HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bcrescimanno

2,542 karma · joined September 28, 2009

Brian Crescimanno https://www.linkedin.com/in/briancrescimanno

Director of Engineering at Shopify

submissionscomments
bcrescimanno··on Epic launches anti-cheat support for Linux, Mac, and Steam Deck
For context, ProtonDB is a database of Steam games and how well they work on Linux through Wine/Proton. A huge number of the "borked" games are using some kind of anti-cheat and that's the main reason the game doesn't work.

EAC is one of the most-used anti-cheat systems in gaming. Between EAC and BattleEye, you're hitting the Pareto Principle for anti-cheat support.

Four of the top 10 Steam games use anti-cheat and therefore cannot run currently. Two of those four use EAC.

https://www.protondb.com/

bcrescimanno··on I switched from macOS to Linux after 15 years of Apple
While this isn't a hard and fast rule, GSuite adoption outside of the "tech sector" is extremely low. We have to recognize our own biases and that the experiences of the average HN reader doesn't reflect the larger business world.
bcrescimanno··on How useful was the Netflix Prize challenge for Netflix?
Former Netflix employee (2010-2013) here and, if there's one thing Netflix does as well or better than anyone in the industry, it's running the numbers. In particular, in those days, we had two key metrics that were strongly correlated and we would attempt to drive up: Streaming hours and account retention. Higher usage was strongly correlated with account retention to the point that they were the core of nearly every experiment we did.
bcrescimanno··on Super Mario Bros: The Human Limit
Came here to add comments about Summoning Salt as well. I don't follow speedruns at all; but, I really love his work and I absolutely echo the sentiment that he will get you emotionally invested in his content.

As an interesting aside, not only does he make great documentary style videos about Speed running, he also happens to be the current (as of June 2021) world record holder for Mike Tyson's Punch-Out!

https://www.speedrun.com/user/Summoningsalt

bcrescimanno··on Linus Torvalds on why desktop Linux sucks (2014)
Thanks for sharing! I do think that reverse situation is an often overlooked problem; though, one that I've never found to affect me personally.

I honestly don't know enough about Snap or Flatpak to really comment on them and their advantages and disadvantages. I've always shied away from them because I can't shake Xzibit in my head, "Yo dawg, I heard you like package managers so we put a package manager in your package manager!"

bcrescimanno··on Linus Torvalds on why desktop Linux sucks (2014)
While I think a lot of the complaints he raises here are still relevant 7 years later, it's interesting that both MacOS and Windows have trended more towards a package management system with their respective app stores--with MacOS especially discouraging downloading or running any apps from outside that ecosystem.

Since one can reasonably expect to target "Windows" or "MacOS" the packages in these app stores can be maintained directly by their developers which avoids a lot of the problems that Linus talked about in this video. When you get past the surface layer concept of, "We've sort of overblown this whole package management thing," it's really an argument that the fragmentation of the distributions and shared libraries that can't reasonably be shared.

Even using Arch with its rolling release model and making liberal use of the AUR for the most bleeding edge, I've found myself in exactly the situation Linus describes of needing a newer version of a package because the older one flat out doesn't work for me. I can make it work because I'm technical enough to roll my own package if I need to; but, even my wife who is pretty tech-savvy herself wouldn't be willing or able to go down that route.

IMO, the fact that the conversion in these comments will be rich with opinion and debate (almost all of which will be informed and intelligent) is the crux of the problem. Too many cooks have built too many kitchens--or some such metaphor. :)

bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
I corrected the URL in my post. I was on JoinPeertube.org and watched the, "What is PeerTube?" video that is embedded in that page. If I watched it again, it might not buffer at all. Maybe it was a bad moment. But I consume a lot of content on YouTube and I can't remember the last time a video buffered a single time--let alone several times in the first 30 seconds.

I'm honestly done with this ridiculous strawman about whether the video works. PeerTube is not a viable alternative to YouTube from a content creator's perspective for many reasons which I've already stated; but, I'll summarize:

1. It lacks even a tiny fraction of the distribution and discovery reach offered by YouTube.

2. It lacks the monetization features that allows YouTube to become part of a business.

3. It requires me to provide my own hosting and technical setup which is far more involved than dropping a video into your browser like you get with YouTube.

4. If I, as a consumer with no knowledge or interest in how PeerTube works, "choose the wrong server," I get a crappy experience with videos buffering for ages so I'm disinclined to continue to use the platform leading to reduced audiences on the platform and the feeling of, "doing extra work for nothing."

You can defend it all you want; but, your responses so far have been thinly veiled, "You're too stupid to get it right." I guess maybe I am; but, I'll stand behind that being the single biggest reason that PeerTube simply cannot be a platform to rival YouTube.

bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
Completely agreed. I'd love to see Google (and let's get Twitch in there as well, while we're at it) working with content creators to push for legal change. To me, that's what's most disappointing: Google will spend millions on lobbying to legally collect more and more information about me; but, they don't have the inclination to use their size and scale to push a significant expansion of Fair Use Doctrine (or, if they do, they certainly aren't vocal about it).
bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
As stated above, I watched the promotional video from PeerTube themselves on the JoinPeertube.org website and experienced multiple hiccups in under 30s. If their own hosting isn't cutting it, what chance does anyone else have?

> You probably chose a slow server.

I didn't choose a server. I chose a video. The moment the service asks me to think about what server is hosting it is the moment I don't care enough to jump through those hoops. Never underestimate the value of a consistent experience.

Once again, I don't want to be disparaging to PeerTube--it's a cool concept and I understand the foundations behind it. But, spending 10 minutes with it earlier today made it obvious that it's not going to challenge YouTube as a content discovery platform.

Edit: Corrected the URL from "PeerTube.com" to "JoinPeertube.org" -- I typed "PeerTube.com" in haste and just assuming the URL.

bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
These are great solutions to keep your content if Google decides to lock you out or destroy your content; but, they aren't platforms on which you can build a content creation side of a business.
bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
I'd honestly never heard of PeerTube so I searched it. Ah, they have a "about peertube" video! Should be great! In the first 30 seconds of the video, there were 1-3s long hiccups 4 times. Not exactly a confidence-inspiring start. After figuring out how to find more videos, I tried to play some--but, experienced more hiccups or load times from 20s to a full minute--and some just flat out didn't play at all.

I'm not saying PeerTube doesn't look like interesting tech; but this is clearly aimed at a far more tech-savvy crowd and to put it out there in response to asking for a, "reasonable alternative for a content creator who wants to publish their videos and be able to build an audience" is just totally missing the mark of what makes YouTube successful for creators and viewers alike.

bcrescimanno··on Piano teacher gets copyright claim for Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata [video]
I agree with your assessment of Google; however, what is a reasonable alternative for a content creator who wants to publish their videos and be able to build an audience? You kinda have to go where the audience will be if you don't already have one and I'm not aware of any video discovery platforms with anywhere near the reach of YouTube. I've managed to get out of Google products almost entirely--YouTube remains the exception.

Moreover, let's say a new site comes along and dethrones YouTube. Remember that this whole mess started because of lawsuits that were ultimately ruled (or settled) in favor of copyright holders. Any player in this space will need a method for handling vast quantities of copyrighted material scanning and, like Google, will be heavily incentivized by legal precedent to have that system "err on the side of caution."

I'm not a fan of Google; but, the villain of this story is the horribly outdated and corporate-lobbied copyright system that will push any player in the video space to this kind of draconian approach.

bcrescimanno··on Ubiquiti all but confirms breach response iniquity
It's disappointing to see a breach like this and even more disappointing to see what (at least on the surface) appears to be a lackadaisical response.

At someone who runs a UniFi network in my home with just 4 pieces of hardware (gateway, wired switch, and 2 PoE WAPs) I'm really curious if there are solid alternatives for a managed home network. UniFi really hit a sweet spot of price/performance that made it a somewhat pricey; but, not totally unreasonable option for the home.

Any suggestions from the HN crowd?

bcrescimanno··on Mozilla, Tor Join Calls to Oust Richard Stallman from Free Software Foundation
The Open Letter site itself has an Appendix that includes specifics:

https://rms-open-letter.github.io/appendix

bcrescimanno··on Mozilla, Tor Join Calls to Oust Richard Stallman from Free Software Foundation
The article itself is fairly generic. A rehashing of why Stallman was out in the first place, noting that he was recently re-appointed, and some quotes about why he shouldn't be involved.

See the Open Letter / Petition here for more details:

https://rms-open-letter.github.io/

bcrescimanno··on Roof blows off new Tesla Model Y
Former Model S owner here. Tesla quality, for the prices they charge, is insulting. I had a Model S for 3 years, put about 20K miles on it (which means I wasn’t a “heavy” driver by any means) and it was rattling, had massive panel gaps in the body, and all kinds of little bits just starting to fall apart. The charger door wouldn’t stay closed and eventually broke due to coming open on the highway so many times. After just 20K miles, the car honestly felt like a car feels after you put 150K miles on it.

Then there’s the service. I got an indicator on the massive screen telling me that the radiator needed service. I called the Service center and was told by two different people, “that’s not possible because our cars don’t have radiators.” I said, “look, I’m not the technician here, you are; but, I am reading you the message that the car has on the screen.” Finally got someone who acknowledged that, yes, Tesla’s do have radiators and I brought it in. When I picked it up, the Air Conditioning didn’t work. In the middle of Summer. I called them and told them and they told me there were no openings for service for 6 weeks. After arguing with the service manager for 20 minutes on the phone, he agreed to have me come in the next day and, sure enough, they’d forgotten to reconnect it when they were working on it.

Was it the worst car I’ve ever owned? Honestly, it might have been. When I factor in that it cost over $90K, it’s definitely the worst car purchase I’ve ever made.

bcrescimanno··on Tech sector job interviews assess anxiety, not software skills: study
There are literally dozens of reasons that tech interviews suck. However, they all mostly boil down to the same root cause: there's very little correlation between the content of most interviews and the jobs people will perform. Some real life situations that I've been on one side or the other of:

* Companies doing a "centralized" process that ignores the candidate. The questions are always overly generic and it really boils down to, "You need to want to work here enough to basically take any job we'll throw at you." Sorry, I don't want to work any company enough to just take any random job.

* Coders asked to complete academic problems that will NEVER come up for them in their real work.

* Coders not being allowed to leverage external resources like they will literally do EVERY DAY in their real jobs.

* Managers being asked to be coders in interviews.

* Questions that have binary "right" and "wrong" answers.

* Asking questions that have a million ways to do it and then honing in on one specific disagreement the interviewer and candidate had.

* Interviews that are more about the interviewer stroking their own ego and proving that they are smarter than the candidate.

* Completely ignoring that the absolute best indicator of future performance is past performance; not, "what quiz could this person solve in 45 minutes in an interview."

bcrescimanno··on The fall of Quibi: how did a starry $1.75B Netflix rival crash so fast?
There’s a reason that the phrase, “Content is King” is so prevalent: it’s a fact.

Like many, I saw dozens of ads for Quibi (many of them on YouTube) and the entire campaign was centered around selling me on the concept of short-form content—-something I found hilarious on YouTube since anyone who frequents YouTube is probably already pretty sold on that concept. At no point was I given any indication of what I could watch. Every ad left me totally disengaged because I was either left to guess at what they might have or to assume that their library must be pretty shit if they aren’t going to talk about it.

I worked at Netflix when the company began the idea of a “Netflix Original.” Everyone points to House of Cards as the first (and, in terms of Netflix-produced content, it was) but there was a lesser known first original called “Lillyhammer.” You didn’t hear about it because it was literally dipping the toes into the water of what it meant to “own” content rather that just license it. It wasn’t a signature piece of content we could build a brand around.

House of Cards and Orange is the New Black were the big ones and they came 6 and 9 months later respectively. They were “signature” shows that set the tone of what Netflix originals were all about. I remember the lead Product Manager and I sitting together and discussing whether we should include a promotional photo of one of the characters from House of Cards giving the camera the middle finger in our main experience. We knew that parents and conservative groups might be upset by it being right there in our UI; but, we also knew the tone we wanted to set for our content. We put it in. The content drove our marketing.

It was important that people get on board with the idea of “Netflix Originals.” But it was more important that the content spoke for itself. In Quibi’s case, they need content they can showcase that speak for itself and gets people on the platform. No one will care if it’s “short form” or “long form” as long as it’s GOOD.

bcrescimanno··on Why I Write Games in C (yes, C)
Definitely! Object pools are common in game dev too from what I know. We used them extensively to reduce the amount of GC we needed.
bcrescimanno··on Why I Write Games in C (yes, C)
Disclaimer: I'm not a game developer; but, I've worked on a lot of projects with tight frame time requirements in my time at Netflix on the TVUI team. I also have no experience in Go so I can't comment on the specifics of that garbage collector vs. V8.

I don't think it's necessarily that it "can't" work as much as it takes away a critical element of control from the game developers and the times you find yourself "at the mercy" of the garbage collector is pretty damn frustrating.

The problem we ran into with garbage collection was that it was generally non-deterministic both in terms of when it would happen and how long it would take. We actually added an API hook in our JS to manually trigger GC (something you can do when you ship a custom JS runtime) so we could take at least the "when it happens" out of the picture.

That said, there were often fairly large variances in how long it would take and, while frame time budgets may seem to accommodate things, if you end up in a situation where one of your "heavy computation" frames coincides with a GC that runs long, you're going to get a nasty frame time spike.

We struggled enough that we discussed exposing more direct memory management through a custom JS API so we could more directly control things. We ultimately abandoned that idea for various reasons (though I left over 6 years ago so I have no idea how things are today).

bcrescimanno··on The Fry’s Era
Yep--I remember that, for a very long time, trying to go to Frys.com would simply redirect you Outpost.com. Even when they changed that, it went on for several more years that if you went to frys.com you would find yourself on the Outpost.com site with the logo replaced with a Fry's logo. The online selection was useless. It had little to no understanding of local store inventory. But the worst part was that the search function just fundamentally didn't work. You could type the exact model of a part into the search and it would give you random, unrelated things and not give you the part itself.
bcrescimanno··on The Fry’s Era
Not mentioned in the post: Fry's web presence has always been terrible. Absolutely, hopelessly, utterly terrible. A lot of people in this thread have brought up MicroCenter as a strong counter-example--I'd also throw Best Buy into that mix. Different product line at Best Buy; but, if you look at the web presence, these companies are doing great with Buy-Online-Pickup-In-Store. I often use Best Buy for items that I can't (or just don't want to) wait for even the 2-day shipping from Amazon.

I cannot recall a single time that I was able to find what I was looking for on the Fry's website--including many times I was able to walk into the store and find an item sitting on the shelf. That was even 10-15 years ago and it never improved.

There are a whole lot of reasons that Fry's is on its death-bed; their clear lack of commitment to a strong web presence to drive instant-gratification shopping is an important lesson for other brick-and-mortar retailers.

bcrescimanno··on Home Assistant: Open-source home automation platform running on Python 3
I’ve had the opposite experience. Just had a Caseta switch installed to control some LED recessed lighting.

* the switch itself feels very flimsy and low quality.

* dimming only sort of works.

* the control is extremely laggy. Hit the buttons and wait up to a second before something happens.

* sometimes, the lights just don’t turn on. I’ll watch the LEDs on the switch light up, and then turn off. And then try again. And fail again...

I’ve had it a week and I’m ready to throw it out a window.

bcrescimanno··on Netflix and Alphabet will need to become ISPs, fast
I worked at Netflix when OpenConnect was introduced and I don't remember anyone internally thinking it was unnecessary (though, even at the time, the company was large enough that you didn't know everyone). Quite contrary, this was the era of the 250GB / month cap from Comcast and we could observe clearly that they were throttling Netflix traffic. OpenConnect, the ability to deploy the CDN directly into the internal network of these ISPs served multiple purposes--not the least of which was to expose the fact that they were holding Netflix for ransom. So, to say that was the executive foreseeing things is a bit of revisionist history. It doesn't lessen the impact or importance of OpenConnect; but, it grew out of a very real impasse with a very large ISP.

Ultimately, Netflix did end up paying Comcast in 2014 and, surprise surprise, the throttling stopped.

bcrescimanno··on Mall landlords struggling to find takers at a price they’ll accept
Yeah, we happened to be near the mall yesterday for an unrelated reason so I decided to give it a shot. DSW is always a good option; but, I often find myself frustrated with my size being fairly common (translation: often sold out).
bcrescimanno··on Mall landlords struggling to find takers at a price they’ll accept
In almost all cases, I completely agree with you!

In shops that require interaction to proceed beyond browsing (such as the shoe shops I visited yesterday) I want a salesperson to be attentive and help me so I can spend as little time as possible standing around waiting.

bcrescimanno··on Mall landlords struggling to find takers at a price they’ll accept
Replying here--yeah, the stores inside shopping malls typically lack the real estate to have all the shoes available in the main store and, instead, keep them in a stock room in the back. I've definitely been to both types; but, the mall stores are almost always the "pick a display shoe and have a salesperson bring your size."
bcrescimanno··on Mall landlords struggling to find takers at a price they’ll accept
Here's an anecdote about my experience at a mall yesterday. I needed some new shoes:

I went to the Skechers store. There were 4 people working. Not a single one ever offered to help me. I had to walk up to the counter and the girl looked shocked when I asked her to get me my size to try on. She handed me the box and walked away. I never saw her again and walked out without making a purchase.

I went over to Macy's to the men's shoe section. The section was about 5x the size of the Skechers store. There was one person working who was busy with a customer at the checkout. After waiting for 10+ minutes with no one to help, I left without ever trying on a pair of shoes.

Then I went to Ecco--they are a small shop with only a small number of shoes. While the salesperson was quite attentive and helped me out, the one pair of shoes they had in the store that were interesting to me didn't fit right so I left.

Tried to go to one more store only to discover that this particular location only carried women's shoes.

All told, this adventure had me in the mall for about 90 minutes and I had managed to try on 2 pairs of shoes. Throw in the drive and it was over 2 hours for nothing.

I went home, spent 20 minutes on Amazon Wardrobe, and I have 8 pairs of shoes in my size arriving at my house in a few days to try on.

Stores in a mall have a real opportunity to win on personal service and instant gratification. Hire someone to help me find shoes that fit me well and go with my own sense of style and who makes sure I go home happy. But if my choices are spend over 2 hours for nothing or go online, I'm choosing the latter every time.

bcrescimanno··on Performance Reviews Are a Waste of Time
That's not necessarily true. When managers are doing a good job of regularly communicating with an employee and having critical conversations in regular 1:1s, nothing in a performance review should come as a surprise. If you've ever been surprised in a performance review, your manager failed in their responsibility--and you probably also failed yourself in that you didn't push for regular conversations.

Sure, those disagreements still happen. But, when things are transparent, there's very little risk of a "system breakdown" and a very high chance that a dissatisfied employee (who doesn't seem to be performing well in our scenario) will leave to make room for someone with more potential.

Edit: I just noticed the GP was jedberg; we both spent enough time at Netflix to see what each of us is describing work well in practice. :)

bcrescimanno··on Performance Reviews Are a Waste of Time
> Avoid the temptation to synthesize and anonymize feedback that really should be given directly.

Yes, yes, YES!

When I solicit feedback for people on my team, I always remind everyone that anonymous feedback is the worst. Honest, direct feedback is incredibly valuable.

Feedback should be the catalyst for a conversation; not a one time statement to be interpreted or ignored.

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →