HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bdd8f1df777b

662 karma · joined September 29, 2023

submissionscomments
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
Haha, you would think that these cases count as enough evidence for the government not to have any power over speech. Nope. The Chinese people just oppose those specific cases, and in a small percentage of them, the government reversed course and then the masses are satisfied.

After those happened, they still think that the government intervention of speech is a good idea. The only problem is that a small group of officials not handling the regulating power correctly. But if they were to adopt the American model, how could they be protected from the evil influence of foreign adversaries? You know, like me, an agent of US propaganda. Or Tencent, whose major shareholders are actually not Chinese.

I really can't maintain a straight face hearing Americans repeating that same argument.

bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
I'm not debating that China is bad or not, or if it is an adversary to the US.

My deeply held belief is that we should allow speech from even the most hostile foreign countries. Do you know that every administration of China, starting from Qing Dynasty, resisted the idea of freedom and democracy by painting them as plots of foreign governments to destabilize China?

I am being called a sock puppet of China here, and I have been accused of being agents of US propaganda in China. That is how the future holds. Every thought deviating from mainstream is labelled as propaganda from a foreign government, ergo not subject to the protections of freedom of speech.

bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
> and many orders of magnitude less restrictive.

That's true, but when I had a hard time convincing them when the US were the *perfect* model of no speech restrictions, it's much harder when US is just less restrictive. They will just dismiss such difference in quantity as cultural difference, rather than different principles when China and US had qualitative differences.

bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
If we talk about law, that is probably true. But for the principles, I don't think so.

We want freedom of speech because we can never know that our opinions are the ultimate Truth, so we need to ensure that everyone can speak their mind, and so can the real Truth be propagated and preserved. And that everyone includes foreigners and foreign governments.

Every time China's governments (including the past ones, like the Qing Dynasty) rejects the idea of freedom and democracy, it demonizes them by painting them as plots of foreign governments trying to overthrow and destablize China. So you can see why I am so wary of the argument that it is OK to silence the words if those come from a foreign government.

bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
OK, let me reword. I still can converse with others on Chinese social media, but I will have a harder time convincing them that GFW is a bad idea or that the China's government is wrong restricting speech. Because people not already convinced will point to the US banning TikTok and ask me how China's actions are different. The distinction between the two is subtle, and frankly, while the US actions do not violate the First Amendment, it does breach the underlying principles. I have no convincing argument for them.
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
> Your education was not a lie, but you should still get a refund on your failed education. You clearly did not learn to think critically.

I read both Chinese and English, and I read both the opinions of within GFW and without. If anything, I've critically analyzed every idea from both sides. I can't fathom the hubris of someone who has ever lived on one side yet believes his truth is the ultimate truth and anyone disagreeing must not be thinking critically.

bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
No, they don't arrest people for such abstract concepts. They do arrest people who tangibly threatens the government, like exposing the shenanigans of high officials, or organizing labor protests over the Internet.
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
I was called a US sock puppet on Chinese social media and then a Chinese sock puppet here. I guess people everywhere are the same, doing ad hominem attacks whenever they see people having an opposite opinion.
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
You misunderstood me. I was not talking about doing on TikTok, but on China's own social media and when conversing with other Chinese offline.
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
Say what you will, but I won't be able to espouse the virtues of freedom of speech in China anymore. The distinction you make isn't going to convince any one.
bdd8f1df777b··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
The US bans TikTok citing the same reasons China bans foreign social media, to avoid influence from foreign adversaries (people below says that China never official bans it, but China is inconsistent on that). It is only fair from a business perspective, but it also means that China's ideology wins over American in the end.

The China's own social media is full of posts ridiculing people like me who have believed in the American ideology, espoused the virtues of freedom of speech and rallied against the GFW. They call us naive and credulous. And I can't refute them.

When I was young, I was taught in China that China lost its superpower status after it chose to isolate itself from the rest of the world. And then it isolated itself. I was taught by the US the importance of freedom of speech. Then it ditched it. My education was a lie.

bdd8f1df777b··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
If I offer a product under both open source and commercial license, and then someone uses an open source version without paying me anything, neither for the license nor consultancy, am I liable for damages?
bdd8f1df777b··on Dangers of “decentralized” ID systems
In my working context, a "decentralized" government issued (digital) ID refers to an identity whose verification does not require a connection to the government server (e.g. verification is done by public key cryptography). So the government always has to participate in the issuance of that digital ID, but it doesn't know when and where you have used your identity. ISO/IEC 18013-5 is an example of this type.

By contrast, a "centralized" digital ID phones home every time it presents and verifies. I don't know any standards, but most digital identities in China are of this form.

bdd8f1df777b··on Glibc Buffer Overflow in Iconv
But if you are calling Win32 APIs, you can call Win32 APIs MultiByteToWideChar/WideCharToMultiByte to convert between UTF8 and UTF16. No need for iconv.
bdd8f1df777b··on Glibc Buffer Overflow in Iconv
I've seldom seen UTF16 text file even under Windows. Sometimes, but not that often.
bdd8f1df777b··on Multipath TCP for Linux (2022)
The only practical use of MPTCP for me is to use mobile and Wi-Fi network together to boost the speed. iOS and WeChat both support this. However, I always turn them off because my mobile network is metered. So in the end, MPTCP is useless for me *personally*.
bdd8f1df777b··on Apple Ordered to Pull WhatsApp/Threads from China App Store
Practically it’s a no op. To use WhatsApp or Threads I need an app to bypass the GFW, which is not available on Chinese App Store. So I have an American Apple ID to download a proxying app. Then there is no point for me to download those two apps from the Chinese App Store even back when they still existed.

What I’m really afraid of is that someday iPhones within China won’t be able to login to Apple Store in another region.

bdd8f1df777b··on PuTTY vulnerability vuln-p521-bias
Not at this risk, but possibly others. Requiring both is always better.
bdd8f1df777b··on Apple loses top phonemaker spot to Samsung
> I took a whip through the Xiaomi financials and they talk about profit mix in percentages but I didn't see a break out by line.

Xiaomi's phone is its primary business. If they were operating at a loss on their phones, they wouldn't have any other lucrative business to absorb that loss and turn positive on their profit.

bdd8f1df777b··on Apple loses top phonemaker spot to Samsung
iPhones have only one year warranty in China too. Not sure why.
bdd8f1df777b··on PuTTY vulnerability vuln-p521-bias
I knew requiring public key authentication *followed by* password authentication on my SSH server was not paranoid!
bdd8f1df777b··on Ubuntu 24.04 (and Debian) removed libsystemd from SSH server dependencies
> A back door in the same library is not likely.

But libsystemd is not linked to xz only. By removing it, sshd is free of many other potential risks.

bdd8f1df777b··on Building a Linux Container Using Namespaces: Part – 1 (2020)
Google Chrome

Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/123.0.0.0 Safari/537.36

bdd8f1df777b··on The xz sshd backdoor rabbithole goes quite a bit deeper
You think every time people call an external library to save their effort is a proof of their lack of capabilities?
bdd8f1df777b··on Building a Linux Container Using Namespaces: Part – 1 (2020)
A side note: the page does not declare utf-8 encoding. I have manually change it to resolve some of garbled text.
bdd8f1df777b··on Apple alerts users in 92 nations to mercenary spyware attacks
Several CVEs in the past related to iMessage. And it has surprisingly high privilege. Since I seldom need it, turning it off is better for my security.
bdd8f1df777b··on BatBadBut: You can't securely execute commands on Windows
True, but even if Microsoft pushes an update, it will take decades before all Windows are patched.
bdd8f1df777b··on The xz sshd backdoor rabbithole goes quite a bit deeper
> With proper error handling, that's about 50 lines of C code.

Writing proper error handling in C is a very tedious and error prone task. So it doesn't surprise me that people would rather call another library instead.

bdd8f1df777b··on FFmpeg 7.0
So I'm trying to build ffmpeg via vcpkg today, and it turned out multiple of its dependencies are transitively depending on liblzma, but the downloading of liblzma source has been disabled by GitHub in light of the recent xz backdoor.
bdd8f1df777b··on From xz to ibus: more questionable tarballs
> The project was already compromised, the Git repository isn't any more trustworthy than the tarball.

You are talking about this from hindsight. For other projects, we do not know yet if anything similar is happening. So for them the Git repo is definitely more trustworthy.

> tarballs should be fully reproducible from Git.

That's exactly the same as trusting Git repo more than the tarball.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →