HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

beerandt

3,816 karma · joined January 11, 2019

submissionscomments
beerandt··on We Rarely Lose Technology (2023)
Yea this is economics, not tech.

We also don't build carriages as well or have an army of craftsman doing it, but it's lost/regressed because there's no economic incentives.

beerandt··on We Rarely Lose Technology (2023)
>Fogbank

This is a more interesting example- the theory isn't that we lost the tech, but that the new tech was too good, too pure.

The incidentals of the old, 'dirty' way of manufacturing it (that we just spent billions and billions to destroy and clean up) apparently (speculation, since classified) added some unknown impurities that affected its performance.

And either it needed to be redesigned with the new manufacturing process, or go back to the old process to fit the specs of existing weapons or the weapons would need to be redesigned.

We didn't lose the tech, but other 'advances' in both tech and society (not having workers manually handle dangerous stuff) caused an overall regression, not advancement.

It's the EPA DC chlorine case all over again, of 'progress and safety' actually increasing danger and causing overall regression.

beerandt··on Taco Bell AI Drive-Thru
The follow up question (not quite mc) was actually what put it in a loop for me-

It kept asking 'what kind of drink?' After apparently interpreting engine noise as asking for one.

Wouldn't respond to 'none' or any other response I gave, except to repeat the q.

beerandt··on Final report on Alaska Airlines Flight 1282 in-flight exit door plug separation
Only if you're using technical writing in a situation where you shouldn't be.

Problem is the state of most English education doesn't even teach enough for people to recognize proper unambiguous technical writing, let alone appreciate it or attempt to compose it.

beerandt··on We’re secretly winning the war on cancer
'Cancer Alley' maps are generally just the same cherrypicked socioeconomic/ racial map you see everywhere- especially the refinery claims.

Adjust for those factors and the increased incidence disappears.

beerandt··on Why does Debian change software?
Between snap and having completely different network implementations between "desktop" and "server" versions really made me fall back down the learning curve of nix.

Especially since I was novice at best before the systemd thing, and my Ubuntu dive involved trying to navigate all 3 of these pretty drastic changes at once (oh yea and throw containers on top of that).

I went into it with the expectation that it was going to piss me off, and boy did it easily exceeded that threshold.

beerandt··on Harvard's response to federal government letter demanding changes
They made a big fuss a few years ago about what I read imo as over investing in foreign farm land, esp south America and Africa. Which seems to have completely flopped, if not yet realized.

At this point, you really do have to question whether each university hire was merit based or not, including the fund managers.

beerandt··on The Amazon Appstore for Android devices will be discontinued on August 20, 2025
My very basic understanding is:

They wanted android developers that used google play services to basically be able to submit the same app to the amazon/fire store (without major revisions), so they reverse engineered the framework used by Google for api/hooks between the apps/apks and the "play-services"/OS levels.

Sort of spoofed the environment to prioritize compatibility in order to make it as easy as possible to grow the Amazon app store.

People don't realize that despite Android being nominally 'Open Source', the closed source Google layer on most phones makes it very difficult to exclude Google entirely from the picture and have a user friendly phone environment (both end-user and app-developer/playstore-user).

Basically only Amazon and China had resources to counter it directly with Android, or you could drop that layer and go the less user friendly route of st like AOSP 'pure' phones.

beerandt··on The Amazon Appstore for Android devices will be discontinued on August 20, 2025
They jumped through some pretty giant hoops to make their play services "drop in" replacement, but idk if that's just for fire tablets or if it gets installed on Android too.
beerandt··on Why US Refiners Won't Ditch Canadian Crude
The heavy crude processing is a maintenance cost sink.

Reverting to processing local oil is both cheaper equipment wise (removing the heavy crude vessels and selling them) and cheaper bc you don't pay to pipe oil with the viscosity of sludge across the continent.

Fed quotas are the reason for the current config, configuration, economics.

beerandt··on Why US Refiners Won't Ditch Canadian Crude
Which was debunked as being the same map you see everywhere else making bs claims about the south.

The clusters are poor and poor health, but have no statistical significance to pollution levels.

beerandt··on Why US Refiners Won't Ditch Canadian Crude
Someone doesn't know what turnaround means.

Every refinery shuts down at least twice a year for a multi-week turnaround.

The minimum cost to stay operating isn't paying to keep the high cost vessels running, but to remove and sell them to a place that has that heavy crude locally.

The heavy oil processing is the larger maintenence cost that you think isn't happening.

beerandt··on Plane crashes, overturns during landing at Toronto airport
Ok but 1) both are critical and 2) if it's been snowing and there's 33kt gusts idk how the runway stays snow/ice/moisture free.
beerandt··on Plane crashes, overturns during landing at Toronto airport
ATC calls out gusts at 33kts on his clearance call.

Not excellent, especially if it's cross.

beerandt··on Why US Refiners Won't Ditch Canadian Crude
That doesn't mean that they need to be, long term.

When the turnaround comes to replace some of those oversized heavy-processing vessels, the preference (in an deregulated market) would be not to replace them.

If epa and other regs that dictate output quotas loosen, it'd been easy for preference to change.

beerandt··on Using GPS satellites to detect tsunamis via ionospheric ionization waves
GPS was the more generic term until US Navstar-GPS became such the default that it aquired the generic term. And eventually dropped the Navstar, officially.

Sort of a reverse Xerox/Google/Velcro situation.

beerandt··on Using GPS satellites to detect tsunamis via ionospheric ionization waves
GPS was originally NAVSTAR or Navstar-GPS (names helped, going back to when LORAN was state of the art and other competing dod navigation systems were being developed, like the Navy's TRANSIT sats).

But lots of old school pros like surveyors will still refer to it as 'Navstar', which has resurged with the introduction of competing GNSS systems from other countries. Especially if you want to avoid the GPS/GNSS confusion.

There's debate about whether NAVSTAR itself was ever an acronym/backroom, or just a name.

"NAVigation System using Timing And Ranging"

beerandt··on Users say T-Mobile must pay for killing "lifetime" price lock
Yea it should cost more to break the contract than to honor it.
beerandt··on Can SpaceX land a rocket with 1/2 cm accuracy?
Rtk already is 'relative' error- it requires one or more base stations (with either known absolute location or assumed one for relative positioning).

But survey grade gnss is a web of rabbit holes, if you want to get into it.

And there are ways to get sub mm accuracy both relative and absolute, but idk of one that would be quick enough for the required reaction time of dynamic landing via 'catching'.

But multi-centimeter (4-5) that's really easily doable is probably good enough for other systems to take over from.

beerandt··on Software engineer titles have almost lost all their meaning
That, but more to the point, the value of the term is based on the strong history of regulation and common use, which SWEs as an industry have taken advantage of and diminished.

Which, I get that not everyone agrees on licensing law and philosophy, but it should at least signify mastery of the topic via formal education or apprenticeship.

Most PEs have both of those, engineering degree and licensing internship.

How many SWEs have either? I honestly don't know.

If you don't have either, you are at best senior technician, which should be respectable enough, but for title inflation.

beerandt··on How Waffle House helps Southerners and FEMA judge a storm's severity
Because 1) it's standardized beyond local / state political footprint, and

2) it's measuring basic availability of resources like water, electricity, natural gas, but also availability of food items like eggs, meat, bread. Plus labor.

And 3) in extreme cases, whether the (relatively uniform) building still stands and is occupied/usable.

beerandt··on Hacking Kia: Remotely controlling cars with just a license plate
I'm sorry you never got the chance to live in a high-trust area.

A lot harder to find one now.

beerandt··on Hacking Kia: Remotely controlling cars with just a license plate
The problem isn't that we need better locks, but that we need locks at all.

Within my lifetime we've gone from leaving the backdoor unlocked at night and leaving the car keys on the seat (or in the ignition) from being the normal practice to being unthinkable.

You're focusing on the wrong govt policies.

beerandt··on I have 2000 old VHS tapes in my garage and don't know what to do with them
Tapes especially got recorded over.
beerandt··on End of an era: Landsat 7 mission takes final images
Because you set a min life, but statistics aside, the design for that minimum life isn't usually something that can be tweaked on a continuous scale, but ends up being binned by design constraints.

Eg, you need an industrial road with a 5-year lifespan over a swamp. To meet this minimum you actually have to build a bridge, which when built to industry standards, might start at lifespans of 20-30 yrs.

Space is a bit different because of budgeting for ongoing operations, so you frontload the cap-x, knowing that asking for addl op-x funds later to extend the program will seem like a no-brainer deal.

Plus sometimes it's as simple as: if you design something to statistically survive space launch, it results in something that is overdesigned to just sit in orbit for years (given that it survives that initial launch).

It's similar to human lifespan statistics- if you get over the historical infant mortality hump, every adult seems 'overdesigned' compared to the historical expected lifespan.

beerandt··on WordPress.org bans WP Engine
Yea- same point though. Bad IP advice / strategy.

Don't condone confusing ip policy if you don't want to end up with confusing product names, especially in a resurgence of 'the domain name is the product' of unlimited tlds.

beerandt··on WordPress.org bans WP Engine
The whole standard for trademark law is whether it causes confusion in commerce.

Sounds like they might have a not-great ip lawyer.

Your don't have to claim WP to claim it's being marketed as an abbreviation for your trademark, within your market.

I'm not saying it's a winning argument, but better than whatever the legal framing/ posturing of 'WP isn't our TM' is. Bad PR, if not bad legal take.

beerandt··on DoNotPay has to pay $193K for falsely touting untested AI lawyer, FTC says
Has the chance to make their best marketing material yet.
beerandt··on Hack GPON – how to access, change and edit fibre ONTs
I mean you're right in general- but we're talking about a subset of customers that want to mess with their own fiber connection.

That's either a horde that understands the issue, or is an even smaller subset that is going to be a pita anyway.

beerandt··on Teenager jailed for 18 months still in prison 18 years later
Yea sorry everything was coming up zero because they didn't submit supplemental data, so all filters based on that data (including age and other demographics) come back as zero.

Which is not the way 'nodata' should be returned.

But the point stands- eg Jackson ms didn't submit this year. So your get a 'state total' that doesn't include the majority of the data for the state.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →