HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigbadfeline

699 karma · joined April 6, 2025

submissionscomments
bigbadfeline··on US power demand to reach record highs in 2026–2027 driven by AI and data centers
> It would be informative to know what the 'AI' part of it is

AI is > 90% of new capacity requirements. Crypto energy use is actually falling after some coins moved away from proof of work, especially after ethereum did.

> because now it just seems like engagement bait.

Well, you're shooting at the messenger here, why don't you find that information yourself and let us know? I tried and it's very hard - the various state governments talk about new electric capacity, data centers, and "jobs, jobs, jobs" without revealing what part of the new capacity would go to what consumers, or how many millions of investment will be needed per single job.

The info for Utah - projected increase of households electric bills to cover the capex for new power plants - greater than $500/year in the next several years - all of it to power humongous new AI data centers.

bigbadfeline··on Supreme Court to hear arguments in landmark Roundup weedkiller case
> You can't even get smoked fish accepted through precautionary-principle logic like that.

No, you really can't do that without breaking the Code of Federal Regulations. Smoked products must be labeled "smoked" in addition to many other requirements, and that despite the distinctive stink that self-labels these products. Even the font size is specified to be no smaller than the letters for the kind of meat on the label.

The real issue is why there's no such requirement for glyphosate, having it would be a good starting point.

> This is the same reasoning that puts cancer warnings on bags of potato chips.

I don't think all potato chips deserve, or have, such warnings but some might. Regardless, there might be specific regulations that are over the top and I don't mind admitting or discussing such cases but glyphosate isn't among them.

bigbadfeline··on Supreme Court to hear arguments in landmark Roundup weedkiller case
> Do you have an exclusion trial comparing glyphosate vs non-glyphosate diets?

That's a rather sneaky way to invert the issue. It's fishing for random luck when you ask for more and harder to obtain evidence given existing facts pointing to possible harm. A single study that doesn't show harm doesn't refute those that do.

You have to provide hard evidence that glyphosate (or another non-essential ingredient) does not cause adverse effects, and thoroughly explain the differences with the studies that show the opposite - until you do that, any in-vitro or other studies that show harmful effects count against the use of the product and you cannot ask for more evidence, you can only accept the remedies.

In this case, the appropriate remedies can be different: banning it altogether, limiting it to specific usage (e.g. no pre-harvest spraying), labeling using LARGE PRINT and scary language or some combination of the above.

bigbadfeline··on Norway Set to Become Latest Country to Ban Social Media for Under 16s
You aren't following the news - adult smoking is being outlawed in the UK as we speak - so, your analogy is against you position but supports the person you're criticizing.

More importantly, smoking is a well defined activity but "social media" is anything but - using your analogy, "social media" can be everything from milk to veges to plain water - all of which you want to ban because they're all sold in the same stores where cigarettes are sold. In other words - starve the kids.

Further, school and legacy media can be more toxic than a well designed social media site for kids - vague bans leave the door open to legacy toxicity while closing it to web-based media that could counter the bad sources.

It's far better to focus on toxicity, identify what is "smoking" and what not, regardless of where the "tobacco" might be hidden. After some consensus is achieved, go after the providers, the same way the tobacco companies were sued onto oblivion.

Why do so many people go after the kids instead of after the providers? Too chicken to take on the big ones?

bigbadfeline··on Garbage collection without unsafe code
> Or are you going to reply his opinion has no value, and should abandon the language ergonomic proposals from the improvements roadmap?

I don't deny the existence of special cases or the value of looking for better ergonomics even at the expense of university. However, at the moment Rust is the best option for practitioners who don't have enough time to juggle multiple languages.

bigbadfeline··on The Tech Oligarch's Republic
> "White people" do not have culture.

Keep in mind, you replied to a comment that claimed that "the West" is used as another name for "White" and that's precisely how it's used in those circles.

So, to paraphrase, you deny that there's Western culture and it's part of European Culture. That is, you deny that there are cultural threads common for most of Europe and more so for Western Europe. I hope, I've said enough to convince you that you're wrong.

> But "white" is not a culture, it's a social construct that exists primarily for exclusion.

And? Using your logic, one can say that "German is not a culture, it's a social construct that exists primarily for exclusion" - if you were consistent, you'd also question the right of Germans to have a culture given that Bavaria, Saxony, etc do have cultural differences. The hair-splitting can go even further but the point should already be clear.

> So, yeah, I think "maintaining the culture of white people" inherently requires a concept of white supremacy.

So you claim that "maintaining the culture of Chinese people" inherently requires a concept of Chinese supremacy? Replace Chinese with German, Saxon, whatever... it doesn't compute.

Culture can be used as an excuse for supremacy and there are many other excuses too but fighting excuses instead of fighting supremacy can only help the supremacists.

bigbadfeline··on Garbage Collection Without Unsafe Code
> I don't have any special use case where I would pick Rust instead of one of those languages.

Rust isn't a language for a special case, Rust is universal. Those other languages are for special cases, you're simply a special case developer.

Picking a different language for each special case is the primary problem Rust solves, it's the problem of being a jack of all trades and a master of none.

>> If anything all those attempts prove that for many scenarios, it is better having automated resource management + (affine, linear, dependent, effects) than the pure affine types approach taken by Rust.

Can you write the proof down for us please? I'm curious, how do you prove that "for many scenarios" A+B is better than B+A?

The OP is about doing A in safe Rust, which isn't even an option for many of those other languages which are, at the very least, bootstrapped from unsafe code.

bigbadfeline··on Qwen3.6-27B: Flagship-Level Coding in a 27B Dense Model
> For coding often quality at the margin is crucial even at a premium

That's a cryptic way to say "Only for vibe-coding quality at the margin matters". Obviously, quality is determined first and foremost by the skills of the human operating the LLM.

> No one really believes at face value a Chinese hosted firm isn’t mass trolling every competitive advantage possible

That's much easier to believe than the same but applied to a huge global corp that operates in your own market and has both the power and the desire to eat your market share for breakfast, before the markets open, so "growth" can be reported the same day.

Besides, open models are hosted by many small providers in the US too, you don't have to use foreign providers per se.

bigbadfeline··on Peter Thiel Is Building a Parallel Justice System – Powered by AI
> If the system is correctly designed,

"Correctly" according to who? People with different interests have very different ideas about what "correct" is.

> Yes, it's not going to fix everything because surrounding process will no doubt be human-influenced.

Well, the core process will be more human-influenced, with even less doubt.

Besides efficiency, it doesn't matter who will be executing the process, actually a skewed process is better to be executed by slow and fallible humans than by a tireless machine that doesn't make mistakes while acting against you.

> no, that doesn't mean it's impossible to get value from.

Again, some will definitely get a lot of value from it but a lot more will only provide it.

bigbadfeline··on U.S. banks may soon collect citizenship data from customers
> if you live in a free country, any government you have by definition reflects the will of the people.

There's no such definition, where did you get that from? The only definition is "The price of freedom is eternal vigilance".

> If you're afraid of what the government might do, you're really afraid of what your fellow citizens might do.

In non-fantasy land all power corrupts.

> you might want to pass a law that makes it illegal for a bank to refuse to offer basic services to you

We don't pass laws, our representatives do, we select reps from a pool of candidates but becoming a candidate outside of the established parties is subject to the regulations established by these parties... you get the idea.

> As a citizen of a small country with decently long democratic traditions, I've always found American attitudes like that weird.

There's bliss and then there's reality... which happens to be weird, unfortunately.

bigbadfeline··on Anduril, Palantir and SpaceX are changing how America wages war
> "America is not this way because Trump is president. Trump is president because America is this way."

Trivially true, of course.

> Things aren't going to magically improve if the Democrats win the mid-terms or the next election.

Also true but far from trivial for the vast majority of the US population. The medias of all sorts fervently maintain the illusion that electing the other party is going to fix the damage done by the current one, ad infinitum.

Anyone who dares to challenge the above orthodoxy is quickly canceled/shouted-down/name-called/downvoted/etc into oblivion by bot farms with the latest AI at their disposal.

> Her former friends and allies need to take steps to protect themselves.

I don't see a big difference in the situation of former friends and allies. More likely than not they'd be sold a veiled version of the same, in other words, they'd follow - under the usual vague slogans which mean different things for their authors and audience. To be precise, if there is a way out of this mess, America and her former friends will have to find it, and walk on it, together.

> America is this way and will likely get worse.

Only if we keep wasting time in fatalistic contemplation and fruitless hopes of finding hiding places individually.

bigbadfeline··on America will come to regret its war on taxes
> It lets America print as many dollars as it wants... its own citizens enjoy "exorbitant privilege" and have the costs spread amongst the billions of people who don't live here.

This is a popular and tearful story of privilege but it's untrue today. In order for the "privilege" to exist, the foreign holdings of US debt must increase every year by amounts equal to the yearly US shortfalls... however, since around 2015, foreign holdings of US debt have been falling to flat. Nowadays, not only there isn't any "exorbitant" privilege, there isn't any privilege at all.

The shortfalls are funded by the US population at large via internal debt and inflation.

There's a slight uptick of foreign holdings this year due to instability but any public benefit from that is dwarfed by the losses caused by inflation and tariffs.

The yearly data for foreign holdings of US debt are easily found online.

bigbadfeline··on The big business of survival bunkers
This has been going on for some time, it's an important issue but the OP is nowhere near the important parts.
bigbadfeline··on From Endless Frontier to Enemy of the People: The Assault on Public Science
The problems here are much deeper and bigger than the OP is discussing, it doesn't help that nobody is really wiling to go the extra mile which happens to be the first one for this. A topic for another day.
bigbadfeline··on It is incorrect to "normalize" // in HTTP URL paths
If cxr takes the lead, I'll be happy to help too. I don't have much time but I can provide some support in this monumental struggle.
bigbadfeline··on Anonymous request-token comparisons from Opus 4.6 and Opus 4.7
We already know how to multiply the efficiency of human intelligence to produce better quality than LLMs and nearly match their productivity - open source - in fact coding LLMs wouldn't even exist without it.

Open source libraries and projects together with open source AI is the only way to avoid the existential risks of closed source AI.

bigbadfeline··on TN's Charlie Kirk Act bans student walkouts, protects conservative speakers
> Are you trying to get me to say I won't strike first? Because I will.

"Strike first" is the other name of preemptive war - the most fundamental principle of those you desire to strike... Are you really different?

> but some people genuinely just want to hurt others.

If you look closely you may find yourself among them.

> Go troll somewhere else.

Another projection - the troll preemptively yelling "catch the troll".

If you could escape your obsession with extreme violence and converse like a normal person, you'd find out that there are a lot better ways to deal with dumb ideas. Alas, not today.

bigbadfeline··on TN's Charlie Kirk Act bans student walkouts, protects conservative speakers
> Why do I need to tolerate someone who not only hates me, but would revel in watching me die?

What are the limits of your non-tolerance with regards to someone who is limited to hating you and expressing verbal approval of legal but extreme punishment for people like you?

Answering that question is necessary in order to know if you, and the person you replied to, have the same understanding of the word "tolerance".

For the record, the kind of people who hate you are easily criticized unless they are assassinated, after that they become more or less impervious to criticism.

bigbadfeline··on A New Kind of Hybrid Car Is About to Hit America's Streets
> What EREV does is allow someone that hates EVs to feel like they're not another EV driver with low range problems

It allows them not only to "feel" but also to actually avoid low range problems.

> they're very likely going to be filling-up their EREV tank once or twice in 12 months.

That depends on location and availability of charging stations in the area. In many places it will take many years to get to adequate charging infrastructure and hauling around a backup charger helps in the interim. Regardless, getting stuck on the road twice a year is still two too many.

bigbadfeline··on Elevated errors on Claude.ai, API, Claude Code
I'm pretty sure ai-x writes sarcasm and skips the /s for pure fun. Personally, I'm amused and I like what he's doing. Others have done it before him though, it's not a new trick.
bigbadfeline··on Open Source Isn't Dead
> It seems obvious that there's more to gain for attackers using AI agents to exploit open source repositories, than there is for good samaritan defenders.

Actually the opposite is obvious - the comment you replied too talked about an abundance of good Samaritan reports - it's strange to speculate on some nebulous "gain" when responding to facts about more then enough reports concerning open source code.

> In this new closed-source world (for Cal.com), there's nothing stopping them from running their own internal security agent audits

That's one good Samaritan for a closed source app vs many for an open source one. Open source wins again.

> any open-source business stands to lose way more

That doesn't make any sense - why would it lose more when it has many more good Samaritans working for it for free?

You seem to forget that the number of vulnerabilities in a certain app is finite, an open source app will reach a secure status much faster than a closed source one, in addition to also gaining from shorter time to market.

In fact, open source will soon be much better and more capable due to new and developing technological and organizational advancements which are next to impossible to happen under a closed source regime.

bigbadfeline··on Von der Leyen uses Orbán defeat to push for end of veto in EU foreign policy
> and this veto thing is really crippling the EUs ability to act.

That's the point of it. As it is, there's no reasonable assurance that acts approved by the majority won't sacrifice some of the existential interests of members deemed expendable - "for the greater good". We all know that there's no connection between what politicians promise and what they do - until that changes, having the ability to cripple their actions will continue to be indispensable.

> What is tariffs affect one country more than the others, should it be allowed to veto a tariff decision?

I don't know if individual EU members are allowed to impose additional, national tariffs on non-EU products but why not - a lot of issues can be resolved by giving members more freedom and more say in decision making rather than more coercion.

> What if a majority wants to alter the deal?

They can alter it only for themselves in the way I described above.

It's disingenuous to call the EU dysfunctional and blame that dysfunction on lack of coercive powers. Maybe the EU is functional exactly as much as its levels of development and integration allow, maybe pushing for more creates unacceptable political risks, there's a lot to consider here looking at the excessively bloody and inadequately smart history of Europe - it was a power keg and it still is. Removing veto power won't make it better, it can actually make it go off again, risk is what really tips the scales here.

bigbadfeline··on Von der Leyen uses Orbán defeat to push for end of veto in EU foreign policy
> A minuscule minority overrules the vast majority.

This is not a game of numbers, numbers would have some weight if decisions were affecting everyone equally, but the EU isn't homogeneous, foreign policy issues affect different countries differently depending on geography, culture and history e.g. Central Europe is much less exposed to adverse events, dependencies and risks than the periphery.

As I said before, now it's not the time for coercive changes, wait until integration takes its course and makes the political environment approximately the same for all members, the EU is far from that now.

> but it was the only way to convince countries to form the EU.

Then don't alter the deal and ask everyone to pray for not altering it any further.

> There is no alternative to supporting Ukraine as much as possible.

Depends on what each of the EU members considers possible and what risky - forcing some countries to go against their economic and political security will most likely lead to re-partitioning of Europe and another age of European wars.

It's quite disturbing to observe the continuous lack of an honest conversation about the political realities in Europe, which is precisely how the leading countries of the EU blew Ukraine / Russia... removing veto power only reduces the incentives for that to ever happen.

bigbadfeline··on Von der Leyen uses Orbán defeat to push for end of veto in EU foreign policy
> many issues that are known will have their veto used don't even get brought up.

It's quite disingenuous to blame the veto power for lack of discussion on important issues, if anything it's an argument in favor of the veto, because the only reason to avoid discussion when you lack coercive power is weak arguments... and there's no need to waste time with such nonsense.

> Removing the veto will expose some nations "true colors" in ways that most do not anticipate.

Another slippery argument - there is absolutely no reason to hide the "true colors" of veto-capable members you disagree with, actually the opposite is true, one will have to come up with more, more convincing and true-color-exposing arguments in order to apply pressure via the electorate of the true colors.

> It's not all sunshine and rainbows of agreement among the EU member states.

No it's not, there are shady forces who dream about coercion for the worse.

bigbadfeline··on Von der Leyen uses Orbán defeat to push for end of veto in EU foreign policy
> EU is asking countries to give up their right to veto foreign policy decisions. Any country can veto this proposal.

Hopefully it well be vetoed by more than one. There is no realistic alternative to veto in the situation the EU is in. It could be an option later on, they have to be patient, now is the worst time to move towards coercive powers.

Especially under such a nonsensical pretext:

>> Von der Leyen uses Orbán defeat to push for end of veto in EU foreign policy

Orban was defeated, democracy worked, veto power is no longer under the threat of abuse, if it ever was. A lot of other issues could be improved in the EU, do that instead of fixing what's not broken.

bigbadfeline··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
> First: because trusted people having such weaponry is, in expected value, believed to lead to less total violence.

Unfortunately "trusted people" don't grow on trees... but those who do grow to the highest positions of power, with the most destructive weaponry under their control, ask for trust with stuff like: "No foreign wars", "I'll end that conflict on day one"... "after bringing prices back down".

With that said, changing the conversation from violence to trust in the ideas and people who control it, is a worthwhile endeavor.

>> The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence

That's quite backwards, violence is an irrational response to today's problems. Demonizing the discussion of those problems as "violence" can't be trusted - if the discussion stops, a rational solution will never be found.

bigbadfeline··on The rational conclusion of doomerism is violence
It's no inconsistent if the people who oppose violence also oppose the legal forms you enumerated.

The comment you're trying to explain is conflating different groups of people and that makes it virtually meaningless.

bigbadfeline··on MEMS Array Chip Can Project Video the Size of a Grain of Sand
> however, I believe acquiring wafers of sufficient quality and depositing layers to be etched could be the bigger challenge here

Definitely hard for a home fab but how about a community fab? Not necessarily a geographic community.

bigbadfeline··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Safety
> Profit is obtained by maximizing traded benefits and minimizing costs.

Gain is obtained by the easiest means available. Your narrow definition of profit is seldom the easiest, cheating is far "superior" especially when it's legal for some.

> None of this requires taking anything away from any other party.

"required" and "preferred" (e.g. because it's far easier) are different like night and day.

bigbadfeline··on Austerity Creates Fascism
> That is only mostly true. In practical terms the opposite of austerity is inflation

Weimar says inflation creates fascism too. Not surprising because scientifically speaking, any sufficiently developed inflation is austerity by another name.

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →