HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

billswift

4,422 karma · joined April 22, 2008

submissionscomments
billswift··on Google threatens to cut ties with Chamber of Commerce over Protect-IP lobbying
No, it's a fight between content providers and everybody else. Or some content providers.

I have heard the Chamber of Commerce's position referred to as "Rotarian Socialism - Free Enterprise, and Keep those subsidies coming." In this particular case they want to expand some members legal privileges which is even worse, long-term, than financial subsidies.

billswift··on What mathematical function starts slow, explodes, and then plateaus?
This is a really bad web site. The page loaded, I saw the poll for a few seconds then it (apparently) redirected my browser to a blank page that took a long time to load. I could see the poll again, for a few seconds at a time, by repeatedly pressing the Back button. (I'm using Firefox 3.6.23)

Several of the formulas presented I don't know the curve off-hand, but none looked like it matched. The closest I can think of is x = y ^ 3 which approximates a logistic (S) curve; starts slow, rises steeply, then slows again, though it doesn't "plateau". Actually, an odd integer greater than 3 would lead to a steeper rise and flatter plateau, the bigger the integer the better.

billswift··on Ask HN: Is there a "sync & share" service for Bookmarks?
This is a bit off-topic, but I have occasionally had trouble backing up and transferring bookmarks, so when I add something to my bookmarks now I usually (unless it's a strictly temporary bookmark) add the URL to a text file. It's a pain, but fairly cheap as insurance.
billswift··on College has been oversold
For anyone really interested in liberal arts, you would probably be better off doing it on your own, even if college was a lot cheaper than it is. Use your money more for things that will repay the investment.

There are some really good resources out there for self-study. An easy one to start with is Ron Gross's The Independent Scholar's Handbook, http://www.amazon.com/Independent-Scholars-Handbook-Ronald-G....

But the much older (early seventies) book This Way Out is even more useful. My Amazon review:

This book is in 3 parts, the last 2 Experimental Colleges and Foreign Study are too dated to be useful.

Part one is the best book for college-level self-study I have used. I first read it in the early 1980s and have reread it several times since, it is only 135 pages but packed with useful advice. The biggest weakness for the current user is that it has nothing on computers or the internet, but some of its advice such as "Write lots of short papers. Long papers kill students and tutors alike. Write lots of short papers. It will teach you too write and that, as we will demonstrate later, is essential" could almost have been written for the Web (most books on creating web pages emphasize short, to the point writing). They also mention the absolute essential for self-education - you must love to read, if you don't, then stay in college where they will force you to read.

http://www.amazon.com/This-way-out-alternatives-traditional/...

billswift··on “Engineering – Over/Under” – evolution...
In other words, "you won't know what 'good enough' is until you see it." I think "iteration" is a seriously under-used idea.
billswift··on Body hacking trick: cooling the hands for better performance
Cold causes blood vessels to constrict, restricting blood flow. It is a totally different response from coagulation.
billswift··on Mass-scale Cold Fusion either becomes reality or proved a scam today
He didn't. He pointed out that people still invest in perpetual motion scams as reason to believe people will keep investing in cold fusion. The fact that cold fusion is less obviously a scam than perpetual motion actually strengthens his point.
billswift··on Now Outages Could Get You Sued
>If you screw up, you could anger the wrong people and end up in a court room trying to defend yourself.

From the post, it looks more like an enterprising lawyer seeing an opportunity than RIM "angering" somebody. Which is even scarier for providers, looking into future risks.

billswift··on Google Denies Requests To Remove Videos of Police Brutality
>their first duty is to their share holders.

Even if this is entirely true, it is quite possible that fighting the law more aggressively may be in their share holders best long-term interest. An excessive focus on the extremely short term has caused many businesses quite a lot of trouble over the last century. For a really interesting analysis of the decline of a machine-tool manufacturing company (the most thorough discussion of the issues I know of) see Max Holland's When the Machine Stopped, about the decline and collapse of Burgmaster, a mid-century "start-up" by an inventor.

billswift··on Richard Stallman on Steve Jobs: correction
There isn't really much of a tension there. For the most part liberty increases security; it is only in very narrow situations, such as war-making, that it does not. Several libertarians, conservatives, and even Bruce Schneier have been pointing that out repeatedly, especially in anti-PATRIOT Act articles, over the last decade.

The problem is that many restrictions on freedom can give the illusion of security, and too many people are willing to sacrifice their own and others freedom for those warm fuzzies.

billswift··on Economics in One Lesson
That is actually the way "rational agent" is used in much of philosophy and has been taken up by AI researchers - a rational agent is one that seeks to obtain its goals within the scope of its beliefs about the world.
billswift··on Grave-robbing DARPA satellite to form new orbiters from dead equipment
Since satellites aren't designed with that sort of ablation effect in mind, I think hugh3's point that it would fall apart as various connecting bits burned through early would be much more likely.
billswift··on Grave-robbing DARPA satellite to form new orbiters from dead equipment
The most expensive part of the whole process is getting stuff into orbit. The main reason satellites have to be super-reliable is that even getting such levels of reliability is cheaper than sending up a replacement.
billswift··on Who You Are
>humans as super rational utility maximisers

Is not an economic model, it is a straw-man of the economic "model" which states that en masse and over time humans behave rationally where their interests are involved. (I put model above in quotes because even that is really only an aspect of how economics models human behavior.)

As many "critics" of economics have pointed out, and as Surowiecki reported in The Wisdom of Crowds, the mass often make better decisions than an individual because, among other reasons, their errors tend to cancel out.

billswift··on Brin on Yegge's post: "I stopped reading it after the first 1,000 pages"
>then also clearly shows him being a dick

And, except that you are hiding behind pseudonymity, your post shows you being an even bigger dick. Maybe you ought to think about what you are writing before you post it.

billswift··on Jwz: Google's pseudonym support "obvious bullshit"
And people who really want to "win" will be as evil as they need to be in order to "win" (however they define winning, hence the quotes).
billswift··on What is the Limit to Human Population Growth?
That is merely a matter of attitude. Right now post-processed sewerage isn't used for food production in most First World countries, but it could be. It is often used on golf courses, and there have been experiments in bagging it and selling it to landscape gardeners as a replacement for bagged cow manure. In the DC area, there was Com-Pro in the 1990s, for example, though I heard it was taken off the market for lack of sales even though it was less than half the price of bagged cow manure. If there was serious need for fertilizer, it could easily be satisfied.
billswift··on How I retired in 9 years on a corporate programmer salary
On the other hand, as todsul pointed out, cutting your expenses can give you more money to invest. Cutting costs that also eat up your time also gives you more time to increase your earnings potential. Owning many things brings to mind the definition of a boat as "a hole in the water into which you pour money" and your time.
billswift··on Ask HN: What makes a great API?
I would put adequate documentation as part of clarity and discoverability, both because they serve the same end and because the inherent clarity and discoverability can increase or decrease the amount of documentation needed to effectively use the API. So maybe I should have said "clarity, discoverability, and documentation".
billswift··on Ask HN: What makes a great API?
From the highest level view:

1) Reliability - it can be counted on to do its job.

2) Consistency - it does it in the same, or at least the same small set of, ways each time.

3) Clarity and Discoverability - it is easy to see or find out what it does.

billswift··on Steve Jobs, LSD and Drug Freedom
Everybody except a very small number of consistent libertarians are that way - the liberals/socialists and paleo-conservatives and neo-cons (Judeo-Christian Socialists) just disagree on what they want the government to do. So we mostly end up with the government doing more and more and more. Most of which is not wanted by some group.
billswift··on Steve Jobs, LSD and Drug Freedom
It is actually a trichotomy: close-minded, open-minded, and so-open-minded-that-all-your-critical-thinking-ability-has-run-out-your-ears. At least a third of HN commenters fall into the third group.
billswift··on Steve Jobs, LSD and Drug Freedom
Goethe was the king of that sort of irrationality.

You might find the essays in Richard Dawkins's book, Unweaving the Rainbow interesting since the thread drawing them together is that understanding something scientifically does not make it less fascinating, if anything it makes everything even more interesting.

billswift··on The Rands Test
>The problem is people become more concerned with the artifact than what the artifact is supposed to be communicating.

This can happen to any formal reporting or management system. Status reports, especially frequent ones, are actually one of the less game-able systems out there. Though they really need to be augmented by more automated recording and reporting of measurables to help keep them honest.

billswift··on Black and white twins
This isn't really all that uncommon. The first time I read about it was the late 1970s, in that case the mother was "black" and the twins were still babies.

The doctor's account of the genetics in the article is wrong, also. There are at least 5 different genes affecting skin color which show mixed dominance with darker being dominant. So a "black" person with a single white ancestor many generations ago can still carry the genes for light skin as a recessive; which can be expressed in their children given the right mix of other genes. Hair texture and color are similar, I don't know about other characteristics. The only reason I know as much as I do about the skin color genetics is that they were used as an example for tracking complex, multigene inheritance over generations in a human genetics textbook I read in the early 1980s (I have not even the vaguest memory of its exact title and authors).

billswift··on Linux Fundamentals
One of Slackware's strongest points, and the reason I have stuck with it, is its configurability. Unfortunately, this can be a problem for newer users since it also requires more manual configuration than most newer distros. Also Slackware's installer sometimes has problems with some machine configurations.
billswift··on Blackboards in Porn
>(Why the teacher has chosen A and S is unclear; these are sometimes used in lower case form as acceleration and distance respectively, but the relationship between them would not then be physically correct.)

A and S are used in elementary math as Area and Side respectively, so for a square it is correct.

billswift··on Letter from a psychopath
Part of a comment I left on a discussion on LessWrong last week:

it has been annoying me lately that there are three distinct usages of "empathy" that are frequently conflated.

1) "Empathy" as the emotional interest in others, could also be called "moral sense", the kind of empathy that sociopaths are said to lack.

2) "Empathy" as the ability to identify emotionally with others, the set of instincts or "firmware" that make interpersonal communications and interactions go smoothly, the kind of empathy that autistics are said to lack.

3) "Empathy" or "imaginative identification with others", a more intellectual version, part of the definition of an intelligent being which is associated with metalaw. The ability to intellectually and purposely imagine yourself in the place of another, even a very different other, such as an extra-terrestrial alien, hence its association with metalaw.

billswift··on Coming Soon: the Drone Arms Race
Actually, the French/UK and German powers were pretty much evenly balanced. Woodrow Wilson's meddling in the war and especially in the "peace conference" afterward was the major factors that led to World War Two.

And on the Japanese front, it was the economic embargo by the US, as a punitive measure for Japan's attacks on China, that triggered Pearl Harbor. That may actually have been more or less inevitable, the Japanese military had too much influence in their society at that time and were seriously out of touch with reality.

billswift··on Status Report: Liars and Outliers
"It's a language that's more intuitive. We already know about moral pressure, peer pressure, and legal pressure. Reputational pressure, institutional pressure, and security pressure is much less of a stretch. And it puts security back in a more sensible place. Security is a mechanism; trust is the goal."

Repeat that last line: "Security is a mechanism; trust is the goal."

What other mechanisms do you see helping improve social trust?

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →