HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

berkay

295 karma · joined April 3, 2007

An IT management geek, founder of OpsGenie and Thundra http://twitter.com/berkay
submissionscomments
berkay··on Why we ditched our free plan
An article attracts discussion is good? sure. I did not know about trak.io, now I do. The attitude in the article towards "freeloaders"? not so good. I won't argue whether it is better or not to have a freemium for "your" company. But commitment should not be broken so nonchalantly. Did you at least grandfather beta customers to a free plan? If not, you did a bait and switch, and that does not make me wanna do business with you (and I would have become a paying customer).
berkay··on How Everyone Got the Top 1% Wrong
I'm afraid you've missed the point. Based on the data 1% is NOT "offenders" as you put it. That iss what's interesting. Take another look at the last graph. The share of wealth for the 1% except the 0.1% has NOT changed in the last 50 years (~11%). Yet during same time period share of wealth for the 0.1% has quadrupled.
berkay··on Turkey has blocked Google DNS access to Twitter
Most people are opposed to be censored. Not enough are opposed to censoring of others.
berkay··on Tarnished Silver
By the professionals Krugman does not refer to political analysts/hacks that spew opinion. He is referring to scientists. He is cautioning Nate Silver against dismissing the work done by scientists who use scientific methods. Nate Silver's crew ignoring scientific studies would be no different than political analysts ignoring Nate Silver's work based on anecdotes.
berkay··on Turkey Twitter users flout Erdogan ban
His record is clean in the sense that (unlike the prime minister) there has been no allegations or evidence of corruption involving him. He has been positioning himself as the more modern, tolerant option the conservative AKP party that has been in power over the decade.

However, it's safe to say that he talked to talk but failed to walk it. When the government started passing laws that undermine the independence of judicial system, free media, etc. he decided to tow the party line and failed to take any action, even symbolic ones, disappointing many that expected more from him.

He also has not taken any action or made any comments to address the corruption allegations against the government. It appears, he is aligned with the current administration in their struggle to hold on to power. Possible conclusions are a)he does not believe they are corrupt (despite significant evidence to the contrary) b) he believes struggle against Gulen movement is more important c) his hands are not sufficiently clean to take any action

His current position is indeed mostly ceremonial but still has impact. More importantly, there is (at least was) discussion to change the system towards a more powerful presidency along the lines of France or US. Gul was presenting himself as the more palatable and clean option (the modern conservative). It is not clear he can convince the masses on this anymore.

berkay··on Twitter is blocked in Turkey
Many sites including Youtube did get blocked in the past, but safe to say this one is different. It is an explicit attempt to silence non-traditional media by the government. They have been working on controlling the traditional media (TV, newspapers, etc.) for a long time.

Recently, social media has been making a bigger impact, hence the explicit play. Current administration sees itself in an existential struggle and willing to do anything to stay in power. The model that they aspire seems to have switched from the west to Russia/China.

Whether they will be able to succeed in silencing social media will have implications beyond Turkey.

berkay··on Why Puppet, Chef, Ansible aren't good enough
Author's point is that we are focusing on the wrong place (puppet, chef, etc.), hence potentially making the problem worse by attempting to deal with the symptoms instead of addressing the root cause. Puppet/Chef etc. may indeed still be relevant and potentially even more widely used as it would become much simpler to develop recipes, etc.
berkay··on Why Puppet, Chef, Ansible aren't good enough
If you're going to make such a loaded, inflammatory statement, at least back it up with some explanation on how you arrived that conclusion.
berkay··on Creating software for sysops
This is very true, particularly when dealing with large vendors. Unlike smaller companies, enterprise software vendors have large independent organizations. Support department often does not have direct access to developers and have to rely on published docs, etc. Support people also get measured according to their "performance" closing tickets.

As a result, if you don't use standard methods to install the software, etc. they often have no clue and quick to wash their hands off the problem even when the problem is clearly nothing to do with how you installed the software.

Never mind that you're probably paying significant amounts every year (15-25%) for support and maintenance ...

berkay··on Frequency
This is awesome. It came up with some cool rhythms as well. Nicely done, kudos to your friends.
berkay··on Busting Comcast's $250 installation fee for 105 Mbps
In my case it does not provide a compelling case. With 50mb, it is plenty fast and do not feel need for faster. backup of my content does not seem to require more bandwidth either for PCs. I use both Backblaze and Dropbox, and they both work in the background etc, again 50mb is plenty.

Thinking more about this, I think I may need more bandwidth if I were consuming more real-time high volume data. May be the upcoming virtual reality apps (Occulus, etc.) will be the next jump in bandwidth requirements.

berkay··on Busting Comcast's $250 installation fee for 105 Mbps
The examples you're giving are mostly about stored data. We're able to foresee why you may need more, photos, videos, etc. On bandwidth, it's harder to imagine. With 50, you can stream multiple HD videos. What would 105 would give me? I don't know. May be Google Fiber subscribers can provide some insight since they have access to much more.
berkay··on Elasticsearch 1.0.0 released
I think the distinction made it this comment is valuable, and echoes our experience. ES is not (at least so far) suitable as a general purpose data store, but it is suitable (and very good) for more than search. For some use cases, it's the best available.
berkay··on Things We Forgot to Monitor
You may want to check OpsGenie heartbeat monitoring, or essentially implement the same idea yourself. Our heartbeat monitoring expects to receive messages (via email or API) from monitoring tools periodically and notifies you via push/SMS/phone if we don't receive it over 10 minutes. I think this pattern is very useful to ensure that alert notifications is working.
berkay··on Things We Forgot to Monitor
Independent infrastructure is a good idea but not always feasible for everyone. At OpsGenie, to resolve this problem, we came up with a solution we refer as "heartbeat monitoring". This basically allows monitoring tools to send periodic heartbeat messages to us that indicate that the tools is up and can reach us. If we don't receive heartbeat messages from them in 10 minutes, we generate an alert and notify the admins. Not out of band management but does the trick to prevent situations like jsmeaton described.

http://support.opsgenie.com/customer/portal/articles/759603-...

berkay··on AWS Tips I Wish I'd Known Before I Started
I can only give you a datapoint. This has not been the case in our case. We never paid more than what we expected.

If you think VPS providers is an alternative to AWS, you have an entirely different use case than ours. For an application with high availability requirements, messages queues, scalable data store, etc. admin work is not "monthly backups". Implementing and maintaining highly available load balancing, message queues, data stores, DNS, auto scaling, etc. all require a lot of work, and often skills that you may not have in the team. AWS makes these tasks easier. You still have to do admin work, but much less of it, and don't have to be expert at each one. That's worth a lot.

berkay··on AWS Tips I Wish I'd Known Before I Started
Not sure why it has to be without EC2 to be useful. The main benefit is indeed the fact that you can have VMs, queue, load balancers, databases, DNS, cache, etc. all using consistent APIs, etc. You can create dev/test environments that are as close to prod as possible with fraction of the cost, etc.

In our case (and I'm pretty sure we're not in the fringe) when you consider all costs including the administrative overhead, etc. EC2 costs are not significant portion of the cost. Just to give an idea, for us, even if someone had offered VM hosting for free, it would not be cost effective for us to move. For a company that have very high processing requirements it could be a different story. I just wanted to mention that the value added by services in addition to EC2 is sufficiently high that even if EC2 costs are higher than alternative (and they are higher), AWS can still provide significant savings.

Time of a highly skilled dev/ops person is (very) valuable, and not something we can buy more of easily. Anything that saves us time, implement faster pays for itself pretty easily. If you don't have a massive EC2 bill, chances are AWS overall is a good proposition.

berkay··on AWS Tips I Wish I'd Known Before I Started
AWS != EC2. Do not assume that AWS is only used as VMs. It's different for everyone but AWS provides massive savings for many companies. It makes sense for many use cases in addition to elastic workloads.
berkay··on Amon.cx: New Server monitoring beta to compare with New Relic
Promising project but the New relic comparison is misguided. New Relic does have server monitoring but it's core strength is in application layer with agents for java, ruby, .net, python, php applications.
berkay··on Awful app review trend among Turkish users
He simply provided a data point, mentioned the sample size, and indicated their responses surprised him. There is no generalization, nothing indicating the conclusion of the sorts you mention. I'm baffled by your interpretation of his comment. "concluded that the whole population of Turkey are idiots?" What makes you think that?
berkay··on How Expedia Buys Its Way To The Top Of Google
Google does NOT only use the algorithm, and manually bans sits algorithm may have misses as it was in the case of RapGenius. I don't buy the argument that search results would be lonely, if Google somewhat punished Expedia for this, it would force them to change behavior. They would fall inline as well as others that may be using these questionable methods.
berkay··on How Expedia Buys Its Way To The Top Of Google
Martin, if what you're saying is true, that's very shady behavior on his part. However, it does not have any impact on what he's saying. Your post seems to say "yes big brands are doing it and can do it because they are brands, suck it up"

I don't think we should accept that same behavior should have different implications depending on who is doing it.

berkay··on AWS Activate
Porting to your infrastructure is not a simple task if you're using AWS services beyond EC2 (DynamoDB, SQS, etc.).

And I don't mean this as a criticism of AWS. We're happy users and have no plans to move off. Just don't underestimate the cost of moving.

berkay··on How to Raise Money
I can relate to most of what you're describing but wanted to point out that your business (any business) is a lot more than "core" of your business. If you're content with the rate of growth, you are already profitable or don't need additional funding etc. than you may not need the VCs. PG's essay repeatedly states not to raise money. But if you do want to make strategic investments, accelerate growth, etc. you will need to do many things that are outside the "core" of your business. In that case you may try to find VCs that have experience doing that, or at least can open doors for you so that you can find the right people to help you get there, etc.
berkay··on Homegrown DevOps Tools at Stack Exchange
"We don't really like the idea of cloud hosted monitoring" Can you elaborate on the reasons?
berkay··on How Technology Is Destroying Jobs
"allows us to go on to do more productive tasks" The idea only works as long as there are sufficient number of jobs in "more productive tasks". If jobs are destroyed but there is no place to deploy the resources gained by the productivity increase, then there is not much value, and there are many negative side effects.
berkay··on Hetzner Servers Compromised
Things seem to be getting worse there. A server we have there just went offline, and their management servers are not responding. I wonder it's part of the exploit or as a result of attempts to "fix" the problem
berkay··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
Not really what I refer to by robust media. I'd say 200+ private TV stations, hundreds of radio stations, 40+ national daily papers qualify to call it "robust". IMO high number of incarcerated journalists is more reflection on the government that ,though democratically elected, does not seem to understand you can't really have democracy without respecting individual rights and freedoms.
berkay··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
"A quick lookup shows that Erdoğan has been in office for the longest time since the 60s (three terms). To me, fears of Turkey becoming a de facto one-party state seems justified, at least absent any other information." You're on to something. One of the underlying reasons of the protests is not only Erdoğan has been in the office for a long time, but also secular sections of the society has lost hope of change of government within the political system (Opposition is in shambles, AKP will likely win the elections again, etc.) There is no political alternative within the system, hence the growing discontent manifests itself in other ways.
berkay··on What is Happening in Istanbul?
The protest to protect the park is nothing more than a trigger. In fact there are even reports that suggest that there is some misinformation and there is no currently approved project to build a shopping center. Still not clear what the facts are since media is not doing its job.

Initial protest was quite small and not many people paid attention to it until the police used ridiculous level of force to disperse the protesters. That's the action that triggered mass protests all over the country.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →