HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

betterunix2

3,500 karma · joined September 18, 2017

submissionscomments
betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
That is an absurdly broad reading of "crimes against peace," so much so that you are just diluting the meaning of "war crimes."
betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
I guess you and I must disagree. Either you think war crimes are no big deal, because according to your broad reading of "conspiracy against peace" pretty much anyone who participates in any war is a criminal, or else you think there is no justifiable war whatsoever. Personally I think WWII was entirely justified, that the Allies had to win that war, and that fighting to win meant that large numbers of people would die. I also believe that war crimes are a big deal and that it is wrong to conflate "war crimes" with "doing something wrong" or "participating in war I disagreed with" or "being on the wrong side of the war."
betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
That is not a war crime. Keep in mind that the Allies lied about all kinds of things during WWII in order to legitimize our involvement, and that we killed millions of people during the war. Countries always lie about war and people always die in war, those are just facts.
betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
"They did it too" was an acceptable defense at Nuremberg; Donitz was not sentenced for the specific crime of unrestricted submarine warfare because the Allies had done the same thing (the US in the Pacific). Iraq also lied to the UN many times.

Really though, this is a stupid comparison. People generally remember the Nuremberg trials in the context of the Holocaust -- genocide, slave labor, and all the horror that accompanied it. Colin Powell did nothing remotely close to any of that, and while there is plenty of criticism to throw at the US for the invasion of Iraq there was no genocide, no ethnic cleansing, no slave labor camps, and a dozen US soldiers were thrown in prison by the US for having tortured and humiliated prisoners under their command.

betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
He would have faded into obscurity and we would all be talking about how terrible his replacement was for lying to the UN.
betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
Is that really the standard for calling someone a war criminal? National leaders always lie about the reasons for war, whether they are the attackers or the defenders.

No doubt that Colin Powell did the wrong thing when he lied to the UN, but let's not throw around the term "war criminal" to mean "someone who did the wrong thing."

betterunix2··on Colin Powell has died
RIP.

This is very sad news. I personally disagreed with many of his actions, especially the Iraq/WMD story, but even so I had a lot of respect for him.

betterunix2··on Netflix's new player breaks the ability to modify the seeking of a playing video
I have been that engineer on occasion, though not specifically with regard to DRM. The pushback has typically been something like, "There is too much money on the line," or even, "If we are not setting the standard on this, someone else will, and it will probably be even worse."

In the end, work is not voluntary for the majority of engineers involved in these things, and so you just have to accept that you are not going to win the argument unless you have a good argument that what you are being asked to build is not possible. Engineers often speak of how DRM is basically impossible, but that is only true in an ideal world; in practice DRM is good enough to satisfy business needs and concerns about web openness have yet to materialize (at least in a way that would undermine the business case for it). The relatively small number of hardware and software platforms one must deal with now further weakens the arguments against DRM.

betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
You may not approve of Biden's job so far, but Trump's presidency was on an entirely different level of bad. Trump's failure to fully divest himself of his business interests left doubts about the intention of every decision he made. Trump's administration was filled with criminals. Trump managed to drag white nationalism from the fringes of society into the Republican mainstream and even had white nationalists and their sympathizers working in his administration. A good argument can be made that Trump led and continues to lead a fascist political movement -- Trumpism exhibits all of the characteristics than define fascism and the argument is mainly one of degree.

There are plenty of things to criticize Biden over, and I am sure that people with conservative points of view are not big fans of his various policies. However, we can at least go to sleep confident that we will not wake up to news that the President had tweeted some radical shift in US policy that blindsided his entire staff and administration. I would love to hear people criticize Biden for policy decisions -- the fact that Biden has a well-defined policy agenda to criticize is itself a huge improvement.

betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
The right's story has generally been that people should get the vaccine if they want to because "freedom." Trump literally said this in front of crowds of his vaccine-hesitant supporters. Prominent Republicans like Rand Paul are going around casting doubt on the credibility of Dr. Fauci and the CDC/NIH, and Republicans have done nothing to address the tidal wave of conspiracy theories making rounds among their constituents.

Get back to me when Trump gets on stage at some rally and says, "Anyone who thinks the vaccine makes them magnetic is a moron." Republicans are free to call it a Trump vaccine if they are saying, "Real Patriots do what their country needs, and getting the Trump Vaccine is what we need Real Patriots to do." If that is what it would take to convince people to get the shot I have no objection. Unfortunately I am not seeing that happen; instead what I see are non-committal statements, shouts of "freedom!" and Republican governors preventing local leaders from imposing mask or vaccine mandates in their states.

betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
That was done in response to concerns that Trump was trying to push the FDA to approve the vaccines faster to serve his own political ambitions:

https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/03/politics/white-house-fda-coro...

https://apnews.com/article/donald-trump-business-mark-meadow...

Moreover, Gov. Newsom's statements did not say that the vaccines were unsafe; he simply said that he was establishing an independent panel of scientists to evaluate the same evidence that the FDA evaluated. At no point did he say that people should seek ivermectim or hydroxychloroquin or that people should just rely on natural immunity.

Even if Newsom did the wrong thing here, it is a far cry from the Republicans, who have pushed the narrative that people should feel no specific obligation to get vaccinated because of "freedom." Trump has stood before crowds of vaccine-hesitant supporters and said, "Get the shot if you want to." Republican governors have echoed that sentiment. The results speak for themselves: Democrats have higher vaccination rates and Democrat-leaning areas have lower infection and lower hospitalization rates compared to Republicans.

betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
No, the Gallup poll says 12% Americans say they trust Congress. People say they do not trust politicians, but the fact is that when politicians speak people listen. Politicians know this and that is why they always give soundbite-oriented remarks and lines of questioning in their various hearings and "debates."
betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
People tend to mistrust government experts when politicians tell them to mistrust government experts. Republicans who say they do not trust the CDC on COVID have no such doubts about the DEA, whose decisions on drug policy are just blindly trusted, simply because Republican leaders have told everyone not to trust the CDC. People do not simply draw their own conclusions; like it or not, everyone is influenced by the people around them and people tend to line up behind their leaders.
betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
Censorship is not what causes large numbers of US citizens to refuse this vaccine. If the Republicans in leadership positions took this seriously from the start and did not go around casting doubt on vaccination far more people would get the vaccine. If the previous president had not politicized the response to COVID and had simply told his followers to do what the CDC says we would have many millions more people getting the vaccine (and for the matter, hundreds of thousands of people would still be alive).

Don't let the Republicans off the hook. This should never have been a political issue, but Republican leaders at every level of government made this political and continue to politicize the pandemic.

betterunix2··on Covid lesson: trust the public with hard truths
...are you not counting HIV as a recent major pandemic? SARS? MERS?

It is also worth remembering that for decades we have been carefully monitoring the spread of infectious diseases to prevent major pandemics from forming. There was no political controversy surrounding those efforts prior to COVID19, not in the US or anywhere else.

betterunix2··on Beware Centralization
Ehh...

It sounds nice in theory, but in practice I suspect such a regulation would at best accomplish nothing and at worst would be a disaster. How do you even define a "social network?" The regulation would either be too broad and wind up covering the comments section of HN, or too narrow and easy to evade. In all likelihood the outcome would be similar to GDPR -- the big companies that inspire it would have little difficulty with compliance while startups would find it that much harder to compete.

betterunix2··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
Yeah, because in the USA nobody ever instituted vaccine mandates until COVID happened. Oh wait, sorry, I forgot about all the vaccines we require children to receive before they can go to school.
betterunix2··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
"That "vaccine granted immunity" was a big one, it rapidly became less symptoms, and from that surreptitiously changed again to well you'll still have a week of feeling like shit if you catch covid, but you'll be less likely to die from it."

The world changed between the beginning of vaccine availability and today. New variants emerged from unvaccinated populations and some of those variants (Delta being the most prominent currently being reported) are able to evade the immune response generated by the vaccine (breakthrough infections). The guidance was updated to reflected newly available information -- would you prefer that the CDC ignore new data and just stick with its initial statements?

The reason we are far from normalcy is that since the beginning of this pandemic people have been refusing to do what they need to do to slow the spread. If people had done what health officials asked, we might have been closer to normalcy. Take your complaints to all those right-wing extremists in the media and the government who politicized a public health crisis and who continue to tell people to ignore the CDC.

betterunix2··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
...where is the false statement? Fauci gave one estimate, then gave another more conservative estimate in an attempt to encourage people to get the vaccine. At no point did he give a number out of the range supported by the available data.

Calling that "purposefully lying" is ridiculous. People who have to present a single number to summarize an entire body of scientific research for the general public always have to make a decision about how conservative of an estimate to give.

betterunix2··on YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking all anti-vaccine content
Closing schools and so forth was part of the flatten-the-curve effort. Really though, the CDC has been driven by the available science and by the reality of the pandemic, and when the CDC's guidance has changed it has invariably been in response to new data on COVID or to changing conditions (e.g. community spread, N95 mask availability, new variants).

It is overly generous to speak of "one side" as if there is another equally valid side to compare with. The CDC is not a political institution and they always cite published research in their guidance and public statements about COVID-19. The anti-mask/anti-vax crowd are going around spreading one fantasy after another, coming up with new and ever more outrageous conspiracy theories and excuses for refusing to cooperate; none of their claims have ever been based in reality, and that is why the story changes on a daily basis and why there are so many contradictory claims being made.

To put this in perspective, the high-level direction of the CDC's guidance has, since the very beginning of the pandemic, been to reduce the rate at which COVID spreads; the changes in their guidance have been about the details. The anti-mask/anti-vax crowd has gone from denying that there is a virus to saying that the virus is no worse than the flu to claiming that masks would suffocate them to whining about how mask mandates violate to their freedom and that they would rather die of COVID than comply with a mask mandate. They went from heaping praise on the last President simply because he was in office when the vaccines were first becoming available to complaining that the current President was being given too much credit for the vaccination effort to claiming that the vaccine is made from aborted fetuses, that the vaccine alters DNA, that Bill Gates inserted microchips into the vaccine, that the vaccine causes people to become magnetized, and that vaccine mandates are proof that the vaccine is the "mark of the beast."

betterunix2··on U.S. to open program to replace Huawei equipment in U.S. networks
The concept of "intellectual property" is a novel myth circulated by the industries that benefit from it, and it always has been. There was a time before copyrights, and I personally think we are already living in a post-copyright age (and, for all their complaining, the major copyright industries seem to agree -- why else pursue things like DRM?). Some future generation is going to be scratching their heads trying to figure out why this current generation wasted so much time, effort, and money trying to stop everyone from using the most effective copying machines ever conceived of to make copies of things.
betterunix2··on U.S. to open program to replace Huawei equipment in U.S. networks
Well, you can buy from European companies like Ericsson if you want to avoid the US and China. Really though, it might be worth bringing your complaints to the European Parliament, which has allowed the EU's tech sector to stagnate almost to the point of irrelevance.
betterunix2··on U.S. to open program to replace Huawei equipment in U.S. networks
So what? The government of China also maintains a network of roads, just like the US. By narrowing your focus you can always find ways that the US is "just like China."

Of course, right now, in the 21st century, the government of China is using its various powers to, among other things, send its citizens who members of a particular minority ethnic group to concentration camps. Criticize the US all you want, but the US government are not rounding people up, torturing them, and then forcing them to work in jobs the government picked out for them. The US does plenty of awful things, sometimes as part of its official policies, but it is still a far cry for the sort of things that the CCP is doing.

betterunix2··on Apple shareholder resolution calls for company to support right to repair
"I'm completely fine monetarily with tossing a phone in the garbage if it breaks and getting a new one"

Maybe. There are non-economic reasons to consider repair instead of replacement, or there would be if repair was a feasible option. For example, maybe someone feels a moral obligation to reduce the demand for tantalum (or to not personally add to it):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_minerals

Apple has basically thrown their hands up and said, "It's just too hard to keep Congolese tantalum out of the supply chain." Meanwhile, their products are hard to repair and encourage people to just buy replacements (and thus consume more tantalum, some of which is paying for the worst war crimes imaginable)...

betterunix2··on The Buffett Indicator
On the other hand it is not likely that interest rates will remain this low for very long. How much money can be poured into 30 year bonds with less than a 2% coupon rate? How long will the Fed continue its asset purchase program? How much more supply can be added to the bond market before demand begins to run out? One way or another interest rates will begin to rise, and then the stock market will be forced to correct.

We have had a 40 year bull market in bonds, but that is almost certainly coming to an end. There is just no more room for that bull to run.

betterunix2··on OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or test workforce
The president does not have the legal authority to make such a general mandate. Congress might be able to do so, but congress works slowly and this needs to happen as soon as possible.

Like it or not, that is the system we have in the US.

betterunix2··on OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or test workforce
That's right, but the fact is that the president's goal is to get everyone who can receive the vaccine to be vaccinated. He lacks the authority to issue a simple vaccine mandate for everyone and is just doing what he does have the authority to do. The vaccine is not just about workplace safety and people who work from home should still get the shot.
betterunix2··on New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
Actually the relationship between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force is well understood. It would have to be related, given that the weak interaction is the cause of beta decay, which results in a neutron becoming a proton (which has a positive electromagnetic charge) and the creation of an electron (which has a negative charge). The force carrying particles of the weak force can also have electromagnetic charge, further demonstrating the connection between the two phenomena.

You can reason about all the forces being related in some way. For example, beta decay happens in free neutrons, but does not happen in a helium-4 nucleus; there should be a connection with the strong nuclear force that explains this. In some sense the fact that we can observe or measure an interaction implies that it must be related to other forces, since our ability to make an observation is itself dependent on such connections (in the end you need some electromagnetic effect that your eyes can perceive).

betterunix2··on New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
Are you asking if a photon is a particle or a wave? It is widely known to be something that our brains have trouble understanding, since it behaves as both at the same time. Thus, "shut up and calculate!" as the response when students try to figure out what quantum physics "means."
betterunix2··on New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
It is certainly possible. What we think of as a long timescale for the age of the universe may be very short in some future epoch where the fundamental forces further split, just as we see the epoch of electroweak unification as being short.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →