HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bill_joy_fanboy

237 karma · joined November 13, 2018

submissionscomments
bill_joy_fanboy··on Prisoners in the US are part of a hidden workforce linked to popular food brands
> Incomprehensible to you that this a sincerely held belief? In fact I have been the victim of violent crimes, and I have given statements advocating for maximum leniency.

Well, I won't call you a liar. I've seen people do this before, and I've always been just... confused.

> I want what is best for my community, and retribution is not.

I think this is the crux of the disagreement.

My belief is that retribution is the immune system of civilization.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Prisoners in the US are part of a hidden workforce linked to popular food brands
> "Well established"

Not really.

I hope you or your family are never hurt by a criminal. However, if that does happen, I assume you will be okay with the criminal going to a summer camp where they sing songs, play games, and eat bonbons. ;)

bill_joy_fanboy··on Prisoners in the US are part of a hidden workforce linked to popular food brands
Noted this in a comment above, but restating it here: If someone has wronged me or my family or society at large in some kind of serious manner, rehabilitating is not really a concern for me. I think they should be punished. Plain and simple.
bill_joy_fanboy··on Prisoners in the US are part of a hidden workforce linked to popular food brands
If someone has wronged me or my family or society at large in some kind of severe manner by committing a crime, I don't really care if they are rehabilitated. I want them punished. Why complicate things?

Also, I recognize that there are a lot of people in prison in the U.S. who shouldn't be there. I think our the way people end up in prison needs reform, of course. However, once there, the point is to punish people for doing something wrong, IMHO. "Rehabilitation" is not the point of prison.

bill_joy_fanboy··on What do premarital experiences have to do with marital quality? (2014)
I think I broke your brain.
bill_joy_fanboy··on What do premarital experiences have to do with marital quality? (2014)
My guess would be that this would depend on income bracket.

My worry if divorced would be splitting up my retirement savings. Alimony would probably be comparatively cheap.

Still, most people who get divorced probably have nothing to divide and no income to divert to the poorer spouse.

If you look at mid-to-high-income homes, I bet alimony goes up.

bill_joy_fanboy··on What do premarital experiences have to do with marital quality? (2014)
> Nothing? This is worse than nutrition studies in terms of being able to draw conclusions.

This research result doesn't have to prove causality conclusively to be useful.

It is an established fact that higher numbers of premarital partners among women correlate positively with likelihood of their eventually seeking a divorce from their husband. I think it's also been shown that this correlation exists for men as well, though it is not as strong.

This correlation is either causal or it is not. That is to say, (1) more premarital partners for women causes divorce odds to shoot up, or (2) women who have tendencies to have more premarital partners have some other quality that causes them to be more likely to get divorced.

Either way, good advice for a future husband is to avoid marrying a woman who has a lot of premarital partners (provided he wants to avoid being divorced).

The research result is useful for men to think about in spite of its inability to firmly establish causality.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
If you care about your population surviving, you know that a birth rate below 2 is a serious problem that must be solved.

Allowing your populace to sedate itself with weed/booze/porn/etc. is the opposite of solving this problem.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
This isn't really a good answer.

"Society" isn't really a unit. The decision to "tolerate" alcohol isn't unanimous, I mean.

> If we can tolerate the harms from alcohol, why can't we tolerate the (much lower) harms from cannabis?

Because you're just adding more harm. Those who don't drink but smoke weed are now harmed. Those who drink and add weed are now even worse off.

There is no way to make the logic work.

If someone steals $100, it doesn't make it better for them to say "Yeah, well, that guy stole $1,000". It doesn't make their actions okay.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
Well, a society that makes deleterious substances illegal is more alive than one that embraces them with open arms. Don't you think?
bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
Why is the argument always "It's less harmful than alcohol..."?

Alcohol is definitely bad. What does marijuana have to do with alcohol?

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-term_effects_of_cannabis#...

Immoral? Yes.

However, that's not the only factor. It's actually bad for reproduction.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
Beer is okay. Therefore, weed is okay.

I follow your logic.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Germany unveils bill to legalize cannabis
They won't.

Birth rate in Germany is ~1.5-ish.

The West seems to be dying by a thousand cuts. This is yet another cut.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
> This is not the role of the police. Their role is solely punishment and deterrence.

Wrong. The role of the police is to enforce the law.

If the law says you are not allowed to be in possession of certain substances that you are in possession of, then you have committed a crime and the police can arrest you for it. End of story.

> Passing a law against drug use is pre-crime when the only real justification for the law is to prevent other crimes.

It is not pre-crime. By definition, pre-crime is arresting someone before breaking the law. If possession/use is illegal and you do either of those things, you have committed a crime.

I repeat: You have already committed a crime if you use/possess illegal drugs. It cannot be pre-crime in such a scenario.

Also, it's perfectly reasonable and practical to make something illegal because it leads to other (more damaging) actions.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Living without a smartphone: The definitive guide
I agree with you. Our global leaders are trustworthy, as is our education system.

We're the smart people. We think the right thoughts.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
A lot of people would probably be willing to give up a minor drug or alcohol habit to have/keep a high-paying intelligence job.

I would certainly accept being "always sober" as a condition of employment if the job was one I really wanted.

I can't find the study, but I seem to remember that alcohol consumption follows the 80/20 rule. A small amount of alcohol consumers consume basically all the alcohol, with non-alcholics consuming very little. If you consume very little, it's probably not a big deal just to go without completely.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
Or, we could call them non-degenerates.

You can call them whatever you like, I suppose.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
Yeah, why prevent anything bad from happening, LOL

BTW, if it's a crime to use certain drugs, and you use those drugs and are arrested, and that arrest prevents further crimes, this was NOT an example of "pre-crime". You committed a crime. You used illegal drugs.

"Pre-crime" is not an accurate description of what I'm talking about.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
This has gotta be the most intellectually dishonest comment I've ever read.

Nobody trusts U.S. intelligence agencies anymore, bro. Whatever.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
Might it not be smart to prevent those crimes from happening by preventing drug use/abuse in the first place?
bill_joy_fanboy··on Oregon decriminalized hard drugs – early results aren’t encouraging
Alcohol as a "luxury market" is really just a marketing gimmick. It's dressed up to be palatable and to entice people. Dealers gotta make money.

"Society" isn't really a unit. Plenty of people would happily make alcohol illegal if they had power. It's not ethically acceptable to drink in a lot of communities (even in the U.S.). Some countries prohibit alcohol present day.

My point is that the status of alcohol as "ethically acceptable" is far from universal.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
For an intelligence officer, I would say, yeah, you should probably never be high or drunk. Maybe "never been high/drunk" is too strict.

If you're mopping the mess hall, you can probably go home and have a six pack if you want. Just not on the job...

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
The United States is constantly at war.

If spying prevents war, it's not working. LOL...

bill_joy_fanboy··on Senate votes to let people who’ve used marijuana work at intelligence agencies
Saying "it's okay to do something bad" (smoke weed) because "someone else did something worse" (drink booze) is hardly an argument.

Both are not ideal for people in positions of public trust.

I don't want my intelligence officers drunk OR high. Is that too much to ask?

bill_joy_fanboy··on Marijuana addiction: those struggling often face skepticism
You don't get flu-like symptoms from quitting gambling. Is gambling not addictive?

Addiction has nothing to do with physical symptoms. It is an urge to engage in a behavior that is damaging.

I think you need to get your definitions straight.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Reinventing the E.R. for America’s mental-health crisis
Like you said, I think looking at younger ages is sufficient.

In 1999, teen (15-19) suicide was at around 8/100k, and it's now around 11/100k. It's lower in absolute numbers than in the general population, but there's still a disturbing uptick.

https://www.charliehealth.com/research/the-us-teen-suicide-r...

bill_joy_fanboy··on Reinventing the E.R. for America’s mental-health crisis
One way to cut the nonsense is to look at things that can't be fudged.

Suicide is an example. You can't "overdiagnose" suicide unless you outright lie that it happened. The rate for suicide was something like 10/100K in 2001 and is hovering at 14/100K now. This is a significant increase.

If more people are killing themselves, it's almost certain that there are far more people are also miserable or struggling than there used to be.

This seems like pretty direct reasoning, but I suppose it could be flawed.

bill_joy_fanboy··on Time to bring back asylums?
Where did you come up with the numbers 90% and 10%?

Did you just make them up?

bill_joy_fanboy··on Young adults and mental health: Is more childhood independence the answer?
It's difficult to worry about higher-order emotions when your basic material needs aren't met.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →