HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bengillies

456 karma · joined May 6, 2011

http://bengillies.net
submissionscomments
bengillies··on A New Look for Facebook
I believe it falls under the Association fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy).

The assumption is that because both designs share a common attribute they are both intended for the same purpose and therefore if one design is bad for a particular reason, the other design must also be bad for the exact same reason.

This isn't necessarily true with Pinterest, which has a different purpose to Facebook, and therefore likely requires a different UI.

bengillies··on Effective JavaScript Reviewed
If you're using a library that stitches together multiple JavaScript files - all of which work when included via separate script tags - and the resultant file doesn't work (due to the issue mentioned in TFA at least), then that's a bug in the library that stitches multiple JavaScript files together, and should be fixed there.

Adding a semicolon to the start of your IIFE doesn't really hurt, but it's a workaround more than a solution.

bengillies··on Effective JavaScript Reviewed
I think more that the bug is in the code that's doing the wrapping, and therefore the fix should also be in the code doing the wrapping, and not in the code being wrapped.
bengillies··on Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes
It's cool and all but, if it's not included in the box it's not a feature. It's an optional extra.
bengillies··on JavaScript: Function Invocation Patterns
Exactly. Stuff that's built directly into the language isn't a pattern, it's a feature (perhaps a wart in this case). From Wikipedia [1]:

In software engineering, a design pattern is a general reusable solution to a commonly occurring problem within a given context in software design. A design pattern is not a finished design that can be transformed directly into source or machine code. It is a description or template for how to solve a problem that can be used in many different situations. Patterns are formalized best practices that the programmer must implement themselves in the application.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_design_pattern

bengillies··on Rsvp.js
Hmm, didn't know that, thanks. I suppose if you really wanted to you could add a test to see if postMessage was async or not...
bengillies··on Dart is ready for the real world
From what I've seen of both, TypeScript seems like the language that Google should have created in the first place. It has similar goals, but without the "let's create a whole new VM and replace the entire JacaScript runtime in all browsers" ambition (which is ridiculous).
bengillies··on Rsvp.js
Not having tested it personally I can't say, but I'd imagine it's a lot faster.

I'd be more interested in how it compares to using postMessage which, from testing, is definitely a lot faster than setTimeout (like fast enough to be worth switching to if available).

bengillies··on Why I think Node.JS is a terrible platform
> Node.js is async for people who don't actually know what they're doing

"Node.js is rubbish and if you like it and try to argue otherwise then, as I've already said, you don't know what you're doing so I can just ignore you."

Clever.

bengillies··on Here’s to the Misfits
Here's to the Misfits?

Here's to the people who fit in. Here's to the people who try really hard but never quite get there. Here's to the people who don't fit in but always wanted to. Here's to the people who do the dirty jobs cos they they pay the bills and no-one else wants to. Here's to the underdog. Here's to the loser. Here's to the person who actually finishes their degree. Here's to the 50 year old who's still innovating. Here's to the 25 year old who isn't.

Different people are different. Let's celebrate all of them not just the chosen few from the subgroup we've marked out as "special" this year.

bengillies··on An iPad Lover’s Take On The Nexus 7
You're probably correct but then, why judge the Android OS as a whole based on the fact that there are a few rubbish devices out that run it?
bengillies··on An iPad Lover’s Take On The Nexus 7
I know I'm not supposed to feed trolls, but:

> Android is inferior to iOS. > > But that's the point of Android.

The point of Android is to be not as good as iOS? Really? That's the point of Android?

Do you make the claim that all cars are rubbish just because some companies make rubbish cars? No. Different cars are different. Obviously. So it is with Android devices.

If one Android device is on a par with the new iPad (or at least in the same ballpark according to MG Siegler) then please judge that device based solely on that device, not on other devices that are similar in OS name only (not even version).

If you're comparing iOS to the full spectrum of Android devices out there, then please compare the full spectrum of iOS devices out there as well, including the iPhone 3GS which is, in this day and age, a POS cheapo smartphone (compared to top of the range Android phones at least).

bengillies··on Armchair scientists
Sometimes though, it is enough just to criticise. Sometimes it's someone else's job to make things right and to listen to other people who may not be able to spend the time and effort on getting stuck in and doing it themselves. Sometimes that person isn't even capable of joining in, due to factors outside their control (it's a closed insular corporation for example).

And sometimes, the people dealing with the problem are only taking the approach that they're taking because they're tackling the problem from within a particular organisation that has its own related set of problems that affect its take on the solution. And in such cases, the best solution is sometimes not the one that's open to that organisation, so they take a different (less good) path. The best solution may even be one that destroys the organisation involved, and it may be really obvious.

If nobody is allowed to criticise anything that they're not actively involved in trying to fix, the world would be a very boring place (and Government would have a very easy job).

bengillies··on AirBnb's new site design
It loaded for me in ~30 seconds on a 2011 Macbook Pro. I don't see what your loading experience has to do with anything. Different people have different connection speeds in different parts of the world (my connection speed varies within the same building depending on congestion, etc).

That said, all the fancy pictures do look very nice, and certainly draw you in like no other travel site that I've come across (when it eventually loads).

bengillies··on Introducing The New IFTTT
I'd be a _lot_ more excited by the update if I could add my own custom channels for less popular sites, or use other custom channels that other people have added.
bengillies··on Jeremy Ashkenas hates cross-browser consistency
If what you want is cross browser consistency of sparse arrays (that is, if you _really_ want to use them), then you should probably use ES5-shim or something instead.

Jeremy Ashkenas can support or not support whichever parts of built-in array behaviour he wants, given that:

a) It's his library b) It doesn't try and copy the standard ES5 API anyway

bengillies··on Smart people don't think others are stupid
> I think a truly "smart person" is someone who is always staying open to the possibility of people changing radically, however unlikely that may seem.

But a truly "person who is currently acting smart" may realise that they simply do not have the time to continue treating this "person who is currently acting stupid" as if they're simply acting that way, and may make a temporary value judgement about that person fully in the knowledge that it's an over-simplification and useful only in the present situation. Doing so may also be a smart thing to do, as it allows said person to actually get something done.

bengillies··on Please Don't Become Anything, Especially Not A Programmer
You realise that you're not supposed to reply at all to your own thread if you're trolling right?
bengillies··on Please don't learn to code
> Programming is logical thinking in practise. Programming is breaking a problem set down, thinking step by step through it, thinking of edge cases, and making it work.

If the benefit of everyone learning programming is logical/critical thinking, breaking a problem down and thinking of edge cases, etc, then why not focus on teaching everyone how to do that instead?

A good way of doing that may very well be teaching some form of programming, but unless you explicitly state the goals up front a lot of people are very likely to miss the point completely and either teach just programming, or learn just how to code.

bengillies··on Brendan Eich: The infernal semicolon
FWIW the GitHub JavaScript style guide also recommends that you don't write JavaScript _at all_, unless you can't help it.
bengillies··on Hit Shift key 4x on a NYTimes article and see what happens
I believe the original name for them is Purple Numbers[1], though as Dave Winer mentions, the NYTs implementation doesn't appear to create the links properly.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purple_Numbers

bengillies··on Google introduces Dart, a new programming language for web applications
To a point, JavaScript already has type inference: https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/es-discuss/2011-September...
bengillies··on A review of all available Hacker News iPad Apps
Just curious, but what's wrong with the web version, viewed through Safari?

Or failing that, something like Flipboard?

bengillies··on Facebook Timeline
> Where's the line?

Apparently, it's wherever Facebook decides it is.

bengillies··on Why UK startups should stop trying to be US startups
Sure, but he makes no attempt to define what this "UK culture" they all need to adopt is (bar stating that The Beatles were popular and that Motley Crew were more like Motley Crew than a band that wasn't Motley Crew).

American culture's been slowly infiltrating the UK for decades (I don't have a problem with that), why should a particular group of people suddenly start rejecting it?

bengillies··on Cutting the Gordian Knot of Web Identity
I think he's assuming that browsers defer password storage to some sort of cloud-based password storage service (presumably of your choosing). Hence the mention of needing to trust the cloud.
bengillies··on Why every programmer should have a Tiddlywiki
Not in the near future no. In the far future, it depends on how the new filesystem api turns out. There are some thoughts going on about using node for such things, though they are only that (thoughts) at the moment.
bengillies··on Why every programmer should have a Tiddlywiki
Hi, I'm a developer on TiddlyWiki.

I'm not sure if this is the done thing or not (I'm relatively new to posting on Hacker News so apologies if not) but if anyone wants an online version of TiddlyWiki (that handles revisions, multiple users, has a RESTful API, etc), then we're currently working on a service called TiddlySpace (http://tiddlyspace.com), which is basically an extensible online note taking app based on TiddlyWiki. It's on GitHub too.

bengillies··on Wagn: a new breed of wiki
It looks remarkably similar to TiddlyWiki (http://tiddlywiki.com). Any influence there or...

(Disclaimer: I work for Osmosoft (who make TiddlyWiki))

← PreviousPage 5 of 5