Good'ol money printing.
> If you keep buying those things then the world economy will remain strong. Economies are damaged only when people stop buying things.
Boring stuff like stagflation takes care of that.
699 karma · joined April 6, 2025
Good'ol money printing.
> If you keep buying those things then the world economy will remain strong. Economies are damaged only when people stop buying things.
Boring stuff like stagflation takes care of that.
It is independent from the point of view of copyright law !!!
What GPL zealots wish to define as "independent" doesn't matter, blinded by their own zealotry, they end up arguing for extending the notion of copyright into pure absurdity in a grotesque contradiction to their own, rather feeble "principles".
> Therefore it is not an independent implementation.
You're ignorant about copyright and law in general. Copyright grants certain limited privileges for near verbatim copying only - it covers PARTICULAR EXPRESSIONS of ideas, NOT the ideas themselves - these are basics you know nothing about but you keep insisting to replace them with your hallucinations. I don't think you're human, no human is so deprived of comprehension.
In this case, an independent expression means one that doesn't have substantial verbatim or juxtaposed parts of the original. I can read as much poetry of some poet as I wish, and ape his style and topics as much as I wish but as long as there isn't any near-verbatim copying, my poetry will be independent for copyright purposes.
> Therefore it is not an independent implementation.
I told you already - go sue! You'll be told the same as I did here, as Oracle found out when they sued Google.
Don't waste you breath/tokens - sue - it's the only real argument.
If you don't sue, you prove to everyone that you know you're wrong but you're knowingly trash-talking in order to create uncertainty and confusion.
Who's going to pay for the new plants, that's the issue, nothing else.
"The market" can't figure that out and gets it wrong without additional regulation. If all ratepayers pay for new capacity used only by a few corporations, for their new power needs and their own profits, these corporations get to socialize their capital expenditures while privatizing their profits - that's a form of theft, without any exaggeration.
> you may want to read the discussion "Is the GPL actually viral across dynamic linking?"
What does that have to do with the price of tea in China? We are talking about an independent implementation of a BSD driver for Ext4-strucutred storage but you keep bringing up unrelated random pieces of chatter from around the web.
> but that the GPL does not provide enough protection.
But you don't understand the difference between copyright and contract. The GPL, or any other license based on copyright, cannot prevent the creation of the driver in question because it doesn't involve any copying of the kind protected by copyright law.
> if you are not interested in solving that problem then we don't need to continue this discussion.
Except, that's not the problem we are discussing.
Indeed, there's no point in continuing this discussion, you don't understand the basics, cannot follow the line of reasoning and keep getting lost in hallucinations.
In other words, you don't know what you're talking about... Everything I write is verifiable, have you heard of AI chat bots? Why are you going around asking old ladies for the latest gossip?
> yes, it is disputed, and the claim has not been tested in court.
Why don't you test in court? Do it, let's see what happens. Why did Linus wave middle fingers like a confused clown when Nvidia's lawyers stuffed the GPL2 with their driver? There was no lawsuit, only buffoonery in place of the promised "protection".
> but it is an argument being made.
There are millions of "arguments being made", 99.9% of them are BS, if you can't defend your arguments with facts, logic and court decisions don't waste e-space by regurgitating useless gossip, especially on HN.
> BSD licenses don't do that. they give me the right, but they don't protect it.
So, that's your reason to go on a crusade against the rights provided by BSD licenses.
Oh, that's sneaky - "Let's protect people from a license that gives them more rights than ours"
Your "protection" amounts to shilling for an absurdly extended interpretation of copyright powers while it's being sold as a defense against these very powers - this kind of diabolical nonsense is the opposite of protection.
Maybe, in some alternative universe, that could be correct but it isn't anywhere on Earth.
You can write a BSD-licensed driver as a Linux module and distribute it separately all you want - copyright law is OK with that.
The moment you insert the module into the kernel the whole thing, kernel + driver becomes a derivative work and you're forbidden from using it by the GPL - the license, not copyright... Copyright only gives the creators of the kernel the privileged power to impose that contractual restriction.
Long time ago, some BSD guys were trying to convince me that the GPL was primarily a weapon against BSD and other less restrictive licenses but I didn't believe it back then... boy, was I wrong.
You showed me how the GPL can be used for threats against the free modification of software by arguing for the addition of new, absurd powers to copyright - the opposite of what the GPL proponents are promoting it for. It's indeed a license that must be avoided at all cost.
There's no such thing as "an extension to some program". A derivative work is a work that contains the original. Using the privileges provided by copyright law, the creator may impose licensing restrictions on how the original work is used - but that's contract law, not copyright.
For example the GPL and the AGPL define different sets of use restrictions, none of that matters in this case because the original work is not being reproduced or used per se.
As I already said in my other, down-voted comment - copyright is only about verbatim, or near verbatim copies, in whole or in part - it's the spirit that both judgment and the letter of the law are supposed to follow. Copying of functionality is not subject to copyright.
For example, one can use the same topic for a work of poetry for a similar aesthetic effect and that doesn't infringe other poems.
The GPL used a hack to stretch copyright law into a near opposite but stretching it further goes into absurd territory, achieving the opposite of what the GPL claims to protect.
Unfortunately those aren't made at McDonald's or at any other fast service establishment. In other words they are neither fast nor cheap to build.
If we exclude local commute, the US has a pretty good transportation system, as it is, road transport is indispensable in this mix, at least for now. It would make more sense to convert cars to EV's and use the saved fuel for trucks than to redo the transportation system.
That's not the case here. A re-implemented piece of software that does not contain meaningful verbatim excerpts from the original is not subject to the copyright of the original.
Derivatives are not subject to copyright, unless they are close to, and contain substantial verbatim copies from, the original. It's a virtual certainty that a vibe-coded Ext4 FS is none of the above.
Redefining copyright as some weird patenting of similar ideas is absurd.
A pretty good analogy for the grid being killed by the data centers shot at it.
Just unfortunate for the grid, as fortune would say.
Using that definition amounts to classifying all real markets as non-free.
Unregulated markets cannot exists in reality or in a sound theory, only in wishy-washy fairy tales.
Indeed, but this is only a good argument for barring trans women from competing against females. You see, if trans athletes are so rare, only a very small number of people would be adversely affected by such a restriction, they can live with it.
On the other hand, the ban would calm down a large number of female athletes who are seriously disturbed by the mere possibility of competing against men, especially in contact sports, but not only.
Women are women, not only physically but also emotionally and mentally. Setting out on a crusade to change the thinking of millions of women is seriously dumb when a simple restriction, affecting 3 people total, can avoid it.
Now, think about making such a dumb idea a cornerstone of some party's political messaging... that can happen only if said party wants the other side to win.
I would insist that the deployments of a technology should be disconnected from the technology itself - I criticize AI too, and I get a lot of downvotes for it, but I try to separate the science of AI from its economics and politics.
The harms of AI and other technologies come from two sources 1. Capital destroying market bubbles and 2. Deployments motivated and enabled by political and moral corruption.
Both of these are in turn enabled and sustained by legislation. That is, we have to talk politics, not technology and not AI. AI has a great potential - both for improving human life and for making it a lot worse and which way it goes depends entirely on politics.
If we fail to cleanly separate these issues and keep moralizing about technology, we will be chasing red herrings and bumping heads in the dark all the while the tech is being deployed against us.
The amount of useless slop in the app store doesn't matter. There are no new and useful apps made with AI - apps that contribute to productivity of the economy as whole. The trade and fiscal deficits are both high and growing as is corporate indebtedness - these are the true measures for economic failure and they all agree on it.
AI is a debt and energy guzzling endeavor which sucks the capital juice out of the economy in return for meager benefits.
I can't think of a reason for the present unjustified AI rush and hype other than war, but any success towards that goal is a total loss for the economy and environment - that's the relation between economics and deadly destruction in a connected world, reality is the proof.
When it comes to paying for new capacity however, the priories are suddenly reversed, as I explained in another, top-level comment.
Isn't Liberty Utilities one of their existing customers? Which is now being denied power in order to serve those new and "exciting" data centers?
Who is going to pay for the tripling of capacity? All ratepayers, of course.
Who is going to benefit from the new capacity? Only the data centers, of course.
Socialize the capital expenditures and privatize profits - how come the media is completely silent about it?
That's a rather crude analogy which misses the major dangers of vigilante hacking. A better analogy is allowing private guards to shoot you on suspicion of you having stolen their money based only on a claim that the money found in your wallet might be theirs.
To understand the problem, think of vigilante justice where some person/group assumes the roles of police, judge and executioner, circumventing due process which is due for a reason.
What happens if a corp doesn't like what you have on your website, spoofs some logs as if coming from it and then hacks the site to disable your ability to communicate?
Well, in that case you're toast. You may go to the judge, pay lawyers and waste your life on lawsuits fighting against a corp with a lawful reason to hack you because if this becomes law, you will be guilty until proven innocent - that's very costly and hard to do. Your chances of successful will be virtually zero meaning the corps get a license to silence you with impunity.
Why do they expect women to want children? To be snatched by the government and sent to die in a nationalist war against their own brothers and sisters?
Some people do need to see a shrink there but I don't think Russian women are among them.
Plenty of gas pumps to go around, more of them aren't going to provide anybody private with more of what they crave the most which data centers do provide. That's the reason for the push to abandon EVs and reduce their competing demand for scarce electricity.
New electric capacity, paid for by the ratepayers, would benefit those same ratepayers if used for EV charging but big biz isn't in the game for them.
Which smartphone OS provider isn't?
> Not for me.
There's nothing better on the market unless you want to go dumb phone only.
Energy prices factor into everything else, so there literally will be a lot more than higher oil/fertilizer prices.
The end of civilized relations between countries is a sign of sick and dying civilization and we are there already, plenty of other evidence too.
> even if it causes famine in poorer countries.
So compassionate of you.
Yeah, and don't forget, this is all about helping the environment and the Iranian people, freeing them from that pesky and unnecessary for life energy by releasing some much needed smoke. /
If your house burns down, it's only your loss and possibly lower profits for your insurance company.
> Why is it a danger for the value of money to be correlated with major things happening in the real physical world.
If the financial system burns down it will be everyone's loss and there's no insurance. It's like you have to pay a steep price because some rich dudes have burned down half of the houses in your neighborhood, they get to privatize profits and socialize losses - the dudes like that but the rest don't.
> If a bank gambles it's deposits on snake oil like Tesla or Ai Companies... the worth of that bank rightfully collapses.
"it's deposits" aren't bank's deposits, they are depositor's - like yours and your neighbor's. In a sane world, nobody would care about "the worth of that bank" but the disappearance of depositors money is such a humongous failure of the system that the too big to fail will be immediately bailed out - I've already explained who'd be paying for it.
This outcome is a natural consequence of the repeal of Glass-Steagall and the rest of the New Deal, that process was completed by the end of 1999.