HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bh42222

1,273 karma · joined May 6, 2011

submissionscomments
bh42222··on Agile: 5 years later and you're still doing it wrong
This implies discipline and Agile (big 'A') are mutually exclusive.

No, I would say big 'A' brings discipline, but if you already have tons of discipline, it can't add any more.

bh42222··on Agile: 5 years later and you're still doing it wrong
Sadly Agile has indeed jumped the shark.

I have always seen Agile as a way to fight the Waterfall process. Another way to see it is to add professionalism and discipline to companies who don't have things like unit testing, code reviews, etc.

In his long write up Steve made two points which I think are the most important:

1. Waterfall is known to be bad; I hope we can just that as an axiom today.

I added the emphasis on 'hope'. I hope so too, but I'm afraid the end of Agile might mean the triumphant return of Waterfall.

2. Google is an exceptionally disciplined company, from a software-engineering perspective. They take things like unit testing, design documents and code reviews more seriously than any other company I've even heard about. They work hard to keep their house in order at all times, and there are strict rules and guidelines in place that prevent engineers and teams from doing things their own way. The result: the whole code base looks the same, so switching teams and sharing code are both far easier than they are at other places.

Google sounds like an exceptionally disciplined software-engineering company indeed! This to me implies they do NOT need Agile.

Why would you introduce something designed to professionalize software-engineering to a company which is super disciplined and professional? You wouldn't! The only thing you can introduce is bullshit like 8:00 AM meetings. No wonder Steve hates Agile so much.

But again, everything he says about it being an infomercial and aimed at stupid people is true. But it is still a God send if this meme virus infects a death march plagued Waterfall process which does not use unit testing or even has source control.

Now why would a good developer be suck in such a place? Well maybe you live in an area where there is not a lot of tech. industry and jobs. Maybe you live there because all your family and friends are from there. Maybe your child has severe asthma and you can't afford to leave the gold plated health insurance plan from your corporate job in a non-software company that's big enough to have a software department.

I can't quite imagine how Agile could help a company like Google. But I know how it can be a great benefit to much less disciplined companies.

And I really do fear that the end of Agile means the return of Waterfall. Because Waterfall intuitively makes sense to people who don't understand software engineering. And there are a lot of them outside of silicon valley.

And Waterfall doesn't just plague obscure places with no tradition of technology. The US north east, home to MIT, IBM and formerly DEC, Waterfall has always been big out here too, and it's not because we're not smart.

bh42222··on Sloppy Reporting on the Self Driving Car
Right. But I want my car to drive me to work and back while I sleep or read. But to get there I think first business must commercialize it through their simple desire to increase profits, then it may become cheap and accessible enough for average Joes like me.

When you require two people with a driver's license in the car at all times you kill any profitable commercial reason to use self-driving cars. And that to me is a huge mistake.

Commuting to work (if you drive > 2 0minutes at highway speeds) is probably the most dangerous thing by far that all of us do on any given day.

Distracted drivers, drunk drivers, sleepy drivers (like me!) this is why we need self-driving cars.

But I think the path to mass use of self-driving cars goes through commercial use of self-driving cars.

bh42222··on Sloppy Reporting on the Self Driving Car
That would restrict it to big business.

But the requirement that two drivers need to be in the car will restrict it to no one who wants to invest in it to be more profitable.

Right now this is simply for experimentation and I wonder who'd drop one million dollars just to experiment?

bh42222··on Sloppy Reporting on the Self Driving Car
They are only hard to support from advertising.

For any service which requires payment for access to the information, said information tends to be hard. Blomberg news and the Wallstreet Journal, are examples for this in terms of financial news.

bh42222··on Nevada approves regulations for self-driving cars
Of course, you could also just take a taxi.

Oh it will be a taxi all right, just not driven by a human...

bh42222··on What Craigslist Did Right: User Management Without Usernames or Passwords
Scribd over-complicating things since they used PDFs to display text.

I just visited their site again, I'm not exactly sure what they are using now, it does look good, but my god is it slow on my low end machine.

I am not surprised to hear they are needlessly complicating session tracking as well.

bh42222··on The 'Undue Weight' of Truth on Wikipedia
Wikipedia recreates all the limitations of a physical set of encyclopedias. This includes doing a sort of OK job of summarizing relevant facts.

This is a limitation for physical encyclopedias because paper, and even more so shelf space, are expensive so some facts have to be prioritized over others. And you can't easily make corrections to a book after it is printed and sold, and since research never stops a paper encyclopedia will frequently be out of date, thus it can never be that accurate - so why expend a ton effort to make it more accurate in the first place?

Electronic encyclopedias, like Wikipedia, don't have the same inherent limitations. Wikipedia just happens to have re-created them for the same reason electronic calendars by default show you one month at a time, even on the 30th and 31st, rather than a chunk of next and last months.

The reason so many people are so motivated to complain about Wikipedia and all it's limitation is because everyone intuitively can sense there ought to be a better way.

1. Notability of facts is a red herring. Text is easy to compress and storage space is cheap.

2. The need to summarize topics is a red herring. Having a summary "front page", or "top", or "above the fold" etc, combined with more in depth, detailed sections, is a standard way of organizing information on the web. An electronic encyclopedia really ought to use that kind of presentation strategy.

3. Primary sources, new research and minority opinions would naturally be part of the lengthy, detailed version of a topic.

And if you want to go completely crazy you could do things like allow voting. Allow people to sort what the default view is by general popularity.

Even crazier, sort by popularity based on experts opinion, work out a way for experts to electronically sign or approve articles, and allow people to choose a set of "experts".

Go totally bonkers and verify the experts so that someone could choose to see the top evolution articles as rated by Richard Dawkins.

Or alternatively re-crate all the limitations of a physical set of encyclopedias.

bh42222··on Fun with analytics: pitting Hacker News and /r/programming against each other
The original reddit, the one where pg article still made it on the top of the one and only front page, replaced Slashdot for me.

Once reddit was taken over by trolls, HN replaced reddit.

And now, it's HN with a small selection of sub-reddits with tiny and/or strictly moderated communities.

bh42222··on Unix as IDE
For autocomplete, I don't know enough about vi or vim, but emacs has it:

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1616753/make-emacs-semant...

For refactoring, that's just an advanced text across many files manipulation feature, and emacs certainly can do it, but you might have to work on your .emacs file.

The numerous other things sound like either things you can do in gdb or valgrind, or again just advanced text search/editing.

Now all of this is not elegantly pulled together. You need to create this for yourself, make all these tools work together by developing a development environment for yourself. But once you do, you may be surprised just how elegantly everything works together.

bh42222··on How a big movie studio (unfairly) forced a student to give up his senior thesis
Uhmm... what were the lawsuits about before he dropped his insurance? Parachute not opening?
bh42222··on The Senate’s SOPA Counterattack?
Don't forget:

The Constitution doesn’t constrain private actors, of course. This language would immunize them from liability under any and all regulation and under state or common law. Private actors would not be subject to suit for breaching contractual promises of confidentiality. They would not be liable for violating the privacy torts. Anything goes so long as one can make a claim to defending “information systems,” a term that refers to anything having to do with computers.

Elsewhere, the bill creates an equally sweeping immunity against law-breaking so long as the law-breaking provides information to a “cybersecurity exchange.”

bh42222··on Double Fine Adventure
I know reddit has a "cool story bro" meme, which means the opposite. But this IS a cool story!
bh42222··on Star Trek as a purely symbolic artifact of past times
I would be very surprised to find dog fighting in most of Western Europe. (The UK might have some)

But in Eastern Europe, sure.

bh42222··on How to Succeed as an Introvert
Well if you're shy enough it will stymie your social life. Also it has nothing to do with introversion.

But I think the OP's point is that "introvert" now means anyone who could be either, shy, or socially anxious, or any number of other things.

I remember not that long ago the on-line geeky community embraced Asperger syndrome as an excuse for lacking social skills, or being socially anxious, or forever alone, etc. People who clearly did not have it claimed they had a "light" version of it. Other people called them on it, fortunately that meme did not sick.

But the all my social awkwardness is due to me being an introvert (when in fact you could very well be an social super awkward extrovert) meme is sticking.

That's too bad for those who are not socially awkward at all, but are introverts. But oh well. We just need to invent a new term which will not be co-opted by every shy and socially rough extrovert who thinks she's an introvert because he doesn't have enough friends or enough recognition at work.

bh42222··on Mapping the Road Ahead for Autonomous Cars
Yep, actually driving the car yourself becomes a purely vanity activity.

Except when you build shelves in your garage rather than buying cheap ones at the store, you could actually build better shelves than reasonable money can buy. But it's hard to imagine even the most talented and dedicated hobby driver outracing a computer.

Future car games will have to be set either in the past (horses are very important if cars have not been invented yet) or in some kind of special human drivers only scenario.

We still have equestrian events in the Olympics, so F1 as a human drivers only future equivalent of antiquated transportation based competition?

bh42222··on Mapping the Road Ahead for Autonomous Cars
Autonomous cars don't drink, or text, or sleep, or get distracted, etc.

Any politician against autonomous cars should be attacked for being for more death on the roads thanks to alcohol, texting, sleep deprivation, old age, etc. Call them pro-murder in an attack ad during an election and we'll have legal autonomous cars everywhere in no time.

Speaking of autonomous cars don't drink and drive, why isn't MAD lobbying for autonomous cars as hard as they can? And where are the insurance companies on this? Don't the see dollar signs when the think of just how much mass autonomous car use could reduce accidents and injuries?

bh42222··on Stack Exchange: How does noise affect programmer productivity?
Peopleware is a book every software manager should read.

And ALL mangers I have worker for in large corporations had read it, but it did not matter! Noise and cubicles everywhere!

So my question, is how do we prove to a majority of large companies that noise negative affects their bottom line?

bh42222··on Too Young to Fail
I can't help but cheer for any kid (yes, I'm old, so they are all kids) who takes Peter Thiel's offer.

Laura Deming is especially easy to cheer for, as she's working on age extension. (Did I mention I'm old?)

It's great to hear she's meeting with other investors as biotech has always suffered from high capitol requirements. Super science ain't cheap. I really, really hope this sparks a fire in Silicon Valley for funding biotech startups.

The other major thing biotech startups suffer form is regulation. It's just so SLOW and expensive to approve any new drug, device or treatment.

I am not sure if regulation can be "hacked". My only advice is to mention industrial and veterinary biotech, were a lot of advances can be made much, much quicker. Life extension for dogs and cats, why not.

bh42222··on Harvard, Princeton Targeted in Asian Discrimination Probe
For example, are there proportionally more Google employees from Caltech or more startups in YCombinator with Caltech graduates?

Since they are all based in California now, I would think yes. But since Larry and Sergey Bin are both from Stanford, I'd expect a disproportionate number of Stanford grads at Google.

In any case, one way universities market themselves is by looking at the average income of their alumni. Since Harvard grads often end up on Wall Street, I would not be surprised if Harvard comes up on top.

But you could argue that's just the financial industry connection. What if you restrict your search on science and engineering majors? Well then we already know MIT and Caltech are better.

bh42222··on White House Refuses To Comment On Petition To Investigate Chris Dodd
The very last part covers potential solutions, none of which have a great chance of success due to the vested interests but should be tried anyway

What happens if we try them all and they (as expected) do not succeed?

If they don't have a great chance of success, why can't we find other solutions?

bh42222··on White House Refuses To Comment On Petition To Investigate Chris Dodd
The fact that it's a whole book makes me nervous.

A strategy which requires a whole book to be explained sounds like giving up on anything simple and claiming we can go through 1001 non-radical steps to eventually get to a happy place.

This to me is a form of denial. You realize simple solutions can not be practically implemented and you convince yourself a marathon of tiny changes is the way to go.

(Disclaimer: I have not read that book.)

bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
The lack of diversity I am talking about does not come from averaging a large number, but from the fact that unlike Mississippi, all of Japan, Canada and the EU have very high standards of living, nationalized health care, and very extensive social safety nets, as well as very high education levels.

Simply put you and I have different definitions of culture.

To me GDP, GNP, level of education, standard of living, etc, are all economic measures, which are indeed numerical and thus trivially easy to compare.

But my definition of culture includes, language, national identity, customs (this is very different from laws), holidays, music, rituals, food, etc.

And I would argue that those things don't change even as GDP and standard of living go through revolutionary levels of change.

Prime example: Ireland.

For a very long time Ireland was one of the poor, agricultural nations of Europe. Then legal and tax changes were introduced and a few years later people were talking about the Celtic tiger, and English laborers were going to work in Ireland for the first time ever. And even now after the real estate bubble has burst, modern Ireland is astronomically far away from potato famine Ireland in terms of GDP and standard of living.

But culturally it is mostly still the same.

China before communism, China after the economic reforms in the 1970s, China today, all economically VERY differently. Culturally there's been big changes too, but not nearly as huge as the economic ones.

Right before Thatcher, Britain's economy was so bad, predictions had it reaching Albanian levels of prosperity in a decade or two. How culturally different is Britannia of that time compared to Tony Blair's cool Britannia of the booming 90s?

So Massachusetts and Mississippi are very different in terms of GDP, education and median income. But to me they are both obviously American. That's very different from Holland and France, or the UK and Holland, or France and Spain. While the GDP there is much closer, they are very, very different cultures.

Let's do a thought experiment:

You go to Holland and try to grok how to live there. You have an iPhone translation app that can translate text you take pictures of and voices it hears. You use that to make your way, pick up some Dutch and figure out things like how to buy food, how to get a job, etc.

Once you feel you get it, move to France and repeat. Then move to Spain or Germany, or Italy and repeat.

At the same time lets find someone form Holland who does not speak English.... crap that's not really possible. Germany maybe, if we look hard enough and go for the older population I bet we can find a German who does not speak English.

And we give them the same iPhone app and send them to a state in the US, and when they feel they grok it, we move them to another state.

Assuming you both happen to be equally bright and grok your first state in the same amount of time, who do you think will to through 5 states first? You in Europe, or the German in the states?

I'd argue that if you grok one US state, that's it, game over, you grok ALL of the US. English is spoken. Turkey day is Turkey day, as is July 4th. Food differences are slight, but the stores all sell overwhelmingly the same things. Except for a bit of local programming, same TV and music on the air, etc.

bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
Most people in Russia and China and much poorer than most Americans. It's hard to compare the US to anyone, it is both huge and rich. Canada is probably the most US like country. (I might get downvoted by Canadians now!)
bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
OK, your first paragraph is hard to comprehend. Language is "culture" but that's boring. Europe is more diverse - but trivially? Political, standard of living, industry are apparently real differences according to you? And art somehow snuck in there too, but I guess the totally of language based art, poetry, books, etc, somehow is boring?

If we are going to cherry pick how we compare places, I say let's start with climate. When talking about climate clearly Mississippi and Washington state are far more different than Sweden and Finland.

Only an American could completely discount language and want to talk about GDP or GNP and industry composition. Very CIA fact book page. I freely admit by GDP and standard of living all of Western Europe is less different than Mississippi and any of the "blue" states.

Hell if we're going to use CIA country fact book style information to measure differences then all of the OECD countries (this includes Japan, Europe, Canada and the US) are on average less different than just the US states.

Now think about that. Does it make sense to say that just the US states are more diverse then a group with includes both Japan and most of Europe?

I guess if you're an American and think language is "culture" and boring then yeah that can sound right to you.

bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
I'd argue that English and French Canada are about as different as any of these pairs.

Really? You speak English, you can go to any shop in Hawaii, NYC, Alabama or Texas and buy what ever you want.

I am sure you can do the same in Toronto. Could you do the same in Montreal if you don't speak French and the clerk doesn't speak English?

If you don't speak French, are red-green color blind and have never noticed the hexagonal shape of a certain street sign, do you know what you should do in your car when you see "Arrest" on a street sign?

I guess what I'm trying to say is that the difference between Montreal and Toronto is plainly, objectively and obviously greater than that between any two places in the US.

Even in the French heavy parts of Maine and Louisiana at least the street signs are still in English.

bh42222··on The Power of Introverts: A Manifesto for Quiet Brilliance
How does one begin to test which of these theories is correct?

This brain imaging study:

http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/199907/the-differenc...

Indicates that the default mode for the introvert brain is to keep the parts of the brain responsible for internal stimulation busy. In extroverts it seem default mode is to pay attention to external stimuli.

While unpleasant social interaction will force everyone to take a break, this would explain why introverts like me find even very pleasant social interaction tiring. It just takes energy to pay attention to external stimuli. Extroverts don't have to spend that extra energy.

That's why one of the tell-tale signs of real introversion is a dislike for music while working. It doesn't matter if it's your favorite music, it's distracting. But for extrovert it would not be.

Born introverts are also a tiny minority of the total population, and this combined with everything else makes me suspect extroverts with social anxiety are in fact most of these "introvert" cases.

bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
No I would not.

A simple proof. Swedish is a Germanic language, the people are a Germanic people. Finish is a Finno-Ugric language. That's not even one of the Indo-European languages! Magyar is in the same language group.

In other words, despite their physical proximity over thousand of years, Finns and Swedes have maintained a huge cultural difference.

And the same goes for almost any two old world neighbors. Even the ones you may think of as super similar. As big as the differences between Oregon and Mississippi are, they really ain't much compared to the differences between France and Holland, which geographically are much closer together.

bh42222··on Five Days in the Valley: An East Coaster's Take on Silicon Valley vs. NYC
... it is worth noting that Americans can see a far greater diversity of cultures and geographies without leaving their country than is possible in most other places.

This is plainly false. Just two quick examples: No difference within the states is as big as the difference between French and English speaking parts of Canada. And a tiny country like Switzerland encompasses French, German and Italian speaking populations.

A Londoner would cross six or seven national boundaries by covering less distance than it takes me to actually leave this country.

This contradicts your first sentence. Also a Londoner will meet several nationalities, I don't know what you mean by "boundaries." Also a New Yorker should be right up there with Londoners.

bh42222··on Programming is the new High School Diploma
Pilots (including maritime pilots)

If you are under 50, I would bet most planes (at least in the military) will be piloted entirely by AI before you die. The same should be true for most large ships. Most planes are already piloted by AI most of the time today.

← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →