HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ben0x539

4,454 karma · joined September 23, 2010

submissionscomments
ben0x539··on Unchecked Java: Say goodbye to checked exceptions
Whoa, I've been having opinions about error handling and result types and checked exceptions for like years and I never considered that Java couldn't be "properly" polymorphic over checked exception types. Thanks for pointing that out.
ben0x539··on Displayport: A Better Video Interface
As a habitual comments skimmer, thanks for selling me on the article. :)
ben0x539··on Linux has achieved a 3% desktop market share
Yeah I admit at this point in my life, much like I used to start up the SNES to play Zelda back in my parents' living room, I start up my Windows system to play Monster Hunter or whatever, while trying really hard to ignore the whole desktop thing on that system.
ben0x539··on Linux has achieved a 3% desktop market share
> I'm trying really hard to come up with a scenario where optimizing the desktop experience for the average user is a bad thing.

Again, maybe I'm a sore loser, but it definitely feels like a lot of software is becoming increasingly hostile to me, personally because it's being optimized for a presumed average user. I have no beef with this average user and it's globally a totally correct optimization to make stuff work for them as well as possible, but it means that software makes tradeoffs that are inconvenient for me personally.

The most common use case is streamlined by removing options that clutter up the settings menu or banishing the buttons I press a lot into some tertiary menu, or niche features I rely on become unsupported and then get removed (of course with forced auto-updates, because the average user experience is improved by them) to free up developer bandwidth for the core features. And then I end up using a different off-brand window manager with the serial numbers filed off that barely works in general, but works for my specific 'workflow" exactly like I want it.

Of course, at the same time I also benefit from general improvements targeting the average user. It's only about the tradeoffs.

ben0x539··on Linux has achieved a 3% desktop market share
It also helps that there have been very few important (big, complicated) applications in the past decade or two. Firefox is there? My development environment is there? I'm probably good.
ben0x539··on Linux has achieved a 3% desktop market share
ok maybe i'm a sore loser, but looking at where the popular desktop OSes have been going going i think i'm fine with linux remaining an enthusiast thing
ben0x539··on Tumblr’s core product strategy
> So paid social networks just can't work, because a "free with ads" service will trivially outcompete it before it starts to visibly rot.

The "free with ads" service will "outcompete" by immediately being in basically-infinite debt, right? Is that really still "competing"?

ben0x539··on Tumblr’s core product strategy
Everybody website is trying to pivot to doing what tiktok is good at, instead of what they were good at. Most websites are probably not going to eat tiktok's userbase.

I guess we can't have nice things because what those websites are traditionally good at isn't profitable. I can't really be surprised that monetizing tumblr proves challenging, when it seems to consist of like half starving artists, half anti-capitalist shitposters, and half young adults talking about fanfic. I remember monetizing blogging being a running joke on the site over a decade ago, and I can't imagine it's gotten easier with, you know, the economic situation impacting those demographics.

ben0x539··on Threads has passed 2M sign ups in the first 2 hours
The way Twitter verification used to work and why was of any value to other users was that, if your twitter name was, idk, the name of an important politician or company, the blue checkmark meant that someone at twitter took some amount of care to check that you're actually that politician or company. Like, "verified" meant that twitter verfied their identity, tying the twitter account to some sort of external credentials. You used to know that you're talking to the actual company support team or whatever.

Now it just means someone paid some amount of money. They're "verified" in the sense of like verifying the email address you used to sign up with to an olde timey web forum, and maybe that you're probably not an absolutely minimum effort spam/scam bot. However the "verified" checkmark is still basically useless because it doesn't verify an identity or credentials anymore, and it's easy enough for bad actors to get the checkmark to then impersonate some brand or website or whatever, and have their posts get privileged by The Algorithm.

So, previously "verified" status was useful for people to be able to tell that the posts they're reading are really from who they think they're from. Now, "verified" status means that bad actors and bad posters get their posts boosted ahead of normal posts, so the replies to any mildly popular thread are going to be full of attempted scams and tepid takes. It's become completely useless for its original purpose and makes content discovery worse.

ben0x539··on Threads.net
Someone at Facebook hates concurrent programming and is aiming to do for threads what Stack Overflow did for google searches for info about stack overflows.
ben0x539··on Github.com is down
Ah, I read step 3 as "a bunch of data gets condensed into one public indicator" rather than "a bunch of data gets published"
ben0x539··on Github.com is down
I figure plenty of people wouldn't really mind if you left out the decentralized part specifically, but I assumed a bunch of nice things about git are there because they were basically required for a decent decentralized workflow.
ben0x539··on Github.com is down
Previous job had a locally hosted Github Enterprise and I was always resentful when everybody else on Twitter was like "github down! going home early!". :(

Of course it still sucked when some tool decided I needed to update dependencies which all lived on regular Github, but at least our deployment stuff etc still worked.

ben0x539··on Github.com is down
> At that point it's worse than what you already know from your browser - it may show the service is having issues when you can access it, or that the service is ok when you can't.

Worst case you have more data points to draw conclusions from. Status page red, works for me? Hmm, maybe that's why the engineers in the other office are goofing off on Slack. Status page green, I get HTTP 500s? Guess I can't do this thing but maybe other parts of the app still work?

ben0x539··on Github.com is down
I think as an external user I'd be happiest if they just provided multiple indicators on the status page? Like,

    Internal metrics: Healthy
    External status check: Healthy
    Did ops announce an incident: No
    Backend API latency: )`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_)`'-.,_
And when there's disagreement between indicators I can draw my own conclusions.

I guess in reality the very existence of a status page is a tenuous compromise between engineers wanting to be helpful towards external engineers, and business interests who would prefer to sweep things under various rugs as much as possible ("what's the point of a website whose entire point is to tell the world that we're currently fucking up?").

ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
My view is that the design of this site, targeted at niche users, is not alienating because it is designed by people from the same niche. It's great for that purpose much like niche tools like git or whatever are for people in the right niche, but I don't think you can apply this strategy when designing something that needs to have mass appeal for its business model to work.

The success of this website is that it doesn't have to be successful along the same metrics as substack or reddit or tiktok to fulfill its purpose.

ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
That's honestly great to hear. I've not been super convinced of the way I've seen AB tests used to justify decisions but I figured it's just me not liking the results, and that the prevalence of shitty websites means that the businesses with good websites are just not competitive and disappear.
ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
> Not having some indication is worse than it flashing.

I figure it's more that there's no one-size-fits-all thing. "Normally", that isn't a problem, because you just switch to another program that suits your preferences/takes good care of your brainworms. It just becomes frustrating when companies tie their services to uncustomizable programs (like for instance a website) narrowly designed for their archetypical user persona.

... but beyond that there has to be a better way to do this?? Surely this particular thing has been designed to death a million times. I think with Google Docs, I get to assume everything is saved all the time, so this is the default state that doesn't need to take up space on the screen. In the risky situation where I alt-f4 before the save call returned success or whatever, I get the javascript popup telling me stuff wasn't saved and I can cancel and wait a few seconds. In the other risky situation where the save call just keeps failing for a prolonged amount of time (because my wifi died, usually), I think it says that somewhere in the UI, and it seems like a good enough justification to grab attention to me.

ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
Yeah so you put in the address of the author or site owner or something, standard procedure.
ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
I fear the wider, wider problem is that hubris pays off, it's not economically optimal for most sites to show this humility you'd like to see. Someone decided it's worth it to annoy us grumpy nerds in order to sell fractionally more stuff to the statistically average user.

I don't think apps/sites are getting worse about this, it's that they're getting better at optimizing for users who aren't me. It's probably just deeply frustrating/alienating to have to use products that you're not the target audience for (and that's increasingly almost all products).

(To be clear this isn't meant as derision of the 'statistically average user', it's perfectly justified that not everything is built to suit me, the protagonist of reality.)

ben0x539··on Flashing elements alienate users
It doesn't have any flashing elements until you click the thing, that's probably what counts.
ben0x539··on All IP addresses are equal? “Dot-zero” addresses are less equal (2013)
It's "popular" in that it's widely deployed, but I think it's fairly unpopular in that people really don't enjoy operating it. When I worked for a high traffic website, I was told people would occasionally reach out like "hey can we just ipv6-peer with y'all so our users don't have to talk to you over our cgnat. it's putting a ton of load on the cgnat gateway".
ben0x539··on Try: run a command and inspect its effects before changing your live system
I agree that there should be universal undo, but I think by contrast the (informally) transactionality of the "try" model can be a big deal if your system is concurrent.

If you do a thing, find out it isn't what you wanted, and then undo it, while at the same some other process is observing the mutated state, that's potentially a much trickier mental model. If you undo a configuration change and in the meantime a background process has acted on the new configuration, how do you roll that back? Rewinding the timeline is one thing, but maybe throwing out all the work that happened with the wrong configuration is even worse than the status quo.

From the top of my head I am thinking about accidentally changing retention windows or bash history max size where the data loss is super indirect and you'd have to hunt down the undo button for a completely different process, or changing a log format so you end up with a file that's mixed json and plain text logs.

(Of course, "try" presumably applying the changes in a completely synthetic way after the fact could be its entire own can of worms in a very dynamic system if there's a risk changes are applied in the wrong order or skipping some atomicity dance.)

ben0x539··on The C Standard Library Function Isspace() Depends on Locale
Well, sometimes the users ask to see them and they don't like numbers very much.
ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
That's fair. I figure a lot of the same design pressures apply though, and of course there's a cost to diverging from what the rest of the world is doing.
ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
Yeah, until you're trying to install something that uses OpenGL. :)
ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
I imagine at some point people were like "is it more work to investigate this (and similar future questions) or switch to shipping AppImages instead". :(
ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
Yeah, in general, things work out nicely. :) I figure this genre of post and the post it's responding to are mostly about exceptions.

My impression is that exceptions become more and more prevalent as (app?) development practices diverge from the workflow that distros have spent decades optimizing their processes for (ie., apps are developed with package managers that don't map well to distro packaging).

ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
I'm responding to a comment that expects app developers to make do with a specific version of a library. That expectation seems to be in line with that in the post that TFA responds to, which is unsurprisingly addressed in TFA.

There's a lot of "it's not that hard"s in that post. Of course we all prefer software that just works after being installed with the distro package manager. I don't want to install a container runtime to run grep or netcat or whatever. Meanwhile app developers have to balance their own priorities, it gets complicated, and, I guess increasingly often, "ship X feature to Flatpak users" wins over "make the lives of users/maintainers of Fedora easier". It's just another tradeoff, and sometimes the cost of making do with one version of a library isn't worth it.

ben0x539··on Response to “Developers are lazy, thus Flatpak”
It's a lot, but I think we've lost that battle and society has collectively decided it's okay to sacrifice untold amounts of storage space in service of things like more stable installations, extra features, etc. It's aesthetically displeasing to install a 10 GB text editor or whatever but I don't think it's generally ideal in application development to optimize for very limited storage on phones either, especially with phone storage presumably just growing bigger over time too.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →