HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

banachtarski

2,796 karma · joined July 16, 2012

programming for ~20 years and counting. math background. generalist with some emphasis on machine learning, graphics, physics simulation, compilers, and server technology. I dabble in electronics and FPGAs.
submissionscomments
banachtarski··on Ask HN: Advanced Linux users, which distribution do you run? Why?
Lifelong linux user.

For desktop I’ve settled on Arch and it’s been smooth sailing for over ten years. The package management is vastly superior to ubuntu/debian and most mainstream distros. As a software developer, I often need recent mainline releases of major compinents like gcc/clang and other such libraries. Other distros force me to manage these manually and tend to have bad packaging conventions.

For server, I tend to do whatever is the “default” of the cloud provider I am working with as they tend to be tested the most and get security patches the quickest.

banachtarski··on Announcing The Zig Software Foundation
C++ is actually the sweet spot for expressiveness and complete control needed for the work I do on consoles and embedded devices. I was excited for zig because in many respects it really does feel like a better C, but I think philosophically, it’s more oriented around building particular types of systems. Disclaimer, I’ve sunk only about 35 hours into Zig so it’s possible it would be different with more experience but that’s about all the time I can realistically afford for a trial run of a new technology these days.
banachtarski··on Announcing The Zig Software Foundation
Maybe an unpopular opinion among Zig programmers, but the lack of operator overloading is/was the true buzzkill for me as someone that tends to do a lot of math/science work in C and C++ both. Getting operators in C++ is one of the biggest productivity boosts compared to when I work in C.
banachtarski··on India bans TikTok, WeChat, and dozens of other Chinese apps
Let's talk about modern day since that's the topic at hand. Who was the last US citizen you know of to be arrested, detained, and killed for voicing opposition to the way the government is run. I'm not saying the US government is perfect (especially in this time, far from it), I'm just saying the comparison isn't remotely apropos. I would say I have the "correct" level of confidence in this regard.
banachtarski··on India bans TikTok, WeChat, and dozens of other Chinese apps
Trying to draw a parallel between Google and a country that literally tortures and murders its citizens for "unsanctioned beliefs" is disingenuous. Cut the bullshit.
banachtarski··on The End of OS X
> still not 100% GPU support

I'm a graphics engineer so I'm not sure I understand this argument. When I talk about weaker and worse-performing hardware options and drivers on Mac, I'm referring _mainly_ to GPUs.

> Non-existent multimedia (video, audio) options

This... is simply not true (?)

Also, regarding Gnome/KDE, I dislike both and don't use either. Something like i3 with zero-to-know configuration is already pretty great out of the box.

banachtarski··on The End of OS X
How is better hardware-to-price ratio and driver performance a "personal preference?" Do you not want those things? If you're saying that having a particular UI is important, that's another matter. I'm just explaining what it is that caused me to ditch the Mac ecosystem.
banachtarski··on The End of OS X
I just "use linux" and I get all the benefits with much better hardware (more memory, disk storage, speed for compilation), better drivers (important especially for GPU support for either graphics/rendering work or machine learning) and my downsides are... what exactly? Itunes, Mail, etc, none of the software shipping with MacOS is actually any good. I don't use Safari. From your perspective, what aspect of the "customer focus" materially improves anything? ICloud? The thing that lost a ton of my data over the years? Safari? The thing that doesn't even support WebGL 2 or other standards that are a decade old? (seriously, safari is the new internet explorer).
banachtarski··on Mark Zuckerberg faces employee blowback over ruling on Trump comments
> Once upon a time, hacker culture was anti-authoritarian.

Wanting to rely on experts to provide accurate information (reporting, history, medicine, science, weather/natural disasters) doesn't not make me pro-authoritarian. The stupid anti-establishment fever needs to stop somewhere. I think in a world with free speech, I can also have the reasonable expectation that the leaders to not promote violence, racism, or bigotry.

banachtarski··on Mark Zuckerberg faces employee blowback over ruling on Trump comments
Facts and editorialism are not the same thing. I want my medical textbook (and the journalist reporting on it) to not lie to me. Whether I elect to choose the treatment after side effects are disclosed is up to me. I'd rather not have to make a medical judgement as to which of 10 pharmaceutical companies are making a false claim however.
banachtarski··on Mark Zuckerberg faces employee blowback over ruling on Trump comments
What an obtuse viewpoint. It's not just about you. Misinformation actively harms society as a whole. Anti-vax, fake remedies, Holocaust-denials, etc. The people taken in by such lies propagate damage beyond their immediate circles.
banachtarski··on Mark Zuckerberg faces employee blowback over ruling on Trump comments
Nonsense. Even basic human checkers for high profile demonstrably false statements or calls to violence would be sufficient at this point.
banachtarski··on In protest of the web{*} bulldozer, a response to websocket port scanning
So much misinformation and FUD in this article. It's immediately suspect that the author had to lookup what websockets even WERE. No mention of the permissions system? This is a super low-quality article to make it to the front page.
banachtarski··on Lomuto's Comeback
Ah OK I understand now thanks for clearing that up. I meant that the end effect was similar but not so much that the mechanism was identical.
banachtarski··on Lomuto's Comeback
I'm speaking broadly about desktop/console CPUs which I have low-level familiarity with. I don't know of any CPUs in this class that don't perform some form of speculative execution.

I'm not sure if eager evaluation is related to the topic at hand and was speaking specifically about speculative execution. Eager evaluation is just what pretty much every language except Haskell (or Haskell-like) does.

banachtarski··on Lomuto's Comeback
I’m unconvinced because the instruction set sizes are already becoming fairly bloated (increasing microcode translation cost and i-cache pressure) but also because CPUs already do speculative execution which has a nearly equivalent effect to the idiom you’re referring to.

*edit: wording

banachtarski··on Bitcoin Halving Just Occured
It's an "extreme statement" but to be honest, I'm inclined to agree. As a currency, it's an absolute failure. Far too volatile, illiquid, and unregulated to be even remotely usable/reliable. As for everything else? It's still looking for a "solution" that isn't just something hype driven.
banachtarski··on Circle – A C++ compiler with compile-time imperative metaprogramming
Circle is honestly a breath of fresh air and much more palatable in terms of usability/speed than the existing constexpr facilities or proposed reflection IMO.
banachtarski··on Valve drops VR support for macOS
This is the type of bullshit comment that makes me login and bother replying. Anyone in the industry that has needed to work with Apple knows their stance on games is inane. This is in spite of the fact that games make the lion’s share of revenue on their app store and they know it. This in spite of the fact that the majority of games on their iOS platform suck. Games is really not in their dna and boy does it show.
banachtarski··on Intel's flagship 10th-gen desktop CPU has 10 cores, reaches 5.3GHz
That's a very simplistic view of the architecture. Consoles in general have multiple CPU complexes and caches that do not straddle the boundary, and also multiple memory buses.
banachtarski··on Intel's flagship 10th-gen desktop CPU has 10 cores, reaches 5.3GHz
You're kidding me. Half the multithreaded PS4 optimizations I needed to make were related to atomic interlock exchanges over the numa boundary.
banachtarski··on Intel's flagship 10th-gen desktop CPU has 10 cores, reaches 5.3GHz
Precisely. Not only that, most games that run on consoles are generally NUMA aware and use NUMA aware algorithms.
banachtarski··on Intel's flagship 10th-gen desktop CPU has 10 cores, reaches 5.3GHz
Gp comment mentions AAA. We PACK the core occupancy and for many titles, it’s essentially a ship requirement.
banachtarski··on [dead]
As if ytd returns on anything so volatile was a useful metric. Not noteworthy. I can probably find two points in time where the delta was more profitable than almost anything. Doesn’t make it a sound investment or demonstrate its value.
banachtarski··on Proving that C++'s grammar is undecidable
Turing completeness and undecidable parsing grammars are completely orthogonal concepts.
banachtarski··on Google Pixel Buds
> and it's vanishingly unlikely that Google got this right.

this is the fanboy part. I'm not a google fanboy (I own none of their products), but you can frame your comment differently (aka more neutrally). Just say what it is about the air pods you like, ask if google's pixel buds do the same, or just research it yourself and provide information as opposed to speculation. What makes it a fanboy comment is the bias, and you've still done nothing to dissuade me from believing you possess it.

banachtarski··on Google Pixel Buds
Typical fanboy comment. If you don’t have the information to make an informed comparison, don’t attempt one
banachtarski··on Benchmarking C++ Allocators
> This argument smells like bullshit, sorry, and it's totally not justified in the article. Giving just numbers without even explaining a potential causality points to benchmark setup failure more than anything.

Why? This argument sounds perfectly reasonable and is true in many other contexts as well.

banachtarski··on The Lost Art of Structure Packing (2018)
Right I mentioned "store size of the key on the map" as the second option for K&R/Ansi C.
banachtarski··on The Lost Art of Structure Packing (2018)
Wrong answer. This is brittle and relies on the memory always being initialized correctly and will be prone to all sorts of issues in the wild. Better is just either templatize on the key type or store the size on the map.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →