HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bakuninsbart

2,176 karma · joined August 16, 2019

Aware of many things but proficient in none.
submissionscomments
bakuninsbart··on Programming Is Mostly Thinking (2014)
Same, and since we are on the topic of measuring developer productivity; usually my bad-but-kinda-working prototype is not only much faster to develop, it also has more lines of code, maximizing my measurable productivity!
bakuninsbart··on Calculus Made Easy
> In math you can't often solve a more advanced problem such as Calculus problem without understanding the more foundational math such as algebra, fractions, etc.

This is true to a good degree, but maybe a bit less so than you believe. Trigonometry is a topic that only clicked for me after finishing my uni calculus curriculum, I didn't get a great grade, but got by with a technique similar to how we handle complex numbers: Instead of giving up after being unable to solve an eg. weird chain of sin, arccos etc. functions, just declare it to be u(x) and do the calculus bits around it. In the last step substitute the actual function back in and you have an incomplete, yet technically correct solution.

bakuninsbart··on Huawei building chip equipment R&D center in Shanghai
There's some truth to this, but in my opinion especially the line about not respecting their citizens rights is a cop out. In China there are plenty of silly situations like building a highway around a house, because the person didn't want to sell. The difference is that they then just build around it, instead of incessantly discussing back and forth for decades on different approaches. Many western countries have in effect neutered their ability to move through a) lack of long-term accountability in public administration and b) a motivated minority having greater influence than the silent majority.

For politicians it is usually prudent to just kick controversial stuff down the road a couple of years for the next person to pick up. While something the Elizabeth line is greatly beneficial to London as a whole, it is annoying for neighbors, at least while being built, and for the majority EL isn't a deciding factor for election, for those neighbors it might be.

bakuninsbart··on Yes, social media is a cause of the epidemic of teenage mental illness
Eh, no they won't really get over it. I interact with plenty of people in their thirties and fourties who still have a chip on their shoulder because they were "losers" in highschool.
bakuninsbart··on We've been here before: AI promised humanlike machines – in 1958
There are plenty examples of self-awareness and reasoning, and even some that are arguably emotive, like laziness, annoyance or playfulness. I'm not sure what cognition means in this context, but I suspect it has some kind of metaphysical component to it?
bakuninsbart··on Julian Assange granted permission to appeal against extradition to US
Yeah, once you start kidnapping your allies citizens openly, a lot less goodwill will be returned. And the US isn't powerful enough to just bully the rest of the world without repercussions.
bakuninsbart··on House passes bill to force TikTok sale from Chinese owner or ban the app
Reciprocity in this case is supposed to mean "We allow your companies in as long as they follow the local laws, and you will allow our companies in as long as they follow the local laws." TikTok is following American law, which is significantly more permissible in terms of speech than China.

American social media giants thought it was too damaging to follow Chinese law and voluntarily retreated (Google), played the game until they got burned (Facebook) or silently comply (Bing/Microsoft).

In the case of Facebook, they didn't want to share data on Uighur separatists, who organized protests on Facebook, which in turn left hundreds of people dead. Barring any kind of moral judgment, this obviously wouldn't fly in the US either.

No, at the core of this issue is the realisation that a social media giant has enormous influence on the minds of the next generation, and having this be in the hands of foreign powers is very dangerous. Of course, the US doesn't want to be super open about this, since 4/5 global players in social media are American, and they'd rather not have other regions get similar thoughts.

In the end, the reasoning is sound while the justification is hypocritical.

bakuninsbart··on The end of Britain's weeks-long general elections
Being Germans, the idea of someone not being able to identify themselves is inconceivable, worse even; illegal.

Of course this precludes many homeless people from voting, and often from receiving other services, but order must be held in higher regards than compassion.

bakuninsbart··on Downside at NVIDIA (and the Nasdaq at large)
I think the expectation is that as companies begin drawing moats around their data, it will be harder for new players to enter the market. As these models progress, it will just get more expensive to compete, so only the big players will have a shot. OpenAI might only have a slight advantage at the moment, but they have proven they can do it, they have the talent necessary to continue to innovate, and some great backers, including the government through Larry Summers. All they need is a boatload of money, and that's exactly what they are getting through their huge valuation.

I have no idea if that reasoning is sound, but it is at least plausible. I've compared most of the big LLMs, and OpenAI still has a really solid lead imo., mostly due to tooling. But I also suspect they are very close to GPT5, but will wait to release it until they have serious competition, eg. through Gemini.

bakuninsbart··on Real estate giant China Evergrande will be liquidated
A slow down in the rate of urbanisation isn't a reversal. I think you'll be hard pressed finding data to support your argument.
bakuninsbart··on A Terribly Serious adventure: Philosophy and war at Oxford
Derek Parfait is one of the greatest philosophers in my opinion. He died too young, but his philosophy can be called contemporary.

If you're interested, his book "Reasons and Persons" is central and quite accessible. Part 1 is boring to some, but can safely be skipped in that case.

bakuninsbart··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
According to international law, you have to adhere to local law in occupied territories, which Israel isn't doing.
bakuninsbart··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
You are allowed under international law to lead war with significant amounts of civilian casualties. The issue being judged is claims of Israel committing a genocide. This is just a preliminary order while the full case is considered, and it might be bad PR to disregard it, but nothing else will come of it.

When hearing 'genocide', most people immediately jump to the Holocaust, but the definition used by the ICC and IL in general is far more permissible:

Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:

(a) Killing members of the group;

(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;

(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;

(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;

(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

A to E are horrible acts by themselves, but what makes a genocide is intent, and intent is very hard to prove. Personally, I think SA brought a very strong case forward, the genocidal tendencies of key Israeli decision makers and exeters are well published. In the US and Europe, the political class and general public just ignore the evidence currently, and a ruling of the ICC might help people 'wake up', but not much tangible consequences will result from it otherwise.

bakuninsbart··on Let's talk about joins
Exactly, that's why they shouldn't be used. If you feel the need to use a right join, swap the direction around. And only use inner joins if it is the only type of join you use, otherwise specify conditions in the where clause. Both serve to significantly lower mental overhead when dealing with queries.

Natural joins are naturally more implicit, and while SQL tends to be a little bit verbose, given the significance of data integrity and the dififculty of testing SQL, the trade-off goes very clearly towards being explicit.

bakuninsbart··on My Grandpa Was a Nazi
Last november, leading figures of the AfD met with Neo-Nazis to discuss plans on 're-migration'. AfD is without a doubt a fascist party, and would love to turn Germany back into a reactionary hellhole.

https://correctiv.org/en/top-stories/2024/01/15/secret-plan-...

bakuninsbart··on They flocked to build China's cities. Now they are aging with little retirement
Pensioners don't do revolutions, the only reason they are the most important demographic in many Western countries is because they vote. Some of them will probably get support from the state, some will move back to the country side and work there until they drop dead, others will have to rely on their kids or more informal work in the cities.
bakuninsbart··on FAQ on Leaving Google
AGI might solve world hunger, although that particular problem seems to be more about societal organization and trust between people. AGI would without doubt lead to an incredible productivity boost though, and that helps solve many existential problems we currently have as well.
bakuninsbart··on How Group Chats Rule the World
Millenial here, my group of friends is probably falling outside of the norm, but there's been a distinct drive away from social media in general. A good half does not have any public social media like Twitter, Instagram etc ("private" being things like whatsapp or telegram). A good quarter has reverted to old Nokia phones and respond to emails within 3 business days.

Sometimes I get a tinge of fomo when thinking about what others do with social media, but when I dwell on it for 5 minutes, I realize I just don't care that much.

bakuninsbart··on Dynamic programming is not black magic
Interesting quote, since my mind immediately went to Critical theory, one of the schools of philosophy probably targetted by Popper.

Over the last 200 years, the definition of science has been deliberately narrowed down a lot, mainly to combat pseudo-science and misinformation, but I think partially also to create an in-circle of academics. There are few good definitions of science, and usually they are a bit self-contradictory or insufficient to capture the underlying goal of science; the building of a corpus of verified knowledge. Falsification is a very high standard, that cannot always be applied, but it is still a good first test to filter out possible bullshit.

In deductive studies (formal sciences but also often in other fields) we need to have acceptable axioms, and rigorous deductions from these axioms. In inductive studies, you need good data and valid methods to derive meaning from that data. A lot of research actually falls somewhere in-between, and we wouldn't want to outright dismiss it, as many subjects would be too elusive to study at all, but we still have a vested interest in understanding them.

A lot of research, and I would count psycho-analysis in there for the most part, kind of walks the line between pseudo-science and proper deductive or inductive studies. These fields definetely build a corpus of knowledge, which often turns out to be true, but there are fewer good measures of filtering the bullshit from the nuggets of truth, and that substantially devalues the field. The risk, not exclusive but especially pronounced, is that acceptance of research becomes more a measure of eloquence than depth of enquiry.

And fields can be collectively wrong, even in the more rigorous fields that lend themselves to proper testing or deductive reasoning: You mention Newtonian Physics, but there are too many examples to enumerate: Quantum superposition was extremely controversial when first proposed, and poor Lobachevsky was ruthlessly mocked for his perfectly valid development of hyperbolic geometry.

bakuninsbart··on Show HN: Start every terminal session with a vivid reminder of life's value
I'm surprised that there's someone out there seeing it that way, and would be interested in hearing your reasons if you don't mind. Unless I'm hungover from a Saturday evening, Sunday is the day where I can be most creative and most free.
bakuninsbart··on "Nightmare Tenant" Story Amplified by Seattle Times Crumbles Under Scrutiny
My sister is paying half her salary for a crumbling flat in London, and nobody is eating the rich...
bakuninsbart··on The housing shortage is larger than you think
3 years ago, and it was induced by government policy. At any given point since I've become politically aware (around 08), there's been at least one narrative around China's coming collapse, and it hasn't materialised in the slightest yet.
bakuninsbart··on I Love Ruby
I think the point about expressiveness is exactly what makes ruby so divisive: It is great when you are deep within the ecosystem or do exactly what the ecosystem expects you to want to do, and an absolute pain if you want to do anything non-standard.

The supports_feature-method is probably defined somewhere 5 abstractions deep. If you are lucky that is, it might also be part of some library's weird meta-programming of supports-* that no LSP can point you towards. I've never worked in an ecosystem that celebrates implicitness as much as ruby does, and it is driving me nuts.

The fact that finished code looks great and reads well doesn't balance the scales in my book.

bakuninsbart··on The Case for Memory Safe Roadmaps
My dad is in his 60s, started his company with some friends in the 90s. None of them got super rich, but they are all doing well, and all slowly going into pension. The company grew to a mid-size level, but actually most of the early employees stayed, and I think the average tenure is still probably > 10 years. Switching jobs every 3 years is weird, it is pretty much the time it takes to learn the ins and outs deeply enough to be an expert. There's some sense to it, as after learning all you can, it might be better for your career to search for new challenges. There's also the nonsense that switching that often generally yields significantly higher pay.
bakuninsbart··on The Inside Story of Microsoft's Partnership with OpenAI
Well I think it is interesting that Adam D'Angelo remains on the board. If the theories about a power struggle are correct, he managed to be part of the "coup" attempt, and remain at the seat of power despite it failing.
bakuninsbart··on Ask HN: Why are SWE in the US more expensive than SWE in Europe?
I had copilot on as default for a while and it was more annoying than useful. Now I only use it if it is a task I expect it to do well, but honestly most of these could equally be done by becoming a vim/grep wizard.
bakuninsbart··on Henry Kissinger Has Died
Americans bombed the people of Laos for sport killing tens of thousands and crippling many more. Kissinger directly enables and supported this. The man was a monster and should have died long ago.
bakuninsbart··on Italy bans cultivated meat products
The vast majority of Italian culinary tradition stems from the late 19th century or after that. Dishes like carbonara are from the 50s. Pizza as we know it is from the US and was reintroduced to italy by American soldiers. Italians ate rice and beans, same as everyone else, before the
bakuninsbart··on Italy bans cultivated meat products
Those who go hungry eat beans not meat.
bakuninsbart··on Italy bans cultivated meat products
Ultra-processed does not necessarily imply being unhealthy, and lab-grown meat isn't ultra-processed. Arguably, it is less processed than farm-grown meat.

And it doesn't involve the extreme suffering of animals, a point not even raised yet, but far more important than your health.

← PreviousPage 4 of 23Next →