HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bcrescimanno

2,542 karma · joined September 28, 2009

Brian Crescimanno https://www.linkedin.com/in/briancrescimanno

Director of Engineering at Shopify

submissionscomments
bcrescimanno··on Objectify: A Better Way to Build Rails Applications
FWIW, I'm not a Rails developer; so take my comments as you will.

I don't think the problem people seem to have with Objectify is that they see it as a totally invalid solution to a problem--and I agree with your assessment that many people see this problem as very real.

My own take is that I find it disingenuous to call it an Object-Oriented solution to the problem; it's not. That doesn't make it bad, invalid, or wrong. It rightly raises a few eyebrows to talk about effectively calling namespaced procedures as if it were the pinnacle of Object-oriented design.

bcrescimanno··on Please don't let gaming consume your life
I'm sorry for the loss of a friend; I don't pretend to know how you currently feel.

That said, I think there's a pretty big leap you're taking from "playing a lot of games" and "had a heart attack at 32." Obviously, I don't know this person; but I do know a lot of folks who have gone on binge gaming sessions who have never had heart attacks.

I'm not saying there isn't any connection or that it didn't contribute in any way; however, let's be honest with ourselves and admit that a binge gaming session, while not in any way healthy and certainly a likely contributor to this person's poor health, most likely did not cause a heart attack.

bcrescimanno··on Show HN: I love Essential Mixes. So I made this.
Thanks for the tip; I'll give it a listen. OO has been at it a LONG time as well--definitely listened to him back in the day as well.

Sasha, Oakenfold, and Ferry Corsten around the 1999 - 2002 timeframe were my soundtrack. Some really great anthems from those days!

bcrescimanno··on Show HN: I love Essential Mixes. So I made this.
The one from Shanghai was just awesome! It was the first one I sought out on the site and listened to again.
bcrescimanno··on Show HN: I love Essential Mixes. So I made this.
Those are definitely some good names today; but if you want a bit of a history lesson I'd check out Sasha in the late 90's and early 00's.

Also Oakenfold, Paul Van Dyk, John Digweed, and Carl Cox were all in their prime during those days.

bcrescimanno··on Show HN: I love Essential Mixes. So I made this.
I really can't describe how much I'm enjoying going back and finding mixes from that era. Not only is the music great; but I feel like I just stepped into a time machine!
bcrescimanno··on Show HN: I love Essential Mixes. So I made this.
Right around the turn of the millenium, I downloaded a couple dozen Essential Mixes while I was on the GT campus. This just made my day--I really hope any legal issues can be avoided and this can stay online. :)
bcrescimanno··on 5 Things They Told You Not To Use In JavaScript
Only responding to clarify: the only part I will admit was incorrect was the quote, "and, by extension, his consulting and training enterprises." Everything else I said I stand by 100%. Maybe I'm wrong and that's not his intent--but it's certainly the perception I have; having watched this same scene play out time and again.
bcrescimanno··on 5 Things They Told You Not To Use In JavaScript
Your entirely predictable defense of your husband notwithstanding; I don't mean to diminish Thomas's contributions to the Javascript community at large nor the quality of the work he does. I hope I made that point entirely clear in my original post (and if I hadn't, I hope I am doing so now). I call it how I see it; and I see no need to repeat myself as to why I believe what I posted. Attempting to call my argument fallacious with absolutely no justification other than correcting one minor (and somewhat irrelevant given that self-marketing is important regardless of one's current occupation) incongruity is little more than an attempt to drag me into a 2-on-1 battle royal in which I refuse to participate.
bcrescimanno··on 5 Things They Told You Not To Use In JavaScript
I'll say that I disagree with just about every point made here and certainly not because of some religious fervor. I won't enumerate them all, and I completely refuse to get drawn into the debate of semicolons vs. no semicolons; but statements like this,

"Whether you like it or not, whitespace is significant in JavaScript. A linebreak indicates, in most cases, the end of a statement; a semicolon is automatically inserted for you."

Are just flat out absurd. Like it or not, automatic semicolon insertion is NOT significant whitespace and the second sentence completely contradicts the first by pointing out that ASI happens in MOST cases--but not all. If whitespace were truly significant, it would apply in ALL cases. Again, I'm not debating whether you should use semicolons or not--but I'm willing to flat out state that Javascript does not have significant whitespace; no matter how you want to spin it.

That said (and now here comes the "someone had to say it department") this strikes me, yet again, as Thomas being contrarian for the sake of getting a rise out of folks to draw attention to himself. I mean no disrespect with this statement; but anyone who has followed him for a long time on Twitter knows that he's apt to taking an unpopular position and leveraging it as a marketing opportunity for himself (and, by extension, his consulting and training enterprises). That's a fine approach; but, I felt it time someone identified it for what it is. Thomas is a smart dude and he's built some amazing things; but his public persona and style is carefully crafted and contrarian and we're all buying in by popularizing the debates he either creates or catalyzes.

[Edit: fixed a typo]

bcrescimanno··on Yelp, You Cost Me $2000 by Suppressing Genuine Reviews. Here’s How You Fix It
So there's a resource out there that claims to let the customer do a good portion of that research by aggregating real customer reviews and you berate him for using that research? Calling the guy "stupid" for believing a bunch of supposedly satisfied real customers while at least 10 extremely negative customer experiences were hidden from him is bullshit.
bcrescimanno··on I Guess I'm Not A 501 Developer
Why does it always have to be one or the other? Why do we feel the need to assign labels to everything?

And why in the holy hell are some programmers so damn single-minded that they can't accept that others who are passionate about programming can also be passionate about other things. I'm passionate about my job and consider myself among the extremely lucky few who gets to do what I love for a living (and, at the moment, in a place I love doing it making for a great combo). But I'm more passionate about my family at home. I'm also passionate about the music, movies, games, and other arts.

Devoting yourself to one thing is not being passionate about it--it's having a single-minded focus and lacking passion about anything else. Can we please stop confusing those points?

bcrescimanno··on IPhone Will Fail in a Late, Defensive Move (2007)
Don't forget that there's a whole segment of these guys who are basically paid to get it wrong--being the one guy who says, "this obvious winner is going to fail" attracts a lot of eyeballs.

Remember, being a pundit isn't about being correct; it's about getting people reading what you write.

bcrescimanno··on IPhone Will Fail in a Late, Defensive Move (2007)
Hindsight, of course, is 20/20--but to be fair to this journalist, there were some very real reasons to think the iPhone wouldn't really succeedn (at least not in an industry shifting way). At the time, the carriers maintained almost full control over the whole ecosystem and if entrenched players like Nokia couldn't force their hand on anything, what reason did people have to believe Apple could? Moreover, the initial price point was exorbitant for a phone in that day--and people should remember that the real explosion of iPhone sales didn't happen until the 3g brought about the subsidized model.

What was underestimated was the public's desire for a smart phone catering to people as people not people as employees.

And let's not forget that it brought about a "touch-revolution." In 2007, all the anti-Apple group could talk about was how "without a physical keyboard, it's just going to suck."

With all of that said, reading this piece suggests the author was more drumming up pageviews by presenting a contrarian view than actually writing an article he believed in.

bcrescimanno··on Julian Assange Starts Talk Show On Russian TV
In most cases, I'd agree. But when my flagging corresponds to assaulting someone who many around these parts see as some kind of folk hero, I'm not surprised when some downvotes come simply from people annoyed at me for calling Assange out for being a publicity whore.

That said, my guess is any upvotes are simply people agreeing with me as well.

bcrescimanno··on Julian Assange Starts Talk Show On Russian TV
Flagged.

Primarily because Julian Assange is little more than a publicity whore and this latest move is just more evidence of that truth. He's little different than the Kardashians of the world. Moreover, I just don't see how him starting a talkshow is at all "newsworthy."

[Edit] Now that the inevitable down-voting has begun, I'll just comment that when I flag a post, I feel it's reasonable to leave an comment as to why I flagged it. FWIW, I could have just flagged it and let it go without taking the negative hit.

bcrescimanno··on In praise of Objective C
FWIW, I was reading the article as someone with no Objective-C experience (outside of skimming a few references) and I could tell he was talking about a library rather than a language. It'd almost be analogous to writing an article titled "In praise of Javascript" and proceed to talk about jQuery functionality. jQuery has certainly had an impact on the Javascript language; but the two (despite popular opinion to the contrary) remain entirely distinct.
bcrescimanno··on In praise of Objective C
This article reads a lot more like "In praise of Cocoa" than anything specific to Objective-C, the language. The author clearly sees them as one beast when they are quite separate. It's somewhat reasonable to lump them together since developing anything in Objective-C without Cocoa is generally prohibitively difficult given the lack of other library support.

That said, nothing he's really talking about has to do with the language itself (save, perhaps, for the performance characteristics closer to C++ than Java). He's more praising what C# developers always praise: he's basically describing it as "Java done better than Java."

bcrescimanno··on An introduction to the JavaScript Module Pattern
FWIW, If you want instantiate-able objects, the module pattern is probably the wrong option in that case anyway.
bcrescimanno··on [dead]
Despite agreeing with the general concept that we have a problem as hackers with constantly interrupting and clarifying points, I've flagged this post for the following reasons:

1) It shows a real lack of class to call an individual out by name when you're talking about etiquette. Yes, I realize that the title of the article was meant to be attention grabbing--all the more reason to flag it.

2) There's very little context as to what the actual conversation was about. The implication is that there was really no reason for Yehuda (or anyone) to interrupt. But without the real context, I don't know if it was a person butting in trying to look intelligent or a person trying to avoid people at a user group listening to someone suggesting a dangerous technique that shouldn't be allowed to grow.

3) The premise "Let them speak in public; let them be wrong!" is absolutely faulty and the comparison to the Dale Carnegie story was a total straw man. There is a world of difference between correcting someone in polite, social conversation and correcting someone in the context of a presentation in which the attendees may be seeing the speaker as an authority or expert.

Now I wasn't there, so I'll neither condemn nor condone the way this was approached--but the article itself is little more than a smear against one person and I find it distasteful.

bcrescimanno··on If hotels billed like hospitals
What really troubles me, that I didn't see represented in this video, is not so much the total amount of the bills but the sheer number of them. These days, a hospital visit results in bills from (at the very least)

* The hospital * The doctor (or doctors) who may have spent a total of 10 minutes with you * The lab company that did your blood work (if it was done) * The lab company that did you CT scan / MRI / Ultrasound / X-Ray / other expensive diagnostic exam. * The pharmacy that provided any medications you were given while at the hospital.

What's worse, is that if you look, most triage areas have a sign stating all the services are independently operated and you'll receive these separate bills. Confusing and obnoxious--but ok. The trouble begins when you discover that, though your insurance is accepted by the hospital, it's not accepted by one of the other people or services (of which you had no real choice but to use the service available on-site) isn't. The hospital might assign you a doctor that doesn't take your insurance and then you're screwed.

bcrescimanno··on GitHub and Rails: You have let us all down.
FWIW, that last bullet, aside from being the most egregious example of hyperbole in TFA, shows a complete lack of understanding of how git works.
bcrescimanno··on HaXe - Code Once. Deploy Everywhere.
Ah, "code once. deploy everywhere." Few examples of marketing to engineers spark quite the same level of skepticism as this oft-repeated claim.

Ignoring, for a moment, the complexity of deploying software across multiple platforms, it's important to remember the multiple form-factor problem. The same software doesn't work from a user's standpoint on multiple platforms if the UI isn't correct for that device. The best example I can give is "mobile versions" of sites and apps, clearly targeted at the form factor of a phone, being delivered to a 10" tablet. It's crappy.

Bring in the obvious elephant in the room of the number of times this claim has been made from an engineering standpoint and truly failed to deliver, and I yawn every time HaXe is mentioned.

bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs used patents to pressure Bill Gates into 1997 investment in Apple
Completely agreed, even if all they did was break even on the deal financially (or honestly, even if all that money had eventually gone up in smoke) the value of having a real competitor to point to at that time was worth every penny.
bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs ignored Warren Buffett's advice for a stock buyback
Presumably, the stock would be reissued at a point where forces other than supply & demand would have had an impact on the price as well. Yes, the additional available shares on the market would cause a dip--but that dip would not necessarily negate the other effects that (could have) impacted the stock price since the buy-back.

I'm not ignoring the effect; I'm just not viewing it in vacuum.

bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs used patents to pressure Bill Gates into 1997 investment in Apple
[Edit: math was corrected above] I'm not following your math, 18.2 million shares of Apple today would be worth about $9.8 billion--for a $151 million investment. I'm sure there are nuances that I don't fully grasp; but that's a huge discrepancy.

FWIW, I didn't mean to imply that MS should have held onto that investment; I was only answering the question about the purely financial ROI.

bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs used patents to pressure Bill Gates into 1997 investment in Apple
I don't know that the full numbers are well known, but this Ars article reveals some of the details:

http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2010/05/apples-stock-r...

FTA: All told, Microsoft spent a little over $151 million to acquire 18.2 million shares of Apple stock, for roughly $8.31 per share. Microsoft confirmed that it sold all of its AAPL holdings some time ago, and likely did so at a healthy profit—after all, AAPL has traded significantly higher than $8 for many years. But what if Microsoft had held on to that investment just a little longer?

bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs used patents to pressure Bill Gates into 1997 investment in Apple
Agreed; the title of the article is linkbait at best. This is far less "patent pressure" and more an appeal to a long-time colleague to lay down arms because it was a lose-lose for everyone. For Jobs, it was more of a concession that though he knew he was in a fight that he couldn't win. Truthfully, I find that story far more interesting and compelling than the ridiculous assertion that this was a form of "patent pressure."
bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs ignored Warren Buffett's advice for a stock buyback
We aren't talking about re-issuing shares--we're talking about buying them back to be re-issued at a later date. The act of buying them back would shrink the supply and (in theory) drive up the price.
bcrescimanno··on Steve Jobs ignored Warren Buffett's advice for a stock buyback
Theoretically, fewer public shares means that the value should go up (basic supply and demand curve). Apple could then sell their shares at the higher price and effectively earn a return (the reality of how this would happen is more complex--but it all adds up to this basic premise).
← PreviousPage 8 of 13Next →