HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bananaface

281 karma · joined July 10, 2020

submissionscomments
bananaface··on Org Mode's new site
https://github.com/Somelauw/evil-org-mode
bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I think that's why I'm being downvoted too, but frankly if the codebase is so bad that something is being copy/pasted hundreds of times to the point of unmaintainability, the abstractions that same team would build would probably also be disastrous, and much harder to deal with. Is that preferable?

But tbh, I'm skeptical of the premise to begin with. It's still easier to gradually consolidate 100 slightly different uses of a pattern than blindly create an abstraction that adequately covers those 100 uses. If your team is useless, it's better that their code be fragmented and atomic anyway, because big mistakes are inevitable. You don't want to make it hard to touch those mistakes. You want that code to be uncoupled & disposable.

But at that point the argument is getting pretty abstract. Depends on the specific codebase.

bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I said this below but I like to distinguish technical debt as having metaphorical "interest" - specifically, it becomes more expensive to pay back the longer you leave it, the ball of debt grows over time. It's stuff that gets baked into a product, and then is difficult (or impossible) to un-bake, and gets more difficult the more the product grows around it.

Aside from the initial increase in cost when you forget how the original code worked, tests are no more expensive to write in a year as they are today. Not significantly, at least. So I'd just class them as incomplete product - the effects are negative and can be expensive, but it doesn't dig you into a hole.

bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I agree, I just wouldn't call it tech debt. It doesn't become more expensive to fix over time, except for the bump when you forget how the original code works. There's no metaphorical "interest" that you draw down on.
bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I would say: technical debt is anything that makes the system more expensive to maintain (and grow) over time, and becomes more expensive to fix the longer you leave it. If it's just a bad or incomplete aspect of the system, that's not sufficient. It has to become more expensive over time.

So e.g. lack of functionality isn't tech debt, but a bad abstraction is usually tech debt.

bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I wouldn't even say lack of testing is technical debt - it's just another feature that isn't implemented. Once you implement it, problem's solved.

It doesn't make the system worse/more expensive as it grows, and it doesn't become more costly to "fix" the bigger the system gets. IMO those are the operative features of tech debt.

bananaface··on Technical Debt: Why it'll ruin your software
I would argue copy/pasted code is usually not technical debt because it's very isolated and easy to change, and it's cheap to consolidate it later. Crappy abstractions are a way bigger source of technical debt than repeating yourself IME. It's a lot easier to create a new abstraction than modify an existing one, so you generally want to wait as long as possible.
bananaface··on Don't Use VPN Services (2016)
Thanks! This makes sense.
bananaface··on Don't Use VPN Services (2016)
Unless you explicitly need speed, or they're your only option, why do people use VPNs for privacy over Tor? Do they provide any benefits other than being faster? I thought Tor was a much more secure option if privacy in particular is your objective.
bananaface··on Permanently remote workers seen doubling in 2021 due to pandemic productivity
Smartphones have notification schedules for stuff like this. You can enable/disable different notifications during different hours.
bananaface··on Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t
I think a deeper network has less degrees of freedom in which to move, or rather, in which to move usefully, because parameters are more interdependent. That means in order to generate a useful function, it has to learn more abstract features than a shallow and wide network. This is because any adjustment to irrelevant features that are unique to a small number of examples has a larger negative impact on the rest of the data than it would in a shallower net (except in the latter layers). Over time, abstract changes are stochastically rewarded and specific changes are penalised, at least for the earlier layers, and the latter layers then have to work with this more abstract information so they simply can't overfit that much.

Would be interested in OP's take on this though.

bananaface··on Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t
Doesn't the fact the network is discrete (floats have a maximum precision) mean this isn't actually the case? There's a finite number of states the net can be in, and one (or more) is best.
bananaface··on Flame retardant may cause hyperthyroidism in cats
I would argue you see that uncomfortably often
bananaface··on The Programmer's Price (2014)
Completely disagree with the superstar thing. Some developers are hundreds of times more effective than others even if you ignore raw output, because they know where to apply their effort.

There are games written by one person that are more fun and sell better than games written by teams of 1000. Some one-man open-source libraries are used by ten people, some are used by millions. The degree to which you can control that is your multiplier.

bananaface··on Timekeeping in Financial Exchanges
Some forms of HFT work by getting information from other exchanges before you, then front-running on price differences.
bananaface··on Rust After the Honeymoon
It's a shame, though. Content aggregators at least should allow the ones that exist to bubble up.
bananaface··on Reddit's Stock Threads Become a Must-Read on Wall Street
Someone who doesn't own a stock benefits from the publicity. Peter Schiff has made a lot more money from books and his gold brokerage than investing in gold.
bananaface··on OpenAI is giving Microsoft exclusive access to its GPT-3 language model
It's not captive. It's quite replicable (and impossible to monopolise), it's just expensive.
bananaface··on You weren't meant to have a boss (2008)
Doesn't matter. If I got a large chunk of the long-term payoff, I'd care about tackling those problems. The issue is incentive, not the difficulty of the work.
bananaface··on OpenAI is giving Microsoft exclusive access to its GPT-3 language model
Auto-formatting punctuation - or syntax. You can show it a few examples and it will insert punctuation into raw words coming in from speech recognition, or convert badly formatted Python into well-formatted Python. It can correct syntax errors in C++ (!).

More generally, it can convert text from a simple, unstructured form into more complex, more structured form, with just a few example transforms. It's astonishingly good at it, but I haven't seen much on the public net about it. I don't know why people aren't exploring it more tbh.

bananaface··on How tech workers at Kickstarter formed one of the only unions in the industry
Thank you for explaining.
bananaface··on Why I stopped reading HN (2010)
Forums like this, reddit, etc. become worse over time partly because people demand (superficially) high-quality comments. People who's time is valuable are less likely to comment.

When a very talented & experienced person says, "that's a bad approach" with no explanation, you should pay close attention, but that type of comment gets downvoted into oblivion and on HN is explicitly against the rules. It's very artificial, that doesn't happen in real life. People who's reputation precedes them don't have to justify themselves. Guido Van Rossum is not going spend time laboriously correcting the things he disagrees with on open forums like this - he probably isn't browsing the forum in the first place. You have to adapt to that.

That becomes a cycle, and gradually the average quality declines as each successive tier of experience gets sick of it (and of being ignored when they try to articulate the problem) and leave.

Hacker News is not as vulnerable to this as other communities, and I'm not sure why, but it's still a problem.

The core issue is that external reputation is both hard to decipher on Reddit-style forums, and not rewarded when it exists. Every post is judged on its local merits, who posted it is usually irrelevant. Sounds good, but it just leads to people BSing. So HN is full of overwritten pedantry and BS, interspersed by the odd person with actual, hardcore experience getting sick of it and writing a lone, high-effort rebuttal. Which will tend to do well, but... It's not the typical post. Most posts are high-effort bullshit and resultant arguments.

bananaface··on How tech workers at Kickstarter formed one of the only unions in the industry
How does the protection work in the case of e.g. Brexit going badly? Do they have insurance policies that pay out if the UK economy tanks?
bananaface··on Patent Lawyer Turned Judge Advertises for Patent Trolls to Come to His Court
An alternative and IMO better fix would be to have patent cases decided by juries.
bananaface··on Fortunately, I don't squash my commits
The problem with rebasing is you might break every one of those commits, which defeats the purpose of chunking the work like that in the first place (since its no longer an honest reflection of what was happening/what worked at each point).
bananaface··on H&M Hit with Record-Breaking GDPR Fine over Illegal Employee Surveillance
Quite a lot of companies function better when managers are poorly paid, obedient and basically apply a replicable system with minimal autonomy. It would suck to work there but structures like that absolutely exist & are very profitable.
bananaface··on Facebook Prediction Market Launches in US and Canada
>This isn't trading, though. It's forecasting.

That's not my point. The point is people don't give away predictive edges for internet points (or reputation). There are many reasons why but the lack of a betting & trading StackOverflow is one symptom. It's just an example, but TBH it's not that relevant since this market wouldn't involve revealing edges.

>People go near real money strategies like that all the time.

Absolutely, and it's a problem with real funds. But:

- It's a lot rarer.

- There's a much stronger incentive for other people to quietly take the opposite sides of those bets, which normalises the market.

We'll see what effect it has, but I think this marketplace will just end up following the values on PredictIt.

bananaface··on Google: “Any harm Epic has suffered is not irreparable and is of its own making”
I don't think that's correct either. They just have to show that Apple is engaging in anti-competetive behaviour as defined by the Sherman Act.
bananaface··on Google is giving $1B to publishers to help convince governments not to take more
Right, and a serf can technically leave. But they can't, because they lose access to the pertinent resource. Where else can they farm?

I don't like the media, I'm not trying to make out they're weak. My issue is that Google monopolising attention and then unilaterally taking news website's work for free is BS. They're skimming the vast majority of value from the industry with no kickbacks. They get away with it because no inidividual news organisation can fight. The only option is collective action (won't work, too much reward for defecting) or legislation.

bananaface··on Google: “Any harm Epic has suffered is not irreparable and is of its own making”
The basis of the lawsuit is that the TOS are unreasonable. It doesn't matter if they broke them, in fact they had to to even bring the lawsuit.

They might still lose but the fact they broke the TOS won't count against them.

← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →