HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

betterunix2

3,500 karma · joined September 18, 2017

submissionscomments
betterunix2··on New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
That is the big question in physics today! There is the hypothetical "graviton" which, as you should expect, has zero mass. There are theoretical problems due to the poorly understood interaction of general relativity and quantum mechanics -- if you could resolve those problems you would have a "theory of everything."
betterunix2··on OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or test workforce
...nevermind all the other people you interact with in your life.
betterunix2··on OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or test workforce
How much was required for mandatory polio vaccination? MMR? Smallpox?

Vaccine requirements have been commonplace for decades now, and society has greatly benefited from it.

betterunix2··on OSHA to require employers with 100 employees vaccinate or test workforce
"the vaccine doesn't prevent spread"

Citation needed. This contradicts the most recent research and information available, and all one must do is a quick search to turn up dozens of published papers on this topic. The vaccine reduces the transmission of COVID, and that is an important public health goal.

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
COVID vaccination may have become a political position, but vaccination in general is not. Where are all the debates about MMR, hep-B, polio, etc.? We have required vaccinations in our children beginning in infancy for generations, and I am not hearing any governors or representatives saying that we must end the practice.
betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Citation needed? A quick search turns up study after study from one country after another finding that COVID vaccines both reduce the rate of infection and reduce the rate of transmission even with the delta variant.

You are right that people are overstating what the vaccine does, and that is where politicians actually have a chance to do something useful. Unfortunately there is a major political party that is doing the opposite, spreading false information, and shouting about "freedom" while working to stop local leaders from taking action...

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
For comparison the flu shot prevents infection in about 60% of people who receive it. The point is not to prevent infection in every single person who receives the shot, it is to prevent infection in or transmission from enough people that the virus will not spread from person to person.

Vaccination is not a political position in the US. We require children to receive numerous vaccines from infancy onward and that policy is broadly supported across the political spectrum, and has been for generations now. Where are all those political debates about the polio vaccine, or MMR, or hep B etc.? All I hear are crickets...

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Every other vaccine you have received was meant to protect the population you live in (which includes yourself); sorry, but you thought wrong.

As for hospital bed utilization, maybe you would be less dismissive if you took a trip to Idaho and got into a car accident:

https://healthandwelfare.idaho.gov/news/idaho-activates-cris...

Broken arm? Not life-threatening, here's some pain killers, go away and let us deal with these COVID patients.

Or maybe, "This one has less than a 10% chance of survival. Let him die, we need to focus on saving people who are more likely to make it."

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Ah yes, science, always being updated with new information. So unreliable! Let's stick with ranting of random people on the Internet, who have definitely not changed their story from "there is no virus" to "Bill Gates put microchips in the vaccine" to "the vaccine makes people magnetic" to "the vaccine turns people into lizards..."
betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
No, the unvaccinated population, where the virus keeps being replicated, breeds variants of all kinds; the vaccinated population applies selection pressure that favors vaccine resistance. If the entire population is vaccinated variants would not emerge at all because the virus would not spread from person to person (and would eventually disappear from the population).
betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Citation needed, because that contradicts the CDC's guidance:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br...

"people fully vaccinated with an mRNA vaccine (Pfizer-BioNTech or Moderna) are less likely than unvaccinated persons to acquire SARS-CoV-2 or to transmit it to others"

emphasis mine

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Yes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_infection#By_dise...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity

Do not think in terms of "your vaccine," because vaccines are about preventing the spread of a disease within a population.

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
That is not how vaccines or diseases work. Vaccines are never 100% effective at preventing infections or at preventing people from having to go to the ER. One vaccinated person surrounded by unvaccinated people will eventually contract the virus. A large unvaccinated population also breeds new variants, eventually resulting in vaccine-resistant variants that put those who are vaccinated in danger.

The fact is that a particularly vulnerable person is better off surrounded by vaccinated people even if they themselves are unvaccinated than if they are vaccinated but surrounded by unvaccinated people. This is a good and long overdue policy that should be widely replicated wherever vaccine supply permits.

betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
...that is why I could never be a libertarian. People have repeatedly proved themselves unwilling or unable to live up to the libertarian ideal of behaving "rationally."
betterunix2··on Biden to mandate coronavirus vaccine for federal workers
Vaccination is not a political position. Vaccines only work if a large majority of people are vaccinated and people who refuse to receive the shot are putting everyone else in danger. A basic function of a government is to protect public safety, and that is what a vaccine mandate does.
betterunix2··on 20 years after 9/11: Will we ever stop taking our shoes off at airports?
The only parallels are between COVID conspiracy theorists and 9/11 conspiracy theorists. Nearly all federal COVID guidance from the CDC has been well-reasoned and carefully balances public health goals with the reality of life in America. State and local measures have been questionable, but all that says is that state and local governments are not really up to the task and should have universally deferred to the CDC.
betterunix2··on 20 years after 9/11: Will we ever stop taking our shoes off at airports?
The fact that the shoe rule does not apply to precheck speaks volumes about how arbitrary it is...
betterunix2··on Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone (2016)
Universities, especially in Europe, base hiring and tenure decisions in part on where a researcher's papers are published. A paper published on arxiv has less value to advancing one's career than one published in a journal run by a well-known academic publisher.

This also makes it hard for researchers to organize their own journals, separate from the publishers. Many universities (again, particularly in Europe) use the publishing company as a proxy for the quality of a journal, rather than letting researchers within a field make that determination on their own. Thus researchers are forced to stick with the exploitative publishing companies because universities demand it, despite spending most of their time reading and sharing preprint copies of papers.

betterunix2··on Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone (2016)
"Generally I like supporting people's hard work"

You did not support anyone's hard work. The researchers who wrote the paper receive none of the money paid to publishing companies, nor do the peer reviewers, and sometimes not even the editors (and in my experience, paid editors from Springer introduce more errors than they fix).

Before the Internet, before TeX and related tools, those fees were needed to cover the cost of printing copies journals and shipping them to libraries. Prior to the 1970s academic publishers were typically run by universities and charged only break-even fees, and few complained because there was no better alternative that could effectively spread academic research around. Then a bunch of commercial publishers began eyeing academic journals (probably because they knew they would never have to pay the authors) and from the 1980s onward academic publishing has been for-profit. Instead of going away when the Internet rendered printed journals obsolete, these companies have instead opted to not print most journals and charge fees for online access.

betterunix2··on Who's downloading pirated papers? Everyone (2016)
I doubt the EU will take the lead on such a thing; the EU has a lot less tolerance for new technologies upending traditional institutions than the US. European universities basically require professors to publish in journals owned by a handful of publishing companies, which has served to cement the power of those publishers (American universities tend to be a little more open minded about new publishing models in my experience). I have heard European researchers complain that people were citing the arxiv version of their papers rather than the "official" version -- it made it harder for them to advance their careers.
betterunix2··on The Worst Businessman of the 18th Century BC (2018)
They did not truly use the same script the entire time. Like all writing systems the script did change as people simplified characters for their own convenience and as spoken (and thus written) language changed. New characters were added over time and old characters fell out of use. Cuneiform originally developed from commonly used pictograms that were used for various purposes (accounting, identification, etc.) but were not "true" writing.

Same thing happened in China and Mesoamerica. The degree to which people were aware of the change in the characters is debatable, but there was certainly some awareness among the scribes and elites in later centuries (e.g. the Talmud records a debate about the Hebrew writing system). I suspect that at least the elites of Mesopotamia knew that the system had changed because they had access to much older tablets than what they themselves were producing. At a minimum they knew that the language had changed, since they were literate in both ancient Sumerian and whatever the common language of their city was (Akkadian, Elamite, etc.), and they likely recognized regional variations in the characters on tablets they received from other cities.

betterunix2··on Dutch entrepreneurs avoiding negative interest by opening multiple bank accounts
The economic consequences of deflation are very destruction. Cash may become more valuable, but a prolonged economic contract will leave you with less to buy with that cash.
betterunix2··on Dutch entrepreneurs avoiding negative interest by opening multiple bank accounts
"assuming one is fortunate enough to have enough income to even have savings"

This cannot be overstated enough. In the USA a myth has developed about "personal responsibility" in which people have a choice, they can save for retirement or they can spend their money on other things; we tend to forget that for roughly half the country there is no such choice because just paying for basic living expenses (food, shelter, clothing, and transportation to a job) will leave nothing to save. People bought the myth and allowed defined-benefit pension plans to be replaced by IRAs and 401k plans.

"Which cause the rich to get richer, and the poor get poorer."

The rich should get richer if they are compounding their investment returns over time. The problem is that for more than 40 years America has been in the grip of politicians who have attacked government programs of all kinds, insisting that we cannot afford to pay for anything that benefits the poor while also insisting that we have to cut taxes on the rich (naturally, the tax cuts also benefit those very politicians). The fact that the poor cannot invest (for lack of capital) is not the reason they are getting poorer; they are getting poorer because for decades we have reduced the scale and scope of government programs that benefit the poor (or that benefit everyone equally).

betterunix2··on Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed
"a hard requirement to keep the lights on around the world"

That is a bad example of what we need the petroleum industry for. A combination of wind, solar, hydroelectric, and nuclear power could meet the world's electricity needs for many decades to come, especially as we have become so much more efficient with our electricity use compared to previous decades. The very link you provided states, "Globally, fossil fuels account for a much smaller share of electricity production than the energy system as a whole."

The bigger challenges are transportation (especially airplanes and cargo ships) and the chemicals industry, where oil is much harder to replace. Electric cars and trains are doable with sufficient infrastructure investment, but for cargo ships the only real alternative right now is nuclear power, and I am not sure we have any viable alternatives for air transport as we know it.

betterunix2··on Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/19/climate/koch-brothers-pub...

That is not "just responding to demand," it is actively working to inflate demand. Oil companies have worked hard for decades to keep people in their cars, including participating in the conspiracy to dismantle electric streetcar lines across America (along with GM and several tire manufacturers). You say we need to make oil less competitive, but oil companies are actively working against efforts to do so.

betterunix2··on Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed
There is a better solution: the government reins in corporations that are creating a problem for the world. Once upon a time that was a non-controversial idea.
betterunix2··on Big oil coined ‘carbon footprints’ to blame us for their greed
"the longstanding culture war between left and right"

...by which you must mean the "culture war" that only the right wing seems to know or care about. It is not really "between" the left and right as much as it is a right-wing concept that people on the left almost universally roll their eyes at (or fall into the trap of actually responding to right-wing agitation).

"Neither side has to do any thinking"

Except that, as you point out, one side is responding to scientific results indicating a serious and growing problem, while the other is not. One side is thinking, or at worst dependent on a group of people who at least try to push their personal biases out of the way when they are thinking. The other side reflexively calls all of it some combination of "socialist," "hoax," or "government takeover," without even acknowledging the existence of a problem.

Yes, I know the downvotes are coming for this, but the fact is that the Republican party has stopped even trying. You can be pro-oil-company and also be pro-reducing-carbon-emissions. Where are the Republican proposals to develop industrial-scale carbon capture to offset all those tailpipe and smokestack emissions? Carbon capture could have been an entirely new industry for oil companies to expand into, growing their businesses while reducing net carbon emissions. Instead Republicans lined up behind someone who declared climate change to be a Chinese hoax and stopped even suggesting alternatives to the Democrats' proposed solutions.

betterunix2··on Apple’s crackdown on multicast
Coming soon: developers are restricted to using AppleTalk, special permission required for IP networking...
betterunix2··on Moderna Is About to Begin Trials for HIV Vaccine
A person with HIV will actually be infected by multiple variants simultaneously, since the virus mutates rapidly within a single host (tons of variants will be produced in a single day). So, even though the immune system will fight the virus and produce antibodies, the virus stays one step ahead. That also means that a person will not develop long-term immunity after being exposed to the live virus (and can even be infected multiple times with different variants and strains), and is the main challenge with developing an HIV vaccine.

I am no expert but my understanding is that AIDS occurs when a variant targeting receptors more specific to CD4 T-cells begins replicating (or begins replicating at too high a rate), which results in T-cell counts falling below some threshold. So a person will go through an extended period without feeling any symptoms, possibly transmitting the virus to others (hence the importance of widespread, easy access to testing), only to be incapacitated by AIDS later when the "balance" of the variants changes (assuming they do not receive HIV-suppressing medications).

betterunix2··on Moderna Is About to Begin Trials for HIV Vaccine
Actually the immune system does fight HIV during the acute infection stage after a person is first exposed, and antibodies are generated. The immune response to HIV is what does most of the damage to the immune system, since a typical immune response to virus infection involves the destruction of infected cells. HIV infects certain immune cells, which will either self-destruct when the infection is detected or will be destroyed by other immune cells.
← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →