The show that demonizes, humiliates and dehumanizes working class people by filming them being evicted?
78 karma · joined October 12, 2015
The show that demonizes, humiliates and dehumanizes working class people by filming them being evicted?
> I even sync back up the played location.
That sounds cool, how do you do it?
Genuine question: have you recently taken a train in Denmark, Sweden, the Netherlands, Germany or anywhere else in Europe?
I don't understand why dang and other mods justify their gatekeeping when they edit the title to use 'expensive words', like they did here. It makes me feel so frustrated. Stop with the academia-industrial-complex and let people link to articles/papers how they want to. Stop with the PR already (removing 'iPhone').
It would be beautiful if it, as well as recording your progress, if the system would also enable you to contribute back to the curriculum, allowing you to create a better suited lesson (an alternative) for the next learner, who now has a choice of two lessons, one new lesson complementing the original lesson. Or it could add a step that was missing. I think some distributed application framework like holochain or DAT would be perfect to build this on.
The closest I've seen a modular education system is Ryan Carson's TreeHouse, where there are 'tracks', topics and courses - which are all made up of modular components that are available and reorganized based on the learner's interests/wants/goals.
I guess what is behind it is my frustration and anger with the increasing widespread acceptance of black box computing devices - which are supposedly ‘user controlled general purpose computers’, yet are increasingly not, and which are instead actively spying on us and policing us in a million different ways.
[Edit: what follows is an articulation of various things I’m currently witnessing (a stream of consciousness), as well as frameworks I’m currently learning to apply, that I want to record for myself and others - potential allies who are concerned with this as well]
I’m angry that our overall tech and science literacy is constantly decreasing. I’m angry that a lot of things are getting more and more locked in (Tivoization), blocking learning and making it increasingly unfriendly for beginners
What this looks like in practice is that the essential/necessary ‘ladders‘ to learn and accomplish something (the age and current-skill level -appropriate materials or tools/technologies) are kicked away, with those who kicked it away (locking it away) claiming that they did not use those ladders themselves. They instead claim others can follow in their footsteps - without having, or being given, access to the very same ladders they needed to climb up themselves. This is bourgeois gatekeeping. There’s a book written about an economic theory by economist Ha-Joon Chang, called ‘Kicking Away The Ladder’, that I believe illustrates this well:
“How did the rich countries really become rich? In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain 'good policies' and 'good institutions', seen today as necessary for economic development. Adopting a historical approach, Dr Chang finds that the economic evolution of now-developed countries differed dramatically from the procedures that they now recommend to poorer nations. His conclusions are compelling and disturbing: that developed countries are attempting to 'kick away the ladder' with which they have climbed to the top, thereby preventing developing counties from adopting policies and institutions that they themselves have used.”
The two main strategies originally used by the global north as they developed, yet which global south countries are now denied access to in north-south relations, are: protectionism and government subsidies.
The exploitation that happens today on a large scale between north-south, seen in the way global south countries are plundered and abused by the global north capitalist firms and governments, is the same phenomenon that we see (on a smaller scale) in the global north capitalist education system, where rich capitalists can get their children tutoring and give them much more patience and attention (as well as opportunities to take over a family business or other non waged intellectual labor - in opposition to waged manual labor - and a chance to develop favorable relationships with other capitalists) than parents of working class children, perpetuating antagonistic class relations.
-
Also I shouldn’t be talking about MacOS internals (SIP, etc.) because I don’t know enough about it yet.
Thanks for clarifying, and no, please do not wear any such badges!
> cannot be reasonably described as moderate
Are you aware that you’re claiming not to pass judgement, and then do so in the very same sentence?
I think it seems immoderate to you because, like many others on this website (including me), we were all on the inside of the knowledge-monopoly walled-garden that Aaron talked about, where most research isn’t accessible to you unless you join the capitalist academia-industrial-complex (that last part is my own description, not Aaron’s), such as attending a university with a huge endowment (Harvard and other Ivy League schools), or living in a tech-cluster that the government has invested in for many years (Stanford&Silicon Valley) - why else does the most ‘exciting’ research happen at private institutions like these?:
“The world's entire scientific and cultural heritage, published over centuries in books and journals, is increasingly being digitized and locked up by a handful of private corporations. Want to read the papers featuring the most famous results of the sciences? You'll need to send enormous amounts to publishers like Reed Elsevier.” [1]
What makes it so one person is allowed to privatize knowledge and charge another a rent to access it? Why have governments allowed this enclosure of the scientific commons (amongst others), which is really an inheritance that belongs to all?
Privatization of knowledge is artificial scarcity that does not have to be there. It keeps the majority of society locked out, especially the working class, as well as people who live in the Global South.
This beautiful story from a few days ago is just one of many that shows the incredible power of Sci-hub:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25685819
I think that most intellectual laborers who themselves have conditional access to trade secrets and patents due to their employment with the capitalist/propertied classes (who are the so called 'owners' of this privatized knowledge), underestimate how difficult it is for others to follow in their footsteps, to try to copy what they did (myself included). In other words, we fail to see and acknowledge how much contrived scarcity is created by the US-‘led’ global Intellectual Property system and agreements, which allows capitalist firms to claim ownership of knowledge through trade secrets, patents and copyrights - which are then used to control where scientific research is done and where it is not. It ultimately holds back innovation, and the sharing of all kinds of emancipatory and empowering technologies locked up by capitalists under capitalism.
The most violent and advanced form of this capitalist enclosure of knowledge is the criminal enforcement of ‘trade secrets‘. The use of this mechanism, and the state institution that allows it, is the biggest capitalist perversion of science and technological development humanity has ever seen. [2]
Instead of contributing to firms and institutions that privatize knowledge, I hope we will continue joining in efforts to liberate science and technology from capitalism, creating an unconditionally available shared commons library that is accessible to all around the globe.
As we are currently part of the small group of people who are privileged recipients of this inheritance, I believe we have no excuse to not contribute to this battle for universal access, on all fronts, especially considering the fact that digital technologies have brought with them the possibility for a zero marginal cost of reproduction of knowledge. Sci-hub and similar efforts are a fantastic start to this.
For another strategy that helps reclaim technology from capitalism (and which really blew my hair back), check out the work of Bob Haugen, Lynn Foster and Pospi (Mikorizal) on Valueflo.ws / hREA. [3]
[1] https://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamj...
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25447697
[3] http://mikorizal.org/Fromprivateownershipaccountingtocommons...
This. Apple is making the use of many security functions black or white: either you allow complete control by Apple, or you have little to no protection at all. Instead they could easily allow the user to customize, and make a selection that works for them (which was the standard in older versions of OSX - pre-Big Sur [1]). The above defending of a giant faceless corporation, by @filleduchaos, is what is mind-boggling.
This feature obviously helps protect some users (non tech-literate ones), but for many it means completely turning off many useful security features ('opting out' by turning off SIP) with a lack of any sort of granular control/customization, on a device they supposedly own. It's a shame this new capitalist encroachment on user privacy is met with such understanding.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25078034, https://sneak.berlin/20201112/your-computer-isnt-yours/
That's the spirit! And abolish all privatized and monopolized knwoledge. Abolish Silicon Valley.
"Place Silicon Valley in its proper historical context and you see that, despite its mythology, it’s far from unique. Rather, it fits into a pattern of rapid technological change which has shaped recent centuries. In this case, advances in information technology have unleashed a wave of new capabilities. Just as the internal combustion engine and the growth of the railroads created Rockefeller, and the telecommunications boom created AT&T, this breakthrough enabled a few well-placed corporations to reap the rewards. By capitalising on network effects, early mover advantage, and near-zero marginal costs of production, they have positioned themselves as gateways to information, giving them the power to extract rent from every transaction.
Undergirding this state of affairs is a set of intellectual property rights explicitly designed to favour corporations. This system — the flip side of globalisation — is propagated by various trade agreements and global institutions at the behest of the nation states who benefit from it the most. It’s no accident that Silicon Valley is a uniquely American phenomenon; not only does it owe its success to the United States’ exceptionally high defence spending — the source of its research funding and foundational technological breakthroughs — that very military might is itself what implicitly secures the intellectual property regime.
Seen in that light, tech’s recent development begins to look rather different. Far from launching a new era of global prosperity, it has facilitated the further concentration of wealth and power. By virtue of their position as digital middlemen, Silicon Valley companies are able to extract vast amounts of capital from all over the world. The most salient example is Apple: recently crowned the world’s most valuable company, Apple rakes in enormous quarterly profits even as the Chinese workers who actually assemble its products are driven to suicide." [1]
[1] Wendy Liu, https://tribunemag.co.uk/2019/01/abolish-silicon-valley
Maybe. I feel like you’re completely missing the point of my post too.
Boeing should be forced to publish all trade secrets that were used in their planes which contributed to the deaths of these people (so basically all IP that Boeing owns), and they should have all their patents annulled.
> I suspect — and feel free to call me naive, but I don’t think I’m wrong— that the majority of people working on Uber’s technology would prefer to build a system whose social impact they could be proud of. Based on my admittedly limited sample size of people I know in the tech industry, I feel like lots of people working at companies like Uber are there because they want to solve interesting technical challenges and deploy useful innovations in the world. I believe that if given the choice, most would prefer to build a system that makes the world a fairer and more equitable place. The problem is that this choice is, for the most part, withheld from them, and whatever individual intentions they may have are inevitably co-opted by the capitalist structure in which they make their living. By working together to counteract these prevailing systematic forces, though, they may be able to open up a space in which to envision alternatives.
Applications built using Holochain are literally using a novel pattern that hasn’t existed before. If you know of a project that uses the same agent-centric ontology, please let me know, because I’ve looked far. As to why the lack of diversity of protocols in existing platforms (or non-usage of new protocols), I think the reason many platforms/protocols aren’t adopted is because the commons has been plundered: trade secrets block progress and have led to the creation of the web as walled gardens. Great for capitalists and advertisers, but crap for individuals.
> People don't want everyone to have a complete platform to them to say anything they want. So somewhere someone has to be doing some deciding of who gets a platform. Protocols can't magically solve that problem.
Who is 'people'? Who do you speak for? Could you share any sources that back up your claim?
From your (seemingly) quick dismissal, I’m curious to know if you read up on the actual tech? I’d be curious if you have any critique on the underlying tech?
I agree that any community needs moderation but that doesn’t mean we should have a faceless company doing it. It can be done by making cooperative block-lists/blacklists, and sharing those among participants. We don’t need the middlemen at all, in fact they are unaccountable, and are dangerous by themselves since their only focus is to exploit users and extract a profit for shareholders.
As I said though, I’m curious about any critique about Holochain tech (the software pattern). Personally I think it’s inevitable that we will move in that direction imo: the direction of an agent-centric web, a space of direct protocol negotiation and renegotiation.
I’d like to make you aware that Holochain also paves the way for new types of value accounting systems. If you are curious, check out the work of Lynn Foster, Bob Haugen, Pospi and others on hREA / http://valueflo.ws. They are in the later stages of developing a fully featured, fully distributed, Resources Events Agents (REA) accounting system built using Holochain - creating one of the world’s first Network Resource Planning software [1] that uses an official ISO standard.
It's some really groundbreaking stuff here, that's got me super excited and hopeful.
[1] https://wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Network_Resource_Planning
I suspect — and feel free to call me naive, but I don’t think I’m wrong— that the majority of people working on Uber’s technology would prefer to build a system whose social impact they could be proud of. Based on my admittedly limited sample size of people I know in the tech industry, I feel like lots of people working at companies like Uber are there because they want to solve interesting technical challenges and deploy useful innovations in the world. I believe that if given the choice, most would prefer to build a system that makes the world a fairer and more equitable place. The problem is that this choice is, for the most part, withheld from them, and whatever individual intentions they may have are inevitably co-opted by the capitalist structure in which they make their living. By working together to counteract these prevailing systematic forces, though, they may be able to open up a space in which to envision alternatives." [1]
-- Wendy Liu
[1] https://medium.com/@dellsystem/dont-put-your-faith-in-uber-7...
Holochain’s novelty lies in its use of DHT’s to create, store and retrieve data. Like Git source chains, it then uses cryptography to guarantee data integrity in this distributed application context. You’re basically agreeing in advance on which functions to use. Instead of using proprietary functions that are kept secret behind a firewall or limited through an API, Holochain allows you to create and use apps that directly enforce and verify open rules in a 100% distributed peer to peer way. To the best of my knowledge this sort of system hasn’t been seen or invented before.
Thy have great descriptions on their website:
[from https://holo.host/faq/]
“Holochain maintains data integrity without the need for global consensus. It uses an agent-centric approach, combining ideas from BitTorrent and Git, along with cryptographic signatures, peer validation, and gossip.
An overview:
- hApps have validation rules.
- Agents have their own local, tamper-resistant hash-chains recording their actions, built upon hApp rules.
- Each hash-chain entry is cryptographically signed (multi-party actions, like transactions, are mutually countersigned).
- Data is shared to random peers who validate it.
- Validators gossip to share good data, warn against bad data, and blacklist bad actors.“
Their code is free software, available on Github here: https://github.com/holochain
Protocols instead of platforms:
https://medium.com/holochain/holochain-reinventing-applicati...
Why are we asking this question? It should be up to the individual but it’s not - and hasn’t been for years. Virtue signaling.
It’s a joke that at this point Bezos and co. (including all the ‘Amazon-friendly‘ legislators in congress) are taking over and monopolizing all these verticals. It’s never been so apparent that bourgeois democracy is a complete joke. Today there is no democracy in the workplace, and the working class, in the form of temp/gig workers, are literally getting murdered by being forced to work during Covid [1].
Bezos grew his net worth by $70 billion, while hundreds of thousands of Americans died.
[1] ‘Amazon says 19,816 workers have contracted COVID-19’ https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/1/21497941/amazon-disclose-...
In that sense it gives voice to the anger of the oppressed, the downtrodden. It's pure solidarity. Marx' critique is ammunition. Ammunition to unshackle our chains and claim our communist freedom.
> If I kind of saw myself as at-one with the basic Silicon Valley ethos, like I used to, this would definitely put me off before I fully ingested the argument.
Would you be willing to share which bits speficifally put you off in this text(or would have before you didn't see yourself as at-one with the ethos)? Are there maybe any specific words or labels?
> I wish I had an example of an introductory text in the style I would like to see. I will try to find something like that. I'm sure it exists, given how much writing there has been on this topic over the last decade.
Yeah I would love to see that. Please do share if you want to and if you have it at hand.
I think being in the bourgeoisie sucks for the bourgeoisie, and I'm curious to what extent it is possible to describe the alienation experienced by the capitalists/dominators (who are consciously dehumanizing proletarians their whole lives). Class traitorism should always be encouraged (Engels, Geuvara, etc.), and I'm still exploring narratives that support it.
> You're going to have to break that down for a 21st century software developer on a SV messageboard.
I love Wendy Liu's explanation on this, it's the best I've found:
"The Silicon Valley model of technological development is structurally flawed. It can’t simply be tweaked in a more socially beneficial direction, because it was never intended to be useful for all of society in the first place. At its core, it was always a class project, meant to advance the interests of capital. The founders and investors and engineers who dutifully keep the engines running may not deliberately be reinforcing class divides, but functionally, they are carrying out technological development in a way that enables capitalism’s desire for endless accumulation.
Consequently, fixing the problems with the tech industry requires revisiting the economic assumptions that underpin it. If technological development is to be truly liberating, it cannot be funded and developed by an imperial machine, driven by the hare-brained schemes of growth-hungry investors, and owned by a miniscule clique not accountable to broader society.
What’s needed instead is a movement to reclaim technology: to prevent its capture by capital, and direct it towards creating social value. Of course, the tech giants are not going to cede this ground easily. This is why the demand of the future will not be to tame or reform Silicon Valley, but to abolish it. For it to serve society, technology will have to be liberated from the constraints of corporate ownership and subjected to democracy.
If this is hard to imagine, it’s probably because we’re so used to the way technology works in today’s economy that most of us are unable to see beyond its horizons. But it’s time we started seeing Silicon Valley for what it really is: not separate from the economy, and not its saviour, but instead capitalism on steroids. All the negatives we associate with Silicon Valley — useless gadgets that no one needs, companies with billion-dollar valuations going up in smoke, exploitation of precarious workers — are a microcosm of a broader economic system. Abolishing Silicon Valley, then, means more than breaking up a few corporations; it’ll require a fundamental transformation of the economic structures that govern society.
Transformation
In the coming years you’ll read a lot of columns agonising over how to ‘fix’ Silicon Valley. Most will be technocratic, evacuating politics from the discussion. This is, after all, the framing that allowed Silicon Valley to grow so powerful in the first place: a binary choice between technological development on capital’s terms, or remaining stuck in the past. But structural problems require structural solutions. Rather than relying on ‘ethical’ founders or investors to change the system, we need collective action to challenge it.
This will mean undoing the labyrinth of intellectual property rights, which are intended to protect corporations and commodify information. It will mean revisiting the funding model that gave rise to the ‘go-big-or-go-home’ culture responsible for so many wasteful start-ups, shifting away from the return-driven venture capital model, and towards a state-backed social entrepreneurship with public responsibilities.
It will also mean building worker power, within the tech industry and beyond it. Within it, the long-term goal must be a union culture encompassing all workers involved in production. That means not just the highly-paid software engineers but contractors packing boxes for Amazon, or driving for Uber, or cleaning offices in Silicon Valley should all have representation in decision-making structures. And beyond the confines of the industry, a wider-organised labour movement needs to offer resistance to technology being used to facilitate increased worker exploitation through surveillance or regulatory arbitrage.
None of this will be easy, of course. Reclaiming the emancipatory potential of technology will require prying it from the clutches of capital. But that is a worthy fight. If the task of politics is to imagine a different world, then the job of technology is to help us get there. Whether technology is developed for the right ends — for the public good, instead of creating a privatised dystopia — will depend on the outcome of political struggles." [1]