HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bananabiscuit

685 karma · joined May 21, 2016

submissionscomments
bananabiscuit··on A trillion-dollar coin could be minted within hours of an emergency decision
Not sure why your being downvoted. Nothing about this makes any sense, I don’t think your questions have obvious answers unless you already knew how it works.
bananabiscuit··on A trillion-dollar coin could be minted within hours of an emergency decision
Probably not rhetorical, I don’t think most people know about what obscure laws that make these kinds of loopholes work. I’m actually surprised you thought it was common enough knowledge that you suspected the question was rhetorical.
bananabiscuit··on New York's largest healthcare provider fires 1,400 unvaccinated workers
I read their link:

> This study demonstrated that natural immunity confers longer lasting and stronger protection against infection, symptomatic disease and hospitalization caused by the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2, compared to the BNT162b2 two-dose vaccine-induced immunity.

bananabiscuit··on Paracetamol use during pregnancy – a call for precautionary action
My initial reaction was similar: “everyone uses Tylenol, if there was something really that bad about it, we would have seen it more”. But then someone pointed out that we have much more ADHD today than in the past and that does coincide with the more casual use of Tylenol starting in the 70s and 80s, so maybe we really are seeing the bad effects of Tylenol use during pregnancy after all.
bananabiscuit··on U.S. debt default could wipe out 6M jobs and $15T in wealth
I’m don’t really know how macroeconomics works too well, and no article about this debacle that I’ve read really explains what the repercussions are of the debt ceiling getting raised higher and higher. Surely this must have some end? Or can we just keep going forever?
bananabiscuit··on Arizona officials hold press conference on elections audit results
Dr Shiva brought up some interesting questions and I think we definitely need good answers for them from the county. And it also shows that just because there isn’t obvious evidence of fraud, doesn’t mean evidence can’t be found when you actually start investigating.

However one curious thing about his report is the question he had about how the stamp appears to go under the triangles that were printed on the envelope. He implied there was fraud involved here and that it might be some sort of “photoshop mistake”. The guy has 4 degrees from MIT, some related to computer science, it sounds like he has extensive experience in computer vision, so how is it possible that he (nor any of his team) realize they were looking at not raw images, but the output of an edge detection filter, which plainly explains why the text appears to be “under” the triangles?

It’s not possible that he could have missed a detail that anyone who paid attention in the first week of an intro computer vision class would have fought. That sort of implies his whole analysis was not done in good faith and should be thoroughly scrutinized before any other of his implied conclusions are to be taken seriously.

bananabiscuit··on Chess pros burn a Michael Phelpsian 6k calories per game
Yeah maybe. I don’t really know what you mean then, Because there isn’t really a “typical” physique for people that burn insane amounts of calories per day. Power lifters and marathon runners both regularly burn calories in high ranges like that yet their physiques are totally different.
bananabiscuit··on Chess pros burn a Michael Phelpsian 6k calories per game
Burning calories isn’t what leads to muscular physique, looking at any marathon runner is proof of that.
bananabiscuit··on Windows 11: Just say no
What if they lock the next version of DirectX behind Windows 11?
bananabiscuit··on Considerations in boosting Covid-19 vaccine immune responses
Obviously the vaccines weren’t studied enough if we are only finding out now that certain age groups might be at more risk from vaccine side effects than from covid itself (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/10/boys-more-at-r...)

OPs Lancet article shows there is not a consensus on effectivity of boosters, but you will never hear that from the left media.

I understand science is a process, and things that we might think are true/false/undetermined now might change based on new evidence. My complaint isn’t that scientist aren’t magically getting everything right first try, but that there is clear bias in the media towards some narrative and while most people happily will take that for granted with right wing news sources, they think left wing news sources are somehow immune to spreading misinformation.

bananabiscuit··on Considerations in boosting Covid-19 vaccine immune responses
Interesting how much of a double standard there is in the media when it comes to promoting booster shots before the effects of doing so are adequately studied, but then pre-maturely shutting down other potential treatments (ivermectin, fluvoxamine, hcq), when there isn’t really a consensus for either thing.

Shooting from the hip seems to be fine as long as it has the effect of administering more vaccine doses, but everything else is to be ridiculed and held to much stricter standards of scientific proof.

bananabiscuit··on Why doesn’t natural immunity count in the US?
If you read it carefully, that CDC study compares vaccinated vs unvaccinated in the population of people that recovered from covid.

It does not compare vaccinated (and not recovered) vs recovered (but not vaccinated), but I have seen many people misinterpret it in this way including journalists.

I think this sort of misdirection is by design with how often I see it happening, the right does not have a monopoly on spreading misinformation.

bananabiscuit··on Nearly 1 in 3 Americans experienced a weather disaster this summer
Cliff Mass’s post is a good read. I can barely justify faulting climate change deniers anymore exactly due to the kind of very low quality reporting of the science behind it that he points out.
bananabiscuit··on Reddit communities ‘go dark’ in protest over Covid misinformation
This makes me sad but is also actually kind of hilarious.

> The r/PokemonGo subreddit, representing players of the augmented reality game, announced it was going dark and would stay private until Reddit removed sites spreading misinformation about Covid.

Really? r/PokemonGo mods are to have influence over what kind of discussion people can have about a constantly evolving medical situation?

bananabiscuit··on Judge’s order requiring hospital to give Covid patient ivermectin
The study that originally was widely and loudly used to turn the public opinion against HCQ had actually been retracted just 2 weeks after being published and without much fanfare.

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

Since then there have been studies that show HCQ can be effective in early treatment.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33042552/

However, the damage seems to have already been done.

bananabiscuit··on The US Intelligence Community’s Assessment on Covid-19 Origins [pdf]
While saying that they might know where the virus came from seems to be allowed, saying for example “I think China created the virus via gain of function research” would still get you banned from Facebook today according to these rules: https://m.facebook.com/help/230764881494641
bananabiscuit··on Having SARS-CoV-2 once confers much greater immunity than a vaccine
I disagree and there are also doctors and experts that disagree.

There is no reason to assume medical experts are free of groupthink. There is also no reason to assume the medical industrial and related government regulators are free from corruption. Which makes it all the more important to question the advice we are given by “experts” and ask if it makes any sense. To me it doesn’t.

bananabiscuit··on Having SARS-CoV-2 once confers much greater immunity than a vaccine
Reducing a 1% chance of re-infection to .5% does not imply that population needs to get vaccinated.
bananabiscuit··on Immunity Generated from Covid-19 Vaccines Differs from an Infection
I’ll personally take the risk of being reinfected with COVID.

Either way, at a <= 1% risk of re-infection, I’m no longer a real liability to society so please just leave it for me to decide and don’t force me undergo any unnecessary medical procedures.

bananabiscuit··on Immunity Generated from Covid-19 Vaccines Differs from an Infection
Sorry. I never said and never even meant to imply that you should try to get sick instead of getting the vaccine. Only that if you were already sick, that it greatly shifts your own risk/benefit profile in the direction of not getting the vaccine.
bananabiscuit··on Immunity Generated from Covid-19 Vaccines Differs from an Infection
That mechanism of action is just what I’ve seen put forth by immunologists commenting on the these kinds of results.

While the author’s opinions on the necessity of vaccines do differ, they do agree on my main point: that empirically, natural immunity is indeed robust and tentatively even better than vaccine acquired immunity.

It looks like getting a vaccine helps boost immunity in all cases, whether you had a previous infection or if you had 2 doses and I would bet even after the booster, each additional shot will continue to provide some marginal benefit. So keep getting jabs, I guess, or you’re killing grandma.

I think at this point throwing in “you should vaccinate (regardless of your individual circumstance)” into your conclusion, even if it’s a complete non-sequitor, is a hedge against losing your job/funding/respect of your equally frightened peers. The COVID research equivalent of the “making the world a better place” SV trope.

bananabiscuit··on Immunity Generated from Covid-19 Vaccines Differs from an Infection
This is true. But given the already high baseline immunity for previously infected people, the messaging for them should be somewhere closer to “you can get the vaccine if you want” rather than “you must get the vaccine otherwise you are causing the pandemic”.
bananabiscuit··on Immunity Generated from Covid-19 Vaccines Differs from an Infection
The spike protein targeting antibodies produced by the vaccine do indeed target a wider range of spike mutations than the spike protein antibodies from previous infection. However, vaccines only target spike protein, while a previous infection will cause your body to produce antibodies for a much larger set of targets on the virus, which in practice leads to a more robust immunity. This is supported by data from Israel and some recent studies.

https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/309762

https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/310963

https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.24.21262415v...

bananabiscuit··on CDC: Covid vaccine effectiveness fell from 91% to 66% with Delta variant
There’s a CDC study that shows vaccinating while previously infected, further boosts your immunity by more than double https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr...

What they don’t mention is that previous infection alone is at least as good as vaccination alone. According to data from Israel, previous infection is about 6x more effective in fact. https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr...

Given that, I don’t at all agree with the conclusion of that CDC study that you HAVE to get vaccinated if you had a previous infection.

bananabiscuit··on FDA Approves First Covid-19 Vaccine
Was going to make a long winded post describing all my views on this but thought better of it. For me personally, the decision is very simple: I already suffered through COVID, the current data shows naturally acquired immunity is at least as good as any vaccine, therefore there is no good reason for me to consider getting it.

If my ability to make a living will be held hostage based on my vaccination status, or if https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/4980 gets passed, I will change my mind and get the vaccine just so I can gtfo of here.

bananabiscuit··on FDA Approves First Covid-19 Vaccine
In my experience, the intent of people asking me why I don’t want to vaccinate is almost never to really understand my perspective and my reasons for not doing so. Instead the goal is usually to find the first statement I make that they feel they can easily attack (ignoring all other reasons I state), and then attack that statement and conclude that I am a conspiracy theorist antivaxxer.
bananabiscuit··on How is efficacy vs. severe disease strong if 60% of hospitalized are vaccinated?
Very high quality article. I wish all reporting on this topic was as nuanced.

I think it is important to add that although the vaccine is indeed effective against preventing severe disease, the same data from Israel does still show that the vaccine is not as effective against contraction of the disease (only 39% effectiveness).

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/23/delta-variant-pfizer-covid-v...

bananabiscuit··on How is efficacy vs. severe disease strong if 60% of hospitalized are vaccinated?
From what I’ve seen, it’s extremely rare that you get a high quality article like this one, regardless of whether it is provaxx or antivaxx.
bananabiscuit··on 74% of recent Covid cases in parts of MA were among the vaccinated – CDC study
I am familiar with Simpson’s Paradox but I carefully read your linked article anyway and it truely is enraging to me when statistics is twisted to lie to people. I totally agree there is a very large amount of really bad headlines and non-expert pundit conclusions from right wing media. And it is harmful. I wish more people took the time to understand what statistics are actually saying. Unfortunately I think some portion of the population might just be incapable of properly understanding stats, it really is a hard and tricky subject.

That said, I don’t think the data from the OP’s CDC article is a case of Simpson’s paradox. The quoted statistic in the CDC article is that 74% of infected people were vaccinated. I am comparing that to the vaccination rate in MA of 69% (also from the article). The denominator in one stat is a strict subset of the denominator of the second stat. Simpson’s paradox requires disjoint denominators.

So that being the case, I would still like for actual experts to follow up on this data and come to some conclusion.

bananabiscuit··on 74% of recent Covid cases in parts of MA were among the vaccinated – CDC study
So if that is the current understanding of how the vaccine works, isn’t it important to follow up on data that seems to not align with those statements? If 69% of people are vaccinated, I would expect <69% of recent COVID cases to be from the vaccinated.

When we get data that contradicts what we expect, it needs to be taken seriously, it needs to be broadcast, it needs to be followed up on, and the correct conclusions need to be drawn from experts in a transparent way.

← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →