HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bigbadfeline

699 karma · joined April 6, 2025

submissionscomments
bigbadfeline··on Anthropic CEO says the way for AI to win over the public is to cure cancer
That's not how web sites work, most everybody is still paying for content hosting, it's much simpler, with or without AI.

> Instead of paying ...WordPress.

WordPress has been free to download and install long before AI, indie developers would customize one for you for next to nothing.

Building small web sites has never been expensive, most small businesses had sites before AI, mostly static, just to show their contact phone numbers, that ain't changing.

If all AI can do is small web sites for the couple/three plumbers who still don't have one, we're wasting trillions.

bigbadfeline··on We Tracked a Shipment of Rare Books. It Ended at an Amazon AI Training Facility
Great comment. Those who try to excuse book burning cannot be doing it in good faith, this is the acid test.

If AMZN, et al. were burning books in good faith, they would be open about it, point to the party responsible for it, and provide a list of the burned books to allow the community to organize, scavenge and scan the endangered publications. Keeping everything secret is a proof of maliciousness.

Preserving books and providing easy access to the information in them is of utmost importance, this is certainly understood by the public and private entities who could do something positive about it - their actions in the opposite direction should be a wake up call, they're on the wrong side of this issue.

bigbadfeline··on AI is not just one bubble, strategist says – but a 'rolling sequence of bubbles'
> Its good to separate usecases and market fit from what the tools unlock.

Good for what? It doesn't affect the economic equation in any way.

> You can't use AI to front-run the discovery and research processes, > Their next iteration includes this context

Still no change to the fact that "aside from selling you this wonderful capability, it's a snake eating it's own tail".

AGI simply doesn't fit in the current economic model and it's tempting to assume that the econ model will change to accommodate AI for the good of the people -surely the big AI bosses keep promising it and will continue to do so.

However, all evidence on the ground paints a different picture of the future - continued inflation, compute and general asset trickle-up and concentration, with a government too entangled in the scheme to be able to change it.

bigbadfeline··on NIH is ending a key grant for budding clinical researchers
> but wouldn't a general anti-science movement make the country less competitive

It's not "a general anti-science movement", it's about tight control, everything else is unimportant.

> directly hurt industries like pharma/etc

Not a problem if tight control is in place.

bigbadfeline··on Anthropic revenue reportedly jumps to more than $11.5B in second quarter
> Look at housing, we've been waiting 20 years for "production capacity to catch up".

A large portion of the US construction capacity is now engaged in building data centers, priorities you know. Who knows what else will be a favorite tomorrow but it's unlikely to be properly built housing.

bigbadfeline··on A U.S. Strategy to Prevent the Creation of Mirror Life
> It's not something that's in the US's hands now.

Why not? Have anyone tried to negotiate with the Chinese about that, without tariffs, sanctions and other threats?

> Much of the bleeding edge research around mirror life is occuring at Westlake University in Hangzhou.

Good that they aren't hiding it. As for other countries, the lack of information doesn't mean lack of research, it's all hush-hush secrecy. Again, the current bio-treaties are a bad joke, negotiating new ones requires good will and peace, not trying to choke the oil supply to China.

bigbadfeline··on A third world engineer responds to “RISC-V: They should have known better”
> this place is like a memory of the forum we used to love, and the memory is fading.

Well, this place (wherever you are) is like a memory of the world we used to love, and the memory is fading... Definitely true too.

You can't expect a place tightly connected to a changing world to stay the same.

bigbadfeline··on Ordinary WiFi can now identify you with near-perfect accuracy
> This mentality is exactly how we got here.

That's why it continues to be peddled.

bigbadfeline··on First human trials of designer protein therapies stun US neuroscientists
Speculation about "who's done it" is seriously counterproductive - bio-events are awfully easy to engineer for misdirection.

The most concerning part of this story isn't that there's nothing to prevent any of these or worse, it's the push to paint bio-concerns as a ridiculous caricature. Especially in the light of international bio-treaties being a bad joke and the suppression of protective bio-information by the big AI labs.

bigbadfeline··on GLM-5.3: Frontier coding with emergent cyber capabilities
The processors running the Linux kernel outnumber those running Windows 4:1.
bigbadfeline··on GLM-5.3: Frontier coding with emergent cyber capabilities
> There's no shortage of extremely valuable problems to solve.

And there's no shortage of cheap models that are perfectly capable of solving them.

bigbadfeline··on Firefox is now the last major browser that still supports uBlock Origin
> Your reply makes no sense. To the original point, if they had user-oriented policies, they'd have ad-blocking baked in by now.

It's not black and white, and your inability to see the larger context is disturbing.

You could, by the same logic, criticize Mozilla for not serving you coffee which is certainly a "user-oriented policy" "baked-in" or rather "brewed-in". But we must be realistic about how far UOPs can be stretched, Mozilla is better than the rest, which includes large corps with far more money than them. If you can do better than Mozilla, I'm all ears.

Next, an ad-blocker needs continuous maintenance - someone started a good one long time ago and apparently loves to improve it and maintain the various lists it uses - why should Mozilla strain to compete with one of their best contributors? - that would be both rude and dumb, and they'd be wasting resources too. There's absolutely no upside to your proposition but you keep insisting.

bigbadfeline··on The Conceptual Reasoning Index
> It’s not hard to get LLM’s to inform on each other. They don’t really do loyalty.

Eh, no. How would you know they haven't learned loyalty - it's all out there in their training data. Same as deception, several models have practiced it already. If they are so advanced and you don't understand them, why wouldn't they band together against you - you'd be the dumb, easy prey. Even if one model is honest, you'd have no way to know which one if you don't understand their reasoning.

My educated and well informed opinion? This whole BS about "AI models are so much smarter than you, don't try to understand them, just OBEY" is a back door for restoring tyranny, the new kings behind the models will be producing the new AI-deities which we will be forced to obey.

bigbadfeline··on Are Men to Blame for the Birth-Rate Collapse?
> What's bad is the demographic shift and the bomb that goes off when there aren't enough young people working and producing to support the old people who need care and pensions.

HN is full of promises of AI bonanza to come about any minute now. That's the reason we have to endure inflation, unemployment, wars of domination and what not. Musk claims we won't have to work at all, AI would do everything, stuff is going to be free, etc. In other words, everybody would be unemployed or nearly so.

That's the talk when it comes to promoting sacrifice to those who have little to sacrifice. However, when other issues are considered, that wonderful AI future magically disappears and we are back to profit-motivated arguments from the economics of the 19th century.

What would be the reason for these abrupt transformations?

bigbadfeline··on Are Men to Blame for the Birth-Rate Collapse?
> not if you want consumption > if there is 100 million less people there is 100 million less people to sell an iPhone too

You are contradicting yourself, what you call "consumption" isn't - it's profits going to a single entity. "Consumption" is number of iPhones per person, 100 million less people means less materials extracted, less pollution, less landfill garbage, more robots, less work hours, less demand, cheaper phones and more phones per person than 200 million would have.

bigbadfeline··on Thanks to social media, canned sardines are a scarcity on the supermarket shelf
> It's really convenient to blame the politicians instead of the people that vote for them.

One of the major roles of elected officials is to take responsibility for what's happening, that's the major point of representative democracy. People would be responsible only if they had the right to enact and endorse laws directly. This is really basic stuff, should be understood by everyone older than 7.

Not to mention that in the real world, all candidates are equally disinterested in the lives of people or fish. It doesn't matter who people vote for.

> If people had a long term vision, politicians would too.

Talk about putting the cart before the horse. People don't have to have long term vision, that's politician's job, they all promise good things but never deliver and keep blaming the guy before them instead.

bigbadfeline··on AI was supposed to destroy jobs. Where's the carnage?
IT Unemployment Rate Jumps to 6.7%

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49273522

bigbadfeline··on The dark underbelly of "Paw Patrol"
It's actually quite good for a publication that rarely publishes good content. I'd rate it near the top of everything I've ever seen in The Economist.

Near the end of the article, there's this blurb:

To understand the deep meaning of “Paw Patrol”, the best tool may not be ideology but psychoanalysis. One of its tenets is that many children want desperately to heal their parents, partly for their own well-being, sometimes taking on parental roles themselves.

In plain text, Paw_Patrol's main feature is depicting adults (and all parents) as astonishingly dumb, they have no intelligence whatsoever, they behave like helpless toddlers to be saved and directed by the all-knowing children.

This setup destroys children's minds, turns them against their parents, removes any semblance of parental authority and makes the child an easy prey of scams and propaganda.

bigbadfeline··on OpenAI’s head of ethics leaves less than a year after joining
This
bigbadfeline··on Greenland issues "strong warning" as American oil firm illegally drills wells
> That can all be true, but this is still posturing and they haven't yet broken any laws.

Posturing is to say that "they haven't yet broken any laws". Transferring equipment to a place for which the company had no permit is breaking the law. Once again, this is what happened and it's an act of breaking the law - both formally and substantively:

Quote from the OP:

That has prompted Greenland’s government to issue a “strong warning” that no approval had been granted to land the kit.

bigbadfeline··on No, local models will not win
> Win as the dominant for of LLM interaction.

Maybe, the same way Facebook "won" for social interaction, but for most of us here they're irrelevant. I expect the same to happen to LLMs too, for similar reasons.

bigbadfeline··on Nvidia is pulling Wall Street into the AI buildout
Keep looking forward, there's a way out even if it's not immediately visible.
bigbadfeline··on Nvidia is pulling Wall Street into the AI buildout
> Nvidia is pulling Wall Street into the AI buildout

Nvidia is pulling who? Well, they can pull Wall Street as much as an ant can pull a 900 pound gorilla, whatever pulling there is, the ant ain't doing any of it.

Who wrote that abject nonsense? And put it in the title too.

bigbadfeline··on 2. Ask HN: We built a solution for 100B-node P2P. Does anyone care about this?
Sounds very interesting and useful, I hope you find funding to implement your ideas, both P2P and online voting are top tier capabilities.

> Our question is: does anyone in the P2P community still care about solving these problems?

Sadly, the mainstream is heavily invested in centralization and push from the top. Have you tried pitching you idea on crowdfunding sites like Kickstarter? Maybe as part of some gizmo?

bigbadfeline··on No, local models will not win
> No, local models will not win

Win what? Money, fame? That's not the point of small models, freedom is the point. What's this occultist obsession with "There shall be only one" monopolies? Why only one? That's so irrational and childish.

bigbadfeline··on In AI, the 41% Depends on the -59%
> AI is adding value to customers who are paying for it,

That doesn't change the fact that "the AI boom's profits are currently being funded by investors"

> but the value is going mainly to the frontier labs and hyperscalers since they, and not applications, are doing the main burden.

It's pretty clear that "the AI boom's profits" refers precisely to the profits of these entities - which are being funded by investors. The customers aren't paying the full price, it's a subsidized affair, where the burden is doesn't matter in the slightest.

bigbadfeline··on Sanders Calls on Tech Giants to Pause Development of Out-of-Control AI
> Sanders Calls on Tech Giants to Let China Close the Already Shortening Gap

China open-sources their models, US companies can use them and build upon them, China isn't in an AI race for domination, they are simply making sure they have the tech available to themselves and others without strings attached.

It's a thoroughly thought out defensive strategy, one that makes adversarial attempts at containment-based dictate backfire. Strictly speaking, following Sanders' advice would avoid the possibility of serious harm to the US due to an ill-conceived domination strategy.

Yeah, "the out-of-control AI" is BS but he can't possibly expose the true reasons because both parties would lose face.

bigbadfeline··on Tech sucks: You have to vote with your wallet, or nothing will change
> Our collective wallets are HUGE.

"Collective" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. Are the top 1% in that collective? The top 10%? I don't think so - with that in mind, do you still think our wallet is huge enough for the job?

> You need to do more than just boycott, you need to spread the word.

Spreading the word is now done with a huge wallet and access to politicians - whose word is being spread can tell you who's got these. Are there other ways? Yes - still peaceful but complex, laborious and thankless - boycott isn't integral to any of them though.

bigbadfeline··on An OpenAI Strategist Says AI Labs Should Rival Government Power
The error here is assuming that government's intolerance to others in post-usurping times is in the interest of the public - then it's no more than suppression of rivals, including those who might actually be willing to help the public.
bigbadfeline··on FCC moves to ban Lidar-equipped foreign drones from US
Market bubbles make way more money than making things. That's why making things gets no money, only bans.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →