HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

baranul

1,222 karma · joined January 8, 2024

submissionscomments
baranul··on Fil-C: Garbage In, Memory Safety Out [video]
Of the group of languages presented, your argument has more merit for Go. With C# and others, there is an additional OOP argument in there, that splits into different factions.

But what is being overlooked, is the massive numerical dominance of C programmers and projects, along with legacy and embedded code. There is going to be a preference for writing and using C, that could arguably fuel Fil-C for a very long time.

baranul··on Fil-C: Garbage In, Memory Safety Out [video]
I think it's not so much that Fil-C renders Rust completely useless, but rather it reduces the supposed validity and wild arguments to frivolously rewrite anything and everything in Rust.
baranul··on I regret migrating to Codeberg
Agree. Providers who don't want to deal with LLM generated code should be respected as part of the free market. Let the market decide which direction is for the better or at least allow for niches that cater to certain audiences.
baranul··on Show HN: I replaced a $120k bowling center system with $1,600 in ESP32s
That's questionable, in terms of both outcome and cost. LLMs can misunderstand intent, hallucinate, or produce unwanted results too. As you noticed. But, among the advantages in favor of real programmers is outside of the context understanding of what the customer may want and fixing their request or solving the problem in unforeseen ways, despite the expected result not being properly stated.

True, LLMs can spit things out faster, but often in context to needing greater specificity and giving cookie cutter results. In regards to that, humans can copy and paste too. The time saved on the front end, can be lost by needing to come up with tighter specifications or the need for human review, to ensure quality.

baranul··on It's an Apple Lisa, on a FPGA
This and the various Lisa emulator projects are a great way to keep a piece of history alive for younger generations and the nostalgic. Besides the true experience of it, there might still be some new ideas to come from understanding how things were done.
baranul··on OpenAI’s accidental attack against Hugging Face is science fiction that happened
A way to help prevent some of that catastrophic damage, is to make companies accountable for what their AIs do. A major problem with AI companies is that they like to point to the AI, as if they're minimally involved innocent bystanders, when that's the furthest thing from the truth.
baranul··on Iran says it attacked Amazon infrastructure in Bahrain
Regular people can only hope that cooler heads and more sense can avert this obvious disaster. It's like watching cars about to crash into a brick wall, yet drivers have their foot firmly on the accelerator, instead of the breaks.
baranul··on ICE to Pay Thomson Reuters $125M to Find Voter Fraud
> guise of democracy

That's a very appropriate term. There has always been various forces who either believe the majority of citizens don't deserve democracy or that they are above it.

baranul··on Judge approves $1.5B Anthropic settlement for pirated books used to train Claude
You do indeed appear to have a valid point. Many "chosen" companies, like Uber for example, appear to have broken numerous laws. Legal action against many such companies comes suspiciously slowly, where they have already obtained massive profits and value, before the possibility of being shut down comes. Then, when they are finally pulled into court, they have all kinds of money for the best lawyers and have already paid the right politicians (and others).

When the legal judgements for wrongdoing are finally handed out, they often come across as just an inconvenience or kind of tax, which is easily handled in comparison to the profits they've already made. Yet, if average Joe or persons not considered as being of "the right type" were to do such actions, they quickly get the full book thrown at them. Often, the full measure of legal punishment, where their company and life is or about nearly over.

baranul··on Show HN: I replaced a $120k bowling center system with $1,600 in ESP32s
This is arguably a dangerous fallacy, particularly for anything critical. When the person doesn't know programming, it becomes harder to guide agents and do reviews, leading to overlooking issues and accepting mistakes. This gets amplified for any creative solutions or fixing future problems, where it is something the LLM was not trained on or has limited data about the subject. Plus add how much money spent on tokens.

Maybe a way for non-programmers to better understanding what they are saying, is to think about translation. It's kind of like saying a person doesn't need to know anything about Spanish to now sell LLM translated books from English to Spanish.

Yes, the LLM can do translations for you, and quickly. But, as you don't know Spanish, you won't know how good the translation is. You are less likely to catch all kinds of mistakes, from bad grammar to wrongfully translated idiomatic expressions. The less Spanish that you know, the more likely you are to be impressed or fooled into a false sense of security. Then when native and fluent Spanish speakers read your books, they may rate it as mostly gibberish and nonsense.

baranul··on AI advice made people 3x less accurate but 2x confident, researchers found
Agree. AI behavior, when interacting with humans, is based on making money. Making people feel uncomfortable or challenged, will usually not be the preferred business strategy. But, it would be interesting if people could easily select the AI's personality type or to what extent it can be adversarial to the comments or ideas given as input.
baranul··on Can humans hibernate their way to Mars?
Not that they never had the idea, however, this was not mentioned in the article. The point was by getting there quickly enough, they wouldn't need to worry about hibernation for trips to Mars.

Hibernation for humans was never going to be an easy feat, as animals that do it, have all kinds of genetic level adaptions. For Mars, arguably not worth it, unless a scientist makes a lucky discovery and it's relatively easy to implement.

baranul··on Setting up your spare Mac for Claude Code to control, a step-by-step guide
It's a no win trap, except for the tech bros cashing in on investors burning money. Data centers using up the available clean drinking water, people with no jobs paying higher electrical bills, stressing the electrical power grid to the breaking point, historically unparalleled IP theft to divert money away from creators and their content consumed with tokens...

https://isaiprofitable.com/ (Is AI Profitable Yet?)

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/music/articles/largest-i... (“The largest IP theft in human history”)

https://www.recordinglaw.com/news/authors-protest-ai-empty-b... (Don't Steal This Book)

https://finance.yahoo.com/energy/articles/why-ai-boom-break-... (Why the AI Boom Is About to Break the U.S. Power Grid)

https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2026/1/21/ais-growing-thi... (AI’s growing thirst for water is becoming a public health risk)

baranul··on Stripe and Advent have made a joint offer to acquire PayPal – sources
The point about crypto is worth exploring. Many would prefer to cut the middleman out and crypto can be a way to do that.
baranul··on Israeli ministers announce plans for illegal settlements in Gaza and West Bank
The scary thing is that if they can so easily turn a blind eye to funding another country's obvious crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing, that they can do so domestically as well. Many would argue that the domestic infrastructure to perpetuate such is being rapidly stood up.
baranul··on Can humans hibernate their way to Mars?
The other solution is to get there faster. The most likely candidate, for get there faster, is some form of nuclear powered propulsion.
baranul··on Are we offloading too much of our thinking to AI?
Way too many people like to reach for the easiest path. They will often assume or have blind faith that the AI or online answer is correct. Coming up with the solution themselves or taking time to understand why something might be the correct answer, can be just too much work to be bothered with.
baranul··on Your 'app' could have been a webpage (so I fixed it for you)
> Nobody here is talking about the fact that a significant number of users want apps, too.

This is true, as it depends on the nature of what is being presented and if offline usability is preferred or doable.

Everything as a website, can arguably be an equally bad fit for situations, as everything as an app. Flexibility and careful study is required.

baranul··on Wikipedia escapes Category 1 designation under the UK Online Safety Act for now
It's more like, “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely." If there is no or not enough resistance, certain sadists and egomaniacs see that as a sign to power grab and cause suffering.
baranul··on LinkedIn is a cesspool of scammers and identity theft
And often, the person doesn't need nor are looking for a job, so are just getting continually spammed. Where if you are actually looking, you can email your personal list of recruiters, of companies and persons you actually know or were recommended by real life friends.
baranul··on $65K to work at Anthropic? Debate ensues amid IPO wave
The visa sponsorship angle has to be factored in as well, as they may believe a few desperate for a visa candidates would show up. Happens more than people are aware of.

A large percentage of companies will underpay people or even commit wage theft, if they can get away with it.

baranul··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
There is also the fact of newer "closer to C" alternatives like C3[1] and Zen C[2], or more intriguing C family alternatives such as Odin[3], Jai[4], or Vlang[5].

Zig is kind of trapped. It can't go "head to head" with heavy weights like Rust, who specialize in safety, are more mature (post 1.0), and have lots of corporate support. Then there are the other C alternatives, who each offer something it doesn't have.

It appears the only way for it to maintain its position, is through heavy hype and marketing, but the whole Bun ordeal and extensive beta issues are subtracting from any such attempts.

[1]: https://c3-lang.org/

[2]: https://github.com/zenc-lang/zenc

[3]: https://learnxinyminutes.com/odin

[4]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IdpD5QIVOKQ

[5]: https://codefreelance.net/apps/vlang.html

baranul··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
> I don't see any hate

People know what jealousy, slander, and unprofessional behavior are. Including how the V project is treated, regardless if certain others pretend not to or try to blank out others for noticing.

> What's your involvement with the language

Just responding to the comments of others, like the truthful one made by f-serif.

Not part of any V organization, just use the language (and some others). Which is more than I can say for a number of accounts where their profiles clearly say they are directly part of or work for the Zig organization.

baranul··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
I think the open to close ratio needs to be provided in any such comparison. It would arguably give a better indication of which project is doing a better job at addressing incoming user issues and bug fixes.
baranul··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
To make a better comparison, you have to add up Zig's issues on GitHub that weren't brought over and abandoned.

That would be Zig's 700 or so Codeberg issues + the 2,700 or so GitHub issues.

baranul··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
> Vlang is a ridiculous project

With over 37,500 stars, over 2,300 forks, 826 contributors, books written on it (in Japanese and Portuguese, besides English), and a Wikipedia page; vlang is clearly a significant and successful open-source project.

> entirely driven by hype

People can plainly see Zig (and other HN pushed languages) directly engaging in marketing propaganda and hype (with HN accounts clearly stating they are from those projects) using social media (including HN) at levels way beyond anything anyone could accuse the V project of doing. The creator of vlang is also not a native English speaker, where the creator of Zig (and other competitors) have no such excuse. They know exactly what they are saying, the connotations of it, the cultural nuance surrounding it, and what it means in English.

> ridiculous that it got $800/month with nothing to show for it

Jealousy over vlang getting as much (or more) donation money (in 2019) from its supporters was a central theme in numerous social media and website posts made directly by Andrew Kelley[1]. Even to the extent he and the Odin creator[2] were asking people to give them money, instead of to the V project. Many would consider such behavior as extremely bad and unprofessional. Also note, there is no reverse of such behavior to be seen by the V community at them, instead we see uncalled for conduct and statements being directed by them towards the V project.

Donations that vlang had received and continue to receive, is from their supporters. Some of these paying supporters have even come to HN, to publicly express their support[3][4][5] against competitor false accusations and disinformation. Competitors should have nothing to do with someone else's supporters giving donations, in the same way that vlang's creator does not speak on who donates or supports their projects.

> I haven't seen any hate spread for it by Zig.

It is documented, on HN no less (and elsewhere), where people can see Zig's creator directly slandering vlang's creator[6] and this kind of unprofessional behavior encouraged followers to do similar.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39495369

[2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20231704

[3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31801287

[4]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31801262

[5]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31812189

[6]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20230351

baranul··on Microsoft latest report shows 25% emissions raised due to AI data centers
There is clean(er) and safer renewable energy. The human race doesn't have to pollute and climate change itself into near extinction to greedily chase prosperity at the expense of its children's future.
baranul··on Postgres rewritten in Rust, now passing 100% of the Postgres regression tests
And that's the trap. Relying on a "perfectly" crafted test or a LLM to verify what is unknown. Yes, LLMs can be very useful, but perhaps it's best for us to be realistic.

> making the computer check its own work

Kind of like the Spanish teacher telling his students they can grade their own tests, then being surprised that Billy was always giving himself 100%, when he's nowhere near that bright or fluent.

It wouldn't be so bad, if people were more upfront with being unsure or made it clear they were extrapolating from smaller and limited data. But usually, like many of these unusually cocky LLMs, what is too often reported to the public is "perfection" and many inconvenient truths "swept underneath the carpet".

baranul··on SpaceX wants to launch 100k more Starlink satellites for 100x the bandwidth
At what point are people going to have a conversation about all the pollution and the consequences of so many satellites burning up (metals and other toxic stuff) in the atmosphere and fragments falling wherever.

100k... how much can we keep putting up and let keep falling around the world? Multiple other companies and countries want to do the same as SpaceX.

baranul··on Postgres rewritten in Rust, now passing 100% of the Postgres regression tests
Yeah, like to see more disclosures about this. Not to mention the whole background debate on the real costs for the AI companies, at what point prices go up to reflect that, or the possible consequences of being overly reliant on this technology.
← PreviousPage 3 of 16Next →