504 karma · joined December 2, 2019
Let me google that for you:
>control: the power to influence or direct people's behavior or the course of events.
-George Orwell
The opposite, actually. The civil rights movement of the 60s was infiltrated, surveilled, and disrupted by secret police, and largely ended with it's greatest leaders being assassinated and mass riots.
Then Nixon launched the War on Drugs in the 70s and mass incarceration began.
In the 80s we saw Democrats and Republicans further ramping up the war on drugs, with the passage of laws such as the Anti Drug Abuse Act of 1986, while at the same time it was soon revealed that the CIA was helping their Nicaraguan Contra friends raise money by importing billions of dollars of cocaine into inner cities as a part of the Iran Contra conspiracy, initializing the crack epidemic. The investigations into these wrong doings was quickly shut down, the investigative journalist leading the charge was suicided, and the government officials responsible were pardoned.
Fast forward 30 years, and the mass incarceration levels have been holding steady and communities are even weaker by some metrics than they were before the civil rights movement, though perhaps we've made some marginal improvements in states where cannabis has been legalized, but we've still got a lot more to do: namely, ending the tyrannical and racist war on drugs at the Federal level.
What about all the Democrats and Republicans who are ultimately responsible for the laws governing the police system and who have for years tacitly or explicitly supported the war on drugs?
>If someone opens up the Facebook app for 5 minutes a month they are considered a MAU. Suggesting that browsing an app for a few minutes out of a day is comparable to authoritarian control over 1.4 billion people demonstrates a complete lack of perspective in reality.
Your strawman is what lacks perspective of reality. The average FB user spends 30-60 minutes on Facebook each day, depending on the source.
By "unusual" I mean anything that has intended or unintended negative effects on society, such as what was seen with Cambridge Analytica, or FBs emotional manipulation studies.
>It can find common errors. It can find bad behavior inserted by unskilled people. But against groups that know about current work, you won't find anything
Yep, and without a 3rd party audit, we can't even begin to approximate the degree of hypothetical bad behavior that exists affecting billions of people due to regular developers doing what they're told by their product managers (or of their own volition), let alone a nation state APT.
Yep!
>You're confusing finding accidental bugs with an actor trying to hide behavior. The latter you will not find if the actor is as big as a FAANG or nation state.
Wrong, wrong, wrong. Here's but one of many examples: https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2019/08/a-very-deep-d...
>it shows that a code audit will not turn up malicious behavior if the owner is actively trying to hide stuff from you.
Yes, code obfuscation is a thing, but it's not a perfect silver bullet like you falsely claim, and often only serves to slow down researchers.
Of course it is true though that many bugs and vulnerabilities remain hidden which we may never find, and yet that's not a valid reason not to look for them, because there are many which are found every single day.
The perfect is the enemy of the good.
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/06/every...
In terms of software security vulnerabilities, there is so much low hanging fruit making exploitation trivial. Even if a small team within an intelligence agency knows about a zero day deep in the stack, addressing vulnerabilities higher up in the stack that are easily exploited by script kiddies necessarily reduces attack surface.
However, what we're talking about here is not so much about security vulnerabilities, as it is about design flaws (or features) which have harmful effects on society.
This is so plainly false its silly. Have you ever heard of a code review? What do you think security researchers do? Google Project Zero. Plenty of things are found all the time at the higher (and lower) levels of the stack, even if something unknown remains deep within.
>And most of the activity by big companies is not in code, it's in data it is currently beyond anything on the near horizon.
Audits have no problem finding out what type of data is being collected (see PCI || HIPAA compliance). That would be a great start: for people to be made explicitly aware of all the data points that are being collected on them.
Are you implying that since we can't audit every single thing, auditing anything is useless?
Seeing how the sausage gets made certainly can make lots of people lose their taste for it.
What is this alternative you speak of?
>He voices far out opinions to take advantage of his audience and doesn't have anything actually interesting to say.
Agreed, though corporate mass media in general also takes advantage of their audience and likewise has nothing interesting to say.