636 karma · joined November 29, 2012
There is much the same problem with those who work in the political realm in D.C. They are constantly derided as do-nothing on a macro scale, but on an individual basis a lot of effort is put into how laws are constructed and amended. This is analogue to the situation in the intelligence community -- a lot of work is done by individuals and the organization they are a part of to preserve civil liberties, but disclosing the nature of their collection abilities in the interest of the transparency of their protection of civil liberties is absolutely counter-productive. A big difference between the two, is that the political worker can disclose their work while the intelligence worker can not.
I'm not denying that there are instances of overreach, but I'm merely making the point that the framework for protection of civil liberties is not a piece of glass that shatters on the first stone thrown against it. It is an organic process, which is subject to upper and lower bounds in order to come to rest at a medium level with which both the public is suitably comfortable, and which gets the job done.
Those who have served in the military or as civilians in the department of defense have given up a lot of their personal liberties in order to provide for the common defense. Service. It's not a concept I expect you to understand if you're reading this from a Starbucks while pitching your new startup idea to your friends. It entails willingly giving up the ability to talk to your friends and loved ones about anything you do -- you often end up telling people that you do some mundane job because you can't answer their followup questions. It means getting called into work or off of vacation because your small piece of the world has gone to shit, and not having anyone to vent to about it. It also means placing the very notion of where you live in the hands of the government, and sometimes being forced to be away from your family for years. It is all these things and more, but it is not ever something one should be made to feel ashamed of doing.
There are thousands of employees right now in the NSA who aren't even allowed to come to their own defense on the matter, because DoD has deemed that speaking about the situation is a security violation. They have to sit there and endure that the people around them who are very ignorant as to what it is NSA even does, just plain get it wrong. Well, as my NSA/CIA security clearance finally closed out yesterday, I have no qualms about speaking on their behalf.
The public is completely and utterly wrong about the motivations of the NSA and the information they were provided as "fact". Everything has been skewed to paint a picture that is damning and I would definitely be angry about if it were true, but it just isn't. There is a culture of protecting American civil liberties in the NSA. It's almost pathological -- anything that can potentially affect a US person is given extremely wide berth. There are major auditing and oversight mechanisms in place in case someone were to ever run a query that affected a US person. So the notion that in 2 years, the intelligent, passionate, and devoted people I came to know have somehow flipped around and violate rights willy-nilly now is a ludicrous idea. If this were true, we would be seeing a thousand whisteblowers (true whistleblowers, not Snowden) coming out of the woodwork trying to correct the system.
It is not true that the government doesn't care about the rights of individuals just because you want it to be true. Those that are employed are individuals too, and are not being magically compelled to carry terrible secrets against their individual moral codes and ethics. They are carrying out a mission of defense which extends into the technology of this century -- even cars have had 100 years for us to deliberate and come up with the current system of laws that govern that technology. While the legal framework for their actions are up for debate, their collective character is not.
The current public climate surrounding those who have been in the intelligence community hearkens back to days of activists yelling "Baby killer! Baby killer!" at passing by Vietnam vets. A few of you who are self-reflecting will at some point in your life when the intelligence practices becomes more public, regret your outrage and overreaction at this time. I feel like the rest will not, because it was a passing trend and never really affected you directly either way.
I would like to thank those that have served (including the author) and continue to serve for their part in upholding their oath. It may seem like no one gets you, but a few out here in the public sector do. In the cycle of the public raging against government powers, and then asking why the government didn't do more about x situation, the people in service get lost in the mix.
I hope that regardless of who you are reading this, that you have the ability to empathize with those who are outside of your personal story, with whom you will never have any interaction with. That I happen to know some of their faces doesn't change the fact that I don't assume the faceless ones are perpetrating a great conspiracy against the American people. I just assume that they're serving.
I don't see them as whistleblowers, because their actions stand in contrast to Ellsberg. For one, neither of them tried to go to a higher authority to report wrongdoing -- that is the very first thing that a potential whistleblower must do, is handle things at the lowest level possible and allow the situation to rectify itself before taking matters into their own hands. When that fails, then you escalate to higher authorities. Secondly, Ellsberg surrendered himself to the court system willingly, knowing full well that he could face life imprisonment. Manning was caught and brought to justice after having bragged on an AOL chat to someone about his "hacking", while Snowden fled the country taking with him a trove of classified documents which could be in the hands of other countries, weakening any argument (to me) that he had the US's best intentions at heart. My argument about Snowden is that he knows so little about the programs he supposedly leaked -- I watched his interview and was astonished at the blatant lies in it (see my other post on https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5885846), not to mention him saying that he could wiretap any american (or even the president!) at any time. True whistleblowers are caught in the middle of something that they have solid knowledge of, but are unable to change the course of, so they go to the public in order for the public to do the course correction.
I agree. It's an elitist culture of special agent assholes and "everyone else". Trust me, I don't like the FBI. But, people within the organization also have very little power to change it -- they're extremely reticent to any kind of change regardless of efficiency gains. It took months of planning for them to even consider using an excel macro I wrote that could save millions of dollars per year.
>2) Institutional culture plays a large part in abuses that continue through administrations and even changes in departmental leadership. Institutional culture doesn't simply change because the head of the beast is re-appointed. (And even in the case of the current elected head of the Executive, many things have not changed though changes were promised, but that's a slight digression.) You talk about people with different moralities, and then mention that "people are much too lazy to be putting that much effort into a government job." I read that as regardless of people's personal opinions, they're too lazy to challenge the status quo and would rather keep their heads down and receive their paychecks. Without whistleblower protections, that's exactly the environment that's fostered.
I agree, whistleblower protections would be a massively positive change in how governance works in the US, and would make people accountable for decisions which have significant impact on national policy, security, and economy. That being said, I don't see either Manning or Snowden as whistleblowers.
>Finally, in my opinion, all this is moot. We should necessarily question those in authority, we should necessarily limit the power given to those in government, and we should necessarily suspect those in power to have anything other than our own best interests in mind.
Definitely. I'm personally hoping that this stuff spawns a legitimate third party as a true representative of what this generation's ideals are heading towards. The smart money, though, is on incumbents commandeering the messages and subverting them a la Tea Party.
It's not really my concern whether or not you believe what I say, as you are not my target audience. You are already convinced of your rightness and my wrongness. I'm typing to the people who want actual facts to back the discussion.
>That does not seem to jibe with the details reported here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/nsa-br.... How would you explain that discrepancy between your claims, and those of the WaPo? Note that the WaPo story does include at least a degree of hard evidence, in the form of documentation.
What they don't post is how many firings/missed promotions that has led to. Each incident would be just one phone number or piece of information, so in the case of the "20"->"202" mixup, they could have targeted 300 phone numbers and now that's 300 incidents. If that was a contractor that was responsible for that, they're already gone. If it was a government employee, they're likely not an analyst anymore.
The Washington Post's story only backs what I said. If the NSA was so trigger-happy to violate American rights, why would they even keep track of the number of violations? Bragging rights at the end of the year? In the example they used, they were targeting Egyptian citizens, and the US phone numbers got caught in the crossfires. Sounds to me like people legitimately trying to do their jobs, and human error working against them.
I don't believe in the veracity of the leaked documents detailing PRISM. As I'm not in there anymore, this is not a confirmation of anything, just personal belief (speculation). I, for one, have seen one too many shit powerpoints floating around NSANet written by some military E-6 trying to explain some difficult concept to a group of E-5's. What do they do? Generalize and over-simplify. Just because it has classification markings doesn't make it official -- when I emailed friends to say "Hey, you want to get lunch today?", sometimes it was marked as top secret because I forgot to change it.
A sysadmin is a job that has little to no understanding of operating concepts, architecture, and program scope. It's someone you go to when you accidentally lock yourself out of your account and need to change your password. It's a Tier-1 technician who sees a green box in a network diagram go red, and start making phone calls to people who are actually capable of a root-cause-analysis (tier-3 technicians). So, a sysadmin swoops up a bunch of powerpoints knowing nothing about the operational details of the programs they seem to be describing, and posts them for people to read and make their own conclusions using only those powerpoints as a source of information. That whole way of starting a public discussion is flawed, because the information contained therein is so utterly questionable to me. Regardless of that, I'm glad that online privacy (which is something I strongly believe in) is finally being publicly discussed, which is why I said that.
>You aren't the voice of reason. You're the guy with his fingers in his ears and his eyes closed. You are the worst possible neighbor to have in a democratic society. Until you are directly and personally affected, you will continue to argue that those who oppose surveillance are all "unreasonable" to expect the gov't to follow the law, or for even "believing" that the gov't does not, despite clear evidence of wrongdoing.
Not going to touch that one.
>The NSA keeps _all_ of the source data. A file can be built at any instant by a simple query. The distinction of not having a "file" at some particular moment is without meaning. One might even argue that the architecture of the systems are designed to allow this "lie" to be told. At the very least, officials have demonstrated their willingness to exploit this semantic loophole, which by the strict rules of logic, evaluates as "true" but which all honest people consider "lying through your teeth".
It's not all kept.
>The NSA passes evidence of non-terrorism, non-national-security, ie domestic crimes to domestic law enforcement on its own accord, as has been reported widely in the press. Additionally, US intelligence services have in the past been caught passing inside information to commercial interests, also well beyond the scope of "strictly foreign surveillance".
You're confusing NSA with FBI.
>You have no proof of that. Even given the little that is actually revealed about the NSA so far, it is not reasonable to claim that the NSA has followed the rules in this particular scenario, given the many examples of rule-breaking, and the NSA's demonstrated contempt of FISC rulings.
I do have proof. I was in the NSA and I took the yearly FISA training. NSA analysts take FISA violations very seriously, and always err on the side of US person if in doubt. Why? Because collecting on a US person is the quickest way to get fired.
>I can say with complete confidence that you are wrong again. Laura Poitras, Jacob Applebaum, many others have been receiving extralegal searches, seizures of their electronic devices at the border for years. Just a few weeks ago, a family received a visit by virtue of their internet searches. Even if you were correct, it is an extreme threshold for opposition to gov't lawbreaking. You think that no person should make a fuss, until the speech of "white suburban bloggers" is targeted?
Now you're confusing NSA with NCTC http://www.nctc.gov/about_us/how_we_do.html. Awesome. NSA does not watchlist people. That's a combination of the Terrorist Screening Center (FBI) and NCTC. That being said, Laura Poitras and Jacob Applebaum aren't going to be on that list unless they're somehow funding Hezbollah.
All in all, I find your response to be composed of pure internet anger and no factual content.
What all of the anti-NSA sentiment fails to address is the actual truth of the matter. The NSA is the only intelligence agency with its shit together, and provides the most actionable intelligence to decision makers. That being said, their collection strategy is determined by policy makers (in Washington) based off of what policy makers deem are the most important priorities. This means that the cycle works like this:
1. Policy makers determine what are their priorities pertaining to foreign policy, national security, etc.
2. *Policy makers provide that list of priorities to the NSA.
3. The NSA returns with what is needed in order to fill those priorities such as budgets and policy changes.
4. Policy makers take that information and weigh the cost/benefit of changing current policy, allotting more funding, etc.
5. NSA sends reports on collection, which policy makers have access to.
6. Policy makers take that information and provide feedback as to the helpfulness of it, who it was briefed to (as in, how high it was briefed), and what direction they are more interested in seeing reporting go.
The NSA is a well-greased cog in a malformed machine. Don't blame the NSA for performing the duties they've been directed to do -- blame the politicians directing them to do it.
In closing, the whole fact that public policy is shifting from all of the backlash is kind of heartening in that it shows the public does have a say in the process. I can't speak to the things in the news, but I will say that collecting on a US person is the fastest way to get fired in the NSA. That's probably why I find it so ironic for all the people deriding NSA now, and NSA having to take the "neither confirm nor deny" stance.
2. Except that wasn't true, it was the former employer: http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/08/pressure-cooker/
3. FOIA requests get processed by the same people under the Chief Public Liaison Officer.
1. The NSA does not keep a "file" on you. Domestic matters are the FBI's territory. The NSA is tasked with strictly foreign surveillance. If information is contained in databases that correspond to your communiques, it is not catalogued as "Kevin Collier", because that would be a direct FISA violation and trigger administrative removal of the data along with reporting about how the violation occurred.
2. I can almost say with complete confidence that our national security resources aren't being used to target white suburban bloggers.
3. By flooding NSA public relations with these useless requests, you're blocking potentially real requests from being processed. If you really cared about getting actual information about programs, you would back EFF, etc. efforts.
I think this part very much weakens your argument and should be removed entirely. First, the NSA has nothing to do with domestic surveillance -- that falls upon the FBI. Secondly, you can collect all of the data that you want, but you won't be able to prevent the lone wolf element (as opposed to organized terrorism), especially with no national database of firearms.
The thing that the average HN reader doesn't realize is how much responsibility is on the shoulders of those who choose to spend their time in service to the country (this could be for any country). I couldn't imagine the comments that I've seen about blacklisting former government workers and publicly shaming service men and women coming from anyone who has carried this kind of responsibility.
My sidelining aside, you're definitely correct about TAO people being very skilled. I would have definitely loved to join their ranks. They wanted to swap a couple bodies to trade for me, but my division head wouldn't let me go =\
This isn't supposed to be reddit, where people downmod something because it is an opinion that they don't agree with.
If 11 year old BBS-hacking NSA-conspiracy-fearing me had an opportunity to talk to and ask questions of former NSA analyst/programmer me, I would definitely have come up with a better discussion than the HN community.
At least my upvote will counter at least one close-minded person.
-Limiting exposure of the information already divulged
-Preventing further (especially unintentional) classified information spills
-Limiting adversaries collecting on what information and to what degree people are knowledgeable about
The fact is, if you're a legislator who is given compartmented access, you should know better than to propagate information that has been unintentionally released. For one, it promotes discussion of classified information in unclassified spaces. Secondly, it gives apparent validation to information that might not necessarily be true.
It's getting really tiresome reading these flavor-of-the-day NSA bashing articles, having worked at NSA and having eaten of the tree of knowledge. The intelligence community does not dictate foreign policy or collection policies. They serve at the direction of the federal government under the DNI (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Director_of_National_Intelligen...), who is appointed by the president. They carry out the tasks that are given to them under the direction of the administration. There exists a feedback system which allows agencies to understand what information was vital in helping make decisions and what information wasn't important.
Here comes the tricky part: politicians clamor for more information in order to make better informed decisions -- just look at the situation with the possible use of chemical weapons in Syria. When intelligence agencies don't come up with anything actionable, politicians ask "Why not?", to which the agencies respond, "We don't have enough access to real time information.", or "You stated that X mission wasn't important so we stopped supporting it.". Then the politicians rewrite legislation in order to prevent further roadblocks to obtaining information in a timely manner with which they can make decisions.
All of that happens, and you want to blame an intelligence agency for doing its job at various levels of efficiency? In that entire process, the agency only gives feedback as to what its capabilities are and what it needs in order to increase its capabilities. The administration and legislators determine the scope of the work which the agencies function in.
There is no secret conspiracy, people. It's a very simple system: you vote in people and then tell them that you want the prevention of terrorist attacks prioritized above funding NASA. The public is then made aware to what degree the politicians were willing to go to in order to expand intelligence powers, so outrage ensued. Now, there is legislation being pushed forward (not successfully yet) in order to limit the powers. Is this not a representative democracy working to correct its mistakes and push towards a more perfect union?
In a hardware sense, I can take apart an object (like a smart phone), and see how it works. In a software sense, it's much harder to decompile something and see how it is working if the scope of the project is large enough.
Software patents are bad (in my opinion) because the things which get patented are the things that form the foundation for what almost every programmer works with in their daily routine. Things that are abstract ideas such as "Connecting to a server to process a payment" might seem like a logical thing to patent as a software idea, but if I transferred it to its real life analogue it becomes unpatentable as a business practice: Person A gives payment to Person B, who then forwards payment to Person C.
All this being said, I'm not aware of any legitimate software patent suit that didn't involve corporate espionage. Can anyone link anything to show me a legitimate use of our court system in order to protect an innovation that should be protected?
If you're saying, "I know what the NSA does because Snowden, some slides, and people on the internet told me so", then you're still in the group of heavily misinformed. I would definitely like to see information brought to light from the government's side in a constructive way, and help frame a national debate over these programs. Discussing the legality of foreign and domestic surveillance and constructing a (public) legal rationale will, hopefully, provide a solid foundation for future generations.
Regardless of what is or isn't going on, it's pretty obvious to the common citizen that the rationale for current actions are derived from equivocating legalese.
-Is it okay to collect intelligence on foreign governments? -Is it okay to collect on allies? -What are the boundary markers for the government abusing its power? -Can we amend the constitution to reflect privacy concerns of the 21st century? -How many civilian casualties are the threshold for being a tolerable amount in America?
Just questions to get you thinking about things. I feel like the majority of people's indignant outrage, if not translated into action in fixing a perceived problem, is passively accepting the status quo.
All I'm saying is that if there was a significantly flawed system, I didn't see it and I was pretty deep. Take that how you want.
It could be feasible, but now your custom platform is a lighting rod drawing all of the attention of intelligence resources into cracking it.
When you work for the NSA, you can take a managerial route or a technical route for promotion. This means that you can achieve the highest rank (GS/GG-15) being either a manager or just being good at your job.
I once wrote a report which countered reports that other people had written, resulting in some angry phone calls demanding me to redact my correct report so as to not make them look bad. I responded with a no to all of them, and when circumstances proved the validity of my analysis, I was rewarded for standing my ground and not punished.
All in all, the people working there on the whole cared about doing what is right, is what I found. In that light, NSA stood in stark contrast to the FBI culture of major bureaucracy and lazy/inefficient practices.
As an example of the culture, I learned to program at NSA because when I said I was interested they said, "Here's a book and some servers.".