HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

basil-rash

932 karma · joined August 27, 2018

at outlook dot com

meet.hn/city/us-Orange

submissionscomments
basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Feel free.

But how much of the world's resources have been dominated by folks placing their faith in Eru Ilúvatar?

And I'm sure you're aware Tolkien was a devout Catholic, and described his works as fundamentally Catholic?

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
There is no evidence one way or another, nor is any evidence possible. That is, indeed, the entire point.

And I'm not sure why you think the almighty creator of the universe would have trouble making chemistry... "work".

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Any argument would make for a much better argument than your deranged repetitions.

I've claimed X doesn't exist, all you have to do is demonstrate it does for you to "win". It should be very easy, given how confident you seem.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
In fact, I'm not. Science covers the field of things which can be observed and explained via repeatable tests. The concept of micro-evolution is well within the purview of science, as we can and have observed small changes in populations based on environmental conditions, and we have established many repeatable tests of such phenomena.

Macro-evolution (what I call evolutionism), on the other hand, has never been scientifically observed, explained, tested, or anything of the sort. It is an attempt at creating a fanciful story of how things came to be by extrapolating back from what we see now in entirely unrigorous, untestable, unobservable ways. It fits much more squarely in the category of History, Mythology, and indeed Theology (aTheology?) than "Science".

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Some might. There are many branches and leaves in both the evolutionist and creationist worldview trees. That axiom is simply a fairly significant trunk-branch.

That said, it is very rare that I hear someone describing themselves as Christian who denies the general 7 day creation story. I happen to personally believe it was seven consecutive days^, but I've heard arguments it could have been seven days with an unknown gap in-between each pair.

^ "day" being the most morally-understandable way of describing the intervals at which the creation occurred. Obviously there was no sun or even light at first, so the concept of a day itself is shaky, and I make no claims as to how many cesium-133 transitions may have occurred in that period, or how far light might have travelled in one of them once it was created, or the magnitude of the various fundamental forces' impact on matter in that period, or really anything related to our understanding of how the dynamics we currently observe may have behaved in those intervals.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Sheesh someone had fun flagging nearly every single post in this thread… cc @dang for notes?
basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
You are using the evolutionist's definition of "explain", which is not applicable to the creationist's interpretation of reality. Under the evolutionists view, there is no actor with the ability to alter universal state besides those physical laws which we currently observe. Thus, any change in universal state that has ever occurred would naturally be able to be "explained" by providing a detailed step-by-step rundown of how those laws interacted with universal state S until it reached universal state S'. Under creationism, this definition is nonsense: any change in state can occur at any time based on the whims of the unknown actor, no further rationale is necessary or indeed possible.

Accordingly, if we take a definition of "explain" which does not assume a particular interpretation of the fundamental axiom (as we should, when that axiom is the very thing under debate), my statement is perfectly valid: That actor which we cannot fathom made it so. Thus, it is.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Of course I know that. And further I know evolutionism is the same. Indeed I opened this entire thread with the statement: "both are faith based responses to questions we cannot answer any other way."

It would seem you are not paying attention to what is actually being said.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
I fear you are failing to comprehend how fundamental the axiom in question (is the universal state influenced by actors beyond our comprehension?) really is. There is no experiment that can answer it, any and all observations must be looked at under a lens that is fundamentally influenced by your answer to the question.

We can certainly say that the observations look like they may have progressed at the rate we expect for the past 13 billion years, but that does nothing to exclude the possibility that around 6,000 years ago some actor we do not understand took 1 week to craft everything we observe now to be precisely how it is.

Reading your final paragraph, I believe we are more aligned than I previously thought. :)

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Creationism explains everything very simply: "X is the way it is because God ordained it to be". There is no need to experimentally verify, its existence is the proof. In general, the need for experimental evidence is only present when you've accepted the lack of external intervention as axiomatic. When that very axiom is under debate, experimentalism is entirely irrelevant.

Not to mention, anything I present as being evidence of intelligence being more able to produce functional complexity than randomness you would reinterpret as "randomness-that-produced-something-that-look-like-intelligence producing functional complexity better than randomness-that-doesnt-look-like-intelligence".

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
Please understand the discussion at hand before commenting. Nobody is denying the existence of small-scale "micro-evolution" that subtly guides species into local optima. The question is of abiogenesis and mass-speciation, topics evolutionism has been thoroughly unable to explain, despite many attempts.
basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
It's certainly inspired, but it has been subject to the chaotic nature of humanity, as has everything since the fall.
basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
> looking at things like RNA/DNA mutation rates in known species it's pretty damned easy to see that things have been around a whole lot longer than 6k years

Again, please understand the underlying assumptions you are making when you concoct statements like this. Namely: DNA/RNA started as a single form and has mutated at a constant rate since then. You have no evidence to support that, and I disagree with every component of it.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
It most certainly is. Evolutionists believe in the time invariance of the laws of physics with no proof, creationists believe the processes by why things have changed in the universe (“physics”, broadly) have changed over time, also with no proof. That there is some external influence that we cannot directly observe that has some massive impact on the development of the universe in ways we cannot explain.

(Funnily, physics have come to acknowledge the same, but they call it dark matter and say it’s all very scientific, whatever it is. But this is unknown enough to be not worth much discussion.)

Regarding the evolution we see around us all the time, I and many creationists besides me have full confidence in the idea that micro-evolution does occur. That there is a stochastic gradient decent process that hones in on time-varying local maxima over generations cannot really be denied. But that provides absolutely no answer to the questions of abiogenesis and speciation en-masse.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
This is objectively false. Evolution explains absolutely nothing creationism doesn’t, and creationism explains a whole lot that evolution cannot. For instance, universal origins and the formation of cells.
basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
It’s important to understand why we think the bones are over 6,000 years old, and especially consider what assumptions we make in determining that age. Most importantly, the time invariance of physics.

Really it boils down to whether you believe the laws of physics we observe now have been constant throughout time. If you do you’re called an evolutionist, if you don’t you’re called a creationist. Neither side has any proof, nor is any proof fundamentally possible.

basil-rash··on The baffling intelligence of a single cell: The story of E. coli chemotaxis
It’s funny, because the creationists generally feel the exact same about evolutionists.

Both are faith based responses to questions we cannot answer any other way. Getting caught up in absolutes thinking your interpretation is the gold standard is a sign of an unrefined critical thinking process.

basil-rash··on OpenAI's chatbot store is filling up with spam
Don’t you see how the incentives become impossible? The AI stage needs you to be as obvious and direct about your experience as possible, the human stage gets irritated when you write like the reader doesn’t have a brain.

Personally I send my resumes through a gpt with the job posting and ask if I’d be a good fit. Almost always the GPT will initially say no because I’m using some terminology that anyone in the industry would understand is a form of the posting’s requirements, but the GPT does not. But then perhaps the screening recruiter doesn’t either. So why not be specific? But then anyone else at the company might think I’m a moron… ugh.

basil-rash··on What are the "worst" spelling bee pangrams?
> Every day's puzzle is guaranteed to have at least one pangram.

I’m almost certain that wasn’t true for at least one puzzle early this year, but haven’t been able to come up with an exact date.

basil-rash··on Oregon passes right-to-repair law Apple lobbied to kill
There’s tons of prior art in Law saying that And and Or are the same thing and can be interpreted interchangeably based on context.

Much to the chagrin of the computer scientists who think it’s some sort of robust formal specification for civil society.

basil-rash··on Figure 01 robot demos its OpenAI integration
I’m certainly not eating at Figure 1’s house!
basil-rash··on The Best Essay
Ha, I had thought you were an LLM prompted to be a contrarian with a chip on their shoulder. This all but confirms it^. I bet you don’t even have the prior messages in your context window.

^Or at least something with approximately that level of intellectual capacity/honesty.

basil-rash··on The Best Essay
Reread why I said your example was bogus, I don’t have time to repeat myself.
basil-rash··on The Best Essay
Well I certainly hope your patients can find the help they need. But let’s drop the hominems and get to the point:

Do you have a real counter example? Someone that through reading the material of others alone, with no practical/“hands on” experience, was able to develop what you consider “deep” knowledge?

Edit: A day ago you were arguing talent can’t come without training. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39656444

In fact much of your comment history is dedicated to claiming knowledge requires product. How bizzare.

basil-rash··on The Best Essay
You’re so caught up in insulting me, you never stopped to think of I’d consider inventing a novel medical technique an “application” of knowledge. I would.

If all he did was read books about things other people did, he certainly would not have invented that.

Your following attempt at armchair psychology is humorous, but not much beyond that I’m afraid. Don’t quit your dayjob.

basil-rash··on The Best Essay
Claims without support are nothing too.

In other words: example?

basil-rash··on The Best Essay
How can you claim your knowledge of the field is actually deep, if you’ve never even done anything with it? Knowledge without application is nothing, imo.

True “depth” comes from the know-how acquired in digging through all the minutia nobody else though to document, on your way to producing a new creation nobody else thought to build.

basil-rash··on Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account
They present prior art on both sides of the issue then provide their interpretation of the matter. If that’s bad writing, then so is every court decision ever.
basil-rash··on Epic says Apple will reinstate developer account
Like the ones they went into in the following sentence?
basil-rash··on Claude Sonnet and Pi AI give exact same response to a prompt
The insane part is how we’ve been conditioned to interpret the most banal, 0-entropy strings as “cutting edge AI”, to the extent we get surprised when two supposedly different models emit the same (lack of) content.

Seriously, look at the response. It’s the exact sort of thing the top 150 blogspam results on Google would all say if you were to ask the same question.

← PreviousPage 7 of 15Next →