HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bill_joy_fanboy

237 karma · joined November 13, 2018

submissionscomments
bill_joy_fanboy··on The traffickers are winning the war on drugs
Do you understand what "winning" the drug war would entail?

Realistically, it would involve making anyone who was involved in importing or selling illegal drugs disappear instead of just imprisoning them for a while and then letting them out to do it again.

You got the stomach for it?

bill_joy_fanboy··on What Americans die from vs. what the news reports on
That's because all major media outlets in the U.S. are run by the same people.
bill_joy_fanboy··on Asked to do something illegal at work? Here's what these software engineers did
Is it really counter-productive, though?

Propensity to do harm through crime, violence, etc. is largely a genetic attribute.

Take a violent drug lord for example. Do you really want a woman capable of loving him allowed to continue on as if nothing happened?

bill_joy_fanboy··on Asked to do something illegal at work? Here's what these software engineers did
Well, that's nice that you feel that way. But, you don't get to decide what people "deserve" or what "should" happen.

I happen to disagree. I think these crimes (and many others) should follow you more or less permanently.

My opinions on what "should" be the case have just as much validity as yours.

Please be self aware when you are making baseless moral claims.

bill_joy_fanboy··on How did sports betting become legal in the US?
The article is about gambling in the U.S., not cigarettes in Australia.

Also, these policies usually fail in getting existing users to quit, but they succeed in deterring prospective users. The idea that these policies are "not going very well" is an incredibly narrow-minded and short-sighted perspective.

bill_joy_fanboy··on How did sports betting become legal in the US?
Not a lotto fan, but, in theory, the money collected by state lotteries goes to some sort of public good (scholarships, etc.). Don't get me wrong, I still see them as destructive, but they don't operate with the same intent.

These new sports books are operating purely to enrich the owners of the platform. Ban 'em.

bill_joy_fanboy··on How did sports betting become legal in the US?
Or, just make it illegal.
bill_joy_fanboy··on US to target more businesses after Hyundai raid
I told this exact argument to a supporter of deportation policies, and they responded with this:

"I don't care about higher grocery prices. I don't care about economic efficiency. I just want them gone."

I don't believe you understand their value system.

EDIT: In particular, an appeal to economic prosperity will not win an argument with someone who isn't basing their decisions on economics.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Google: 'Your $1000 phone needs our permission to install apps now' [video]
Your comment makes it sound like this is reasonable. It is not.

This is a complete and total ripoff. Everyone knows it.

bill_joy_fanboy··on There Goes the American Muscle Car
> Salaries have outpaced inflation until recently.

This is just not true.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
> I don't want money for free. I want to be able to earn it, and earn well. I want to feel like I've accomplished something.

Well, if that's true then I wouldn't bother being a landlord. Being a landlord just means your name is on the title of a building such that it allows you to extract money from people who need a place to live. It's not creative, it's not original, and it's only possible because they aren't making any more real estate, but they're always making more people.

I said above to another commenter: I would also like to be a landlord one day. I'm sure I'd be a decent one. But, I won't be pretending like I'm doing anything productive... I'm just extracting money from the fact that my name is on a deed. Nothing more, nothing less.

It's just how our economy is set up, and, like everyone, I plan to try and take advantage of it. I won't be kidding myself, though, that I'm somehow a productive or noble small business man.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
This was also my experience.

I've been a perfect tenant my entire life, and I was still always treated like trash by every landlord I've rented from. I don't think they make a distinction.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
You may have a more reasonable stance than most landlords, but that doesn't change the essence of the transaction.

If you could get higher rent without getting punished by the market (turnover), you would do it. If you could spend less on maintenance without getting punished by the market (turnover and reduced resale value), you would do it.

Many, if not most, landlords push both of these levers to their absolute limits.

The essence of being a landlord is that you've got your name on the title of a scarce resource that is difficult or impossible in some cases to duplicate: real estate in a particular location. The fact that your name is on this title means that you can extract value from people who need a place to live and did not arrive there first so they could buy the cheap property, build the building, etc.

Don't get me wrong, I hope to be a landlord too some day. Ownership is what matters when there's nowhere else to move. I look forward to the rent checks. However, I won't be pretending there's anything noble or fair about what I'm doing. It's just how the rules of our economy are set up.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
You're arguing with me, but this statement...

> Everybody wants to maximize their money received and minimize their money and work expended to whatever degree possible.

...is exactly in agreement with what I said above.

The ideal business is one where you take in money and have no expenditures. E.g., If you're a landlord, you want super high rent and no expenditures on maintenance or improvements.

I would also accept the other direction. That is, a tenant wants use of a property for no rent, ideally.

My point was that small businesses aren't noble somehow. They want money for free just like everybody else.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
Isn't that what court is for?
bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
I somewhat agree, but I still think the "job posting" market needs regulation.

If you aren't going to shutdown offshoring and the importing of labor through the abuse of things like the H1B program, you aren't going to accomplish much in terms of fixing how the average American worker is treated.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
I actually hope such open roles are spammed.

I recently saw a project that spammed online job postings with AI slop resumes. This is great since... if your posting is slop and you don't intend to hire, you should have your inbox filled with slop. It only makes sense.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Proposal to Ban Ghost Jobs
They all want to be, though. All business want to be big-time like Amazon, but not all of them are so lucky.

I don't understand the making of excuses for small businesses as though they are somehow morally better than large businesses.

Every business owner, regardless of the size of the business, wants free labor.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Conspiracy theorists unaware their beliefs are on the fringe
> This is mostly used incompetently, but occasionally used maliciously.

It can also just be a good heuristic. If a person or group/org with a reputation for dishonesty tells you an "idea", it's reasonable to throw shade.

> I think I see this most commonly in politics, where if <obviously bad> person supports an idea, then that idea must be also bad.

The conclusion is not always this direct, but it is completely reasonable to question ~why~ the obviously bad person holds that idea. What do they gain from pushing the agenda? Some people are so intellectually dishonest that everything they say is suspect.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
You believe the official government unemployment numbers?

That's kind of like saying you believe the official government inflation numbers.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
If people don't want things to continue to deteriorate, then the economic disenfranchisement of the American working class must be put to a stop. It's really pretty simple.
bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
> Not so implicit, "I will be your retribution".

I don't particularly like the idea of tariffs, but it is what it is.

Having to put up with policies you don't like is simply the social consequence of applying unpopular policies for four years in the other direction.

If the opposing party supports outsourcing, importing of labor, no protections for domestic industry, then they should expect retaliation from people who don't like those policies and who have the means to vote in someone who will push for whatever they view as corrective action.

This is a democracy. If one party pushes unpopular policies (unpopular to the other side), don't be surprised with the opposition pushes back.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
> What these people don't realize is even if they make 200K a year and drive an 85K financed F-250, they are effectively in the same class as someone making 50K a year managing a Dollar General.

More people making under 50K per year voted for Trump in 2024 than voted for Harris.

Your numbers are off.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
That may be your lived experience, but it doesn't match the data.[1]

The working class is shifting to Trump because his rhetoric matches what they want to see: trade restrictions, protections on domestic labor, and the return of good/stable manufacturing jobs.

Trump is almost certainly not the best representation of the American worker, but he's winning because he, at least, tells them what they want to hear.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2024/11/14/nx-s1-5183060/why-working-cla...

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
> Because things can definitely get worse.

Absolutely.

If people don't want things to get worse, then the abuse and disenfranchisement of the American worker must end.

That's kind of where we are at this point.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
> Then they’ve failed to imagine how much more difficult their life will become under excessive tariffs.

Again, these workers don't have jobs. When the John Deere factory closes down in your town and moves to Mexico, tariffs sound good even if it's just to punish such companies and the abuse of their workers.

If you're unemployed and living on whatever odd jobs and government assistance you can get, tariffs won't make one bit of difference in your life. Factories may even return, and your life may improve. It's better than just accepting your situation.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
This is quite an anti-worker comment.

"They still have cereal and fast food and they're not getting shot so they're fine." LOL.

bill_joy_fanboy··on 2025 Recession Indicators Hit Fashion and Wall Street at Once
A lot of supporters of the trade restrictions don't care. They're working people who don't own a lot of stocks and all they've seen is their jobs sent overseas.

To them, it doesn't even matter if things get "worse" for a while. Their life is already meeting every economic headwind imaginable.

bill_joy_fanboy··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
> It's true that free trade is hugely beneficial to the US economy as a whole, particularly with the USD being the reserve currency.

It's true that free trade is hugely beneficial to large cap U.S. companies and their shareholders.

If you are U.S. worker without a lot of equity in the market all you notice is that your job gets outsourced.

bill_joy_fanboy··on America desperately needs more air traffic controllers
This is completely true.

I make less working remotely in a LCOL area than I would in the HCOL area where my office resides. The differential in COL, though, is so high that I'm saving a lot more. In other words, I'm making less but I'm building more wealth.

Most of the money that goes into living in a HCOL area and commuting to office is just pure waste to satisfy the egos of upper managers who want to preside over a big floor of workers.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →