HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigbadfeline

699 karma · joined April 6, 2025

submissionscomments
bigbadfeline··on The dead economy theory
> In my now long lifetime, I can't tell you how many times I've heard the phrase "This time it really is different"

This isn't an argument and it shows a fundamental lack of understanding of risk and game theory.

Besides, it's always been different, in the sense of boiling frog temperature going up. The present case is more different because this time, the rate of rising is high enough to make the frogs uncomfortable... and you're trying to calm them down and keep them in the water:

> Look frogs, the temps've always been rising, "many times I've heard the phrase "This time it really is different" for it to turn out that it really wasn't all that different."

> Maybe this time it is, but I'd put my bet on isn't.

Bro, it's not about betting... you have to try hard to learn something about risk.

bigbadfeline··on U.S. Seeks to Give Weapons-Grade Plutonium to Startups for Fuel
> So much has changed since

There's no solid proof that the changes were for the better, but such a proof is absolutely necessary. If anything, we've been recently observing deepening quid pro quo between government and business, at the expense of public interests.

> would probably require a state sponsor

The probability of that is far above zero while it should be practically indistinguishable from it - which is not realistic.

> It really can't, over a million people die annually from air pollution alone, never mind the billions expected to perish as a result of downstream effects of climate change.

It's pretty clear you're looking at the wrong equation. I am all for nuclear power but plutonium is absolutely irrelevant to the plight of pollution and climate.

Nuclear power has to be built slowly with great caution together with renewables in order to exclude Fukushimas, Chernobyls and Three Mile Islands. It's hard as it is even without plutonium in the mix. Much like in the case of rushed AI and data centers, "move fast and break things" is the wrong attitude here.

There's conventional uranium fuel with low enrichment which is hard to separate, it can work as well or better than plutonium for power in civilian installations, the latter isn't necessary, it only adds risk without any benefit compared to uranium.

> Frankly a nuke or two is nothing by comparison,

This is breathtakingly wrong. What follows "a nuke or two" can wipe out 90% of the globe, and the US isn't going to be spared. If you don't understand that, you need to research more.

bigbadfeline··on What it would take to rebuild U.S. manufacturing might
> Better than your kids having to move to China for upward mobility, which is the way we're currently headed.

I see, we're currently headed in the direction of falling skies, imminent nuclear threats and various other nasty Godzillas which, of course, urgently require more sacrifice from the population for more "preventive" wars, both trade and kinetic, so that the value of assets concentrated in very few hands can grow faster.

It's really urgent, honest! These same hands benefited greatly from globalization, but now, on the way back, it's your turn to sacrifice for their continued benefit.

bigbadfeline··on U.S. Seeks to Give Weapons-Grade Plutonium to Startups for Fuel
> DOE is not and has a proven track record of controlling nuclear material in far more challenging scenarios than some startups with enough diluted PU for a reactor.

Really? In the case of the Apollo affair, also known as NUMEC affair, the DOE lost enough enriched uranium for several nuclear bombs. NUMEC wasn't a big company.

Your statement is backwards. The larger the organization using the material is, the easier it is to control its use. Multiple cases of "some startups" are the opposite of that and a lot harder to control.

> enough diluted PU for a reactor

Diluted PU is chemically separable, no need for fancy centrifuges, "some startup" can easily extract weapons grade material and it doesn't take much to cause irreparable harm to the US.

> Those risks are frankly trivial compared to the ones related to pollution and climate change people are willing to endure because it doesn't tickle their monkey brain with the "nuclear" word.

A rogue nuke can do a lot more damage than pollution, especially in the current political climate. You severely underestimate the difficulties of safeguarding nuclear materials too. Pollution and climate change are several orders of magnitude less risky than willy-nilly distribution of plutonium.

And of course, "monkey brain" is a cheap manipulation attempt.

bigbadfeline··on The OSS Sabotage Manual Became Corporate Best Practice
> I want to believe AI is the solution, but it's far from certain.

AI could be an important part of the solution... or it could be used to make the problems much worse, unimaginably worse, if good men do nothing smart enough to prevent it.

bigbadfeline··on Private equity bought America's essential services
> This is exactly how pensions work: newer members to the defined benefits plan pay for older members.

No, that's now how they work, if that was the case, there wouldn't be any need for PEs to buy and enshitify the assets we are talking about here. Your current description contradicts your previous comment.

I'm not going to explain it to you, there's enough information about the topic.

> At the ballot box.

We don't vote for PEs. And who we vote for makes no difference to them, these truths are so basic, it's a shame you don't know them.

bigbadfeline··on Private equity bought America's essential services
> But sadly it’s not some evil dudes at the top doing this transfer, the market force behind it is because we promised old people way too aggressive paychecks when they retired.

You seem to be quite confused about pensions, not only "old people" have pensions. Actually the vast majority of contributions to pensions funds come from people who aren't old at all and are actively employed.

> If they do not have the higher PE returns, they basically go out if cash in 10 years and everyone would scream bloody murder.

Where would they "scream"? On the internet? And who'd hear them? The answer is nobody in any PE cares about anyone screaming.

PE's operations have nothing to do with screaming old people, that viewpoint simply avoids the real issues and replaces them with red herring age baiting.

bigbadfeline··on Sam Altman: I was wrong, AI unlikely to lead to jobs apocalypse
> AI is a losing bet either way. It’s a “dehumanising" technology, controlled by a handful of people.

That's not a law of nature, it's a consequence of the current system of laws, and only one of its problems among many others - this is important to understand because removing AI (an impossible task, but let's hallucinate), isn't going to fix the system.

> at currently zero overall value for humanity itself,

The value of AI is currently negative - the costs outweigh the benefits, but the reason for it is the rushed and economically reckless deployment. Again, that's not due to how AI has to be it's due to how we do it.

> This whole AI displacement of human values and creation won’t go down without a fight,

There are a lot of ways to "fight", the good ones don't involve getting physical or getting mad.

> what we see are just the first ripples of human collective anger and unlike in the movies, my bet is on the humans.

Anger is a recipe for disasters. AI is here to stay, the cat is out of the bag, there's no way to put it back in, it's basic politics. Fixating on AI, instead of fixing our ways of using AI, is a major blunder.

The fix isn't as simple as "in the movies", it's outside of the mainstream but that space is a minefield too - there's a lot to learn before good choices can be made.

bigbadfeline··on Stablecoins Are Private Money. That's Why They're a Risk to the Economy
First, it's not a malware site, it won't harm you or you machine in any way. I don't agree with their recent attempt to ddos, but linking to them doesn't encourage that, you are using their service for free, think of it as a punishment.

Second, if you really think it's wrong to link to that archive, you ought to provide another link, unencumbered by walls. When such is lacking, anything is better than none.

bigbadfeline··on SK Group chairman says memory chip shortage will last until 2030
China to the rescue again, even while their chip makers are being hit with sanctions and tariffs.
bigbadfeline··on Flatpak Will Depend on Systemd
> systemd-appd doesn't exist yet.

This avoids the question, apparently because the design of this part makes it certain that when it does come into existence, it will depend on the rest of systemd.

The problem with systemd is that it's purposefully designed to be a viral monolith, without this it's got no purpose. We've been with this long enough to pretend otherwise.

bigbadfeline··on C extensions, portability, and alternative compilers
> Surprised about FreeBSD. My experience is that porting Linux software is usually pretty easy as long as it's not using some Linux-only feature (io_uring for instance).

I'm not sure why you're surprised, the parent of you comment clearly stated

"on FreeBSD you often run into systemd dependencies or other non-posix behaviors"

which means, software written for Linux often uses "Linux-only features" such as systemd and other non-posix dependencies that are foreign to the BSDs and traditional UNIX. Thus, it shouldn't be surprising that Linux software is hard to port to the BSDs.

Linux used to be a pretty good UNIX, I'm not sure what it is now.

bigbadfeline··on Memory has grown to nearly two-thirds of AI chip component costs
Well, let's remove the sanctions from China then and we'll get a better idea about costs and spin-times.

BTW all RAM is severely overpriced, not only the one using the latest process nodes.

bigbadfeline··on Memory has grown to nearly two-thirds of AI chip component costs
> Micron is a US company

Micron doesn't make RAM for the consumer market, they serve corporations only. That's been the case for about 1.5 years now.

> and US did the same against Japan in the past

And the USSR self-isolated from China like 20-30 years before they... disappeared.

bigbadfeline··on Why is Vivado 2026.1 dropping Linux support for free tier?
You know, it used to be "The customer is always right".

But it's become "Whaat? Are you talking to us you uncivilized, stinky hippy peons? How dare you? We serve only the rich corps now, we don't care about you or your money."

> But customer facing is such an awful position for the wages they usually make.

So you're saying that rich AMD doesn't pay their employees enough and for this reason, their unsatisfied customers should be careful not to say bad things about the company to the employees mistreated by that same company... There are too many logical errors here to describe in a short comment.

bigbadfeline··on Memory has grown to nearly two-thirds of AI chip component costs
That's such a nonsensical argument, it holds for every other business too and in this case it's just a lame excuse for monopolization. If you are that chicken and can't stomach competition you should not be in business anyway.

The current RAM manufactures were convicted of conspiracy to manipulate prices back in the 2000s or thereabout, doing so is their modus operandi, but this time the government is participating in the racket.

bigbadfeline··on Memory has grown to nearly two-thirds of AI chip component costs
There's no risk to businesses that are paying bonuses of $ 1 million, per worker, per year - like the RAM makes Samsung and SK Hynix.

They are drowning in money but they don't invest in new production in order to maintain high prices. By doing so, they form a virtual trust with monopoly control over pricing. What you call "risk" for them is our best hope, China can't enter the market soon enough.

Oops, the US government is blocking the Chinese chip industry in every way possible and thus becomes a factual member of the aforementioned anti-competitive and anti-consumer trust.

bigbadfeline··on Airbnb's Chesky Says US 'Misunderstanding' Use of Chinese Open-Source AI Models
> Or is being behind not a problem? If it's not a problem, why then would it be a problem for China?

Do you understand the difference between being a target of domination and falling behind? Replacing the words of others with your own straw men is a sign of a mind poisoned by ideology.

China has always been behind the US, they've provided the US population with a lot of affordable goods and made some US corporations very rich. Guess what, they've never had a problem with it until they became a target of bullying and talk of domination. And even then, they are quite reasonable and even-handed.

> That just seems like a rather routine labor dispute.

The thought of looking at this as a "routine labor dispute" never even crossed my mind. I'm talking about efficiency of capital, that "dispute" is how you learn about the wasteful use of US capital, information that you can only get by reading between the lines.

The US would be better off and further ahead if China was a market participant and we didn't have to pay exorbitant prices for hardware. In other words, if we haven't started a trade war with China, but rather used them to gradually build the necessary generation and semiconductor capacity, we would be further ahead of them, and they wouldn't mind it.

bigbadfeline··on Airbnb's Chesky Says US 'Misunderstanding' Use of Chinese Open-Source AI Models
> Sure! So make sure you are continuously clamoring from every corner that China must slow down its adoption of AI.

I don't see any signs that China is rushing AI adoption, they are simply trying to stay close enough to the US to counter the obvious and loudly proclaimed existential threat of external domination, words supported by wide-ranging sanctions and tariffs.

> I'm not sure what you're talking about. I don't know much about economics.

That's not unusual and I can't blame anybody, except the professional economists, for the sordid state of econ education in this country. Unfortunately, that doesn't make it less of a deal breaker, one cannot claim to understand the political landscape without understanding economics.

Nevertheless, I'll give you a few hints - the rushed buildout of data centers stuffed with expensive GPUs, made in Korea and Taiwan, strains both the semiconductor and energy markets, the prices go up but new production is slow to come and always insufficient. Little or even nothing is gained from the rush, except inflated asset prices (market manipulation) and general inflation.

At the same time, the rest of the economy is starved for capital which goes to the semiconductor makers in Korea and Taiwan to pay for $ 1 million bonuses, per worker, per year. The picture is similar on the market for power equipment. War and Hormuz are the icing on the cake.

In other words, the rush causes a spike in demand which causes a spike of inflation, like about 500% for RAM and somewhat less for GPUs, the high costs require more capital for the same assets, which depletes the capital markets and the continuous expansion of demand with stagnating production leads to an inflationary spiral.

The rushed adoption also causes friction on the labor market where subsided AI is used to fire large number of workers. Looks good in the earnings reports (market manipulation again) but doesn't do anything good for the US economy or population. In this situation, blaming the students cannot be accepted seriously.

bigbadfeline··on Airbnb's Chesky Says US 'Misunderstanding' Use of Chinese Open-Source AI Models
> So sure you can churn out free/cheap stuff, but that's not a business model, that's desperation.

Framing it as "desperation" does have some dramatic effect but it says nothing about the potency of the counter-measures being deployed.

> We're completely and demonstrably capable of dominating this space.

That's the kind of blind faith mixed with self-deception that led to the recent war. Depending on who you ask, "we" are completely dominating "them" but the vast majority of "US" aren't dominating anything, we are being dominated by high gas prices and inflation.

Kinky dominatrix games are full of risk and they aren't worth even 10% of their cost.

> We are incredibly competitive, dynamic, innovative and operate with very deep capital markets.

If you knew something about economics, you'd know that the presence of high inflation is a sign of depleted capital markets. Blind faith and reality aren't the same.

> The risk factor is anti-American propaganda and leftist subversion convincing people that adoption of technology is a bad thing... or implementing other ass-backwards policies and we wind up behind.

That's the usual war propaganda, full of meaningless generalities, sound bites and straw men. The value of technology doesn't exist outside of economics - it's the difference between what it provides and what it costs over the time frame of adoption.

In other words, rushing a generally good technology can turn it into a monster - that's exactly what's happening here. It's similar to rushing into war while other means are neglected or deliberately ruined. In both cases the only results are market manipulation, enrichment of the very few and making life harder for the rest.

bigbadfeline··on Airbnb's Chesky Says US 'Misunderstanding' Use of Chinese Open-Source AI Models
> it’s just that there is no economic model to do so

"Just"? Where do I start? That just outweighs all other problems combined, by far.

bigbadfeline··on Why We've Filed a Referendum
> Here in Michigan, people are all for auto factories, but... data centers are a big no no. They use electricity, they look ugly, and they use water. Can't have that.

Because they know economics better than their politicians and academia.

Data centers saddle the public with their power and water capital expenses, for new generation and transmission which are used solely for the benefit of data centers. And get this, in many cases the data bros get sweet tax-free deals for many years.

All of a sudden, the entire economics establishment loves communism for the rich, where the rich get exclusive use of public utilities built and paid for by the public.

The media, academia and politicians silence is deafening, which is why people have to raise their voices if they want to be heard.

bigbadfeline··on Nvidia Removes Gaming Revenue Category from Financial Reports
> if china will do it im pretty sure US economy will take a big hit.

You being "pretty sure" doesn't translate to actual reality. If you followed the events in the real world, you'd know that Samsung workers were about to strike and cripple the company because they were offered only $400K of bonuses per worker, while the workers in the competing (also Korean) SK Hynix were being given a cool $ 1 million.

Your money is going to Korea and Taiwan who charge an arm and a leg and they have absolutely no intention to increase production because they like these prices. The US trade deficit grew because of them, despite tariffs, sanctions and threats.

So, the real world effect of China entering the market would be a stimulated US economy, lower prices, lower inflation, greater consumer satisfaction and lower deficits. That's the opposite of what you feel.

bigbadfeline··on Declining America
> I get culture shock when I go to the south here in America.

Or even from urban to rural areas.

> It's just some old timey 1940s "we gotta keep these different cultures separated" nonsense.

That's a huge mistake right there. Those who want to keep their culture should be free to do so, as long as they don't try to force theirs on others - that's a common and traditional American value which is now being attacked by both extremist segregationists and extremist pot-melters.

> It's nationalism and racism (though it purports to be otherwise).

You should learn what these words mean and stop purporting they mean something else.

> It's all made up. Even culture.

Bro, not only culture, the entire human civilization is made up. The issue is to make it good, not bad, but you seem to be all confused about it.

bigbadfeline··on Declining America
> You'd be surprised how it's not the case in most of the world.

What you listed isn't "most of the world". And the exceptions do not make a rule.

bigbadfeline··on Jeff Bezos says bottom half of U.S. earners should pay no federal income tax
> Even taxing the rich won't solve the deficit, at all.

The economy isn't influenced only by taxation, there are many other important factors which are never considered by the mainstream economists, corporate and government public figures.

Fiscal policies are very important but only in the overall policy mix. Asking "Who do we tax to fix the deficit?" is the wrong question, neither the deficit nor the many other problems can be fixed by taxation alone.

bigbadfeline··on Ask HN: Are advances in AI going to push Linux to a micro-kernel?
> But inertia is a bitch, and insane money is being poured on Linux with little to show for it, just because.

Or maybe because just like C++ Linux has reached the point of no return, no amount of LLMs can save it, big money is the whole reason for its existence.

A replacement can come soon enough.

bigbadfeline··on The Rage of the Billionaires Is Coming
> but if it doesn't, and people start building guillotines,

AI can build guillotines better, faster, cheaper - did you miss Karp's quote?

While people waste their time in pleasant hallucinations about what people would do, they'd find themselves in the Soylent Green factory with no way out.

bigbadfeline··on For 20 years, Stephen Colbert distinguished truth from truthiness
> Ever since he went to the late show... he became much more of a propaganda tool.

Pure coincidence, times have changed, we live in propaganda time now, blatant, unscrupulous, subversive. All media and public figures got pulled into the whirlwind.

Colbert isn't much of a propagandist, with regard to truth and propaganda almost everyone else is worse than him, there's absolutely no reason to single him out.

In absolute terms he could do better, but in the light of nobody being better than him, that's not the issue, the issue is that the already twisted media space will definitely lose from his departure.

The way he was pushed out is quite instructive and points to a rather bleak media future.

bigbadfeline··on Illusions of understanding in the sciences
> everything flows back to philosophy...

Same as flowing forward off the edge of a cliff.

> Can we know what the truth is, and does it exist?

If you tried the forward motion at the aforementioned place you'd quickly find out the answer to that question.

The fact that not many are trying it clearly shows that truth exists, the only question is which way to get there - by science or by fooling around and finding out.

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →