HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bhickey

4,258 karma · joined July 8, 2010

http://bhickey.net
submissionscomments
bhickey··on How does data removal from GPT *work
Transformer editing is an active field of research.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2202.05262 https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.07229

bhickey··on Google “We have no moat, and neither does OpenAI”
https://www.together.xyz/blog/redpajama
bhickey··on New York to ban natural gas, including stoves, in new buildings
The real world isn't basic chemistry and we shouldn't flippantly pretend it is. Stove gas also contains nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and formaldehyde. In a study of (approximately) all children in asthma, researchers found that stove gas explains 14% of all asthma cases.
bhickey··on Frank Rosenblatt
That's because it doesn't. Take a look at papers citing _The transfer of learned behavior from trained to untrained rats by mean of brain extracts._
bhickey··on The Circumnavigators (2017)
The requirement I'm familiar with is crossing all meridians and the equator.
bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
Here's more than you ever wanted to know on the subject:

http://donhodges.com/Controlling_the_barrels_in_Donkey_Kong....

http://www.jeffsromhack.com/products/donkeykong_tech.htm

bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
Jumpman's facing influences barrel behavior. With a four way joystick you can't vary your facing while climbing a ladder unless you pause on the ladder. The ladder climbing sprite is facing agnostic. With a four way stick a player would need to lift off up (or down) to move the stick left and right. On an eight way you can keep climbing with deflecting left and right. Visually you won't be able to detect this.

There is a random component to the barrel behavior. You could potentially detect steering by looking at jumpman's ladder entry direction and examine the behavior of each barrel during his climb. This would be an absolutely miserable task though.

It might be easier to detect an eight way stick by finding buffered ladder climbing: does Jumpman begin ascending a ladder on the first frame in which he can climb and does he start moving left or right on the first frame after he dismounts?

bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
> Either way it's modified.

Yep. The oldest rules I've seen require that the machine have an original stick.

> More to the point the footage is consistent with 8-way movement

Which footage? An eight way stick let's you barrel steer while ladder climbing. I don't believe that this will be detectable from looking at footage alone.

> And the appearance is consistent with an 8 way.

This is impossible to tell from the photographs. The restrictor plate is mounted on the underside of the joystick assembly.

bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
I built exactly this board for a homebrew (S)NES controller. Simultaneous L+R inputs are converted to neutral and U+D are converted to U.

Even with the interlock a player can gain an advantage by buffering inputs.

bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
> Is he the one who came across as a pretty bad husband and father?

I don't think so. The film had footage of Steve Wiebe telling his kid he couldn't help with the potty because he was busy gaming.

bhickey··on Donkey Kong cheating case rocked by photos of illicit joystick modification
Karl is wrong in his claim that the stick appears to be an 8-way stick. Directionality is determined by a restrictor plate mounted on the underside of joystick assembly. Here's an example: https://www.ultimarc.com/arcade-controls/joystick-accessorie...

It's impossible to tell which plate is installed by looking at the top of the panel.

Edit: He does get some things right. My point is that this is surprisingly technical. Even some of the best players in the world don't know how the game works.

bhickey··on The Origin of the “MIT License” (2020)
I asked rms and Hal Abelson about this a few years ago.

Stallman said:

> The term "MIT license" is a confusion. It is used to describe two different licenses; see https://gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html. We call them the X11 license and the Expat license. To distinguish them, we do not use the term "MIT license". The X11 license was, as far as I know, first used by X11. I don't know how it was written -- the question is not interesting to me.

Thanks Richard.

Hal recalled that it was drafted by Karen Hershey at the request of the Technology Transfer Office. Regretfully I don't have a copy of his original response.

bhickey··on Detect ChatGPT Generated Content
Agreed. This is useless. I asked GPT-3 to write a HN post decrying GPTZero:

> GPTZero is absolute trash! It can't even detect plagarism correctly. It's a complete joke and waste of time! Don't bother with it! You'd be better off just manually checking for plagiarism. It's so unreliable it's not even worth mentioning. Just save yourself the time and money and don't bother with GPTZero. Worst AI tool ever!

GPTZero classified it as fully human written. This is a cat and mouse game where the mouse is always going to lose.

bhickey··on Making chloroform so I can sleep better at night [video]
My freshman advisor was a famous[1] organic chemist. He told me that he would do isolate THC, then elongate its carbon tail to induce a more powerful, longer lasting high. When I asked him, he responded that he had no concerns about his ability to make a pure reaction product.

[1] Famous within organic chemistry circles.

bhickey··on Ask HN: ChatGPT et al. and NPCs
I built a demo for NPC background chatter using GPT-J-6B. Each call took about three seconds. I expect this technology to be usable interactively in a year or two, but we aren't quite there yet.
bhickey··on Class Action Filed Against Stability AI, Midjourney, and DeviantArt
This is the same firm handling the CoPilot litigation.
bhickey··on Paizo Announces System-Neutral Open RPG License
It's unclear to me why CC-BY isn't sufficient for SRD material. I'm glad that Paizo is throwing off the yoke of Hasbro altogether, but I don't have a good understanding for what a new license will do that CC doesn't.
bhickey··on At a Cleveland CloudKitchens, operators say they were set up to fail
This has echos of Boston Market, which soaked franchisees and shareholders instead of trying to make a profit on receipts.

https://www.benzinga.com/news/11/12/2181341/a-lesson-in-hist...

bhickey··on The strangest computer manual ever written
https://scsh.net/docu/html/man.html
bhickey··on Tesla broke labor laws by telling workers not to discuss pay, NLRB claims
That's a misleading way of putting it. Tesla said "you have to wear our uniform shirt [because you started wearing pro-union shirts]" and the NLRB told them to get stuffed.
bhickey··on I am not a supplier
> Can you give some examples of such a pure language?

BPF and eBPF, though this feels unsatisfying.

bhickey··on I am not a supplier
> not just with side effects

I think you're using "side effects" in a colloquial sense while I'm using it in a PL sense.

Pure code is deterministic, operating only on its params. Impure code—code with side effects—is something that depends on state outside of its parameters.

bhickey··on I am not a supplier
Haskell is largely pure. There's nothing in place to stop a dependency from putting unsafePerformIO on blast. If a dependency can only do pure functional computation then the worst things it can do are like (1+1=4) or diverge.

From your description it sounds like Deno is using object capabilities -- that's a great step forward.

> Many years ago npm inc treated download and package counts as KPI.

That's bonkers. I had no idea.

bhickey··on I am not a supplier
Can you elaborate on the incentives of package managers? The problem I see with Rust is that it's just really easy to add dependebcies in a way that is difficult in C++.

I don't follow your point about purity. A dependency in a side-effect free language can't suddenly open a socket or access the file system. The attack surface is much smaller.

bhickey··on I am not a supplier
Some months ago after recoiling in horror from a vulnerability in rust I arrived at the grim realization that the "supply chain attack" problem is intractable in impure languages. When a transitive dependency can do anything it will inevitably do something. I don't expect to convert everyone (or anyone) to object capabilities and purity, but I do hope the experiences of the past year have put the fear of God into developers. We should aspire to build systems where a suddenly malicious or busted dependency can't knock over the whole tower.
bhickey··on Svante Pääbo awarded Nobel Prize for studies of extinct human ancestors
> typically enough for a person of his calibre to research approximate solutions good enough for him to run some experiments

And it's hard to overstate his caliber. For those of you who are unfamiliar with the name, Nick mentored Clifford Cocks at GCHQ and pushed him in the direction of inventing public key cryptography.

bhickey··on Svante Pääbo awarded Nobel Prize for studies of extinct human ancestors
Looks like there's a quantum speedup: https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.03581 IIRC there's no epsilon approximation.
bhickey··on Svante Pääbo awarded Nobel Prize for studies of extinct human ancestors
My greatest contribution to scientific progress came in 2010 when I was having lunch with Nick. He described an admixture problem to me, summarizing: "I've got observed populations and I want to build a tree where I pick points for unobserved populations such that it minimizes the edge length of the tree. I can't seem to come up with a good algorithm for it."

"Nick, that's the Steiner Tree problem! It's NP-complete!" He probably would've wasted a few more days going down that rabbit hole.

Edit: Nick has some great Cold War spy games stories that I've only heard him tell in broad strokes.

bhickey··on Svante Pääbo awarded Nobel Prize for studies of extinct human ancestors
I'm surprised that the prize wasn't awarded jointly with Reich.
bhickey··on New technical analysis confirms the evidence against Billy Mitchell
Yep, he's an expert in antenna design and some high voltage electronics that I don't understand. We've done a couple of projects together designing arcade hardware and have a really interesting project in the pipe.
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →