HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

benlivengood

2,633 karma · joined August 13, 2019

submissionscomments
benlivengood··on Non-Zero-Sum Games
With an optimal way of determining fair splitting of gains like Shapley value[0] you can cooperate or defect with a probability that maximizes other participants expected value when everyone act fairly.

The ultimatum game is the simplest example; N dollars of prize to split, N/2 is fair, accept with probability M / (N /2) where M is what's offered to you; the opponents maximum expected value comes from offering N/2; trying to offer less (or more) results in expected value to them < N/2.

Trust can be built out of clearly describing how you'll respond in your own best interests in ways that achieve fairness, e.g. assuming the other parties will understand the concept of fairness and also act to maximize their expected value given their knowledge of how you will act.

If you want to solve logically harder problems like one-shot prisoners dilemma, there are preliminary theories for how that can be done by proving things about the other participants directly. It won't work for humans, but maybe artificial agents. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1401.5577

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapley_value

benlivengood··on Ask HN: What did you read in 2025?
Don't finish; read a good summary if you cared about any character or plot point sufficiently.

I enjoyed it overall but in large part for the detail/immersion which it sounds like wasn't interesting enough to keep you.

All character growth and relationships were very slow burns, and so if you enjoy watching the same characters just dealing with things as they come up then you'd probably enjoy the other books as much as the first three. Satisfying arc resolution happens almost entirely at the end.

benlivengood··on LLMs Are Not Fun
Transformers grew out of the value-add side (autotranslation), though, not really the ad business side iirc. Value-add work still gets done in high-progressive-tax societies if it's valuable to a large fraction of people. Research into luxury goods is slowed by progressive tax rates, but the actual border between consumer and luxury goods actually rises a bit with redistributed wealth; more people can afford smartphones earlier and almost no one buys superyachts and so reinvestment into general technology research may actually be higher.
benlivengood··on Huge Binaries
At Google I worked with one statistics aggregation binary[0] that was ~25GB stripped. The distributed build system wouldn't even build the debug version because it exceeded the maximum configured size for any object file. I never asked if anyone had tried factoring it into separate pipelines but my intuition is that the extra processing overhead wouldn't have been worth splitting the business logic that way; once the exact set of necessary input logs are in memory you might as well do everything you need to them given the dramatically larger ratio of data size to code size.

[0] https://research.google/pubs/ubiq-a-scalable-and-fault-toler...

benlivengood··on LLMs Are Not Fun
In the long run I think it's pretty unhealthy to make one's career a large part of one's identity. What happens during burnout or retirement or being laid off if a huge portion of one's self depends on career work?

Economically it's been a mistake to let wealth get stratified so unequally; we should have and need to reintroduce high progressive tax rates on income and potentially implement wealth taxes to reduce the necessity of guessing a high-paying career over 5 years in advance. That simply won't be possible to do accurately with coming automation. But it is possible to grow social safety nets and decrease wealth disparity so that pursuing any marginally productive career is sufficient.

Practically, once automation begins producing more value than 25% or so of human workers we'll have to transition to a collective ownership model and either pay dividends directly out of widget production, grant futures on the same with subsidized transport, or UBI. I tend to prefer a distribution-of-production model because it eliminates a lot of the rent-seeking risk of UBI; your landlord is not going to want 2X the number of burgers and couches you get distributed as they'd happily double rent in dollars.

Once full automation hits (if it ever does; I can see augmented humans still producing up to 50% of GDP indefinitely [so far as anyone can predict anything past human-level intelligence] especially in healthcare/wellness) it's obvious that some kind of direct goods distribution is the only reasonable outcome; markets will still exist on top of this but they'll basically be optional participation for people who want to do that.

benlivengood··on Ask HN: What did you read in 2025?
I finally got around to reading Wheel of Time. It didn't quite take the whole year but a few solid months. If I had tried spreading it out over a longer period I wouldn't have been able to remember the overall plot or characters, I think.
benlivengood··on Lessons from the PG&E outage
Presumably, like Cruise, if the safety rate is appalling then they get their permits revoked which is 99% the same as jail for a company that only does self driving cars.
benlivengood··on Ask HN: What would you do if you didn't work in tech?
I think I would enjoy building houses, or solar-battery-electrical installations. I like infrastructure (my favorite games include Factorio) and being able do that in the real world sounds both useful and enjoyable/satisfying.
benlivengood··on Guarding My Git Forge Against AI Scrapers
It would be nice if there was a common crawler offering deltas on top of base checkpoints of the entire crawl; I am guessing most AI companies would prefer not having to mess with their own scrapers. Google could probably make a mint selling access.
benlivengood··on Doctors' estimates of the feasibility of preserving the dying for future revival
Yes, at some point Boltzmann brains become higher likelihood but don't forget that interventions are not limited to prior history, e.g. someone builds a machine that performs whole-body surgery based on the timing of radioactive decay. Still more likely to end up with a functioning body than a Boltzmann brain. Most likely to end up with a weirder but more likely intervention (low expectation of it actually working, but not infinitesimal) (and from anthropic perspective)
benlivengood··on Doctors' estimates of the feasibility of preserving the dying for future revival
If the universe is infinite that should happen sometime (not really important) around 10^10^29 meters away. Of course, you don't actually have to die for that copy to exist either, and a copy of the local galaxy etc. is not too much further away (10^10^92 m), so waking up indistinguishably somewhere else after a good night's sleep would happen occasionally too.
benlivengood··on The RAM shortage comes for us all
Precisely the place where government intervention is required to distribute wealth equitably.
benlivengood··on How elites could shape mass preferences as AI reduces persuasion costs
A major con of bedframes is annoying squeaks. Joints bear a lot of load and there usually isn't diagonal bracing to speak of, so they get noisy after almost no time at all. Fasteners loosen or wear the frame materials. I have yet to find one that stays quiet more than a few months or a year without retightening things; but I haven't tried a full platform construction with continuous walls which I expect might work better, but also sounds annoyingly expensive and heavy.
benlivengood··on The RAM shortage comes for us all
If your argument is that value produced per-cpu will increase so significantly that the value produced by AGI/ASI per unit cost exceeds what humans can produce for their upkeep in food and shelter, then yes that seems to be one of the significant risks long term if governments don't intervene.

If the argument is that prices will skyrocket simply because of long-term AI demand, I think that ignores the fact that manufacturing vastly more products will stabilize prices up to the point that raw materials start to become significantly more expensive, and is strongly incentivized over the ~10-year timeframe for IC manufacturers.

benlivengood··on Rsync.net Technical Notes – Q4 2025
Someone pointed out in another HN discussion that for the highest security it would be nice to have an independent service that accepted/pulled ZFS snapshot streams to apply to the backup datasets, as opposed to using ssh and risking local privilege escalations or relying entirely on ZFS user permissions.

Does anyone know of an existing service like this? Is it something rsync would consider hosting/providing? Currently to support sending encrypted ZFS snapshots to rsync.net I need to use the freebsd VM option with its own zpool.

benlivengood··on Average DRAM price in USD over last 18 months
Depending on how many disks you need, buying old PCs on eBay is the way to go because there are still some Xeon E3 ECC models available cheap ($100) with plenty of RAM (16GB) and four SATA ports for a NAS.
benlivengood··on Nano Banana Pro
You have to validate from the other direction. Let CCD sensors sign their outputs, and digital photo-editing produce a chain of custody with further signatures.

Maybe zero knowledge proofs could provide anonymity, or a simple solution is to ship the same keys in every camera model, or let them use anonymous sim-style cards with N-month certificate validity. Not everyone needs to prove the veracity of their photos, but make it cheap enough and most people probably will by default.

benlivengood··on Nano Banana Pro
You want a deconvolution pipeline like https://bartwronski.com/2022/05/26/removing-blur-from-images...

Or more likely https://www.cse.cuhk.edu.hk/~leojia/projects/motion_deblurri... for video

benlivengood··on Basalt Woven Textile
It sounds like printing in a vacuum chamber with reflective walls for IR might work?
benlivengood··on Gemini 3
That's ok; just start publishing your real problems to solve as "AI benchmarks" and then it'll work in ~6 months.
benlivengood··on Yann LeCun to depart Meta and launch AI startup focused on 'world models'
Energy is only ~10% of world GDP whereas AGI might be 25-75% and if paired with advanced robotics would be closer to 100%.

Capital always chases the highest rate of return as well, and margins on energy production are tight. Margins on performing labor are huge.

benlivengood··on DNS Provider Quad9 Sees Piracy Blocking Orders as "Existential Threat"
Free markets are not unbridled capitalism; capitalism needs strong trust-busting and anti-monopoly enforcement.
benlivengood··on Tell HN: X is opening any tweet link in a webview whether you press it or not
This reinforces why I never use the social media apps and only the web versions. Very few apps avoid the invasive engagement-maximization that browsers make a bit more difficult.
benlivengood··on Tiny electric motor can produce more than 1,000 horsepower
You could almost replace the disc brakes with these and have hub motors for free (in terms of unsprung weight). Depends on the torque and safety margin on the 700KW level of performance. For emergency safety you could have a mechanical short to let the motors dump energy into a big heating element as a last resort (risking wheel lockup) but this would truly be drive-by-wire braking.
benlivengood··on x86 architecture 1 byte opcodes
Push, pop, inc, and dec with a 16-bit register argument are one byte, so is ret. That technically gives you enough to do anything, but you can include jz/jnz (which do take immediate bytes, maybe cheating?), stosw, lodsw, clc, and stc to implement Brainfuck (a little harder to perform input/output with single byte instructions, but maybe pretend the OS uses int1 or int3 for calls).
benlivengood··on Emergent Introspective Awareness in Large Language Models
The comparison between base pretrained models and the RLHF production/helpful models suggests that it's likely reinforcement learning which is developing the introspection.
benlivengood··on Nearly 90% of Windows Games Now Run on Linux
I finally got rid of the last Windows gaming box because Windows 10 started warning me about not getting security updates. So far no compatibility issues under Debian with Steam, but I play mostly single-player or multiplayer strategy.

EDIT: I remember now that Civilization 5 for Linux would crash frequently. I switched to Proton and it's been fine since.

benlivengood··on What we talk about when we talk about sideloading
I hereby name the thing that Google wants to allow "supplicating an app(lication)". Installing puts software on a device. Supplicating asks Google for an app, and maybe it gets installed.
benlivengood··on Daniel Kahneman opted for assisted suicide in Switzerland
I find it somewhat fascinating that the article has a giant "Suicidal thoughts? You can find help here:" footer.

I don't think it's a link to an assisted suicide/dying with dignity center.

Society's relationship with intentional end of life decisions is fraught, to say the least.

benlivengood··on It's just a virus, the E.R. told him – days later, he was dead
The system was poorly designed; as pointed out elsewhere: ordering antibiotics before lab results come back is a bad practice. However, the particular sepsis popup required antibiotics to be ordered, and lab results hadn't come back yet, but another procedure (x-ray) needed to be ordered immediately.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →