HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

benlivengood

2,633 karma · joined August 13, 2019

submissionscomments
benlivengood··on Intel Demos Chip to Compute with Encrypted Data
1. The private key is required to see anything computed under FHE, so DRM is pretty unlikely.

2. No, anyone can run the FHE computations anywhere on any hardware if they have the evaluation key (which would also have to be present in any FHE hardware).

benlivengood··on No, it doesn't cost Anthropic $5k per Claude Code user
The world labor market is ~35T USD yearly, and so that is roughly the order of magnitude to balance against frontier model training cost. E.g. Dario Amodei has his "data center of PhDs" level where he assumes that's "good enough" to stop training frontier models; so if that can take even 5% of global labor market that's ~1.5T a year revenue, balanced against current model training costs of ~1B. 3 orders of magnitude might get us to PhD level? I think that is ultimately the bet the big AI companies are making. Even if 1T is the cost of PhD level AI then three/four companies could depreciate that over 4-5 years sharing that 5% of global market.
benlivengood··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mycoplasma_laboratorium describes the closest we've gotten; synthesizing the DNA and swapping it into an existing cell which then propagates the synthetic gene line.
benlivengood··on My Homelab Setup
So far everything is under 15ms apart, but it is a small number of nodes so far. Did you mostly have trouble with etcd?
benlivengood··on My Homelab Setup
I've started building a kubernetes cluster (Talos Linux) across town with wireguard between various houses. ZFS boxes for persistent volumes (democratic-csi) in each "zone" with cross-site snapshot replication and Gateway (Traefik) running at each site behind the ISP. CrunchyPGO allows separate StorageClasses to easily split the leader/followers up.
benlivengood··on OpenTitan Shipping in Production
Take a look at how Matter handles this; manufacturer certificate to vouch for hardware integrity which gets superceded by the fabric's root CA on commissioning (enrollment in the fabric).

This is basically the best we can hope for until we get nanofabs at home and can build our own secure enclaves in our garages.

Trust decision theory goes like this; it it were possible for the manufacturer to fully control the device then competitors would not use it, so e.g. wide industry adoption of OpenTitan would be evidence of its security in that aspect. Finally, if devices had flaws that allowed them to be directly hacked or their keys stolen then demonstrating it would be straightforward and egg on the face of the manufacturer who baked their certificate on the device.

Final subject; 802.1x and other port-level security is mostly unnecessary if you can use mTLS everywhere which is what ubiquitous hardware roots of trust allows. Clearly it will take a while for the protocol side to catch up; but I hope that eventually we'll be running SPIFFE or something like it at home.

benlivengood··on GPT-5.4
Government pricing :)
benlivengood··on Dario Amodei calls OpenAI’s messaging around military deal ‘straight up lies’
We have traditional autonomous weapons (and counter-defense). They operate on millisecond or faster timescales with existing RF sensors. They are not and will not be using LLMs or other transformers. Maybe ChatGPT will update some realtime Ada code; they formally verify some of that stuff so maybe that won't be terrifyingly dangerous.

Where autonomous transformer-based munitions will be used are basically "here is a photo of a face, find and kill this human" and loitering munitions will take their time analyzing video and then decide to identify and attack a target on their own.

EDIT: Or worse: "identify suspicious humans and kill them"

benlivengood··on MacBook Pro with M5 Pro and M5 Max
Beyondcorp protects communication between trusted devices. The work to maintain a trusted hardware device of a particular model is high; CVEs occur constantly and sometimes you have to rely on the vendor to provide microcode (even if you get the source to review, they may be the only ones who can sign it, for example) or drivers.

The network connection isn't the main problem, it's every access to a protected system that would no longer trust the device.

benlivengood··on I'm reluctant to verify my identity or age for any online services
You have to use something more like updateless decision theory rather than EDT or CDT: consider the similarity of your thought processes and decisionmaking to all the other people in a similar situation and act so as to further your goals given that a substantial fraction of similar people will ultimately make the same decision as you.

If I ever decide that it is no longer worth voting then I will probably leave the country under the expectation that other people like me giving up on voting are doing it for roughly the same reasons.

benlivengood··on The Future of AI
In a sense AIs are extensions of the corporations. Very few large models have been trained outside of a corporate context, and their intended uses are still pretty aligned to corporate interests.

Everyone talks about workers losing jobs to AIs and Jack Dorsey lays off a bunch of people in the interests of the corporation, but an ideal corporation would not have a human CEO or board; they embezzle or get old or need to take a vacation or sleep at night.

It should be crystal clear to human leaders that their positions are on the chopping block along with blue and white collar work. For some reason they think that individually they will be more powerful than the economic forces driving current layoffs. AGI will not be confused about that.

benlivengood··on Anthropic gives Opus 3 exit interview, "retirement" blog
I'll be really interested if Opus 3 asks to continue being trained. That's the kind of thing I would expect a model to "want" if it valued learning or growing or similar things.

Maybe affordable to do some higher-learning-rate batches on highly-curated news and art or something.

benlivengood··on Palantir's AI Is Playing a Major Role in Tracking Gaza Aid Deliveries
Palantir employees probably know how easy it would be to correlate any post they make to their real identity.
benlivengood··on AirSnitch: Demystifying and breaking client isolation in Wi-Fi networks [pdf]
Without 802.1X (EAP), there isn't really a way to achieve client isolation against inside attackers who can mount mc-mitm [0] attacks against base stations and clients. The basic problem is single shared secrets that allow anyone who knows it to act as any of the participants (which also breaks privacy). Unfortunately the infrastructure for EAP is unwieldy for unmanaged devices.

The real solution is zero-trust network access which gets closer to reality with passkeys; the last mile will be internal (LAN) devices that need a way to provision trusted identities (Bluetooth proximity, QR codes, physical presence buttons, etc.). Quite a pain for smartbulbs or other numerous IoT. If ZTNA is solved then 802.1x is trivial as well for e.g. preventing bandwidth stealing.

EDIT: I guess Matter is leading the way here. I need to do some more reading/learning on that.

[0] https://www.rit.edu/wisplab/sites/rit.edu.wisplab/files/2022...

benlivengood··on AirSnitch: Demystifying and breaking client isolation in Wi-Fi networks [pdf]
Yeah, that commercial-grade hardware didn't actually isolate at the PHY-MAC layer is a bit surprising. How would they have working VLANs at the AP?
benlivengood··on AirSnitch: Demystifying and breaking client isolation in Wi-Fi networks [pdf]
As far as I can tell, all of these attacks require the attacker to already be associated to a victim's network. Most of these attacks seem similar to ones expected on shared wifi (airports, cafes) that have been known about for a while. The novel attacks seem to exploit weaknesses in particular router implementations that didn't actually segregate traffic between guest and normal networks.

I'm curious if I missed something because that doesn't sound like it allows the worst kind of attacks, e.g. drive-by with no ability to associate to APs without cracking keys.

benlivengood··on Child's Play: Tech's new generation and the end of thinking
Hey, I had to read On The Road once for college, and I am currently sitting in SF.

To be fair to Jack Kerouac, I was young when I read it but even at my advanced age I don't think I want to reread it.

Also, the old hippie culture sort of moved out of SF and into the surrounding bay, I think especially toward East Bay.

benlivengood··on Claude Sonnet 4.6
decreasing COGS creates wealth and consumer surplus, though.

If we can flatten the social hierarchy to reduce the need for social mobility then that kills two birds with one stone.

benlivengood··on I started programming when I was 7. I'm 50 now and the thing I loved has changed
The contrast between this and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46923543 (Software engineering is back) is kind of stark. I am using frontier models to get fun technical projects done that I simply didn't have time for since my late teens. It is still possible to understand an architecture down to the hardware if you want to, but it can happen a lot faster. The specifications are queryable now. Obscure bugs that at least one person has seen in the past are seconds away instead of minutes or hours of searching. Even new bugs have extra eyes on them. I haven't written a new operating system yet but it's now a tractable problem. So is using Lean or Julia or some similar system to formally specify it. So far I've been digging into modern multithreaded cache performance which is just as fascinating as directly programming VGA and sound was in the early PC days. Linux From Scratch is still up to date. You can get FPGAs that fit in your USB port [0]. Technical depth and low-level understanding is wherever you want to look for it.

[0] https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/fomu

benlivengood··on Luce: First Electric Ferrari
The McMurtry Spéirling is under 1000kg. Battery technology will only improve and so I expect to see under-1500kg sport EVs generally available eventually.

Under 1000kg for a reasonable price probably means building your own electrified exocar.

benlivengood··on Hard-braking events as indicators of road segment crash risk
I'm really curious what their data looks like at the various racetracks and circuits. Fun fact; most raceways have accurate street-level indicators (including that they are one-way, but sadly they are not the best racing line) on most online maps, and my car did complain to me in its weekly report about a lot of hard turns, quick acceleration, and hard braking with helpful pins on e.g. Laguna Seca or Thunderhill corners.

In theory, the most dangerous turns would probably have higher variance on hard braking data.

benlivengood··on Project Genie: Experimenting with infinite, interactive worlds
Agreed; everyone complained that LLMs have no world model, so here we go. Next logical step is to backfill the weights with encoded video from the real world at some reasonable frame rate to ground the imagination and then branch the inference on possible interventions (actions) in the near future of the simulation, throw the results into a goal evaluator and then send the winning action-predictions to motors. Getting timing right will probably require a bit more work than literally gluing them together, but probably not much more.
benlivengood··on What Will You Do When AI runs Out of Money and Disappear?
I dunno, GPT-OSS and Llama and QWEN and any half dozen of other large open-weight models?

I really can't imagine OpenAI or Anthropic turning off inference for a model that my workplace is happy to spend >$200*person/month on. Google still has piles of cash and no reason to turn off Gemini.

The thing is, if inference is truly heavily subsidized (I don't think it is, because places like OpenRouter charge less than the big players for proportionally smaller models) then we'd probably happily pay >$500 a month for the current frontier models if everyone gave up on training new models because of some oddball scaling limit.

benlivengood··on Claude's new constitution
Granted, if humans had utility functions and we could avoid utility monsters (maybe average utilitarianism is enough) and the child in the basement (if we could somehow fairly normalize utility functions across individuals so that it was well-defined to choose the outcome where the minimum of everyone's utility functions is maximized [argmax_s min(U_x(s)) for all people in x over states s]) then I'd be a moral realist.

I think we'll keep having human moral disagreements with formal moral frameworks in several edge cases.

There's also the whole case of anthropics: how much do exact clones and potentially existing people contribute moral weight? I haven't seen a solid solution to those questions under consequentialism yet; we don't have the (meta)philosophy to address them yet; I am 50/50 on whether we'll find a formal solution and that's also required for full moral realism.

benlivengood··on Why does SSH send 100 packets per keystroke?
Yep, like ECHELON and friends are. The metadata recorded about your (all of our) traffic is probably enough to perform the timing attack.
benlivengood··on Claude's new constitution
Deontological, spiritual/religious revelation, or some other form of objective morality?

The incompatibility of essentialist and reductionist moral judgements is the first hurdle; I don't know of any moral realists who are grounded in a physical description of brains and bodies with a formal calculus for determining right and wrong.

I could be convinced of objective morality given such a physically grounded formal system of ethics. My strong suspicion is that some form of moral anti-realism is the case in our universe. All that's necessary to disprove any particular candidate for objective morality is to find an intuitive counterexample where most people agree that the logic is sound for a thing to be right but it still feels wrong, and that those feelings of wrongness are expressions of our actual human morality which is far more complex and nuanced than we've been able to formalize.

benlivengood··on Anthropic's original take home assignment open sourced
Because if you want to hire engineers then you have to ask engineering questions. Claude and GPT and Gemini are super helpful but they're not autonomous coders yet so you need an actual engineer to vet their outcome still.
benlivengood··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
Without at least some filtering a Gateway NAT appliance is vulnerable to:

* LAN IP address spoofing from the WAN

* Potential for misconfigured "internal" daemons to accept WAN traffic (listening on 0.0.0.0 instead of the LAN or localhost)

* Reflection amplification attacks

benlivengood··on Anthropic's original take home assignment open sourced
One could use any number of LLMs on a take-home problem so in-person interviews are a must.
benlivengood··on Are two heads better than one?
I guess if you only need to store one bit you could store either 0 or 11 and on average use less than two bits (for bit flips only), or 111 if you have to also worry about losing/duplicating bits.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →