130 karma · joined August 26, 2019
I think they do. Also, Algolia has an official Wordpress plugin for one click installation. Why do you think that exists? Many of the highly trafficked sites in every niche are blogs. Take Mashable, ZDNet for instance. If you really think people don't do on site search on those blogs, then I have no say.
Yes the OP is asking for himself but he doesn't mention he's targeting the HN crowd.
>No, I'm acknowledging your lack of technical skills.
Yes, I already said `I consider myself somewhat tech-savvy` so no need to be snide. But that is beside the point, and you actually just proved what I am trying to say - for a regular user, accomplishing those things is much easier with a WYSIWYG editor that Wordpress or other CMSs offer, than with markdown.
They do, please be assured of that. There is a reason companies like Algolia exist to provide better on-site search.
>If you insist on having comments on your site and force users to sign-in etc this can be easily implemented with an API and some client-side code.
Yes or without signing up and just commenting as guest. Welcome to Wordpress :) (And if I have to build another API just for comments, doesn't it defeat the simplicity of using a static generator like Hugo?)
>This thread is about HN users, not the general population.
I am not sure where you got that from? The author never said he was going to create a blog targeted for the HN crowd or anything like that. Maybe I am missing something?
>Well, no wonder you prefer Wordpress.
At least you acknowledge markdown's inferiority in this case.
>And you will contribute to unethical tracking practices even if your users are not logged in to Facebook or Disqus[1].
I don't care much about that because one way or the other one of the tech giants is going to track us anyway. I would much rather install Google analytics and get a great overview of my visitors. I don't think anyone who is an active user of the tracking behemothos Facebook or Google(which represents most of the internet users) should be concerned about tracking.
But coming to main point, I am actually against Disqus or facebook comments. I prefer plain old self hosted comments(wordpress) for other reasons and this solves your concern as well.
Also, Ghost doesn't even have a commenting service of their own and one would need to rely on Disqus to add comments on a Ghost powered blog :)
>if the author couldn't handle writing markdown and using a terminal command.
I would say this represents more than 99% of the bloggers. Even I prefer a WYSIWYG interface to markdown any day even though I consider myself somewhat tech-savvy. I find markdown to be very hacky when its a bit more than just headings and paragraphs(eg. nested lists with ordered list inside unordered list are so hard to do in markdown)
I had once thought about a different approach - Creating a Google form (for each blog post) and then embedding it on the blog post. Then whenever anyone submits a comment via the form, it would get saved to a Google spreadsheet(this needs to be made publicly readable). The unwanted comments can just be deleted from the spreadsheet. The contents of this spreadsheet can then be obtained in a JSON format and displayed on the blog post using Javascript.
Like the GP, I was also under the impression that Ghost doesn't support commenting by design but you are suggesting otherwise. I find it hard to believe that adding commenting system(something that all major CMSs have had since forever) would be that technically challenging that it hasn't been added even six years after its first release.
Yes none of those static site generators support commenting, making them not very suitable for blogging(they dont even support searches). That is why I am not a proponent of static generators as a blogging platform.
>Rarely have I seen interesting discussion happen in the comments of a personal blog.
I disagree with this and even more so if we are talking about programming blogs. A lot of interesting discussions and rebuttals happen in the comment sections.
Regarding outsourcing search to a dedicated search engine, its a mixed bag. 99% of the users don't even know about the `site:` and `filetype:` stuff. You also have the option of embedding Google site search but the first four results are ads which isn't very ideal. Wordpress search is decent out of the box but if you want something advanced, it has some nice plugins that allow advanced searching with fuzzy matches.