HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigbadfeline

699 karma · joined April 6, 2025

submissionscomments
bigbadfeline··on SK Hynix CEO sees memory chip shortage lasting until 2030
> If demand is projected continue for a long time, this may encourage more competitors to enter this space, so supply will increase.

There are no competitors that can muster the capital to make decent RAM... other than China but China is under a heavy sanctions and tariffs regime, when Apple mentioned using Chinese RAM to ease pricing they were quickly shushed by above.

The current monopolists aren't building new capacity either or are simply pretending to do it. It's a planned monopoly market for reasons I can only speculate about.

bigbadfeline··on X claims it found a Chinese bot farm posting anti-AI data center sentiments
> Spoken like a true Chinese bot

The comment you blame provided factual information about a glaring conflict of interest, yours is a substance-free ad hominem.

Are there Chinese bots on X? Probably... dwarfed by Grok and other domestic AI bot farms with a lot more resources at their disposal.

Bots can be right or wrong independent of their biases so arguing about bot origins is useless, we better focus on the substance.

bigbadfeline··on Tech tries a new message: You'd love data centers if China wasn't making you hat
> But AI isn't a bad guy.

But it can be, as every other tool. Actually, it can be worse (or better) than any other tool. In other words, "AI is this or that" is a meaningless statement, it can be many different things, even the same AI can be "good" for some but deadly for others.

> I am seemingly alone as an AI booster.

Nope, plenty of bot farms are now fighting on the AI PR front. As I said, blanket boosting/bashing is meaningless, it hides the proper approach - for every specific issue one has to ask Quo Bono?

bigbadfeline··on EPA says power for data centers can sidestep pollution laws
> They want computers in racks now and (rightfully imo) look at yearslong approval processes with disgust.

Disgust of the rules for me but not for thee? The rest of us have to follow the rules, but not them.

How about disgust for actual pollution? They could build clean, quiet and fast if "> It's not about the money it's about the time"

It doesn't add up, like at all.

bigbadfeline··on Nvidia Insists It Can Keep Printing Money to Fund the AI Boom
> Silicon Valley is clearly responding to massive demand for AI services > to provide services that people and companies want so badly

Not at all. In economics, demand has little to do with "wants", it means paying the price to buy the service. In that light, there isn't much demand for AI because the companies providing it are losing huge sums of money to subsidize underpriced and mostly free services.

The AI "demand" is now paid for by circular deals and huge debts incurred for the sake of centrally planned subsides - in confirmation of the comment you're trying to refute.

> They’re selling hardware that companies are demanding in large quantities because those companies need the hardware

Those companies don't need the hardware for funded demand (which isn't there), they need it to scalp the hardware market by hoarding and centralizing compute, while suppressing possible competitors - another centrally planned activity lacking any wider economic benefits.

PS. There's another big mistake in this expression "hardware that companies are demanding in large quantities" - the demands increase the price but they don't increase the quantity, because all relevant fabs are running at full capacity, they literally cannot provide more.

bigbadfeline··on Nvidia Starts Pac as AI Chip Maker Builds DC Influence Force
Good catch, the self-contradictions in the excusatory narrative are becoming hard to ignore.
bigbadfeline··on Ask HN: Hugging Face is out. Who is hosting open models?
p2p?
bigbadfeline··on Corporate political donations shatter record at $646M so far for US midterms
> Corporations are only people when it comes to rights and profits. When it comes to responsibilities they revert to being nebulous entities whose behaviors are emergent phenomena that no one can actually be held accountable for.

You do have a point here. Corporate shareholders do have special protections based on the legal principle of "corporate veil", meaning that corporate owners are usually not personally responsible for the corporation’s debts or legal misdeeds.

But they do get to influence elections from behind the veil, as to further grow their privileges, it's a slippery slope indeed.

bigbadfeline··on The turbulent AI era is here
> Doubtful. These tools will be more useful in capable hands than in the hands of a drooling idiot.

"drooling idiot" is just a figure of speech, I'm sure. The point is, the moat is now more like a narrow puddle which few will be incapable of jumping over. Even if you make something better, it's going to be very hard to find in the pile of AI-generated slop. Ergo, popularity and success will be decided by money for advertisement, not skill.

Are there important things that can be done with AI - yes. How many of them can provide income for a small but skilled operation - very few to none at all. That's the reality of it, whatever smart thing you do, AI will catch up with it in the next iteration. The current economic arrangement cannot accommodate AI without degenerating into an idiocracy controlled by selected few.

bigbadfeline··on Omarchy development practices lead to predictable security issues
>> OTOH, fighting bigotry is something we should never leave behind.

> [we] just want to exist without being attacked for being themselves and [they say we're] wolves who need to be shot to protect the sheep.

Weird, you're the author of both of the above quotes but "just wanting to exist" is very different from "a never ending war on bigotry". It's either one or the other, can't be both because war begets war.

bigbadfeline··on GLM-5.3-Flash
And to add to the above: by building their own supply chain for chips, China is helping the unprivileged, those who can't front-run the market with long-term contracts. If China wasn't producing their own chips, the prices for us would be even higher.

Similar to the war-pricing of oil, China's reduction of imports is actually helping to keep our inflation from going even higher.

bigbadfeline··on GLM-5.3-Flash
The export controls were not revoked, only reduced, and not before, but after China refused to buy low performing chips. Top gear was and is still sanctioned, as is any EUVL equipment.
bigbadfeline··on Twitter Viewer – View Twitter Without Account
whackamole is the only way for now, unfortunately.
bigbadfeline··on Banning data centers would blow up the U.S. economy
> There's one thing keeping us afloat right now, and people want to get rid of it.

This is an inversion of reality. The overbuilding of data centers isn't keeping us afloat, it's the hole on the bottom of the capital ship, sinking it fast to keep it pinned to the bottom. The only way to escape such fate is to slow down and build in economically sane way.

There isn't enough money to spend on data centers in a boom-busting inflationary spiral. We're overpaying for both construction and (especially) compute because we've reached their capacity limits long ago.

We aren't building faster, we aren't building significantly more, we are building at insane prices and at huge a loss to society while pissing precious capital in the wind. The opportunity cost is enormous and it's killing the economy.

bigbadfeline··on Goldman partner warns of 'huge danger' in letting AI replace bankers' skills
> Goldman partner warns of 'huge danger' in letting AI replace bankers' skills.

AI is a huge danger for me but not for thee? Who'd have guessed?

I don't think any group should be getting special protections from AI, it's either all-of-them or none.

bigbadfeline··on Andreessen Horowitz is investing billions into a bleak future
> It's completely realistic to imagine a world where robots just do what they're told

Yeah, although there are some wrinkles, doing anything else would be clinically insane.

bigbadfeline··on Andreessen Horowitz is investing billions into a bleak future
> Eh, you see too many of these guys complaining about declining populations for this to be a thing.

Overpopulation is the best way to get to low population - eventually.

> if you had everything - wouldn't you put everything you have for a 10% chance of living [forever]?

No, I wouldn't, that sounds awfully silly.

> What would you sacrifice for that?

Nothing. I don't sacrifice stuff for BS even if it's 100% sure.

bigbadfeline··on Agent Is Not the Model
> I've literally never heard anyone conflate an agent and a model. Ever.

That's because you know enough to disambiguate on the fly, which isn't true for the majority of the population. In other words, you make assumptions about others based on your own condition.

The concern here isn't that someone doesn't know what they're talking about, it's that many of those listening can be misled by the ambiguous wording of people who know very well what they are doing and can even do it deliberately.

> Like Trump thinking people didn't know about the word groceries or that dumb ends with a b.

Again, you're using yourself as source of assumptions about his audience, and worse, you transfer that to a much more complicated subject with unsettled terminology.

bigbadfeline··on Ask HN: Why do corporate failures always seem to punish the wrong people?
> Corporate world is tribal, if not feudal.

And, more importantly, the corporate world is a dependent variable.

bigbadfeline··on Ask HN: Why do corporate failures always seem to punish the wrong people?
> Because they don't believe the disasters were inflicted by them.

It's not quite clear how "they" and "them" are related but I see only two options:

1. Bad managers believe what's convenient for them in order avoid dying from shame - but this is a truism and it has nothing to do with the original question.

2. The managers of bad managers believe that the managers below them can do no wrong - but this is like calling the entire management hierarchy a bunch of incompetents, because believing has little to do with rational analysis and evaluation of important decisions, it doesn't work as an answer to the original question: "Why is there no accountability from certain level up?".

> The other aspect is managing the manager.

That aspect, and its entire paragraph, are a rather confusing reformulation of the original question.

> If and when it fails the issue isn't because the idea was bad it was because circumstances.

The end result of the confusion is a blanket excuse to any and all management failures: "it's the circumstances". The same can applied to everyone and everywhere which could only lead to a world more ridiculous than "Idiocracy".

> but for management, company and even shareholders the outcome matters.

I'm not sure what this is saying, the substance of the original question is why the outcome doesn't matter for the above group? And you already explained that it doesn't matter because "it's the circumstances"... I can't square that circle.

bigbadfeline··on Paul Atkins misreads Adam Smith and the American founding
> If the general claim were so important, why then focus on the specific case?

To make his poorly supported claims look more believable, I've explained that in detail already.

> the whole "invisible hand" thing was not only not the central theme of the book, it wasn't even the central theme of the chapter it appears in.

It's a profusely and clearly expressed claim even without being the central theme. Indeed, why should it be? Besides, what's the central theme? It doesn't seem to be anything related to science.

> Smith never gets to the issue of how industry should be regulated,

His preference for the "invisible hand" and his distaste for regulation are plainly visible, we talked about that too. However, if he wrote these as some sort of passing remarks, he clearly missed the central role of regulation in the economy, without that, it's "economics" without science. Using the invisible hand to sweep the issue under the carpet creates only confusion.

> because he's preoccupied with advocating for the very idea of private industry

Calling his writings "advocacy" is indeed the correct approach. Very far from anything approaching science though.

bigbadfeline··on Paul Atkins misreads Adam Smith and the American founding
> I'd certainly agree with Smith about trade deficits,

So you agree that "Nothing, can be more absurd than this whole doctrine of the balance of trade"?

Further, let's look at these two claims in your quote of Smith:

(A) > "every individual necessarily labours to render the annual revenue of the society as great as he can. He generally, indeed, neither intends to promote the public interest, nor knows how much he is promoting it."

So when in (A) Smith says "every individual" and "generally", he doesn't mean it, he means specifically claim (B) "By preferring the support of domestic to that of foreign industry... he intends only his own gain"

Isn't it obvious that Smith uses the sucked-out-of-thumbs claim (A) to "derive" claim (B) as a special case?

You simply refuse to address the text, focusing on your second-guessing instead. Besides, you're completely oblivious to Smith's opinions stated as facts, because in the above quotes, neither the general nor the specific claims are true. They're just "I say so".

bigbadfeline··on Paul Atkins misreads Adam Smith and the American founding
> Sadly, economics is not yet a science,

Nor is there any visible attempt to make it a science.

> Millions of people know Adam Smith only by his "invisible hand" analogy, which appears only once in the entire book and in a completely different context... the tendency of business to buy local.

That's quite a stretch, I mean, it's your right to second-guess Smith as much as you like, and ascribe some "invisible" intent behind his writing, but the text doesn't support your view.

Anyone can read Book 4, Chap 2, where the paragraph in question appears. The whole chapter is full of incessant, obsessive ramblings against regulation in order to "prove" that self-serving, unregulated action always and automatically does better than any regulation motivated by care for the social good. Smith spells it out black on white in par. 4:

Every individual is continually exerting himself to find out the most advantageous employment for whatever capital he can command. It is his own advantage, indeed, and not that of the society, which he has in view. But the study of his own advantage naturally, or rather necessarily, leads him to prefer that employment which is most advantageous to the society

Then Smith uses this insinuation, is if it were a universal principle, to imply the "free trade" rabbit out of his hat - "Secondly, every individual who employs his capital in the support of domestic industry, necessarily endeavours so to direct that industry, that its produce may be of the greatest possible value".

> real science [is] run over by louder, dumber voices shrieking about "free markets" (an oxymoron)

Well, Smith was a free trader, and in that light, he claimed restrictions to free trade are the foundation of all other market regulations, which makes them bad by implication. Smith was a PR BS-generator.

Bk4, Ch 3, part 2 - "Nothing, however, can be more absurd than this whole doctrine of the balance of trade, upon which, not only these restraints, but almost _all the other regulations of commerce, are founded_ ... But that trade which, _without force or constraint_, is naturally and regularly carried on between _any two places_, is always advantageous."

bigbadfeline··on American AI May Not Survive Chinese Open-Source
> Just because America's scale is bigger today doesn't mean they'll stay #1.

There many #1's, in many different areas, cramming truck-loads of capital into two corps while starving everything else, and doing for meager advantages over the cheap stuff, is economic suicide by opportunity cost.

bigbadfeline··on AI companies destroy physical books – let's scan rare books before it's too late
> It's not a flashy issue

It's a very serious issue, very well known to the people with the connections and power to affect it.

> [ it wouldn't ] make a ton of people vote for you to get re-elected

The tons of people are moved by the media, people are oblivious to the tricks of that trade, for the same reasons, obviously. In other words, this issue isn't something that happens to slip below the radar, it's kept stealthy by well organized engineering and considerable expense.

> and it won't create a ton of new jobs

Nothing ever creates tons of new jobs, the "tons" are reserved for promises and other useless noise.

bigbadfeline··on Micron announces $10B research hub in Boise
Due to sanctions, tariffs and capacity crunch. RAM prices are artificially held high.
bigbadfeline··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
> What you propose is similar to proposing that we'll solve climate change by moving back to horse-and-buggy.

And strawmen, don't forget the strawmen... can you stop doing that for a second? You're just underlying your lack of arguments.

> There will be new datacenters, some communities will successfully resist, but many won't.

We moved from "don't resist or else" to "resistance is futile"... what else is new?

bigbadfeline··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
> I think you're vastly under-estimating the extent to which power grids, water systems, and global supply chains and manufacturing rely heavily on datacenters.

These things were with us and worked better before datacenters even existed. Datacenters are a mere convenience which is now used to force monopolization of compute while subjecting society to extremely risky, but unnecessary dependencies and centralization.

You say we're already there? A good reason to start undoing it ASAP.

bigbadfeline··on Field measurements of neighborhood-scale air temperature impacts of data centers
> The childish behavior is disagreeing with how datacenters are being deployed and reducing that to "more is bad"

Why is that childish? Bubble data-center economics is bad, we have the history to prove it, this isn't the first bubble. Do you have real arguments against it besides calling it "childish" which is itself childish?

> I'm begging the collective here to consider what they are really asking for, because our society, from the government down, is built on the cloud.

You're begging "the collective" to stop worrying and learn to love the bubble... or else? OK, or else what? If everything is already "built on the cloud" there's already enough cloud to go around, built at a normal pace, without bubbles and without incurring huge debts, deficits, circular financing and what not. See, the how can be done better.

> Finding a healthy way to provide compute is important, and "data center bad" doesn't get us there.

That's a strawman, which you sneaked in here: 'reducing that to "more is bad" and then ... to "data centers bad"'

The issue is, and always has been - the bubble way of doing it as bad - slow down and do it properly. Either way the public isn't going to get the benefits of the build-out, at least try to reduce the negative externalities to an acceptable level.

bigbadfeline··on On AI regulation and messaging
D.A. >> Anthropic is ramping up its efforts very quickly in biology and medicine

At the same time, the best Anthro models refuse to answer biology questions, keeping the public in the dark not only about new AI-assisted results but also about conventional and health-protective research.

D.A. >> we hope to have incredible results in the coming years and some early glimmers in the coming months.

So, what changed? He went from a promise of AI bonanza any minute now to a promise to maybe cure cancer in the coming years, that's right, an unspecified number of years. Until that time, we're supposed to eat glimmers of hope because the AI-caused inflation will make food unaffordable.

D.A. >> When we’ve actually accomplished something real, the whole world will hear about it, as loudly as possible, you have my word on that.

And don't forget to stock on ear protection, because when something happens, it's going to be "as laud as possible", you've got Amo's word too - to marvel at in the meantime.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →