HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bergstromm466

78 karma · joined October 12, 2015

smile, you're on camera!
submissionscomments
bergstromm466··on ReMarkable tablet open source tools and hacks
Is the only thing stopping e-ink tablets/devices from becoming afforable because of the high rent/royalties for the patented e-ink technology?

I'm keen to use one because 1) i think over it's lifetime it will likely consume less energy than an LCD/OLED tablet, and 2) because it would be better for my eyes when i'm reading articles/research or books.

bergstromm466··on YouTube-dl's repository has been restored
> Is this real?

I'm as amazed as you are.

> The "love" for microsoft recently is interesting.

The Corporatocracy has never been so polarizing.

bergstromm466··on Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA
I honestly believe this is just a small component, which is a part of the long term strategy of the RIAA and others: a periodical check to test the waters to see where public opinion is at, to be able to guage if they can implement more dramatic and restrictive DRM mechanisms yet [1].

They are either 1) waiting for us to be too exhausted to notice/care/fight back, or 2) seeing whether they have to go further to 'protect content creators' by lobbying for more draconian laws that allow for the use of new DRM strategies. It reminds me of reading about how Corporate personhood was invented to protect freed slaves [2], yet is now used as a way for business owners to avoid personal liability/responsibility. One could even argue that Corporate personhoood is one of the most destructive forces that exists today; causing some of the worst crimes in modern history [3].

It's important we continue to fight back and set a precedent for protecting users over corporations or governments.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Right_to_Read

[2] https://www.history.com/news/14th-amendment-corporate-person...

[3] https://www.counterpunch.org/2013/02/05/corporate-personhood...

bergstromm466··on Your Computer Isn't Yours
> The problem is that people want it that way.

No, the real story here is that Corporations in the USA, and other Global North countries, have both 1) benefited from state/taxpayer-funded subsidies, grants, and research, and 2) are now locking up and monopolizing these discoveries using the international TRIPS system, 'claiming' Patents and Copyrights, 'kicking away the ladder':

"How did the rich countries really become rich? In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain 'good policies' and 'good institutions', seen today as necessary for economic development. Adopting a historical approach, Dr Chang finds that the economic evolution of now-developed countries differed dramatically from the procedures that they now recommend to poorer nations. His conclusions are compelling and disturbing: that developed countries are attempting to 'kick away the ladder' with which they have climbed to the top, thereby preventing developing counties from adopting policies and institutions that they themselves have used."

+

“Rich countries have ‘kicked away the ladder’ by forcing free-market, free-trade policies on poor countries. Already established countries do not want more competitors emerging through the nationalistic policies they themselves successfully used in the past.” [1]

Professor Yash Tandon adds:

“During the 1980s and 1990s I worked in many countries in eastern and southern Africa, and then for four years at the South Centre—2005–09. I can say from my experience that the industrialised countries of the North have been trying systematically to block all efforts by the countries of the South to industrialise. Their mega-corporations have tried—and, alas, succeeded—in privatising knowledge, and using it to promote corporate profits over the lives of people."

[...]

“It is the seeds and pharmaceutical companies of the West that have pirated the knowledge of seeds and medicinal products from the South. But whereas in the South this knowledge was shared as a public asset, the Western companies, having learnt from the South, proceeded to claim it as their private property. They are guilty—morally guilty—for the avoidable deaths of millions of people in the South who cannot afford their ‘patented’ medicines against, for example, AIDS, malaria, tuberculosis and other killer diseases. It is a sordid story. But it is not all doom and gloom. Those who control the system (the global corporations and the international organisations that the West controls) do not get their own way entirely. Wars do not always end in the victory of the militarily or ‘intellectually’ powerful.” [2]

All of this then comes together through Tech's Great-Man theory, that has us idolizing those monopolizers:

"In the movie Steve Jobs, a character asks, “So how come 10 times in a day I read ‘Steve Jobs is a genius?’” The great man reputation that envelops Jobs is just part of a larger mythology of the role that Silicon Valley, and indeed the entire U.S. private sector, has played in technology innovation. We idolize tech entrepreneurs like Jobs, and credit them for most of the growth in our economy. But University of Sussex economist Mariana Mazzucato, who has just published a new U.S. edition of her book, The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, makes a timely argument that it is the government, not venture capitalists and tech visionaries, that have been heroic.

“Every major technological change in recent years traces most of its funding back to the state,” says Mazzucato. Even “early stage” private-sector VCs come in much later, after the big breakthroughs have been made. For example, she notes, “The National Institutes of Health have spent almost a trillion dollars since their founding on the research that created both the pharmaceutical and the biotech sectors–with venture capitalists only entering biotech once the red carpet was laid down in the 1980s. We pretend that the government was at best just in the background creating the basic conditions (skills, infrastructure, basic science). But the truth is that the involvement required massive risk taking along the entire innovation chain: basic research, applied research and early stage financing of companies themselves.” The Silicon Valley VC model, which has typically dictated that financiers exit within 5 years or so, simply isn’t patient enough to create game changing innovation." [3]

[1] https://anthempress.com/kicking-away-the-ladder-pb

[2] https://www.orbooks.com/catalog/trade-war-yash-tandon-2nd-ed...

[3] https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/

bergstromm466··on Stopping some fishing would increase overall catches
What I tried to say is that the framing by OP is hypocritical fear-mongering which benefits US & Eurocentric Imperialism.

Of course I do not endorse China's human rights violations.

bergstromm466··on Your Computer Isn't Yours
> Sorry, but please can you point to any real evidence that Apple allows state-level actors access? From what I can see it is exactly the opposite.

> Sorry, but there are no details about how PRISM works.

> I personally think that PRISM works by externally intercepting data communication lines running to / from the unwitting companies.

Unless you can prove you're ex-NSA or worked in SIGINT, sharing your opinion is not proof. Snowden's leaks are proof.

Why not give weight to the arguments and proof put forth by Edward Snowden? There have been no attempts by the US govt. or the NSA to disprove his leaks. No counter-evidence presented.

My question is: what do you benefit from continuing to deny and refuse to accept Snowden's whistleblowing?

bergstromm466··on The Lonely Work of Moderating Hacker News (2019)
...or maybe it’s important feedback? Why immediately assume malevolence or ill-intent?
bergstromm466··on EU Draft Council Declaration Against Encryption [pdf]
Obesity does not imply over-use of food with high nutritional value.

In other words, obesity comes from worse diets. The working classes are bombarded with corporate foods that contain way too much sugar, etc.

bergstromm466··on Stopping some fishing would increase overall catches
> We shouldn't do business with a country that steals, doesn't play fair, is the embodiment of 1984, and above all, commits genocide.

I do not understand how you can say this about China? [1]

> I think the future posed by Communist China is nightmare fuel and has the potential to eclipse the future we are trying to build

Seriously? [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3LFbOSPfrE

bergstromm466··on Ask HN: How do you prevent code leak from current/former employees?
> we had an intern on our team who told me he hated everything about Apple, and that he used Linux for everything

> I hope that by the end of his internship his attitude had changed.

Why?

bergstromm466··on 100 Years on a Dirty Dog: The History of Greyhound (2013)
What is it like for people in this ‘sketchy place’ when you walk through their neighborhood?

If in your eyes they contribute to making a place ‘sketchy’ - what could their perspective be on you?

How do they see you?

I am asking because to me your comment seems devoid of empathy towards others, and I’m curious how you came to be. I’d like to learn more about your perspective if possible.

bergstromm466··on Copyright vs. Copyleft (2007)
> A few lengthy and insightful sentences then leap into a political (USA) overview. There is no science or even provable elements to the political analysis here, only a debate format where the objective is convincing the reader of the authority of the writer, in this case Wendy Liu.

The same could be said about your analysis. She, at the least, engages the reader to think about Capitalist Property Rights. It's also a small snippet of a larger text/essay, so I would ask you to please consider reading the whole thing before you make up your mind about her positions and overall vision.

> Civilization has multiple centers on Earth and always has, not simply the US East Coast. The GPL has carried on for three+ decades, and look what has exploded in that time. What comes next? A legal framework must engage its epoch, and times change, of course. Massive forces are at work right now, with acceleration.

> Free as in Freedom

I honestly have no idea what you are talking about here, and you provide no useful rebuttal to the points she brings up.

bergstromm466··on Copyright vs. Copyleft (2007)
> the intent of the law is genuinely to guarantee access to the fruits of one's intellectual labour

This seems a naive take when considering that it's Corporations who hold the most Intellectual Property[1] (Patents and Copyrights) and are the 'customers' or beneficiaries of Intellectual Property laws and systems.

It's Corporations who focus on IP acquisition (and thus monopolization) strategies (e.g. Google buying smaller startups to add their Intellectual Property to it's repertoire).

...in other words, the likelyhood of average Joe being helped by the Intellectual Property system to get access to the fruits of his labor is not a common situation at all. Most new innovations are the result of access and engagement with existing Corporate Intellectual Property (plus an expensive education).

[1] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.en.html

bergstromm466··on Copyright vs. Copyleft (2007)
"it wasn’t until the free software movement shed its rebellious roots and rebranded as the more business-friendly “open-source movement” that it really took off. One of the most crucial figures in this effort was Tim O’Reilly, founder and CEO of O’Reilly Media, who built his business empire by identifying the pieces of the free software movement that could be commodified. Suddenly, corporations that had previously considered open source to be dangerously redolent of “communism” were starting to see its value, both as a way of building software and as a recruitment tactic. From there, an entire ecosystem of virtue-signaling opportunities sprang up around the marriage of convenience between the corporate world and open source: conference and hackathon sponsorships, “summers of code,” libraries released under open licenses but funded by for-profit corporations.

If that counts as a victory, however, it was a pyrrhic one. In the process of gaining mainstream popularity, the social movement of “free software”—which rejected the very idea of treating software as intellectual property—morphed into the more palatable notion of “open source” as a development methodology, in which free and proprietary software could happily co-exist. The corporations that latched onto the movement discovered a useful technique for developing software, but jettisoned the critique of property rights that formed its ideological foundation.

Yet it was precisely the weakness of that foundation that made the free software movement vulnerable to co-optation in the first place. The movement’s greatest limitation was its political naivete. Even as it attacked the idea of software as property, it failed to connect its message to a wider analysis that acknowledged the role of property rights within a capitalist framework. Free software pioneers like Stallman tended to approach the issue from an individualized perspective, drawn from the 1970s-1980s hacker culture that many of them came from: if you could change how enough hackers wrote and used software, you could change the world. This highly personalized model of social change proposed an individual solution to a structural problem, which necessarily neglected the wider social context."

+

"the neoliberal consensus of the last few decades has meant that the benefits of technological development have largely flowed to corporations, under the aegis of a strong intellectual property regime. As the free software movement came up against these prevailing economic forces, its more contentious aspects were watered down or discarded. The result was “open source”: a more collaborative method of writing software that bore few traces of its subversive origins."

— Wendy Liu, https://logicmag.io/failure/freedom-isnt-free/

bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
A proposal can be an argument.

"Legal Definition of argument. 1: a reason or the reasoning given for or against a matter under discussion — compare evidence, proof. 2: the act or process of arguing, reasoning, or discussing especially: oral argument."

bergstromm466··on Amazon Academy India
I say -- bingo
bergstromm466··on Amazon Academy India
Yes, educating/training workers in a Global South country that has already been heavily underdeveloped, in order to get cheap labor -- what an original formula.

If you don't see something, answer me this: why don't they do anything like this in the US?

bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
> Here are two headlines I offer without comment that can be searched with your favorite search engine for more information.

Headlines are not arguments...

bergstromm466··on California passes Proposition 22, backed by Uber and Lyft
Yeah, instead I'd rephrase to: 'state-enabled monopoly'. It is enabled through Patents and Copyright laws that keep knowledge, in the form of IP and 'trade secrets', artificially scarce and limited to American/Silicon Valley corporations.

"How can politicians look into TV cameras and say we have a free market system when patents guarantee monopoly incomes for twenty years, preventing anyone from competing? How can they claim there are free markets when copyright rules give a guaranteed income for seventy years after a person’s death? How can they claim free markets exist when one person or company is given a subsidy and not others, or when they sell off the commons that belong to all of us, at a discount, to a favoured individual or company, or when Uber, TaskRabbit and their ilk act as unregulated labour brokers, profiting from the labour of others?" [1]

+

"The IP system is an artificial construct that excessively rewards owners of intellectual property, granting them monopolies over inventions and ideas that in many cases are the product of generations of thinkers and/or publicly funded research.” [2]

[1] https://www.resilience.org/stories/2017-08-03/book-day-corru...

[2] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/12/the-precariat-populis...

bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
Yes. I appreciate the nuance you bring. I would reword where I wrote 'medicare' as: 'affordable healthcare', which in it's current form is (as you described) often a mix between private and public mechanisms/institutions.
bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
> I am curious whether or not you think we should focus on increasing spending to increase medicare coverage or if we should focus on decreasing healthcare costs for the country as a whole.

Yes, both.

> focus on decreasing healthcare costs for the country as a whole

Most importantly, I believe that through the patent system 1) Pharmaceutical Corporations, together with 2), politicians - who are corrupted through lobbying and who thus make advantageous laws (for Corps) - are getting away with murder. Yash Tandon gives a great example of this below:

“During the 1980s and 1990s I worked in many countries in eastern and southern Africa, and then for four years at the South Centre—2005–09. I can say from my experience that the industrialised countries of the North have been trying systematically to block all efforts by the countries of the South to industrialise. Their mega-corporations have tried—and, alas, succeeded—in privatising knowledge, and using it to promote corporate profits over the lives of people."

[...]

“It is the seeds and pharmaceutical companies of the West that have pirated the knowledge of seeds and medicinal products from the South. But whereas in the South this knowledge was shared as a public asset, the Western companies, having learnt from the South, proceeded to claim it as their private property. They are guilty—morally guilty—for the avoidable deaths of millions of people in the South who cannot afford their ‘patented’ medicines against, for example, AIDS, malaria, tuberculosis and other killer diseases. It is a sordid story. But it is not all doom and gloom. Those who control the system (the global corporations and the international organisations that the West controls) do not get their own way entirely. Wars do not always end in the victory of the militarily or ‘intellectually’ powerful.”

- Yash Tandon, Trade Is War: The West's War Against the World

bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
> Which is fine

No it's not fine [that taxpayers "ultimately end up paying for the social security, healthcare, and other unmet needs (lack of paid sick leave, lack of paid maternity/paternity leave etc.) of these contractors"].

The Commons have been slowly plundered. It's the working class who is suffering. Look around you, homeless people everywhere. This is digital Rentier Capitalism, which enriches the ruling classes, and parasitally sucks dry the working class.

"[R]entier incomes from ownership and exploitation of assets are continuing to grow, sucking up ever more of global income. And the state is accentuating these two mega-trends by throwing more subsidies to the rentiers while cutting benefits for the precariat, and while the silicon revolution is channelling more income to those who own the robots, creating a perfect storm of economic insecurity.

A way out of this approaching impasse would be to create a new income distribution system in which more of the rent is captured for society, and used to buttress the precariat’s living standards. In 1936, John Maynard Keynes predicted the "euthanasia of the rentier" before the end of the 20th century. It did not happen. Now is the time to do it. One way would be by building up democratic sovereign wealth funds through a levy on various forms of rent, which are neither morally nor economically justifiable."

Source: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/12/the-precariat-populis...

bergstromm466··on California passes Proposition 22, backed by Uber and Lyft
> incompetence by the state

"In the movie Steve Jobs, a character asks, “So how come 10 times in a day I read ‘Steve Jobs is a genius?’” The great man reputation that envelops Jobs is just part of a larger mythology of the role that Silicon Valley, and indeed the entire U.S. private sector, has played in technology innovation. We idolize tech entrepreneurs like Jobs, and credit them for most of the growth in our economy. But University of Sussex economist Mariana Mazzucato, who has just published a new U.S. edition of her book, The Entrepreneurial State: Debunking Public vs. Private Sector Myths, makes a timely argument that it is the government, not venture capitalists and tech visionaries, that have been heroic.

“Every major technological change in recent years traces most of its funding back to the state,” says Mazzucato. Even “early stage” private-sector VCs come in much later, after the big breakthroughs have been made. For example, she notes, “The National Institutes of Health have spent almost a trillion dollars since their founding on the research that created both the pharmaceutical and the biotech sectors–with venture capitalists only entering biotech once the red carpet was laid down in the 1980s. We pretend that the government was at best just in the background creating the basic conditions (skills, infrastructure, basic science). But the truth is that the involvement required massive risk taking along the entire innovation chain: basic research, applied research and early stage financing of companies themselves.” The Silicon Valley VC model, which has typically dictated that financiers exit within 5 years or so, simply isn’t patient enough to create game changing innovation."

Source: https://time.com/4089171/mariana-mazzucato/

bergstromm466··on California Voters Exempt Uber, Lyft, DoorDash from Having to Reclassify Drivers
> The point is that this often isn't someone's primary job. They take a job at Walmart or driving a school bus, it doesn't pay very well, so they get off work and pick up some rides to supplement their income before going home.

> They don't need health insurance because they got it through their first job or their spouse, and imposing that cost on the second job only requires them to get paid less or have less flexibility etc. as the trade off the company has to make to justify paying the additional cost of mandatory benefits.

Interesting to follow your thinking and your strategies, thanks for open sourcing it. From a European perspective all this sounds absurd though. Having medicare for all and a social safety net is standard in all European countries and other Global North countries.

bergstromm466··on California passes Proposition 22, backed by Uber and Lyft
This will just cause a deepening of the Digital and Information Feudalism that is already going on. It will result in a violent revolution by the working classes, to throw off these chains, and to democratize the use and application of the underlying technologies used by Uber et al. I am sad that American citizens are subjected to these experiments by American billionaires. They are systemically dehumanized, exploited and pushed to their limits. [1]

Why do people still stand behind copyrights and patents, in this age of zero-marginal cost reproduction and transmission of information? [2]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9abrZwnPThE

[2] https://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamj...

bergstromm466··on California passes Proposition 22, backed by Uber and Lyft
only the rent-seeking owners and their shareholders 'like' it. if you cannot see how this business model is dehumanizing and parasitic, and sucks wealth to the top, I'm honestly not so sure what to say to you...

SV companies get their wealth from monopolies granted by the state.

“The basic idea is simple; it is that the ‘state vs market’ diagram of the world is flawed. In reality, there is no such thing as The Market; there are many markets. Even the civil service is a market (for funding, promotion, reputation etc). Competition and collaboration are inevitable functions of any human system. Similarly, the concept of ‘big’ or ‘small’ government makes no sense. In the end, we are always taxed and regulated by someone, it is just a question of who, and to what end?

A better way to understand the relationship between ‘the state’ and ‘the market’ is to see nation states as platforms: makers and shapers of markets. They provide the land, infrastructure and set the rules and goals – in the same way that, for example, the App Store creates, regulates and taxes the market for iOS apps.

The moment you begin to look at government through this lens, two things immediately become clear.

First, a lot of what has been sold to us as ‘free market’ capitalism was in fact the opposite; the privatisation of the platform, creating a series of privately owned monopolies protected from competition, extracting taxation without representation, and profits without prosperity.”

Source: https://medium.com/@AlastairParvin/progress-again-6f6213bdcd...

bergstromm466··on Raspberry Pi 400 Desktop PC
"Does the sub-licensed Intel Management Engine on the Broadcom CPU in the Raspberry Pi 400 call home to Intel servers?"

Tomorrow's headline?

bergstromm466··on Microsoft and the NSA
May I ask for the reason/thought behind your question?
bergstromm466··on Bill Gates - "IP is the incentive system for the products of the future" [2005]
Thanks, I realize I was not as clear as I wanted to be in my comment above

1)

I wrote:

> What would a F/LOSS world, without IP enforcement, BUT with authorship claims and a shared record of 'who was first', look like?

I'd evolve this to: What would a F/LOSS world look like with a system that rewards copying and giving attribution (by being able to find, and getting to work with, other humans that have complementary skillsets), but that doesn't pretend that humans can 'steal' something that is a non-rival resource (software/digital media) [simple example: I can give someone a blueprint of a bike, and I wouldn't lose (access) to my own]? What would a system look like that focuses on tracking authorship claims, which helps humanity see which teams achieved what (a shared record of 'who was first' that helps assess the productivity of a certain team)?

2)

My second argument comes with the way our economic system commoditizes information, creating essentially a world with 'information feudalism'. My question is: is this inevitable? Or can we create non-rival ways of acknowledging wealth? [1]

Sensorica and Mikorizal are moving away from dollars, euros, etc. and towards asset backed accounting, with the use of the Resource Event Agent (REA) accounting model, in what they call an 'Open Value Network' (OVN). An Open Value Network inverts the closed corporate Value/Supply Chain accounting. A 1kg bag of carrots stays a 1kg bag of carrots, instead of becoming denominated in dollars, euros or pesos [2]. This means we start being able to see the flows of resources flowing through our communities. This has never existed before so it's hard to describe.

I'm glad I got to clarify thanks to your comment - also helps my own thought processes

I'd be curious to hear if this resonated, or made some sense to you?

[1] https://eric.harris-braun.com/blog/2007/11/05/id-55

[2] https://medium.com/metacurrency-project/the-metacurrency-myt...

bergstromm466··on Bill Gates - "IP is the incentive system for the products of the future" [2005]
Q: In recent years, there's been a lot of people clamoring to reform and restrict intellectual-property rights. It started out with just a few people, but now there are a bunch of advocates saying, "We've got to look at patents, we've got to look at copyrights." What's driving this, and do you think intellectual-property laws need to be reformed?

+

Bill Gates: "No, I'd say that of the world's economies, there's more that believe in intellectual property today than ever. There are fewer communists in the world today than there were. There are some new modern-day sort of communists who want to get rid of the incentive for musicians and moviemakers and software makers under various guises. They don't think that those incentives should exist.

And this debate will always be there. I'd be the first to say that the patent system can always be tuned--including the U.S. patent system. There are some goals to cap some reform elements. But the idea that the United States has led in creating companies, creating jobs, because we've had the best intellectual-property system--there's no doubt about that in my mind, and when people say they want to be the most competitive economy, they've got to have the incentive system. Intellectual property is the incentive system for the products of the future."

-

Note: I'm against Intellectual Monopoly and turning something non-rival into something rival by making it artificially scarce.

Imagine how smart humanity would be if there were no longer any walls blocking our children's curiosity?

"The current [system] is based on a false idea of “immaterial scarcity.” It believes that an exaggerated set of intellectual property monopolies – for copyrights, trademarks and patents – should restrain the sharing of scientific, social and economic innovations. Hence the system discourages human cooperation, excludes many people from benefiting from innovation and slows the collective learning of humanity. In an age of grave global challenges, the political economy keeps many practical alternatives sequestered behind private firewalls or unfunded if they cannot generate adequate profits."

Are proprietary non-modular black-box solutions the best for our future?

Or does it make people ignorant?

Can discoveries/inventions happen outside corporate walls?

If so, how?

Could, for example, a fractal Open Value Network, used by Sensorica and others, lead to new ways of sharing resources and producing the things we need in an open, transparent way?

I think our current economic system is dogmatic as it hasn't yet found a way to incorporate the zero-marginal cost of digital reproduction/transmission/storage.

The question that is in my mind when posting this is: does creating software require incentives? What would a F/LOSS world, without IP enforcement, BUT with authorship claims and a shared record of 'who was first', look like?

I am slowly learning more about the system and it's origins, and I enjoy the discussions on this website.

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →