281 karma · joined July 10, 2020
Will be interesting to see how this one plays out. I wonder what effect that will have on the market, it makes it much closer to a democracy than a betting market.
>I don't really see how that cashes out in an inaccurate overall system
Imagine a strategy that has a 50% chance of blowing you up completely over 10 years, but nets you 50% more profit if it works. The average return of this strategy is 25% less than a safe strategy (zero risk, zero gain), but it has a 50% chance of winning in this marketplace. If it were real money, nobody would go near it.
Ok, now imagine there's 100 people running strategies with that profile and 100 running the safe strategy. All of the top spots will be held by the suicidal strategy. This is an artificial example but you get the point. Real money forces you to avoid that risk profile as soon as you identify it.
Reputation is also not that great of a proxy, since you can game it. E.g. by using strategies that push all the risk into the tails. If it's money, you have a much stronger incentive to cover your ass against rare but disastrous blowups, since your entire livelihood is at stake (rather than just your ability to play the local game). If you're just trying to look good on Facebook... The risk/reward is different.
In general though parents should be the ones making decisions about their children. Teachers being judged by arbitrary beurocrats i.e. what we have now sounds obviously worse to me.
The whole political argument seems weak to me. I think most parents probably care about academics more than that to begin with, but if political homogeneity is important to a particular parent, why shouldn't that influence their vote?
>There's a possibility the programmer who did the masters was simply unable to get a job after his BSc.
Yeah, that would skew the data completely. Especially if you don't stratify by institution.
>You can't expect college hires to be productive on day one.
To be clear, I don't disagree with this, I'm just looking at it from the persective of employers. Why hire them if you need to retain them for a year or two before they're worth the salary? You need to pump money into them that whole time? Just hire people with experience to begin with.
But like, that's also where this debate normally goes and I think it's the less important point: the bigger issue is the credential is not preparing graduates properly. People should be angry about that, and demand it changes. They should be told that up front, before they purchase.
>the best engineers simply disappear. FAANGs hire them and they basically never actively look for a job after that
This is interesting. I hadn't thought about it in these terms.
(Not meaning to be rude, just that they're already going to be way above average.)
I don't mean this in a superficial sense, I mean: there's no way for a PhD to be certified for investigating the kind of knowledge that's difficult to verify in that context. They can investigate it, but the system is only allowed to give them a qualification for academically verifiable results. It cannot verify esoteric knowledge (unless it can use consensus as a proxy).
Sure, they'll pick that stuff up with experience. We might be talking past each other. I read it as: they're hiring graduates. That might not be what OP meant.
Like, from what I can tell, most BSc graduates... suck. They're not able to program professionally, they damage your codebase. The credential just isn't a signal of adequate ability. Any hiring managers able to chip in here?
PhDs seem to me to be for quantifiable knowledge. They imbue highly specialised skills and imply a huge understanding of technical literature. But they structurally can't imbue skills that are nebulous. They can only teach things that are either consensus, or easy to evaluate academically.
https://emacs-lsp.github.io/lsp-mode/page/performance/
Ordinarily I'd ignore rabbit holes like this but LSP is unusually useful. It's worth a shot.
Eglot: 70 open, 277 closed
lsp-mode: 94 open, 977 closed
(lsp-mode is much more than 3x the size of eglot and has 15x the number of downloads on MELPA)
This is Eglot's code. Try and figure out what's happening in each of these passages:
https://github.com/joaotavora/eglot/blob/master/eglot.el#L41...
https://github.com/joaotavora/eglot/blob/master/eglot.el#L41...
https://github.com/joaotavora/eglot/blob/master/eglot.el#L17...
Contrast with lsp-mode:
https://github.com/emacs-lsp/lsp-mode/blob/master/lsp-mode.e...
https://github.com/emacs-lsp/lsp-mode/blob/master/lsp-mode.e...
https://github.com/emacs-lsp/lsp-mode/blob/master/lsp-modeli...
The lsp-mode code is a lot easier to follow, in my opinion. It's a lot clearer what's happening (although I can't say much about whether either are overabstracted which is admittedly a big concern. I haven't looked into that).
I remember watching an argument between the original authors on Reddit a while back. The lsp-mode author came across as... let's just say more professional. lsp-mode seems much closer to a professional product to me in general.
I'd argue stubborn resistance to most new concepts regardless of their sheen is a contributor. I think people underrate that as a trait. You want some bastions. Loads of it is insane but they also don't make many new mistakes.
They could be completely fixed by just providing examples of all these esoteric elisp functions.