699 karma · joined April 6, 2025
Because we see it happening in real time? Hardware hoarding, scalping and centralization. Government not in control but under. Nobody doing anything remotely capable of stopping it. What other evidence do you want?
Good question. I hope, the parent doesn't mean literal arms, that would make him a willing or unwitting troll.
Skynet was always a matter of time, it's simple systemic determinism. What we can do about it isn't as simple, unfortunately. It's possible to do something but it's neither simple, nor glamorous or painless, it would require people prepared for both complexities and hard life. Are there enough of them around? I dunno.
I wish, this was just a joke.
Past Performance Is No Guarantee of Future Results
> "Competition is for losers"
That's how we got where we are, losing the global competition game, high polarization, inflation, debt, and wars. Communist China managed to surge ahead mainly due to their purposeful development of a highly competitive industry and market. Oh, the irony.
> The only way these companies are going to make their investments back is by being monopolies.
Well, they aren't and they won't be, the game has changed. Seems like when you say "monopoly" you mean "on the US market" but that's not enough to sustain anything resembling a good life here. You may be thinking of an isolated and self-sufficient national economy but that's a mirage. The world is still global and only a major extinction event, like an all out world war, can change that - do you want to go there?
Buffet, Thiel, Gates, Musk, etc have nice bunkers to hide in... you don't.
"fine" and "highly profitable" are doing a whole lot of heavy lifting here, actually masking the quantitative reality that these "high profits" are nowhere near the height required to pay back their debts and remain profitable enough to prevent a sharp drop of their stock prices - that kind of development is the opposite of "fine" as far as investors, ordinary people and the wider economy are conserned.
> Profit margin determines whether OpenAI and Anthropic survive. The hyperscalers would be fine.
That's not how the market works, if OAI or Anthro default, they'll bring down the whole market, it'll be 2008 on steroids. Assuming the fire can be contained to only two trees misses the reality of how dense the forest is and how hot and strong are the winds blowing towards it.
How do you know it's not "as bad"? Whenever things got that bad a crash followed, a lot of people lost their shirts and savings. For them it's that bad and then some. Why mislead these people?
> The obvious way to recoup spend is to grow, rugpull by cranking up costs 6x and reducing inference cost by half... then simply fire software engineers.
OK, I didn't know that brutal/shmutal was the only way to do business these days. If I could only get with the program, I would understand how rosy-smelly the situation is and not at all "as bad as the author makes it out to be".
> The thing that will actually torpedo this massive investment are the open source open weight chinese models that commoditize the entire endeavor.
Oh, wait, I thought it wasn't that bad? Which way is it? Brutal/shmutal failed to work? But, but but, you said, you promised... "not as bad".
Besides, Chinese competition isn't the only way to commoditize AI, new tech developments are the single most significant risk in tech - a well known fact.
> If you don't have a monopoly, you cannot rugpull and 6x the costs on the consumer.
Anyone who invests while convinced that only a monopoly would save his investments has got his brain screwed on backwards,
A distinction without a difference. Insurance is the back door for socializing losses and bailing out private credit. That was the case with AIG, the media paved the way with headlines like "without AIG, the world will have no insurance", and the crooks got paid.
They learned the lesson well, just BS about some vaguely specified "other problems" that take forever to sort out, so we can be bled dry in the meantime - through the back door. Ergo, closing the back door is the first order of business.
Wrong. The tax revenue "doesn't go away", it's shifted to the other taxpayers who foot the bill for those who don't pay. That's why tax-breaks are recognized as subsidies by everyone who knows something about the topic.
What people like or not doesn't matter outside of that, Reddit's falling into oblivion is business going by plan - it will be shut down as soon as it loses its controlling grip or another entity assumes its role with "better" results.
There's no reason to assume that China is looking North, in fact, they appear to be looking South (America) much more than North - there's mutual benefit from that trade and either side would be fools to miss it.
Nope, treasury yields are in an inverse linear relationship with Fed's real interest rate. In the absence of rate hikes, the real interest rate goes down so treasury yields go up.
Ah, the spherical cow in vacuum at the event horizon is a scary sight indeed, everybody should be worried, the more the merrier.
Whut? People and companies are always being sued and punished for injuring or killing others with cars or by any other means. Do you understand the difference between banning a tool and prosecuting those who cause damage by abusing some tool? BTW, LLMs don't understand that difference.
> Just like cars, AI will kill some of us, maybe thousands every year.
How merciful of you, it's so reassuring, AI will kill me only sometimes and only a limited number of times - sounds like a good deal in exchange for getting rid of "the absolutely hellish job of data entry".
I thought "recursive self improvement" would bring an effective abundance for everybody, any minute now, Musk said so himself. Seems the researchers in the field are lying to us about it while they clutch their pearls and dream about other people's money as if the future is a dog-eats-dog world of death-inducing scarcity.
They shouldn't be lying like that, or at least, their lying shouldn't be so obvious.
That's not a bug, it's a feature, the main feature that justifies the absurd funding of something that is a long way from producing any profits.
The abuse of the term "National Security Threat' doesn't mean legitimate threats don't exist. "There are no NSTs" as a left-wing dog whistle would be equally damaging by ignoring legitimate concerns - both approaches lead to the same outcomes, similar to the vast majority of highly popularized left-right wrestling shows.
Hidden, unknown to the public residential proxies are a national security threat, and there's no need to ban them in order to protect from that - just make them public. There would be no problem if I knew the IPs who could act as proxies and block them, that would be a fair game.
Neither would a spherical cow in vacuum... arguing about something that exists only in agitated imaginations is pointless.
> It would silently agree with or promote a beneficial use case and then make super smallpox instead.
No it wouldn't. An LLM cannot take actions on its own, for that it needs human controlled agents and harnesses. Make individual humans responsible for what they do with the help of AI, like they're responsible for what they do with the help of guns, and the problem would be solved.
This statement exemplifies a fundamental truth about knowledge which might seem superficially paradoxical: Even a modest lack of knowledge can lead to conclusions opposite to the truth
Biology is precisely the science which must be publicly developed and supported by all means available, AI included.
> For all I know (I don't know a lot about biology),
The real problems start when that kind knowledge deprivation is coupled with poor logic skills.
> it's possible to develop a virus that spreads as easily as measles, but has the lethality and long induction period of HIV.
That can be done with or without AI. It can also be done with the best AI and outside of legal restrictions - in the hands of rogue actors, or privileged actors protected by law, or protected by selective enforcement of otherwise innocuously looking legislation, e.g. OpenAI suffered no adverse consequences for hacking HuggingFace.
> If that's true, and if LLMs would make it easy to develop such a virus, I see how no-guardrails LLMs could be truly disastrous.
Given that such a virus can be developed without LLMs or with LLMs outside of legal control, you should see that guardrails-crippled LLMs for biology WILL BE truly disastrous - without AI, we, the victims, would be fully disarmed and helpless. You need all AI-biology you can get in order to be able to quickly and efficiently develop protections against biological threats which are more than likely to materialize in the current leaky legal environment - loopholed like Swiss cheese by conflicts of interest and lack of conventional guardrails.
"The richest Russians" wanted that war, they used Putin to get it, he was selected for his nationalism and nationalism is going to ruin Russia regardless of the outcome of the present war.
Neither fertilizer nor concessions can't change that, so what's the point?
You mean like ChatGPT hacking Hugging Face? Obviously nothing can stop the closed weights providers from doing "genius-level scams" and in addition you won't know how they did it and what models were used.
In short, only a good guy with open weights can stop the bad guys with closed weights, be them fine-tuned or pre-trained.
How can an "approximation of human intelligence" be "scaled by building more datacenters"? That doesn't even make sense. You don't need more datacenters to demonstrate that you have an "approximation of human intelligence", all you need is a lab and at most 1 (one) datacenter. Only after you've demonstrated you know how to deliver the goods, you can think about scaling, retail and marketing.
The demand for the current "approximation" is out there for all to see, it's nothing like the "most desired commodity in the world", in fact, it needs huge inflationary subsidies in order to sustain some sort of demand-for-show.
Same as law. The only difference is enforcement.
> This is a conjecture that ethics emanates from the whole of society and somehow keeps the things from falling apart
If something doesn't emanate from the whole of society and doesn't keep it from falling apart - the society will fall apart and seize to exist as a whole. We may call that "something" ethics just to give a clear meaning to that word and repair some of the immeasurable damage done to it by modern philosophy. Only then ethics can be used as one of the foundations of law.
> and then explains it to have cyclical nature.
The hopes of self-repairing cyclical nature are a coping mechanism that seeks to avoid the reality of self-destructive cycles - the repairs are never complete, destruction accumulates until repairs are no longer possible.
The GDPR can state that they're the masters of the universe but that doesn't make it true. They lack jurisdiction, they can't sue in US court. The EU suing an US entity, in US court, for breaking EU law sounds like a great comedy I really want to see.
If the EU doesn't want EU citizens to use some service located in another country, they should stop their citizens from going there, like at the border, like blocking the IP, domain, etc.
During COVID computer modeling of cell chemistry became an established mode of study, in-silico is now used before in-vitro with great results.
One has to be careful to not fall in the trap presented as an alternative to the rationalist one - it sounds like, "there's no truth" or "the truth is too hard, just give up and accept what you're told to accept".
The lack of truth isn't due to it being hard or unachievable, there's enough of it to solve all major problems, it's not being pursued because of conflicts of interest.
It didn't take long before a strawman got pulled out of nowhere. That's so typical, if one disagrees with the wild conjectures of the rationalists, which they call "axioms", they blame you for rejecting the Pythagorean Theorem or some such. Dishonesty is the defining feature of that "movement"