HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

bklyn11201

712 karma · joined October 22, 2016

submissionscomments
bklyn11201··on Free data transfer out to internet when moving out of AWS
Exactly correct. AWS has a giant suite of services, and if they are forced to reduce egress charges, they would raise prices on other services to keep their margins consistent. The market knows this and thus why the market doesn't react to non-news like this.

An interesting question: why does AWS charge so much for egress knowing that it could dissuade some currently-on-prem use cases? It definitely forces optimization, use of CDNs, compression, etc. Previously it likely reduced transfers to another provider, but as the parent alludes to, the use of managed services makes sticking to AWS much more likely. What else?

bklyn11201··on BlackCat ransomware group implodes after apparent payment by Change Healthcare
Are there no legal consequences for knowingly paying money to a known criminal group based in Russia? What about the existing OFAC sanctions?
bklyn11201··on Deploying Web Apps with Caddy: A Beginner's Guide Caddy
1) Nginx Plus and HAProxy have nice consoles to view your thousand upstreams and their current health. The Nginx Plus GUI is Apache 2.0 (https://github.com/nginxinc/nginx-plus-dashboard).

2) Nginx has this concept of rewrite "last" (instead of permanent or temporary)

3) Nginx Plus and HAProxy both have TCP routing OOTB without needing to recompile

4) Nginx and Nginx Plus have more ability to intercept a response from an upstream and modify it vs Caddy's fairly limited handle_response {}

5) Modify body content from upstream seems to require a Caddy module

6) Very difficult to find good Caddy configs and thus why LLMs have such a hard-time helping people with Caddy configs. Having a library of configs would probably help this training

There seems to be an incredible market opportunity for Caddy as I've lost a lost of trust in the Nginx ecosystem and commercial environment. I would get some of these modules into core Caddy so that they are easy to distribute to people used to just installing via apt. And then attack the Nginx Plus features one by one. Add a visual console even though I understand why it doesn't seem like a necessity. I'd love to see Caddy take share and would love to re-allocate my Nginx Plus spend over to Caddy support.

bklyn11201··on Deploying Web Apps with Caddy: A Beginner's Guide Caddy
Caddy is indeed wonderful for straightforward and simple projects.

There are a number of complex configurations used by larger organizations that are well served today by Nginx Plus, HAProxy, and Traefik that don't seem possible with Caddy. And it's difficult to get a sense of whether the Caddy developers are interested in meeting those more complex use cases or whether they want to keep Caddy smaller and simpler.

But yes, by all means, for a simple project pick Caddy!

bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
You're absolutely right. I'm going to do this today.

It's clear from this thread that a) Nginx open source will not proceed at its previous pace, b) the forks are for Russia and not for western companies, and c) Caddy seems like absolutely the most sane and responsive place to move.

bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
Please compare the two and let us know if you think "similar" is the right word.
bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
True and I've made use of the Nginx adapter, but the resulting series of error messages and JSON was too scary to dive in further. The workflow that would make the most sense to me (to exit Nginx-world) would be loading my complex Nginx configs (100+ files) with the adapter, summarizing what could not be interpreted, and then writing the entirety to Caddyfile-format for me to modify further. I understand that JSON to Caddyfile would be lossy, but reading or editing 10k lines of JSON just seems impossible and daunting.
bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
I assume USA companies are by far the highest revenue source for Nginx Plus. Both of these forks seem to be based in Russia. How is a USA company supposed to pay either of these vendors for their consulting or Pro versions?

How long until F5 submits requests for domain ownership of freenginx.org, and how quickly does Angie get takedown requests for their features that look remarkably similar to Nginx Plus features (e.g., the console)?

bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
Right, they will just go after the domain forcing either a rename or a move to a Russian domain
bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
Thanks, I've never seen this fork mentioned before. This alone is compelling:

"Simplifying configuration: the location directive can define several matching expressions at once, which enables combining blocks with shared settings."

bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
HAProxy is a wonderful load balancer that doesn't serve static files thus forcing many of us to learn Nginx to fill the static-file-serving scenarios.

Caddy seems like a wonderful alternative that does load balancing and static file serving but has wild config file formats for people coming from Apache/Nginx-land.

bklyn11201··on Freenginx: Core Nginx developer announces fork
Surely "Nginx" is trademarked, copyrighted, etc. A cool and collected fork would do some basic work to avoid trivial lawsuits, consider the other forks already in the space, and write up a bit on how this fork will be different from the others.
bklyn11201··on Deque Systems Sues BrowserStack for Intellectual Property Theft
axe-core licensed via MPL 2.0: https://github.com/dequelabs/axe-core

Here is the BrowserStack extension: https://www.browserstack.com/docs/accessibility/overview/ins...

I'm curious to hear more from someone who follows this space.

bklyn11201··on 525 Private jets departed Las Vegas after the Super Bowl ended
Sure, yes. What's a more realistic way to implement this in the USA while still allowing small-plane hobbyists to fly easily? Could the FAA mandate landing fees based on emissions / passengers?
bklyn11201··on Nancy Pelosi Made $500k from Her Nvidia Bet, Doubling Her Annual Salary
She's worth maybe $200mm at the beginning of 2023 so invest half in USA equities.

$100mm in SP500 and NVDA is 4% of SP500 so purchase $4mm in NVDA stock at beginning of 2023.

Price increased 237% in 2023. $9.48mm gain.

I don't see how a 500k gain is considered at all noteworthy considering her asset size and considering NVDA's huge gain.

bklyn11201··on Gemini AI
I'm a GPT4 subscriber and a Google GSuite work subscriber. I've been using the latest Bard this morning to write and refine python code, and it's just as good if not slightly better than GPT4. I asked it to refine some obtuse code with lots of chaining, and it did an admirable job writing accurate comments and explaining the chained logic. It's ridiculously anecdotal of course, but I used Bard for all of 5 minutes last time they announced. This time seems different.
bklyn11201··on Show HN: Modern Moodle learning platform open-source alternative
SCORM is definitely still used, but there have been many attempts to replace it with improved content packaging standards.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharable_Content_Object_Refere...

SCORM 1.2 then SCORM 2004 then TinCan and IMS Common Cartridge and IMS Content Packaging

As an LMS developer, how do you avoid the insanity of building to all of these standards and listening to what your next power user asks for? E.g., there is an instructor out there that has been using the same SCORM 1.2 package from 20 years ago and wants your new LMS to support it.

bklyn11201··on Show HN: Modern Moodle learning platform open-source alternative
Moodle : GPL : PHP

Canvas : AGPL : Rails

D2L : Closed : C#

Blackboard : Closed : .Net?

Google Classroom : Closed : Python?

Sakai : Apache : Java

bklyn11201··on Show HN: Modern Moodle learning platform open-source alternative
Here is a killer LMS feature: instructor uploads PDF of this week's reading, and the LLM generates a 20 question assessment with randomized multiple-choice questions.

Or how about thinking deeply about assessment questions that are semi-resistant to LLMs? Justin Wolfers just did a webinar where he talked about visual questions (line moving) as being the most resistant economics questions to LLMs. What about designing from the ground-up to use elements that are LLM-resistant?

Do a really good job of implementing LTI (semi-complex standard) so you can instantly integrate third-party apps. Takes pressure off you to build every tool/feature.

bklyn11201··on Show HN: Modern Moodle learning platform open-source alternative
Congratulations, I'm very excited to take a look. A few questions:

1) Instructure Canvas is another open-core (AGPL) LMS with a billion dollar market cap company backing it. It has tons of features and users. Why build another AGPL LMS? Is it solely because their Rails tech stack is terrible?

2) Do you want other institutions and orgs to develop alongside you? The use of AGPL says no, you want to focus on cloud hosting. Why not build an MIT-licensed LMS to differentiate yourself?

3) Every LMS seems to suffer from feature bloat. Instructors come up with insane feature requests and pretty soon your gradebook supports 3 different types of grading, with points or percentages, dropping the lowest 3 of 7 grades in a weighted category. Do you go down this road of developing features for your power users like every other LMS? If not, how do you avoid it? I see you're already interested in SCORM (an abandoned standard from 30 years ago). How do you avoid chasing every standard, every package, every power user feature request?

bklyn11201··on Squid Caching Proxy Security Audit: 55 vulnerabilities and 35 0days
What do modern server admins use for filtered HTTP/S egress from servers? E.g., if the app has a need to fetch HTTP/S sites for the user but needs to do so in a safe way?
bklyn11201··on The Truth about College Costs
University of Virginia all-in for in-state: $36,314

University of Michigan all-in for upperclassmen in-state: $37,612

All-in includes living expenses, meals, room and board, activity fees, books, etc.

bklyn11201··on SpaceX no longer taking losses to produce Starlink satellite antennas
Honest question: rapid expansion to where exactly? Are you thinking poorer, rural countries? E.g., with cheaper terminals Starlink will more aggressively sell to rural Brazil, Mexico, India, etc? If they can sell the terminal at cost, how low can they price the monthly service for these poorer countries to fill up unused capacity?
bklyn11201··on Ripple token is a not security when sold to the general public
This thread sees it as big rebuke to Gensler and big win for Ripple and other alt-coins:

https://twitter.com/adamscochran/status/1679515811344523267

bklyn11201··on Heat Pumps – The Well-Tempered Future of A/Cs
You need a backup heat source, but it doesn't necessarily mean you need full infrastructure of gas lines, ducting, and gas furnace. You could have an electric backup connected to ducted heat pump (e.g., non-efficient, pure electric) or could use electric strip heating, electric portable heaters, wood stoves, etc.
bklyn11201··on Cormac McCarthy has died
Read The Border Trilogy first (a coming-of-age story set on the US-Mexico border):

  * All the Pretty Horses
  * The Crossing
  * Cities of the Plain
Then Blood Meridian and No Country for Old Men.
bklyn11201··on The Best Pens for 2023: Gel, Ballpoint, Rollerball, and Fountain Pens
My unsolicited advice to JetPens owner: This is the first time I've ever seen the Jetpens site, and it's amazing. The guides are great, and I instantly trust the advice.

I have a $100 cart though, and I'm not going to checkout because there is no Apple Pay or Shop Pay or Amazon Pay option. Sorry I'm too lazy to add my data to yet another e-com site!

bklyn11201··on The cloud backlash has begun: Why big data is pulling compute back on premises
Even with the discounts, savings plans, multi-year commit discounts, etc., the cloud costs are absolutely absurd if you are running stable applications where you understand the future growth, use, and demand. Yes, the cloud is the right place for 99% of apps out there, but the market is sending a clear objective out to all tech companies: become profitable and build a sustainable, high margin on your products. Every maturing company with predictable products must be exploring ways to move workloads out of the cloud. AWS took your margin and isn't giving it back.

https://a16z.com/2021/05/27/cost-of-cloud-paradox-market-cap...

bklyn11201··on Andreessen Horowitz and 'zero interest rate phenomena'
You can only put 10k into I bonds (current rate 6.89%)

You can put massive amounts into TIPS

bklyn11201··on IKEA made a smart air quality sensor to track indoor pollution
How much pre-1993 Ikea furniture still exists in USA homes?!
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →