We didn't do it, our representatives did it for us, mostly unaware of what they were doing and still without a clue about what to do with whatever they've created. No they can't, and they won't, academia BS isn't helping anyone either.
699 karma · joined April 6, 2025
We didn't do it, our representatives did it for us, mostly unaware of what they were doing and still without a clue about what to do with whatever they've created. No they can't, and they won't, academia BS isn't helping anyone either.
Micro is now nano, not amendable to modification, and even if it was theoretically possible, hardware is a super-easy target for legislation.
> Alternatively, just make it illegal to ship any kind of initial bootloader as part of a CPU's/SoC's mask ROM
If you had the political means to enact such legislation, you could legislate much cleaner and easier ways to deal with the problem.
I find myself saying this a lot but I still can't quite figure our why people keep seeking technical solutions to political problems.
I mean, these things aren't comparable, in some limited cases the naive approach might help but insisting on it while neglecting political action is worse than doing nothing.
Apparently you haven't figured out yet that these two are partners. The government restrictions are needed in order to allow other players to perform correlation tracking and deducing your identity.
> Nobody will be able to tie whatever you watch or write to your identity, because they won't have it.
This is untrue in the light of what I said above. The proposed scheme lacks any proof of immunity against tracking and deducing identity. I haven't seen anything like a proof being discussed, while an honestly implemented scheme would require a long and well publicized discussion of the means of protection - to make sure it cannot be abused for political reasons.
The lack of such a discussion is actually a proof that the purpose of the proposed scheme is precisely abuse.
It’s also corporate level. Worse than government actually, because the government deficit is caused by several trillion-level tax cuts that were financed by government debt. Corporate debt comes on top of that.
> A lot of the debt is hidden too.
Accounting is even worse in corpo-land.
> Politicians corruptly waste money to helping themselves,
Again, Wall Street is worse, politicians don't become billionaires - billionaires buy their way into politics.
> Governments are far, far more wasteful and inefficient than anyone realizes.
Compared to corpo-land, governments are frugal.
Button 1: "Stop the AI now to save X GB of RAM".
Button 2: "Erase all browser AI to save X GB of RAM and Y GB of disk"
This isn't asking for consent, it's simply informing the user about what oversized resources are optional and providing an honest way to save them.
The only alternative to that is formal consent.
Well, it's not true, and Utah's legislators know better than the EFF. The whole idea that political restrictions can be fixed by technical means is a scam. Simply put, today Utah - tomorrow the universe. This didn't start in Utah and it won't end there.
The piecemeal removal of privacy and freedoms has reached an advanced stage and one of the major factors that made it possible is the misplaced faith in circumvention by technical means.
> that's a bunch of unfounded hyperbole you just said.
Calling the quote on top "unfounded hyperbole" betrays lack of knowledge and awareness about the subject. Keep in mind that when we talk about real technical innovations, we have in mind published research - not closed or hidden models, some of which we know only from hype but cannot even test. A cursory look at said research reveals more Chinese names than I can count.
Deepseek did introduce real technical innovations, they're in their papers, and there was plenty of talk about another "Sputnik moment" when their first model appeared. If you don't know what that means - it's the moment when the industry mobilizes to "accelerate progress" due to the unexpected appearance of strong competition.
There's a lot more to be said, but it wouldn't do much good to a person who's not following the trends.
I'm not surprised in the slightest, the direction's been clear for more than 20 years now, so I've stopped looking for technical solutions, they will always be stop-gap measures if politics isn't fixed.
You're mixing the places of horse and cart here - the ruling class is ruling because it's organized. Organization comes first, the presence of other organizations, be them ruling or not, has little bearing on the process.
> we just post about it online and click 'like' or post emojis.
That's what you do without organization. It still helps though, getting to the truth isn't easy these days.
"Resistance is futile" is an old slogan of them Borgs.
"the stereotypical parental structure" precedes fascism by a long stretch. And so do forks and spoons, stereotypically used by fascists.
Mixing various side agendas is greatly detrimental to understanding and countering political nationalism, in fact, it helps its proponents.
Who's going to employ them? AI?
I'm so glad these so called "researchers" aren't totally evil, I'm so grateful they're only half evil, give them a lollipop.
Whatever, the way they disclosed it isn't much different from no disclosure at all - the exploit would have been identified in the wild and fixed soon thereafter.
"Researchers"...
It doesn't matter how many are shared but how many are viewed. On a small server community policing works just fine, bad actors are easier and faster to block and to top it off, the smaller reach of each server makes it unprofitable to target multiple serves, fish for their weak points. etc - the dirty jobs become unprofitable which is what matters most.
With the help of AI, small players can do a better job at removing CSAM.
Doesn't follow. Every case you listed justifies LLM inclusion with a similar "everything is expected to be defiled by LLMs" argument, mine is a better wording but still evasively passive and the "expected" part is still nonsense.
Just don't tell me LLM inclusion is justified by "expected" all the way down, like the bottomless money pit it is.
So? Many smaller players actually contribute more.
It's not about a single contribution but about what is better - a lot of power in the hands of a large corp which can afford to obstruct with impunity and do the opposite of "do no evil" versus several smaller players who have to actually compete and are concerned about their image.
Not fundamentally, only until they're compelled to learn from it. The current crop of AI understands neither compelling nor learning.
Of course, Chinese cars in the US are effectively banned by regulations. Proof that VIN can be used for banning.
Because of the I in AI of course. Would you call it false advertisement and go after the providers?
Nobody chooses instances for that, very few know anything about the admin, people just like the content until... in >70% of cases, bait and switch follows
That's why Mastodon is such an incredible mess, it creates the conditions for serious problems, then goes: "you chose what you knew nothing about, nor there's any way to know anything, therefore... you are the problem".
They could be the next "don't do evil" people but practice shows that doesn't last for long. And then the messy license terms become very handy for what comes next.
If they went to the trouble to specify all of their rights over your data, their glossing over about what they can do with it is a solid reason to push for complete clarity or pull out completely.
Yeah, I find that sort of critics to cause more harm than good. The economic case for closed source AI isn't there - in macroeconomic sense, and accounting for all costs, it's more expensive than the value it provides. There's data to back that up, so focus on economics.
On the other hand, hallucinating about what AI can or cannot do is useless, only research can provide the answer.
I don’t want to be snarky but your line of thinking is childish and shows lack of understanding of how products should enter market.
> The Silicon Valley doesn’t work like this. They release products and the second or third order effects can not be predicted.
Unpredictability is a very good argument for slowing down data center construction and AI deployments until the tech can pay for itself.
Now all "order effects" are heavily subsidized with no end in sight, and they needlessly drain too much precious capital out of the rest of the economy. When the "effects" come slower, we'll have a better chance of evaluating them without exposing the economy to the excessive drain and risk it's subjected now.
If you remove the hype and exaggerations, the whole show looks like just another market bubble for extracting money via losing ventures in a negative-sum game.
Civilization needs any new consumers of energy to pay for the new capacity they require, that's not the case here so let's forget about civilization and its requirements.
> energy, not a problem per se. Just generate more, preferably from sustainable sources.
Finally someone with unlimited energy supply, how much of that "no problem" can you provide? Use you preferred sources or others, I'll make no fuss about it, in continuous Gigawatts, please.