illegal regardless of whether your company is public or private
azylman··on The physics of baking good pizza
That's very important in cooking in general, but is definitely not the most important part of baking pizza. Heat transfer is a lot more important, that's why different cooking surfaces (e.g. stone vs. steel) can yield dramatically different pizzas, even at the same temperature. You're going to get a maillard reaction no matter what.

https://slice.seriouseats.com/2012/09/the-pizza-lab-the-baki...

azylman··on The physics of baking good pizza
That only gets up to 280C it looks like, at that point it's not really any different than an oven with a pizza stone
azylman··on Things I Regret About Node.js [video]
It's interesting to hear him say that npm and node_modules are regrets since lots of complaints about Go packaging from people new to Go ask for something similar...
azylman··on Memory efficiency of parallel IO operations in Python
Something seems off here - they mention using 100 workers (a worker for every request). I would expect that to perform way more than 40% faster unless there's a ton of overhead in creating those workers.
azylman··on Bay Area family’s quest to create a backyard container home
Allowing people to put in-law units in their backyard seems like a good move in the short term (to increase supply), but also seems like it might cause problems in the long term: NIMBYs are then _even more_ incentivized to prevent new housing because they're making a killing off the overpriced shipping container in their backyard.
azylman··on Top Ten Time Series DBs
Have you seen Grafana? I've had very good experiences with it. I've never used it with Postgres, but it supports it: http://docs.grafana.org/features/datasources/postgres/
azylman··on Judge blasts Waymo v. Uber lawyers, delays trial until December
Sure, if I started writing my opinion on the case of course I would include it
azylman··on Judge blasts Waymo v. Uber lawyers, delays trial until December
> the only way Waymo could find out for sure what had happened was bring a lawsuit. Or do you think Waymo should have just taken Uber's word that it hadn't done anything illegal?
azylman··on Judge blasts Waymo v. Uber lawyers, delays trial until December
I've been very open about that (it's in my HN profile) and I didn't think it was relevant here since I was quoting the judge and not offering up my own opinions. Apologies if you disagree. :)
azylman··on Judge blasts Waymo v. Uber lawyers, delays trial until December
That's a quote from the judge, not something that I said. The judge also doesn't make any value judgement about whether or not their assumption was reasonable, so I'm not sure what or who you're arguing against.
azylman··on Most Waymo Patent Claims Dropped in Autonomous Car Fight with Uber
The judge asked them to drop all the patent claims, even the one that Google claims Uber is still using/infringing, which means it's unlikely to be related to whether or not Uber was or continues to infringe on them and more likely to be related to the strength of the patents themselves. A lot of patents get invalidated during cases like these...
azylman··on Most Waymo Patent Claims Dropped in Autonomous Car Fight with Uber
Note that the reason he told them to drop the trade secret claims is because they're kind of ridiculous:

> the judge scolded Waymo for being "overbroad" in what it says are 121 trade secrets involved in the case. For example, Alsup wrote that Waymo can't claim that the way it positions light sources in its Lidar is protected, since the design uses well-known principles of physics.

azylman··on Most Waymo Patent Claims Dropped in Autonomous Car Fight with Uber
Google's spin is that they're dropping them because they're no longer using them, but the reality is that the judge has told them they're wrong:

> Judge William Alsup of Federal District Court in San Francisco, who is overseeing the case, urged the company’s lawyers at a hearing on June 7 to drop the patent claims because "you’re going to lose on all these patent claims unless you pull some rabbit out of a hat."

azylman··on Silicon Valley Women, in Cultural Shift, Frankly Describe Sexual Harassment
I really hope that stories like this will let us stop blaming specific companies like Uber and accept that this is a problem with our industry. We're never going to be able to fix this as long as we keep sticking our heads in the sand and pretending it's not a systemic issue.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →