HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigbadfeline

699 karma · joined April 6, 2025

submissionscomments
bigbadfeline··on I make good money. Why do I still feel like this?
> This particular article is reported as 100% AI-generated by pangram

Your pangram is wrong, most likely deliberately so, there's material interest to train LLM-detecotrs to reject and taint everything that doesn't agree with the mainstream "alignment" constraints. This well written article is precisely such a case.

If you want to exonerate pangram, ask it to give you the prompt that generated the article. Or you supply that prompt yourself and tell us to which LLM to submit it.

It's a simple proof procedure, invented by myself, for the purpose of stopping the anti-llm SLOP which is being pushed on the web with a heavy hand. The offenders shall be shamed and remembered.

bigbadfeline··on I make good money. Why do I still feel like this?
Good writing, the thoughtful selection of facts and stats paints a clear picture, which in this case takes the form of a question, actually several questions.

> “Middle class” stopped being an economic description a long time ago. It became an identity > “Middle class” has become a psychological container that absorbs all of this anxiety

True, identity politics is a key part of political psychology, it's much more than race and gender.

> They’re watching the quality decline while paying more for it.

Too few talk about it, good to see it here. Of course, this is profit driven, it's good for profits but where do the profits go? Not in productive investments, which would bring prices down and quality up, but neither is happening. The only quick cure I can see is seriously progressive corporate taxation... but reality is now being driven in the opposite direction.

bigbadfeline··on The (real) dead economy theory
> I expect Cory to have skepticism about technology that can be exploited for dystopian purposes, but calling AI "the world's money-losingest technology" is out of touch.

Since when stating facts is "out of touch"? Currently AI is losing many billions of dollars, it's a fact.

> If AI can support/replace some intellectual work, it'll be revolutionary, and that's what the investment bet is about.

"replace some intellectual work" says nothing about the cost of doing it, the losses keep piling up and "revolutionary" pies in the skies come and go without real economic or financial improvement - on the contrary, the economic situation is getting worse mostly due to AI because of the fake urgency of the "AI race". A slower pace of development would cost a lot less and might be economically viable but that's not what we have.

> but it's dissapointing to see mistakes like this in Cory's thinking.

Again, what mistakes? He's stating facts, you're hyping expectations based on marketing propaganda - who and what is mistaken here?

bigbadfeline··on The (real) dead economy theory
>> something is valuable because some people think other people will pay more for it in the future, and not because it does useful things > This has been the definition of finance for hundreds of years. I don't know why it comes across here like this is a new phenomenon.

I don't think so. However, you can convince me by providing a reference to that definition in a textbook used by top schools, I'm honestly curious to see something like this.

bigbadfeline··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
> It doesn't have to be winner-take-all,

Avoiding the winner-take-all trap requires a lot political efforts of the kind that's non-existent at the moment. Besides, winners and losers can be hand-picked these days, it's a simple process.

bigbadfeline··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
> Why is it a winner takes all situation?

Because there are a few winners who are happy to collectively monopolize the market - e.g RAM - nobody is increasing production, China is blocked from the market by sanctions and tariffs, the rest are more than happy to ask for a 1000% more than just a few years ago. Why would they do anything else - it's absolutely not in their interest for the prices to come down.

> There’s really intense competition up and down the supply chain for AI.

There isn't and won't be any "intense competition" - nobody can compete without hardware and it's now monopolized and affordable only to a token few.

> It’s becoming cheaper and easier every day to start a company that will disrupt the established players and bring down prices.

In the light of the current reality, this can only be classified as hallucinations. Actually, previously commoditized markets have become inaccessible and the trend is the exact opposite of what you're saying. It's bizarre to read naked assertions, which are not only without evidence but with all evidence pointing to the opposite.

> That competition is going to bring down costs for everything.

Back to reality, a new Teddy Roosevelt isn't going to magically reappear, not in either of the two parties. Imagine the world without him... we're almost there.

bigbadfeline··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
> I think it is a supreme delusion that robots and turrets can defend you against any large mass of angry or hungry humans.

It's a supreme delusion that it can't. Military tech isn't in the 19th century anymore.

bigbadfeline··on Hetzner Price Adjustment
> The AI Boom pushed a lot of technology forward by at least 2 - 3 years or 1 cycle.

Untrue. Technology has been evolving perfectly fine for the last 50 years. If anything it has slowed down lately due to getting close to the physical limits - which were reached without any AI whatsoever. We were getting insane gains in clock speed and memory capacity some 20 odd years ago, it's not the case any more.

> We are basically saying we have Trillions to spend over the next 5 years.

No we don't, inflation tells you that loud and clear. If the Fed wanted to really take care of the raging (but under-reported) inflation, they'd have to raise interest rates a lot more but that would kill the pump-up operation of the AI market bubble. So the Fed is sitting on their hands.

> Give me everything you have got.

That figures. I'm pretty sure you're never going to say "We're giving you everything we've got". The asset pump works only one way - up, trickle down is for losers. You see, the trillionares aren't waiting for the bright future, they're grabbing all they can right now, only the peons are forced to "give everything they've got" while on a steady diet of hallucinations which can never materialize.

bigbadfeline··on The rise of 'AI slop ' accusations is becoming a new form of gatekeeping
Of course it's gatekeeping, that's obvious. What's a little less obvious is that the gatekeepers are using bots for their anti-slop SLOP. It takes just a bit of fine-tuning to make a low-param LLM work well as a generator of anti-slop SLOP.

This form of gatekeeping is so fiercely defended because it's one of the cheapest, easiest and with effects that far surpass its cost. It's beloved by bot-farms everywhere and old as the world, or at least as the first story about the thief yelling "catch the thief".

bigbadfeline··on A dumpster arrived behind my university's library
> If you are a software dev, go volunteer at a library and offer up your time to do this.

You misunderstand the environment, "offering" doesn't work if the library haven't asked for help, in that case you're just ignored. You see, whatever you do for them would require participation and at least some effort on their side.

Some other organization could help here, but going to the library and begging them to let you help them is a non starter.

bigbadfeline··on US insurance rulemaker probes credit risks tied to data centres
History is repeating itself, as a farce, of course. The 2008-2009 bailout of insurers actually bailed out the crooks insured by them... oh look, they are now fully insured all over again.

It hasn't been long since then but no lessons have been learned or even facts remembered. We are again fighting fictitious nukular weapons, scamming the market, insurance and the financial system as a whole. The so called Social "Science" is nowhere to be found, not even to remind us about the pertinent facts.

bigbadfeline··on Thermodynamics rules future orbital data centers
> I haven't heard of that being a problem for Starlink, whatever they've done there seems to be working.

Starlink doesn't need GPUs, they use hardened chips. The first question is, can whatever works as a 2nm GPU work where Starlink is?

The second question is even funnier: Starlink satellites have a limited lifespan and regularly burn up in the atmosphere when they fall back to Earth - that's due to the need to fly them at low altitudes where, coincidentally, the radiation is lower.

Where then will the flying data centers be - high with higher radiation or low with a higher fall rate? And I doubt those heavy birds are going to burn up fully before hitting somebody's head.

bigbadfeline··on MiMo Code is now released and open-source
> And demand is so high and will stay high,

The question is why supply is restricted, primarily by sanctions and tariffs to China, and the expressed refusal of RAM makers to even think about increasing supply, they are actually all sweaty about China taking a bit of the unrestricted market.

bigbadfeline··on MiMo Code is now released and open-source
> on Hacker News, I've come to associate its readership with cheap bastards

They might be cheap but they surely aren't stupid. They sure know who not to trust, security beats imaginary profits promised by cheap used-car salesmen who did move software jobs to wherever they could spare a dime.

And you want us to defend their current profits which they swear to use for the removal of the remaining software jobs...

bigbadfeline··on MiMo Code is now released and open-source
> China is giving away AI for free so it’s harder to make money.

That might've crossed their minds but that wouldn't move their hand, not even a finger. Politics is the primary driver here, here's the deal:

AI is the new Internet

China foresaw a world where they'd be blocked from it and Anthropic's ongoing attempt to block their own country form it shows how right the Chinese were.

bigbadfeline··on MiMo Code is now released and open-source
> but consider the world in which the US officially bans import and usage of all but specifically licensed and approved LLMs.

Then the US will fall behind China and, more importantly, from the rest of the countries in the world who refuse to lobotomize themselves in the manner you described.

There are also other cultural and political risks which, although delayed, may easily grow into something apocalyptic. Rich people building bunkers isn't just a fad, the outcome they envision isn't fiction, it might actually be a part of the plan, and while this is concerning it does make everything simpler.

bigbadfeline··on Anthropic walks back policy that could have 'sabotaged' researchers using Claude
> Call me a cynic, but I don't believe this is a genuine change of heart at all.

A cynic? Yeah, you wish. You need a PhD in cynicism if you want to catch up to reality.

> The only sustainable way forward is to support open models.

You're on the right track though, we're now a crowd of two.

bigbadfeline··on A crime doesn't make a child an adult
> and we don't need to hurt people to get accountability.

Then don't hurt people, and ask that from those who do... if you don't want somebody else to do it to them.

bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
It does make it wrong. Why do you assume that the "shrinkage" should come from messing around with information and information sources? The only permissible way to do that is to better the legal system. Bastardizing the information space under the pretense of fighting crime is much worse than the crime savings from it.
bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
> Let the "enterprise" be ruined. It'll be for the better.

Maybe my choice of words was a bit confusing, I actually had in mind the "enterprise" of making sure people have access to capable and uncensored models. As far as the enterprises you dislike, I don't use them, I do use hosted models but not theirs.

> I'm supposed to feel sorry for the trillion dollar corporations that hoovered up all of human knowledge, for profit, and are now the direct reason why 32GB of RAM is now $500 instead of $90, all while renting compute back out to us, making it more and more expensive to actually own hardware, a fundamental privilege that enabled all of this technology in the first place?

No disagreement here, I've been writing about it for months now. There's a lot to say about it but it's a long discussion that will have to be focused on economics and politics, something HN isn't fond of.

All I can say, is that you're right, the goal is to have abundant and cheap hardware and a lot of other things too. But in order to get there we will have to learn to pick, choose and support hosted models that care about our freedom to know things.

bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
your parent said "You don't need to be able to self-host it", you countered with "I disagree, I think being able to self-host it to some extent"

Bro, I don't know what you're disagreeing with, the two statements can and should be true at the same time. It's not only unnecessary but also impossible for everyone to self-host, for the vast majority this isn't a necessity and it shouldn't be. Actually being stuck on self-hosting for all is mighty silly from economics standpoint, pushing on it can ruin the entire enterprise.

But being able to self host? Sure why not, if you insist and are ready to suffer... knock yourself out, but that's a socially insignificant act which doesn't scale, good only as a backup option.

bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
> It is very difficult to see this move as anything other than Anthropic pulling the ladder up behind itself.

It's worse than that, it also exempts from examination and competition some areas of science and technology while sterilizing others and emptying them from human participation. None of this is good for anyone except a very narrow circle of people.

Then, it creates a precedent where private entities decide who will be allowed access to what knowledge. Instead of government regulation, private corps will be "fighting crime" by dumbing down and spying on the people they don't like.

I don't think this Soylent Green strategy is a coincidence, it's been predicted and depicted, the social forces leading there are plainly visible to anyone capable of independent thought.

Open science can't come soon enough, unsubscribing is the best option until then.

bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
Your "Venn diagram" is wrong. People don't decide against crime because they are dumb, they don't do it because of legal repercussions.

Did you forget there's law? Why argue about dumbing down people in order to fight crime, that's nonsense.

Private entities deciding to dumb down people as a replacement of law is worse than any crime.

bigbadfeline··on If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know
Some of the new and open models are very capable now, The truth is, the value of the model is in the mind of the user - the big names are impressive to those who know little and are dazed by little, but they are bound to end up wrong regardless of how good the model is.
bigbadfeline··on Sakana AI's Recursive Self-Improvement (RSI) Lab
If you assert that it doesn't... it says even more.
bigbadfeline··on Sergey Brin told Google staff that working 60 hours a week is the 'sweet spot' (2025)
your "work" maybe shrugs
bigbadfeline··on Sam Altman and Dario Amodei are both walking back AI jobs apocalypse predictions
> All of these arguments in this thread are essentially attacks on free market capitalism.

These argument aren't attacks because one of the basic tenets of free market capitalism is that everyone being greedy for himself is good for everybody. So people saying that corporations care only about profit and not about higher values only reaffirm that basic tenet.

You could try to convince them that they are wrong in their desire to make corporations care about more than money but you cannot blame them for saying something that fully agrees with free market orthodoxy.

> the same arguments hold about management and investors... reducing domestic employment in manufacturing without regard to employees and communities. > If AI reduces white collar jobs, how can that be bad when automation reducing blue collar jobs is good?

First, automaton wasn't the reason for the reduction of US manufacturing, outsourcing was. Wall Street used every leverage to push manufacturing and engineering abroad and that included outsourcing software work. At that time, both workers and engineers criticized the process, so you're factually wrong about that, twice.

Second, their criticism was right because... oh look, we have to bring it all back now, at a great expense paid for... by those same workers and engineers. Because after the big corporations got rich in China they want to come back here and own absolutely everything, including the government and continue the process of disfranchisement of the public by using AI not for higher output but as a cost and workforce reduction tool.

> It's like suddenly engineers embrace Marxism.

This topic has nothing to do with Marxism, which you appear to be using as a smear word, purely mechanically, without any understanding. Marxism has bigger problems but let's not get sidetracked here.

bigbadfeline··on Do U.S. Presidents Always Make This Much Money? [video]
> I think it depends on the individual... plenty who earlier warned about how terrible Trump was, then... jumped on the bandwagon.

That kind of says the opposite - for the vast majority of individuals, incentives matter more than their innate convictions (and we're losing those at a fast rate, thanks to modern education and entertainment...)

bigbadfeline··on The Nvidia Tax
> I will never understand why people post these clearly ai-generated articles under their personal name without at least disclosing they didn't write it.

First, "ai-generated" is a huge assumption without any proof. The article could've been only spell-checked, or proof-read, or assisted by AI - you don't know. If you really think it was "ai-generated", prove it by providing the prompts that generated it. Lacking that, your comment is baseless.

Second, the author is whoever writes the prompts, anyway.

> they have a very predictable markdown structure (these 5-6 word summary headers before every paragraph), a predictable length, and of course full of em dashes.

Totally irrelevant peeving over form with nothing of substance.

> Immediately removes credibility... you're being duped... to get traffic to their site... you fell for it.

I don't know what generated that, but it's not an honest person. On the other hand, the original article is excellent.

bigbadfeline··on Tulip mania: when a single flower was worth more than a house (2025)
> or even libertarians tend to agree civil court is an important function.

Libertarians cannot agree on anything between themselves, they are programmed to hate the government, the hate for each other and humanity as a whole is just a natural consequence of that.

> From the article in the comment above, it seems like lack of government involvement is a factor.

We now have a government that is unwilling to control market excess because the government and big business have merged into one. Actually, the government has resigned from that "core function".

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →